Re Hinds and Australian National University

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION              [2012] AATA  495

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

 2009/5662, 2010/0111, 2010/0354

Re

LYNETTE HINDS

APPLICANT

And

 AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL UNIVERSITY

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

 Mr. Mark Hyman, Member

Date 31 July 2012
Place Canberra

The decision under review is set aside and substituted under section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

Decision Summary

  1. The decision under review is set aside and in its place is substituted the following.

  2. In the email of 1 April 2008 from Professor Peter Grabosky to Ms Kathryn Leonard:

To the paragraph specified in this column ...

...the note in this column is to be appended:

The third paragraph

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal has determined that the record in this and the following paragraphs is inaccurate in dealing with a single misattribution issue when there were concerns over misattribution of authorship in respect of two documents: ‘Policing in the 21st Century: Safety and Security in the ACT – Survey Report’ (2005) and ‘Policing in the 21st Century: Final report from the Focus Groups’ (2005). The first of these was an internal document but had limited circulation beyond the ANU Project team and ACT Policing through its use in meetings with Neighbourhood Watch and community groups.

The seventh paragraph

      The Administrative Appeals Tribunal has determined that the first sentence of this paragraph is inaccurate and misleading. Dr Hinds withheld one power point file from a single colleague but did not exhibit any more general attitude or behaviour involving denying her colleagues access to Project documents.

The paragraph beginning ‘Professor Grabosky at no time encouraged...’

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal has determined that in the third sentence of the paragraph the reference to an accusation of plagiarism is incomplete in not identifying the details of the accusation. The sentence should include the information that the accusation was made by Dr Fleming in respect of an academic paper authored by Dr Lyn Hinds and Dr Tina Murphy.

The paragraph beginning ‘This was a matter between Dr Hinds and Dr Fleming...’

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal has determined that the first sentence of this passage is inaccurate. Access to the PowerPoint file was sought by Professor Grabosky from Dr Hinds on behalf of Dr Fleming, and the matter involved the three of them.

The paragraph beginning ‘Professor Grabosky was always concerned...’

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal has determined that the final sentence of the paragraph is misleading, as it could be taken to be a warning generally against interaction with staff or others at the Centre of Excellence in Policing and Security. The sentence would not be misleading if the words ‘with Dr Fleming’ were inserted after ‘interaction’.

The paragraph beginning ‘The Conference in question...’

      The Administrative Appeals Tribunal has determined that the final sentence of this paragraph is incomplete. The passage should include the information that Dr Hinds did not attend the conference, and that as a result no data collected…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Hinds and Australian National University and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 495
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case under review is between Dr Hinds and the Australian National University (ANU), focusing on the amendment and annotation of personal records as per the Freedom of Information Act. Dr Hinds, a former employee of ANU, sought amendments to two emails written by Professors Grabosky and Braithwaite in response to her grievances. The central legal issues the court had to address were whether the proposed amendments to the emails were necessary to correct inaccuracies, incomplete information, outdated content, or misleading statements. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the motion for dismissal was an abuse of process and if there was a predominant collateral purpose behind it.

The court thoroughly examined the context in which the emails were written and responded to Dr Hinds’s grievances. It noted that both emails were part of the grievance process and were responses to specific issues raised by Ms Leonard, an ANU human resources officer. The court highlighted that the understanding of each passage depended on the broader context and the particular issues being addressed. After careful consideration, the court found that certain amendments were necessary to ensure the emails accurately reflected the information intended for the public record. The court also denied the motion for dismissal, ruling that it was not an abuse of process and did not have a predominant collateral purpose.

In conclusion, the court set aside the decision under review and substituted it with a new decision. The amended emails now reflect the necessary changes as determined by the court. The final orders ensure that the public record accurately represents the information in question, without any misleading or incomplete statements. This decision underscores the importance of maintaining the integrity of records within the public domain, particularly in the context of grievances and Freedom of Information requests.

