Re Batchler

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

MENTAL HEALTH COURT

CITATION:

Re Batchler  [2016] QMHC 12

PARTIES:

REFERENCE BY THE DIRECTOR OF MENTAL HEALTH IN RESPECT OF JAMES ANDREW BATCHLER

FILE NO/S:

No 0265 of 2014

DELIVERED ON:

29 November 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

31 October 2016

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ASSISTING PSYCHIATRISTS:

Dr R Phillipson
Dr F Varghese

ORDER:

1. At the time of each of the alleged offences the subject of the reference the defendant was not of unsound mind as defined in the Schedule to the Mental Health Act 2000.

2.   In respect of each of the alleged offences the defendant is fit for trial. 

3.   Each of the alleged offences is to proceed according to law. 

4.   Copies of the reports and transcript are to be released to the parties for use in the criminal proceedings. 

CATCHWORDS:

Davie v Lord Provost, Magistrates & Councillors of the City of Edinburgh 1953 SC 34, cited
LAI v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)
[2016] QCA 287, cited
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705; [2001] NSWCA 305, cited
Ramsey v Watson (1961) 108 CLR 642; [1961] HCA 65, cited
SCN v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)
[2016] QCA 237, cited
Stapleton v The Queen
(1952) 86 CLR 358; [1952] HCA 56, cited

COUNSEL:

J D Briggs for the defendant

A E Loode for the Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)
S J Hamlyn-Harris for the Director of Mental Health

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for the defendant

Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)
Crown Law for the Director of Mental Health

  1. By reference, filed 14 October 2014, the Director of Mental Health referred to this Court the mental condition of James Andrew Batchler at the time of numerous offences allegedly committed in February, March and April 2014. 

  2. The offences the subject of the reference are assault or obstruct police and drunk or disorderly in premises, both on 24 February 2014, breach of bail undertaking on 19 March 2014, commit public nuisance and drunk in a public place, both on 26 March 2014, wilful damage of police property on 27 March 2014, commit public nuisance on 12 April 2014, two breaches of bail undertaking, both on 15 April 2014, commit public nuisance, deposit injurious matter on road, serious assault of police, threatening violence – discharge a firearm and two charges of wilful damage, all on 17 April 2014. 

  3. It is not in dispute that the defendant suffers from a longstanding mental illness.  It is also not in dispute the defendant is currently fit for trial.  At issue is whether at the time of any of the alleged offences the defendant was, as a consequence of his mental illness, deprived of any of the requisite capacities and, if so, whether that deprivation was contributed to, to any extent, by intoxication. 

    Background

  4. The defendant was born on 8 December 1979.  He first came to the attention of Mental Health authorities in May 2004 when he was admitted to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Batchler and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QMHC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Re Batchler involved a defendant who had a history of mental illness and who was accused of committing certain offences in April 2014. The defendant was deemed fit for trial, but the issue before the court was whether, at the time of the alleged offences, the defendant was of unsound mind due to his mental illness, and whether any such unsoundness was contributed to by intoxication. The court had to determine whether the defendant was deprived of the requisite capacities, such as the capacity to know he ought not do the acts in question, at the time of the alleged offences.

The court had to consider the extent to which the defendant’s mental illness, and any intoxication at the time, contributed to any deprivation of the requisite capacities. The court had to weigh the evidence of the defendant’s mental state at the time of the alleged offences, as well as the evidence of the assisting psychiatrists. The court also had to consider the statutory definition of unsound mind, as set out in the Schedule to the Mental Health Act 2000.

The court found that the defendant was suffering from a mental illness at the time of each of the alleged offences, but that this illness was not of sufficient severity to have deprived the defendant of any of the requisite capacities at the time of the offences in February and March 2014. However, in respect of the April 2014 offences, the court found that the defendant’s mental illness, in combination with the hyperparathyroidism, was of a sufficient severity to have deprived the defendant of the capacity to know he ought not do the acts and of the capacity to control. The court also found that the deprivation of those capacities was contributed to by intoxication at the time of the offences in April 2014.

