Ramsay Health Care Ltd v Information Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Ramsay Health Care Ltd v Information Commissioner & Anor [2019] QCATA 66

PARTIES:

RAMSAY HEALTH CARE LIMITED
(applicant)

v

INFORMATION COMMISSIONER

(first respondent)

QUEENSLAND NURSES AND MIDWIVES UNION
(second respondent)

SUNSHINE COAST HOSPITAL AND HEALTH SERVICE
(third respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

APL094-17

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

10 June 2019

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Justice Daubney, President

ORDERS:

1.   The appeal is allowed.

2.   The decision of the Information Commissioner made on 23 February 2017 is set aside.

3.   The matter is returned to the Information Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with this decision of the Appeal Tribunal.

4.   The parties shall file any submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 21 June 2019.

5.   Unless either party requests an oral hearing, the issue of costs will be determined on the papers on a date to be fixed by the Tribunal.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – FREEDOM OF INFORMATION – RIGHT OF ACCESS – GROUNDS FOR REFUSAL –where Information Commission determined to grant access to information held by the third respondent to the second respondent under the Right to Information Act 2009 (“RTI Act”) – where appellant appeals that decision of the Information Commissioner – whether the Information Commissioner erred in law by holding that a breach of a contractual obligation of confidence does not amount to an action for breach of confidence within the meaning of Sch 3, s 8 of the RTI Act – whether the Information Act erred in law by reading Sch 3, s 8 of the RTI Act as importing a further consideration of the public interest – whether the Information Commissioner erred in law in holding that the appellant did not have standing to bring an action for breach of confidence

Right to Information Act 2009, s 47, s 48, s 49, s 119, sch 3, s 8

Attorney-General (UK) v Heinemann Publishers Pty Ltd (1987) 10 NSWLR 36
Ammon v Consolidated Minerals Ltd [No 3] [2007] WASC 232

Bray v Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Board [1994] 62 SASR 218; [1994] SASC 4478

Callejo and Department of Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 244; (2010) 51 AAR 308
City North Infrastructure Pty Ltd; Treasury Department (CNI case) (Unreported, Queensland Information Commissioner, 9 May 2012)

Coco v AN Clark (Engineers) Ltd [1969] RPC 41
Commonwealth of Australia v Cockatoo Dockyard Pty Ltd (1995) 36 NSWLR 662

Corrs Pavey Whiting & Byrne v Collector of Customs (1987) 14 FCR 434; [1987] FCA 266

Deta Nominees Pty Ltd v Viscount Plastic Products Pty Ltd [1979] VR 167
Esso Australia Resources Ltd & Ors v Plowman & Ors (1995) 183 CLR 10

Henderson and Queensland Law Society [2006] QICmr 2
Johns v Australian Securities Commission (1993) 178 CLR 408; [1993] HCA 56

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Kumar (2009) 238 CLR 448; [2009] HCA 10

Murphy and Health Quality and Complaints Commission [2009] QICmr 39

Optus Networks Pty Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ramsay Health Care Ltd v Information Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCATA 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ramsay Health Care Limited has appealed against a decision of the Information Commissioner, who had found that the Sunshine Coast Hospital and Health Service should disclose certain information to the Queensland Nurses and Midwives Union under the Right to Information Act 2009 (Qld). The appeal concerns the proper interpretation of the exemption in Sch 3, s 8 of the RTI Act which provides that information is exempt if its disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence. Ramsay Health Care Limited argued that the exemption applied because the information was confidential under a services agreement between Ramsay and Queensland Health, and disclosure would breach that confidentiality. The Information Commissioner rejected this argument, finding that breach of a contractual obligation of confidence did not constitute a breach of confidence for the purposes of the RTI Act. The court was required to determine whether the Information Commissioner correctly interpreted the exemption in Sch 3, s 8 of the RTI Act, and whether the Commissioner correctly found that Ramsay Health Care Limited did not have standing to bring an action for breach of confidence.

The court found that the Information Commissioner correctly interpreted the exemption in Sch 3, s 8 of the RTI Act. The court held that breach of a contractual obligation of confidence does not constitute a breach of confidence for the purposes of the RTI Act. The court noted that breach of confidence is a distinct cause of action from breach of contract, and that an action for breach of confidence requires the satisfaction of five cumulative requirements. The court further held that the Information Commissioner correctly found that Ramsay Health Care Limited did not have standing to bring an action for breach of confidence because it was not a party to the services agreement and therefore did not have a contractual obligation of confidence with Queensland Health. The appeal was allowed, the decision of the Information Commissioner was set aside, and the matter was returned to the Information Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with this decision. The parties were required to file submissions on costs by a specified date, and the issue of costs was to be determined on the papers unless an oral hearing was requested.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The decision of the Information Commissioner made on 23 February 2017 is set aside.

3. The matter is returned to the Information Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with this decision of the Appeal Tribunal.

4. The parties shall file any submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 21 June 2019.

5. Unless either party requests an oral hearing, the issue of costs will be determined on the papers on a date to be fixed by the Tribunal.

