Patrick; Secretary, Department of Defence and [2021] AATA 4627 (14 December 2021)
Division:FREEDOM OF INFORMATION DIVISION
File Number: 2020/5485
Re:Secretary, Department of Defence
APPLICANT
AndSenator Rex Patrick
RESPONDENT
AndNaval Group Australia Pty Ltd and Naval Group S.A.
OTHER PARTY
Appeal from: [2020] AICmr 40
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President Britten-Jones
Date:14 December 2021
Place:Melbourne
The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Australian Information Commissioner dated 13 August 2020 and substitutes a decision that the information requested by Senator Patrick on 16 June 2018 is exempt from disclosure under s 45 of the Freedom of Information Act 1982.
........................................................................
Deputy President Britten-Jones
Catchwords
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION – review of decision of Department of Defence that documents are wholly exempt – documents relate to Final Cost Estimate Template submitted for the Future Submarine Competitive Evaluation Process – documents exempt under section 45 of the Freedom of Information Act 1982 – “required by law” clauses do not displace section 45 – an action for breach of confidence may arise from a contractual breach of confidence – consideration of whether an action for breach of confidence requires detriment – the decision granting access to the requested information is set aside and substituted with the decision that the information is exempt from disclosure
Legislation
Freedom of Information Act 1982
Cases
Ammon v Consolidated Minerals Ltd[No 3] [2007] WASC 232
BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Shire of Hastings (1977) 180 CLR 266
Callejo and Department of Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 244; (2010) 51 AAR 308
Corrs Pavey Whiting & Byrne v Collector of Customs (Vic) [1987] FCA 266; (1987) 14 FCR 434
Fomiatti v University of Western Sydney (No 2) [2006] NSWADT 210
Kamminga and Australian National University (1992) 26 ALD 58
Meagher Gummow & Lehane, Principles of Equity
Moorgate Tobacco Co Ltd v Philip Morris Ltd (No. 2) (1984) 156 CLR 414
Optus Networks Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2010) 265 ALR 281; [2010] FCAFC 21
Ramsey Health Carev Information Commissioner & Anor [2019] QCATA 66Secondary Materials
Explanatory Memorandum for the Freedom of Information Bill 1981
The FOI Guidelines under s 93A of the Freedom of Information Act 1982
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Britten-Jones
14 December 2021
Introduction
The Australian Government has embarked on an acquisition strategy for submarines which involved, as a first stage, a competitive evaluation process to choose an international partner. Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act 1982, (FOI Act)[1] Senator Rex Patrick (the respondent) requested access to information contained within contractual documentation arising from the competitive evaluation process. Access was refused by the Secretary of the Department of Defence (Defence), but on review to the Australian Information Commissioner his request was granted. Defence has applied to the Tribunal for review of that decision. The information the subject of the request has not yet been disclosed to Senator Patrick. The Other Parties (together referred to as Naval Group) object to the disclosure…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Patrick; Secretary, Department of Defence and and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] AATA 4627
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether section 45 of the FOI Act was displaced by a "required by law" clause within the relevant contract, and what constituted an action for breach of confidence for the purposes of section 45, specifically whether a purely contractual breach sufficed and if detriment was a necessary element. Senator Patrick argued that the contractual provisions, which subjected the release of information to the FOI Act, implied an intention to exclude the operation of section 45.
The court rejected Senator Patrick's contentions, reasoning that the "required by law" clause in the contract did not expressly displace section 45. Instead, it provided an exception to the contractual obligation of confidence, permitting disclosures required by law, including those mandated by the FOI Act. The court affirmed that access under section 11A of the FOI Act is subject to exemptions, and a document is exempt if its disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence, as provided by section 45. The court found that the contractual terms did not override this statutory exemption.
Consequently, the court set aside the decision of the Australian Information Commissioner and substituted a decision that the requested information was wholly exempt from disclosure pursuant to section 45 of the FOI Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The questions that arise for determination with respect to s 45 are as follows:(a)Is s 45 displaced by operation of the “required by law” clause in clause 9.3 of the CEP services contract?(b)What is an action for breach of confidence for the purposes of s 45? Does it include a purely contractual breach? Does it require satisfaction of the five elements in [5.159] of the Guidelines or is the element of detriment not required?Is s 45 displaced by operation of the “required by law” clause? Clause 9.3(b) of the CEP Contract provides an exception to the obligation of confidence imposed upon the Commonwealth set out in clause 9.3(a). It permits the Commonwealth to provide what is defined as Contract Information for the purpose of the competitive evaluation process to the Department of Defence and the Australian Government (and their advisers) and to any other third party by consent and “as otherwise required by law”. This has the effect of bringing within the exception as to confidentiality any disclosure required by law. In other words, if disclosure is required by law then that disclosure will not cause the Commonwealth to be in breach of the clause 9.3(a) obligation of confidentiality. Senator Patrick says that the exemption provided by s 45 (on which Defence and Naval Group rely to support their claim as to confidentiality) does not apply because the parties to the contract agreed that the access and release of Contract Information will be subject to the FOI Act. Defence says that a proper application of the FOI Act means that any entitlement to access under s 11A is still subject to the exemption in s 45 such that if disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence then the document will be exempt from disclosure. Although not expressly articulated by Senator Patrick, his argument is that by expressly dealing with the question of access to confidential information in clause 9.3, the parties must have intended to exclude the operation of s 45 because otherwise it would defeat the apparent intent of the parties to subject themselves to a regime of disclosure otherwise provided for by the FOI Act. Senator Patrick’s contentions should be rejected for the reasons that follow. The terms of clause 9.3(b) do not expressly displace the operation of s 45. Clause 9.3(b) permits disclosure by the Commonwealth of Contract Information that would otherwise be prohibited by clause 9.3(a). In other words, it provides for exceptions to the obligation of confidence. One of the exceptions is if disclosure is required by law, which would include disclosure required by the FOI Act. Section 11 gives every person a legally enforceable right to obtain access to a document “other than an exempt document”. If a request is made then access must be given pursuant to s 11A(3) “subject to this section.” The section then provides for exemptions and conditional exemptions. Pursuant to s 11A(4), the relevant agency is not required to give access to the document if it is an exempt document. As set out above, a document is an exempt document by operation of s 45 if its disclosure would found an action for breach of confidence.