DZXP, KRQD and QJJS and Innovation and Science Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

DZXP, KRQD and QJJS and Innovation and Science Australia [2017] AATA 576 (19 April 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2015/1257, 2015/1258 and 2015/1259

Re:DZXP, KRQD and QJJS

APPLICANT

Innovation and Science AustraliaAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member CR Walsh

Date:19 April 2017

Place:Perth

The Tribunal dismisses applications 2015/1257, 2015/1258 and 2015/1259 pursuant to s 42B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

........[Sgd]................................................................

Senior Member CR Walsh

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – dismissal application – applications frivolous, vexatious, misconceived or lacking in substance or have no reasonable prospects of success – applications for R&D tax incentive advance/overseas findings made by wholly-owned subsidiary members of MEC groups rather than by head entities of the MEC groups - registrations and findings not effective for subsidiary members for MEC group R&D activities – application of the “single entity rule” for consolidated tax groups considered – R&D tax incentive scheme for claimed overseas R&D activities considered – powers of the Board to do all things necessary and convenient to be done for or in connection with the performance of its functions - applications dismissed

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 – s 25C

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 – s 2A – s 42B – s 42C - s 42D – s 45

Casino Control Act 1988 (ACT)

Industry Research and Development Act 1986 – s 4(1) – s 8 – s 27A – s 28A – s 28B – s 28C – s 28D – s 28G – s 30 – s 30A – s 30C(1) – s 30D(3) – s 31 – s 31(2) – s 31A – s 31B – Div 6 of Pt III

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 – s 355-205 – s 355-210 – s 355-210(1)(d) – Div 701 - Pt 3-90 – s 701-1 – s 701-5 – s 701-40 - s 703-5 – s 719-5 - s 995-1

Tax Laws Amendment (Research and Development) Bill 2010

Tax Laws Amendment (Research and Development) Act 2011

Tribunals Amalgamation Act 2015

Tribunals Amendment Bill 2014

CASES

Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v Grand Shipping SA and Anor (1991) 173 CLR 231

Duncan v Fayle (2004) 138 FCR 510

Irving and Repatriation Commission (1997) 46 ALD 20

Munnings v Australian Government Solicitor [No 2] (1994) 118 ALR 385; 68 ALJR 169

Paraponiaris and Secretary, Department of Employment [2015] AATA 895

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355

Re Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd and Collector of Customs (NSW) (1978) 1 ALD 167

Re Canberra Raiders Sports Club and Commissioner of ACT Revenue (1999) 59 ALD 229

Re Christ Church Circle Oriona Community Inc and Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1995) 31 ATR 1001; 95 ATC 2040; [1995] Admin Review 48

Re Currey and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2007] AATA 1963; (2007) 99 ALD 106

Re Filsell and Comcare [2009] AATA 90; (2009) 109 ALD 198

Re Hare and Commissioner for Superannuation (1979) 2 ALD 233

Re Hinds and Australian National University

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DZXP, KRQD and QJJS and Innovation and Science Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 576
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to this proceeding were DZXP, KRQD and QJJS, who sought review of decisions made by Innovation and Science Australia (ISA). The dispute concerned applications for R&D tax incentive advance/overseas findings made by wholly-owned subsidiary members of MEC groups, rather than by the head entities of those groups. ISA contended that these registrations and findings were not effective for the subsidiary members for MEC group R&D activities, particularly in light of the "single entity rule" for consolidated tax groups and the scheme for claimed overseas R&D activities. The matter came before SM Walsh of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applications for review were frivolous, vexatious, misconceived, lacking in substance, or had no reasonable prospect of success, thereby warranting dismissal under section 42B of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (Cth). This involved considering the application of the R&D tax incentive scheme to overseas activities and the proper interpretation of the "single entity rule" in the context of MEC groups and their subsidiaries. The Tribunal also had to consider the scope of its powers to dismiss applications early, balancing the need to manage its resources with the principle that dismissal powers should be used cautiously and sparingly.

SM Walsh considered the amended provisions of section 42B of the AAT Act, which expanded the grounds for dismissal beyond frivolous or vexatious conduct to include applications that are misconceived, lack substance, or have no reasonable prospect of success. The Tribunal noted that while the power to dismiss is significant, it should be exercised cautiously, and only where a legitimate purpose cannot be achieved by allowing the application to continue. The case involved a complex interplay of statutory interpretation concerning the R&D tax incentive legislation and the application of the single entity rule.

Ultimately, SM Walsh dismissed the applications. The decision was based on the conclusion that the applications were misconceived and lacked substance, as the R&D tax incentive advance/overseas findings were not effectively made by the subsidiary members for MEC group R&D activities. The Tribunal found that, as a matter of law, no legitimate purpose could be achieved by continuing with the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Innovation Australia did not confirm, vary or set aside the Original Findings by the end of the 90 day statutory timeframe for internal review (which began on 20 November 2014 and ended on 17 February 2015). As a result, Innovation Australia was deemed, pursuant to s 30D(3) of the IR&D Act (T2, pg 114), to have made decisions confirming the Original Findings (Deemed Decisions). On 16 March 2015, DZXP, KRQD and QJJS applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Deemed Decisions (being applications 2015/1257, 2015/1258 and 2015/1259, respectively). The three related applications were subsequently joined and were to be heard together. On 25 September 2015, Innovation Australia wrote to the Tribunal seeking to have the matters referred with the agreement of the President of the Tribunal under s 45 of the AAT Act to the Federal Court on a question of law (i.e. a discrete question of statutory construction). By letter dated 2 October 2015, DZXP, KRQD and QJJS opposed this request. Following a teleconference with the President of the Tribunal, Kerr J, on 13 November 2015, the President wrote to the parties notifying them of his decision on this issue, as follows:…on reflection I have concluded that it would be inappropriate for me to express any settled view on that question at the present time.Section 45(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act permits the Tribunal, with the agreement of the President, to refer a question of law arising in a proceeding before the Tribunal to the Federal Court of Australia for decision.The provision does not permit the President to invoke that power independently. While a reference of a question of law requires the agreement of the President any such reference can only be made by the Tribunal as constituted. It is therefore incumbent on a party wishing to take advantage of that facility to first persuade the Tribunal as constituted that that course would be appropriate.For that reason I will proceed without delay under the Tribunal’s significant matters protocol to constitute the Tribunal in a manner consistent with the nature of the matters that it will be required to determine in the above reviews. Once I have so constituted the Tribunal any relevant applications can be pursued before it. On 2 December 2015, DR Johnson notified the parties that the hearing of the substantive applications had been constituted before by DP Siopis J and SM Walsh. On 24 December 2015, Innovation Australia applied to have the applications dismissed pursuant to s 42B of the AAT Act. SM Walsh issued directions for the filing of submissions on this dismissal application and the matters were listed for an interlocutory hearing (s 42B dismissal application) before SM Walsh on 11 March 2016. On 9 February 2016, the parties notified the Tribunal that they had commenced settlement discussions. Consequently, the interlocutory hearing, listed before SM Walsh on 11 March 2016, was vacated. A number of directions hearings before SM Walsh ensued.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The dismissal application was ultimately heard by SM Walsh on 15 March 2017.CONSIDERATIONSection 42B of the AAT Act Section 42B of the AAT Act was amended pursuant to the Tribunals Amalgamation Act2015, with effect from 1 July 2015. Section 42B of the AAT Act, as amended, provides:Power of Tribunal if a proceeding is frivolous, vexatious etc(1) The Tribunal may dismiss an application for review of a decision, at any stage of the proceeding, if the Tribunal is satisfied that the application: (a)is frivolous, vexatious, misconceived or lacking in substance; or(b) has no reasonable prospect of success; or(c) is otherwise an abuse of the process of the Tribunal. (2)If the Tribunal dismisses an application under subsection (1), it may, on application by a party to the proceeding, give a written direction that the person who made the application must not, without leave of the Tribunal, make a subsequent application to the Tribunal of a kind or kinds specified in the direction. (3)The direction has effect despite any other provision of this Act or any other Act. Previously, the power to dismiss was limited to an application that the Tribunal was satisfied was frivolous or vexatious. The Explanatory Memorandum to the Tribunals Amalgamation Bill 2014 described the amendments as intended to modernise the language of the section and to clarify the policy surrounding the grounds for dismissal. The proposed new grounds were considered to be similar to dismissal powers available to other bodies, and:552.…would provide the Tribunal with greater power to dismiss unmeritorious matters early where appropriate. That said, the principles developed in relation to the early formulation of s 42B are of continuing relevance. The Tribunal has made it clear that the dismissal power in s 42B is to be used cautiously and sparingly. That is, if a legitimate purpose could be achieved by allowing the application to continue, it should not be prevented: Re Marnotta Pty Ltd and Secretary, Department of Health and Ageing (2004) 82 ALD 514; Re Hinds and Australian National University [2012] AATA 495; (2012) 129 ALD 476. However, if the application can serve no purpose for the applicant, it should not continue to use Tribunal time and resources: Re Williams and Australian Electoral Commission (1995) 38 ALD 366 (Williams); Re Currey and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority [2007] AATA 1963; (2007) 99 ALD 106 (Currey). One of the most frequently cited discussions on the approach that should be taken to s 42B applications is that contained in Williams, wherein the Tribunal stated that the genuineness of the applicant's belief may be relevant, perhaps decisive, where the subject matter of that belief is factual rather than legal in nature. But where the issue in dispute relates to the legal consequences of an application, the genuineness of the applicant's belief as to the legitimacy of the application must yield to a conclusion that, as a matter of law, no legitimate purpose can be achieved by continuing with the proceeding: see also Re Christ Church Circle Oriona Community Inc and Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1995) 31 ATR 1001; 95 ATC 2040; [1995] Admin Review 48.