R v Miller; R v Presley; R v Smith

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Criminal Appeal)

R v MILLER; R v PRESLEY; R v SMITH

[2017] SASCFC 123

Judgment of The Court of Criminal Appeal

(The Honourable Justice Vanstone, The Honourable Justice Kelly and The Honourable Justice Lovell)

21 September 2017

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - VERDICT UNREASONABLE OR INSUPPORTABLE HAVING REGARD TO EVIDENCE

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON - HOMICIDE - MURDER - INTENTION TO KILL OR CAUSE SERIOUS NON-FATAL INJURY

CRIMINAL LAW - GENERAL MATTERS - CRIMINAL LIABILITY AND CAPACITY - DEFENCE MATTERS - INTOXICATION - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - MURDER

EVIDENCE - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - FUNCTION OF JUDGE AND JURY - SUFFIENCY OF EVIDENCE

The three appellants and another, Betts, were found guilty of murder by a jury following their involvement in a violent altercation in which Betts fatally stabbed the deceased, Hall. The appellants also either pleaded guilty to or were found guilty of aggravated causing harm with intent to cause harm to another man, King. The appellants’ liability for the offences was left to the jury on the basis of either joint criminal enterprise or extended joint criminal enterprise.

The appellants unsuccessfully appealed against their convictions to the Supreme Court of South Australia (Court of Criminal Appeal).  However the High Court allowed the appeals and remitted the proceedings in each case to this Court for determination of a single ground, that the verdicts were unreasonable or could not be supported having regard to the evidence.

Held per Kelly J (Vanstone and Lovell JJ agreeing): allowing the appeal of Miller against conviction for murder.

1.       Having regard to the absence of evidence directly implicating Miller as an assailant and the evidence of his intoxication, it was not open to the jury to conclude beyond reasonable doubt that he was party to more than a plan to cause harm with intent to cause harm.  There was sufficient evidence to prove that Miller must have contemplated that his companions might engage in unlawful and dangerous acts in relation to Hall and King using one or more weapons, and therefore it was open for the jury to conclude that Miller was guilty of the manslaughter of Hall.

The appeal of Miller is allowed.  Miller’s conviction for murder is quashed and a verdict of manslaughter substituted.

Miller’s appeal against conviction for causing harm with intent to cause harm is dismissed.

Held per Kelly J (Vanstone J agreeing, Lovell J contra): dismissing the appeals of Presley and Smith against conviction for murder and Smith’s appeal against causing harm with intent.

2.       It was open to the jury to conclude on the basis of the circumstantial evidence that Presley and Smith, as members of the group who returned to the laneway carrying weapons, joined in the attack on Hall and that they did so with the intention to do at least really serious bodily harm.

Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 11, s 24(1), s 353, referred to.
Miller v R

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Miller; R v Presley; R v Smith and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASCFC 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved appeals by R v Miller, R v Presley, and R v Smith against their convictions for murder. The central dispute concerned whether the verdicts of murder were unsafe and unsatisfactory, given the appellants' levels of intoxication at the time of the offending and the requisite foresight for liability under joint criminal enterprise or extended joint criminal enterprise principles. The appeals were heard by Vanstone, Kelly, and Lovell JJ.

The legal issues before the court were whether the evidence supported the jury's findings of guilt for murder, particularly in light of the appellants' intoxication. This required the court to consider whether it was open to the jury to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt of the appellants' guilt, or if the evidence compelled a doubt. Specifically, the court had to assess if the appellants foresaw that death or grievous bodily harm might be occasioned by a co-venturer acting with murderous intent, and if they continued to participate in the criminal enterprise with that awareness.

The court applied the principles established in *Libke v The Queen*, which states that an appellate court must consider whether the jury *must*, as distinct from *might*, have entertained a doubt about the appellant's guilt. The court found that while there was evidence suggesting Mr Smith may have struck Mr Hall, it was not open to the jury to conclude that Mr Smith acted with murderous intent, as the injuries inflicted were not severe and the evidence regarding his actions was inconsistent. The court also noted the lack of evidence that Mr Smith was aware of a knife being used by another co-venturer.

Consequently, the court dismissed the appeals of Mr Smith and Mr Presley. However, the appeal of Mr Miller against his conviction for murder was allowed. His conviction for murder was quashed and substituted with a conviction for manslaughter. Mr Miller's appeal against his conviction in respect of a second count was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Arising from that ground of appeal, a key issue is whether the levels of intoxication experienced by each of the appellants at the time of the offending was such as to render the verdicts unsafe, in light of the requisite foresight required for liability on the basis of joint criminal enterprise, or extended joint criminal enterprise.Background It is necessary to set out the circumstances of the offending generally, and in relation to each appellant in some detail.Prior to the offending It is common ground that the attack on King and Hall occurred just before 11.00 pm on 12 December 2012 at Grant Street, Elizabeth Park. Hall and King, both of whom lived on Grant Street, were assaulted by a group of males of Aboriginal appearance who had come from 33 Hayles Road, Elizabeth Park, a short distance away. In the hours prior to the attack, a number of people including the appellants and Betts had been drinking together at 33 Hayles Road, Presley’s home. During the evening, Betts, Presley and Presley’s girlfriend left to obtain some marijuana while Smith and Miller remained. As Betts, Presley and Presley’s girlfriend were returning to Hayles Road, Betts paused to urinate against the fence by 12 Grant Street. Hall and King were conversing on the front porch of King’s house at 13 Grant Street. At some stage King became aware that Hall had left the front of his house and was in a laneway (between 10 and 12 Grant Street) talking to two Aboriginal males, Betts and Presley. Hall approached Betts and Presley at the entrance of the laneway and told them not to urinate on the street. Hall was joined by a number of his neighbours, and Presley indicated that he was looking to buy cannabis. Hall indicated that he did not want that behaviour in the street either. There were raised voices and abuse between Betts’ group and Hall including, on some accounts, racial slurs against Betts and Presley by Hall and one of his neighbours. Betts was punched to the mouth and suffered a split lip, and Hall was seen to push either Betts or Presley. Betts and Presley left and returned to 33 Hayles Road. A prosecution witness, Mr Willis, who was at Hayles Road estimated that Betts, Presley and Presley’s girlfriend were gone for an hour and a half, at most. On the group’s return, Betts told others that he had been struck by “three white fellas” who had jumped him in the alleyway. His lip was split and bleeding. Presley said “Let’s go back and see what these people – go and see what the problem is”. Mr Willis said that he saw Betts, Presley, Smith and Miller leave together on foot from the Hayles Road house. Presley had a baseball bat. Mr Willis followed the group in his car and saw the appellants and Betts go into the laneway. He then drove back to Presley’s home.The attack The group of men from Grant Street were still gathered near the entrance of the laneway when the appellants and Betts returned. Witnesses gave varying estimates of the time that elapsed between the first incident between Hall, Betts and Presley and the attack at just before 11.00 pm, ranging from three minutes to 20 minutes.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

VANSTONE J KELLY J
For these reasons I would dismiss the appeal of Smith. Conclusion For the reasons I have given I would dismiss the appeals of both Presley Smith. I would allow the appeal of Miller against his conviction for murder. I would quash his conviction for murder and substitute instead a conviction for manslaughter. I would dismiss Miller’s appeal against conviction in respect of count 2. A jury found the appellants guilty of murder. On appeal the appellants submitted that the verdicts of murder were unreasonable as the verdicts were unsupported by the evidence. The prosecution case alleged each appellant was guilty of murder on the basis that they were party to an agreement to commit a crime, namely assault, and foresaw that death or grievous bodily harm might be occasioned by a co-venturer, acting with a murderous intent and that he, with that awareness, continued to participate in the agreed criminal enterprise. The question for this Court is whether, on the whole of the evidence, it was open to the jury to be persuaded beyond reasonable doubt of the appellant’s guilt.[13] In Libke v The Queen[14] Hayne J, with whom Gleeson CJ and Heydon J agreed, said that the question for an appellate court in determining whether it was open to a jury to be satisfied of guilt beyond reasonable doubt involves consideration of whether the jury must, as distinct from might, have entertained a doubt about the appellant’s guilt.[15] Hayne J said:[16]It is clear that the evidence that was adduced at the trial did not all point to the appellant’s guilt on this first count. But the question for an appellate court is whether it was open to the jury to be satisfied of guilt beyond reasonable doubt, which is to say whether the jury must, as distinct from might, have entertained a doubt about the appellant’s guilt. It is not sufficient to show that there was material which might have been taken by the jury to be sufficient to preclude satisfaction of guilt to the requisite standard.[13] The Queen v Nguyen (2010) 242 CLR 491 at [33] (Hayne, Heydon, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ). See also SKA v The Queen (2011) 243 CLR 400 at [405] – [406] (French CJ, Gummow and Kiefel JJ).[14] (2007) 230 CLR 559.[15] (2007) 230 CLR 559 at [596]–[597].[16] Libke v The Queen (2007) 230 CLR 559 at [113]. It was open to the jury to conclude that Mr Smith hit Mr Hall on the back of the head but that it was not a blow that caused Mr Hall to lose consciousness or indeed even fall to ground. The evidence, if accepted, demonstrated that after being hit on the back of the head Mr Hall ran off. There was some evidence that Mr Smith may have hit Mr Hall in the stomach with the shovel at a later time. That evidence was inconsistent and unreliable. The events themselves provide definition about the intention of Mr Smith. He had in his hands an item which could have caused very serious injuries. He did not however inflict any. It was, in my view not open to the jury to conclude that Mr Smith himself acted with murderous intent. It was open to the jury to conclude that Mr Smith saw Mr Presley with the baseball bat. The evidence was inconclusive as to when and from where Mr Smith obtained the shovel. There was no evidence that he saw Mr Betts with a knife.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: VANSTONE J, KELLY J

Full text does not contain this section.