Rajamanikkam v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Rajamanikkam v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs
[1999] FCA 1411

MIGRATION – appeal from refusal of Refugee Review Tribunal to grant protection visas – Sri Lankan Tamils – whether the Tribunal erred in law in rejecting application on the basis of factual inconsistencies and credibility – determination that applicant concocted primary claims – issues of language, misinterpretation, misunderstandings and applicant’s memory – effect on judicial review of failure by Tribunal to set out in its decision its reasons and findings on material questions of fact as required by s 430(1) – meaning and extent of s 425 requiring Tribunal to invite the applicant to “present arguments relating to the issues arising in relation to the decision under review”

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 425, 430(1), 476 (1)(a), 476 (1)(e), (1)(g), (4)(b)

Lowerson v Repatriation Commission [1994] 50 FCR 252, cited
Abebe v Commonwealth [1999] 162 ALR 1, cited
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu [1999] 162 ALR 577, applied
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Cho [1999] FCA 946, applied
Sun Zhan Qui v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1997] FCA 324, applied
Thevendram v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 182, applied
Sellamuthu v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 247, applied

NADARASA RAJAMANIKKAM & BALAMBIKAI RAJAMANIKKAM v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

NG 1133 OF 1998

EINFELD J
19 NOVEMBER 1999

SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 1133 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

NADARASA RAJAMANIKKAM AND BALAMBIKAI RAJAMANIKKAM
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

EINFELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 NOVEMBER 1999

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.   the application for judicial review be granted

2.   the Tribunal’s decision be set aside and the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for a fresh hearing to be conducted by another Tribunal member

3.   the respondent pay the applicant’s costs

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 1133 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

NADARASA RAJAMANIKKAM AND BALAMBIKAI RAJAMANIKKAM
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent

JUDGE:

EINFELD J

DATE:

19 NOVEMBER 1999

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The applicants, husband and wife, are elderly Sri Lankan Tamils who arrived in Australia on visitors’ visas on 24 May 1996 and on 26 June lodged a combined application for refugee asylum.  On 27 March 1997 a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs refused to grant protection visas and on 1 April the applicants appealed to the Refugee Review Tribunal.  The Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision on 29 September 1998 and the applicants have now applied to this Court for judicial review of the Tribunal's decision.  The success of their application depends on whether there was relevant legal error in the Tribunal's rejection of their…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rajamanikkam v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Af... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1411
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Rajamanikkam v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the applicant, a retired medical practitioner from Sri Lanka, sought judicial review of a decision by the Tribunal to reject his application for asylum in Australia. The applicant argued that he would be persecuted, or even killed, if he returned to Sri Lanka due to suspicions of association with either the LTTE or government authorities. The Tribunal rejected his claims based on perceived inconsistencies in his evidence, particularly in relation to his pension and the security situation in Point Pedro. The applicant contended that any discrepancies were understandable given his age and health, and that the majority of the alleged inconsistencies were not actually discrepancies.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal's rejection of the applicant's credibility was lawful and whether there were any procedural errors in the Tribunal's process. The court examined the Tribunal's reasoning and findings, particularly in relation to the applicant's pension and the alleged misleading evidence provided to the Department. The court found that the Tribunal's primary conclusion on the pension issue had no foundation in the evidence and that its determination of the applicant attempting to mislead the Department was unsupported. The court also noted that the Tribunal's conclusion that the applicant had concocted his primary claims was not raised with the applicant until the Tribunal's reasons for decision were published, which might not represent a breach of section 425.

The court concluded that the Tribunal's decision was flawed and that the matter should be remitted to the Tribunal for a fresh hearing. The court granted the application for judicial review, set aside the Tribunal’s decision, and ordered the matter to be remitted to the Tribunal for a fresh hearing to be conducted by another Tribunal member. The respondent was also ordered to pay the applicant’s costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. the application for judicial review be granted

2. the Tribunal’s decision be set aside and the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for a fresh hearing to be conducted by another Tribunal member