Background

Background to the litigation

This appeal from a decision of the Information Commissioner[1] turns on the proper interpretation of that exemption in Sch 3, s 8.[1] Brought pursuant to s 119 of the RTI Act.Background The following summary of the background, taken from the Information Commissioner’s decision[2] is not contentious. [2] Queensland Nurses Union and Sunshine Coast Hospital and Health Service; Ramsay Health Care (Third Party) [2017] QICmr 6 (23 February 2017). In 2010, Queensland Health invited private hospital operators to bid for the design, construction, finance, commissioning, operating and maintenance of a private hospital on the Sunshine Coast, to be co-located with the public Sunshine Coast University Hospital, which was expected to be built and commissioned by 2018. Ramsay Health Care Limited (“Ramsay”) submitted its ultimately successful bid in November 2010. The Sunshine Coast University Private Hospital (“SCUPH”) opened in November 2013. As part of being awarded the contract to build and operate SCUPH, Ramsay was required to enter into a services agreement with Queensland Health, under which it agreed to treat public patients at SCUPH while the public hospital was being built and commissioned. The services agreement contained the terms and conditions on which Ramsay was to provide public health services on behalf of Queensland Health. On 10 September 2015, the second respondent, the Queensland Nurses and Midwives Union (“QNU”), applied under the RTI Act for access to:(1) document that provides the number of each patients [sic] referred to the Sunshine Coast University Private Hospital (SCUPH) per annum; (2) A report containing a summary of any SAC1, SAC2 and Sentinel Events reports by Ramsay Health Services; (3) Any correspondence, letters or electronic, notifying Ramsay that a breach has occurred in relation to patient care; (4) a complaints spreadsheet that contains a meaningful summary of any complaints from patients regarding SCUPH. On 16 February 2016, after several extensions within which to give a decision, the third respondent, the Sunshine Coast Hospital and Health Service (“SCHHS”), advised QNU that, as it had not given QNU a decision in response to the access application within the time specified by the RTI Act, SCHHS was deemed to have given a decision refusing access to the requested information. On 1 March 2016, the QNU applied to the Office of the Information Commissioner for external review of that deemed refusal of access. On 23 February 2017, the Information Commissioner made a decision setting aside SCHHS’s deemed refusal of access. In particular, the Information Commissioner found that the information was not exempt information under the RTI Act and its disclosure would not, on balance, be contrary to the public interest. This is an appeal against that decision by the Information Commissioner.Decision of the Information Commissioner After setting out the background, the Information Commissioner noted Ramsay’s objections to disclosure of the information:(a)The information was exempt information because its disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence; and(b)Disclosure would, on balance, be contrary to the public interest because:(i) it could reasonably be expected to prejudice Ramsay’s business, professional, commercial or financial affairs;(ii) it could reasonably be expected to prejudice SCHHS’s ability to obtain confidential information.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is an appeal against that decision by the Information Commissioner.Decision of the Information Commissioner After setting out the background, the Information Commissioner noted Ramsay’s objections to disclosure of the information:(a)The information was exempt information because its disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence; and(b)Disclosure would, on balance, be contrary to the public interest because:(i) it could reasonably be expected to prejudice Ramsay’s business, professional, commercial or financial affairs;(ii) it could reasonably be expected to prejudice SCHHS’s ability to obtain confidential information. SCHHS also argued before the Information Commissioner that disclosure of the information would found an action for breach of confidence, and advanced a number of factors in support of a contention that disclosure would be contrary to the public interest:(a)Disclosure could reasonably be expected to cause the public interest harm because it would disclose personal information of a person;(b)Disclosure could reasonably be expected to prejudice the protection of an individual’s right to privacy; and(c)Disclosure could reasonably be expected to prejudice the management function of an agency. The Information Commissioner expressly rejected an argument that breach of a contractual obligation of confidentiality was covered by the exemption under Sch 3, s 8(1) of the RTI Act. The Information Commissioner said:16. Ramsay argues that the information in issue was communicated pursuant to the Services Agreement. Clause 13 of the Services Agreement is a confidentiality clause that requires that neither party to the Agreement disclose any confidential information of the other party without consent. Exceptions to that general restriction are contained in clause 13.2. Ramsay claims that the information in issue is confidential information under the Services Agreement and is therefore subject to the express contractual obligation of confidence contained in clause 13.17. In ‘B’ and BNRHA,[3] Commissioner Albietz said that an action for breach of confidence may be based on a contractual or an equitable obligation of confidence. However, he noted that a contractual term requiring that certain information be kept secret will not necessarily equate to a contractual obligation of confidence: an issue may arise as to whether an action for breach of the contractual term would satisfy the description of an ‘action for breach of confidence’.18. In TSO08G and Department of Health,[4] Right to Information Commissioner Mead applied the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in Callejo and Department of Immigration and Citizenship[5] in finding that, where a contractual term requiring confidentiality exists, disclosure (or threatened disclosure) of information may, in itself, only found an action for breach of contract. An action for breach of contract, and in equity, for breach of confidence, are separate and distinct causes of action at general law. An action for breach of confidence for the purposes of sch 3, section 8(1) of the RTI Act will only be established where the five cumulative requirements to found an action in equity for breach of confidence are met.[6]19. Accordingly, I find that, if a breach of clause 13 of the Services Agreement were to give rise to an action for breach of a contractual term, it would not give rise to an action for breach of confidence within the meaning of sch 3, section 8(1) of the RTI Act. In order to give rise to an action for breach of confidence, the five cumulative requirements referred to in the preceding paragraph (and discussed below) must be met.20. In its submissions dated 29 August 2016, Ramsay argued that this test was too narrow and that until there had been a judicial interpretation of this issue, the test for exemption under sch 3, section 8(1) of the RTI Act should be read as covering a hypothetical plaintiff who would have a cause of action to enforce a contractual obligation of confidence. However, for the reasons explained above, I prefer the interpretation set out in Callejo.[3] B and Brisbane North Regional Health Authority [1994] QICmr 1, a decision of the Information Commissioner analysing the equivalent exemption in the repealed Freedom of Information Act 1992 (Qld) at [43].[4] (Unreported, Queensland Information Commissioner, 13 December 2011).[5] (2010) 51 AAR 308; [2010] AATA 244 at [163-166].[6] See Kalinga Wooloowin Residents Association Inc and Brisbane City Council; City North Infrastructure Pty Ltd; Treasury Department (CNI case) (Unreported, Queensland Information Commissioner, 9 May 2012) at [64-65].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.