The court concluded that the defendant was not of unsound mind at the time of any of the alleged offences, and that the proceedings against the defendant should continue according to law. The court ordered that the defendant was fit for trial in respect of each of the alleged offences, and that each of the alleged offences was to proceed according to law. The court also ordered that copies of the reports and transcript were to be released to the parties for use in the criminal proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. At the time of each of the alleged offences the subject of the reference the defendant was not of unsound mind as defined in the Schedule to the Mental Health Act 2000.

2. In respect of each of the alleged offences the defendant is fit for trial.

3. Each of the alleged offences is to proceed according to law.

4. Copies of the reports and transcript are to be released to the parties for use in the criminal proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is not in dispute that the defendant suffers from a longstanding mental illness. It is also not in dispute the defendant is currently fit for trial. At issue is whether at the time of any of the alleged offences the defendant was, as a consequence of his mental illness, deprived of any of the requisite capacities and, if so, whether that deprivation was contributed to, to any extent, by intoxication. Background The defendant was born on 8 December 1979. He first came to the attention of Mental Health authorities in May 2004 when he was admitted to the Redcliffe-Caboolture Mental Health Unit. At that time he presented with a marked psychotic disorder with disorganised and erratic behaviour, distorted thinking, paranoid ideation, auditory hallucinations and very variable mood state. He gave a history of having become withdrawn and isolated in the year or two preceding that admission. The defendant was diagnosed as having a psychotic episode of uncertain origin, possibly drug induced. He received medication. He was discharged into the community. After a period of instability, during which time he was subject to an involuntary treatment order, his illness was reported to have completely settled by 2006. The defendant worked as a fly in/fly out electrician for about 10 years prior to the alleged offences. He lost that job due to interpersonal conflict, behavioural problems and drug related issues. The defendant identified a change in mental state around Christmas 2013. He reported his mental state progressively deteriorated until April 2014, eventually leading to a full-blown psychotic episode. The defendant reported behavioural changes such as disorganisation and irritable mood and aggression. After the commission of the alleged offences on 17 April 2014, the defendant was admitted as an inpatient in a Mental Health facility. He remained an inpatient for almost two months. At the time the defendant was admitted to hospital, he was observed to be in a highly agitated state with poor insight into his condition. The defendant also was recorded to have an abnormally high calcium level. On investigation, this was found to be caused by hyperparathyroidism. On 21 May 2014, the defendant underwent surgery to remove a parathyroid adenoma. The defendant’s mental state settled rapidly after surgery and with medication. The defendant remained compliant with the medication thereafter. His mental state improved such that by the time of discharge he was pleasant, polite and appropriate in his interactions with others. He also demonstrated improved insight into his illness. The defendant continued to respond well to medications and remained abstinent from illicit substances. He commenced an honours engineering degree. His life had a period of stability. In February 2015 his involuntary treatment order was revoked. Shortly thereafter, the defendant ceased his prescribed medication, against advice. However, his mental health remained stable. He achieved very good marks in his degree and exhibited no signs of mental health deterioration.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I decline to follow the advice of the assisting psychiatrists in respect of the contribution of intoxication to the defendant’s deprivation of the capacity to know he ought not do the acts in question in respect of the alleged offences on 17 April 2014. Conclusion Whilst the defendant was suffering a mental illness at the time of each of the alleged offences in February and March 2014, that mental illness was not of sufficient severity to have deprived the defendant of any of the requisite capacities at the time of any of those alleged offences. In respect of the April 2014 alleged offence, the defendant’s mental illness was of a sufficient severity, in combination with the hyperparathyroidism, to have deprived the defendant of the capacity to know he ought not do the acts and of the capacity to control. However, the deprivation of those capacities was contributed to by intoxication at the time of each of the alleged offences in April 2014. The defendant was not of unsound mind at the time of any of the alleged offences the subject of the reference. I accept the defendant is fit for trial. The proceedings against the defendant should continue according to law. I order: At the time of each of the alleged offences the subject of the reference the defendant was not of unsound mind as defined in the Schedule to the Mental Health Act 2000. In respect of each of the alleged offences the defendant is fit for trial. Each of the alleged offences is to proceed according to law. Copies of the reports and transcript are to be released to the parties for use in the criminal proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established