3. the respondent pay the applicant’s costs

Note: Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant's claims were set out in an interview with a departmental officer on 4 February 1997 (departmental interview), written submissions to both the department and the Tribunal, and oral evidence presented to the Tribunal at hearings on 27 April (first hearing) and 24 July 1998 (second hearing). The submissions were made in four statements or statutory declarations, respectively dated 25 November 1996 (first statement), 19 February 1997 (second statement), 26 May 1998 (third statement) and 6 August 1998 (fourth statement). His case was that he fears returning to Sri Lanka because he will be persecuted, even killed, either by the LTTE or government authorities, each suspecting him of association with the other. The application for asylum was rejected by the Tribunal on the basis of factual inconsistencies in his evidence, stemming from his oral and written statements. The Court has often stated that rejections of credibility of applicants by an inquisitorial tribunal require close scrutiny to determine their correctness in law. Although in legal theory if a tribunal of fact misinterprets evidence given, or comes to unreasoned or unreasonable conclusions about it, it may make an error of law, it will ordinarily be the materiality to the decision and the overall impact of any misinterpretations or unavailable conclusions in a particular case that will determine whether there has been such legal error as to require an order of review. The applicant’s lawyer argued that if there are discrepancies in his evidence it is understandable in light of his age and ill health, but that the majority of the alleged discrepancies are not discrepancies at all and therefore the finding of lack of credibility is not sustainable. It might have been added that it would be surprising if there were no inconsistencies in as many different efforts to present a case as occurred here.Undisputed Facts Some facts were undisputed and were apparently accepted by the Tribunal. The applicant is a seventy-eight year old retired medical practitioner, born in the Jaffna region in 1921. His wife is of a similar age. Their first language is Tamil. They have two daughters living in Australia and one son living in the United States. The applicant has a sister living in Germany. He studied medicine in Colombo, his language of instruction being English. He is able to speak, read and write English and the Tribunal's file contains several letters of the applicant, handwritten in English. At the hearings before the Tribunal the applicant was able to answer, in Tamil or English, before most questions were translated, and to correct some perceived imperfections in the translation. The applicant understands Sinhalese to some extent and was able to manage with Sinhalese patients, but does not speak the language fluently. The applicant practised medicine with the Sri Lankan Department of Health Services for more than 30 years, serving in different regions of the country. From 1943 he spent five years in the Hill Country in the Central province after which he went to the Kandy district for another five years. In 1953 he went to the Ratnapura district and then to the Eastern province until 1963. Between 1963 and 1966 he practised in the Badulla district and then again in the Ratnapura district from 1966. In 1971 the applicant was transferred to his home district of Point Pedro near Jaffna where he worked until his retirement in 1976 when he opened a private medical practice. (Jaffna is the name of a region/province as well as of its main town or city. In the course of this matter hitherto, the name has been used indiscriminately to describe both. Point Pedro is in the Jaffna region.) On 23 May 1996 the applicant and his wife left for Australia.Other claims of the applicant