Background

Background to the litigation

In January 2008, Dr Hinds's contract with the Australian National University (ANU) ended, and she left the university. Shortly after, Dr Hinds lodged a formal grievance with ANU. Ms Kathryn Leonard, an ANU human resources officer, wrote to Professors Peter Grabosky and Valerie Braithwaite on 22 and 23 April 2008, respectively, setting out Dr Hinds's concerns and requesting their responses. Both professors responded to Ms Leonard's requests on 1 and 29 April 2008. Dr Hinds then proposed amendments to the emails from Professors Grabosky and Braithwaite, asserting that some information was incorrect, incomplete, out of date, or misleading. The emails were generated as part of Dr Hinds's grievance process and were responses to issues raised by Ms Leonard, who interpolated her questions into the professors' responses. Dr Hinds accused Dr Fleming, another staff member, of plagiarising her work and bullying her. She also claimed that Professors Grabosky and Braithwaite responded inadequately to her complaints about Dr Fleming. This decision does not concern the merits of these accusations but focuses on the integrity of the two emails as part of the public record.

The matter came before the court as a review of the decision made by ANU regarding Dr Hinds's request to amend and annotate personal records. The primary focus was on whether the emails from Professors Grabosky and Braithwaite should be amended due to inaccuracies or misleading information. Dr Hinds proposed several amendments to the content of these emails, and the court examined whether any of the information sought to be amended was indeed incorrect, incomplete, out of date, or misleading. The court also considered a motion for dismissal by Dr Hinds, which was denied as there was no evidence of abuse of process or a predominant collateral purpose.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is an unfortunate case. A promising academic career seems to have been brought to an end by the events the subject of this review. It is by no means clear that this decision will put the matter finally to rest, although that is surely to be hoped.DECISION The decision under review is set aside and in its place is substituted the following. In the email of 1 April 2008 from Professor Peter Grabosky to Ms Kathryn Leonard (the Grabosky email): In the email of 29 April 2008 from Professor Valerie Braithwaite to Ms Kathryn Leonard (the Braithwaite email):

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In January 2008 Dr Hinds’s contract with the ANU came to an end and she left the University. On 18 March 2008 Dr Hinds lodged a formal grievance with the ANU (A58). Ms Kathryn Leonard, an ANU human resources officer, wrote to Professor Grabosky on 22 April setting out Dr Hinds’s concerns and requesting a response. She wrote in similar terms to Professor Braithwaite on 23 April. Professor Grabosky replied on 1 May 2008 (T8) and Professor Braithwaite on 29 April (T7).CONSIDERATION Dr Hinds proposed 38 amendments to the Grabosky email and 33 to the Braithwaite email. These have been numbered G1-G38 and B1–B33 respectively for ease of reference. Whether any of the information to which amendment is sought is incorrect, incomplete, out of date or misleading depends in part on the context in which that information appears. Three aspects of context may be significant here:(a)first, both emails were generated as part of Dr Hinds’s grievance process, and that in itself establishes a context for the information;(b)second, each passage to which Dr Hinds seeks amendment is part of a larger text, which will from time to time affect how the particular passage is to be understood; and (c)third, the emails were written as a response to a series of issues raised by Ms Leonard. The nature and phrasing of those issues may influence how the passage in question should be read. This point has particular force because each author interpolated the issues raised by Ms Leonard into the email response, so that the reader sees not only the words of Professors Grabosky and Braithwaite, but also those of Ms Leonard to which they are responding.Where necessary or relevant, the issues to which each passage is a response, and the larger passage within which each amendment has been sought, have been set out in the decision. Text which Dr Hinds sought to amend is underlined, and the number of the amendment is where necessary identified immediately after the relevant underlined text. In each case, the author began the email with some introductory text which does not purport to respond to the particulars of Ms Leonard’s text. A number of actions, purportedly taken by Dr Fleming, lay at the centre of Dr Hinds’s grievance process. Dr Hinds accused Dr Fleming of plagiarising her work and of bullying her. She also said that other staff at ANU – specifically Professors Grabosky and Braithwaite – responded inadequately to her complaints about Dr Fleming, indeed so inadequately that their response was a major focus in her grievance process. This decision is not concerned with any of those matters in themselves, but inevitably touches on them where the emails deal with them. In that process it is inevitable that this decision will make reference to Dr Fleming. Dr Fleming was not called as a witness; she has had no opportunity of answering any of the matters raised about her; her only opportunity of giving her side of any issue is in the various papers – emails, letters, an affidavit – forming part of the evidence or prepared before the hearing; and as she is neither a party nor a witness there is no engagement of the requirements of procedural fairness. It is therefore essential to state clearly that this decision includes no finding, explicit or implicit, about any of Dr Hinds’s accusations against or comments on Dr Fleming, or indeed about any of Dr Fleming’s behaviour. The sole concern of this decision is the integrity of the two emails as part of the public record. The Grabosky EmailGeneral introduction