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In its reasons for decision the Tribunal identified eight factors which led to its rejection of the applicant's evidence:1. Misleading evidence given to the Department The Tribunal held:… that in relation to his evidence to the Department concerning his pension and the security situation in Point Pedro the applicant was attempting to give misleading evidence which would raise concerns about whether it would be reasonable for the applicant to return to Jaffna/Point Pedro or otherwise relocate.The explanation for this finding was as follows:The applicant told the Department on 4 February 1997 that he was not receiving a pension. When he was pressed on this at the interview, the applicant claimed that he was not receiving it because his papers had been misplaced in his move from Jaffna to Trincomalee. He was receiving a pension in Jaffna. He claims that it was stopped. However the applicant told the Tribunal that in fact he did receive a pension.At the hearing the Tribunal asked the applicant why he had told the Department that Point Pedro had not been cleared of the LTTE. He replied that he did not say that it had not been captured. However in fact the applicant had told the Department that the LTTE has taken the house and everything and had denied that Point Pedro had been taken over by the Government.These matters require separate consideration.Pension In my view, the Tribunal's primary conclusion on the issue of the pension has no foundation in the evidence and its determination that the applicant was attempting to mislead the Department was quite unsupported by evidence. An extract of the departmental interview was tendered at the hearing. On the pension issue, it recorded:Q:Are you on a pension right now?A:No.Q:You’re not receiving a pension?A:No.Q:Don’t you receive a pension now? Ex public servants receive pensions?A:But now because I shifted away from Point Pedro to Trincomalee I left my papers I misplaced or something I not receive.Q:Are you sure you’re not receiving because as far as I know, like if you originally received a pension while you were in … Were you receiving a pension while you were in Jaffna?A:Yes yes.Q:Alright, or Point Pedro. If you shift to another area that pension still goes to Point Pedro.A:Yes.Q:What it means is that the money is still going there it’s just that you’re not there to get the money and if you want to get the money you need to apply for the file to be transferred to say Colombo or another part of the country and then you can receive the pension where you are. So, would it be right to say that you’re probably still receiving the pension … A:… no …Q:… but you just don’t have access to it because you’re not there and you haven’t been able to shift the money to a place …A(INT):Yes I have.INT:You asked him whether he has the right to get that pension? Q:Yes, you have the right to a pension, is that right, and I mean, it’s quite possible to have money going into the bank at Point Pedro you just, I mean you don’t have it it’s been stopped and as far as I know there’s no reason that they would stop it unless you asked them to.A(INT):Once you’ve shifted from one area to another they immediately stopped the … from that day (indistinct). Q:Right so you have to apply to have it transferred to another area is that right?A:Yes that’s right.Q:Okay so you still have access to a pension. I mean you still would have a right to a pension …A:… yes …Q:… it’s really up to you to put the wheels in motion. Alright.

Decision

Reasons for decision

EINFELD J (dissent)
As I read the decision, there is nothing in Cho which would suggest that where major rejections of an applicant’s credibility in the sense of truthfulness on fundamental claims are not raised with the applicant so as to permit an opportunity to argue and state a position might not in particular circumstances represent a breach of section 425. Although referring to it, their Honours did not dissent from the view of Justice Lindgren in Sun that such a breach may amount to a failure to observe a “procedure” under section 476(1)(a).The Tribunal's conclusions The Tribunal determined that the applicant had concocted his “primary claims”. "Concocted" does not mean an accidental mistake or inconsistency; rather it suggests a deliberate colouring of the case. Here it meant in effect lying and fraud about all the major claims made. As far as I can tell from the transcript, the possible concoction of the applicant’s principal claims was never an “issue arising in relation to the decision under review” as provided in section 425 until the Tribunal’s reasons for decision were published. In relation for example to what was agreed on all sides to be the very important question of the applicant’s arrest and detention by Sri Lankan authorities in Trincomalee for two or three days in April 1996 which the Tribunal found to be a lie, ieHe was not detained and he had not been of interests [sic - presumably "interest"] when caught up in the routine security checks in Trincomalee.the delegate accepted that it occurred and that it represented significant criminal and human rights abuse:·I accept that the applicant may have suffered mistreatment and harassment when he was detained and questioned by the Sri Lankan authorities. However, it would not have been unreasonable for the authorities to question the applicant in relation to a criminal act regarding the murder of the village headman. In addition, the applicant was held for a short period of time and then released, and, after, the applicant was able to depart the area, indicating that the authorities did not have a genuine interest in the applicant;·I have taken into account that the applicant was detained at a time of intense civil conflict, when, as part of national security procedures, it would not have been unreasonable for the Sri Lankan authorities to question anyone they suspected as having information about a militant organisation who was endangering the safety of the general population;·In addition, the applicant stated that the officers had detained him in order to extort money from him. Unfortunately, as indicated by Sri Lanka Country Information, extortion is a widespread problem and is not necessarily targeted at any particular ethnic group. The applicant has been a victim of a generalised abuse of authority which has been carried out by members of all Tamil factions as well as members of the Sri Lankan forces. While I acknowledge that the applicant has suffered mistreatment due to persons breaking the law, I find that the extortion demands made of the applicant were disinterestedly individual, and were not done for a Convention reason;·I have taken into account that the applicant may have reasons to fear danger as a victim of generalised civil conflict between militant LTTE rebels and government authorities, particularly in the northern and eastern part of Sri Lanka. However such danger does not necessarily amount to persecution for a Convention related reasonIn other words, the delegate made no adverse finding as to the applicant’s truthfulness on this matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: