R v Michael Phillip Martin; R v Candace Martin

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: R v Michael Phillip Martin; R v Candace Martin [2017] NSWSC 1106
Hearing dates:3, 22 August 2017
Date of orders: 22 August 2017
Decision date: 22 August 2017
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Hamill J
Decision:

1. The evidence of the letter and the text message in response is not admissible as an admission by Candace Martin.
2. The evidence of Candace Martin’s attempt to retrieve the letter and her lies in relation to the letter are admissible to prove a consciousness of guilt.
3. Order that Candace Martin be tried separately to Michael Phillip Martin.

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – evidence – admission by silence – tacit admission – husband and wife accused of murdering husband’s father – whether failure of wife to rebut inference in husband’s letter that she was involved evidence of an admission – where letter long and discursive – circumstances where silence may constitute an admission – where wife attempts to retrieve letter – where wife lies to police about knowledge of letter – evidence not admissible as an admission – admissible in different form to establish consciousness of guilt

  CRIMINAL LAW – separate trial application – where evidence of letter excluded as admission – letter to be considered by jury on different bases in case against each accused – where accused jointly charged – where substantial body of evidence admissible against both accused – where large parts of evidence not to be disputed by applicant for separate trial – where other evidence to be admitted against one accused only – where case against co-accused stronger than case against applicant for separate trial – whether accused embarrassed or prejudiced in conduce of defence – interests of justice
Legislation Cited: Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW)
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Gilbert v The Queen [2000] HCA 15; 201 CLR 414
Guimond v. The Queen (1979) 44 CCC (2d) 481
Mundey v Askin [1982] 2 NSWLR 369
R v Freeman, unreported NSWCCA 18/12/86
R v Grills (1910) 11 CLR 400; [1910] HCA 68
R v Middis and Ors, unreported SC (NSW), 27 March 1991
R v MMJ [2006] VSCA 226
R v Pham [2004] NSWCCA 190
R v Roff [2015] NSWSC 1853
R v Simmons; R v Moore (No 4) [2015] NSWSC 259
Redman v R [2015] NSWCCA 110
Symss v R [2003] NSWCCA 77
Thatcher v Charles (1961) 104 CLR 57 [1961] HCA 5
The Queen v Darby (1982) 148 CLR 668; [1982] HCA 32
Woon v The Queen (1964) 109 CLR 529 [1964] HCA 23 at 541
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Regina
M P Martin
C Martin
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr B G Campbell (Crown)
Mr G D Wendler (M P Martin)
Mr S Healy (C Martin)

  Solicitors:
Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown)
Stuart Percy & Associates (M P Martin)
Universal Law (C Martin)
File Number(s):2015/00078236; 2015/00120687 (M P Martin)2015/00104796 (C Martin)

Judgment

  1. Michael Phillip Martin and Candace Martin stand jointly charged on an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Michael Phillip Martin; R v Candace Martin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NSWSC 1106
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, Michael Phillip Martin and Candace Martin, were charged with the murder of the former's father. Both accused sought a separate trial on the basis that the evidence against them was disparate, and that the case against Michael was stronger. The evidence against both accused included a letter from Michael to Candace, which was a lengthy and discursive account of the events of the day of the murder. The letter included an inference that Candace was complicit in the murder. Candace did not rebut this inference in the letter, and attempted to retrieve the letter from police. The couple was subsequently arrested, and Candace lied to police about her knowledge of the letter. The trial judge excluded the letter as an admission by silence but admitted it as evidence of consciousness of guilt. Michael appealed against his conviction, and Candace sought a separate trial. The court was required to determine whether the evidence of the letter was admissible as an admission by silence, and whether Candace was prejudiced in the conduct of her defence by the joint trial. The court held that the evidence of the letter was not admissible as an admission by silence, as the letter was long and discursive, and the silence did not occur in circumstances where it could be considered a tacit admission. However, the evidence was admissible as evidence of consciousness of guilt. The court also held that Candace was not prejudiced in the conduct of her defence by the joint trial, as there was a substantial body of evidence admissible against both accused, and the case against Candace was not significantly stronger than the case against Michael. The interests of justice were best served by a joint trial.

Michael's appeal against his conviction was dismissed. Candace's application for a separate trial was also dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Michael Phillip Martin and Candace Martin were jointly charged with the murder of Michael's father, Raymond Martin. The prosecution's evidence included a letter written by Michael to Candace, which the prosecution argued reflected her involvement in the murder. Candace did not rebut the inference in the letter that she was involved in the crime. During the investigation, Candace attempted to retrieve the letter and subsequently lied to police about her knowledge of the letter's content. The letter was excluded from evidence as an admission by silence but was still considered by the jury on different grounds to establish consciousness of guilt.

The matter came before the court on a separate trial application by Candace Martin. The application was to exclude the letter as evidence of an admission by silence. The court considered the application alongside substantial evidence against both accused, which included other admissions and statements made by both parties. The court had to determine whether Candace would be prejudiced in her defence if tried jointly with Michael, given the stronger case against her compared to Michael.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Candace Martin's failure to rebut the inference in Michael Martin's letter that she was involved in the murder constitutes an admission of guilt.
2. Whether Candace Martin's silence regarding her knowledge and attempts to retrieve the letter can be considered as an admission by silence.
3. Whether Candace Martin's lies to police about her knowledge of the letter's content can be considered as an admission by silence.
4. Whether the interests of justice require a separate trial for Candace Martin despite the exclusion of the letter as an admission.

Held
1. The court concluded that Candace Martin's failure to rebut the inference in Michael Martin's letter that she was involved in the murder does not constitute an admission of guilt.
2. The court ruled that Candace Martin's silence regarding her knowledge and attempts to retrieve the letter cannot be considered as an admission by silence.
3. The court found that Candace Martin's lies to the police about her knowledge of the letter's content cannot be considered as an admission by silence.
4. The court decided that the interests of justice do not require a separate trial for Candace Martin, despite the exclusion of the letter as an admission.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the principles surrounding admissions by silence and tacit admissions, particularly in the context of a joint trial of husband and wife accused of murder. In addressing whether Candace Martin's failure to rebut the inference in Michael Martin's letter constituted an admission of guilt, the court held that the failure to rebut such an inference does not automatically translate into an admission of guilt. The court emphasised the importance of the specific circumstances and context of the silence, including the nature and content of the letter, in determining whether there is an admission. In considering whether Candace Martin's silence regarding her knowledge and attempts to retrieve the letter could be considered an admission by silence, the court found that silence alone does not equate to an admission unless there is a clear duty to speak, which was not present in this case. The court also held that Candace Martin's lies to the police about her knowledge of the letter's content do not constitute an admission by silence, as the lies themselves were not admissions of guilt. Finally, regarding the application for a separate trial, the court found that while the evidence of the letter was excluded as an admission, it could still be considered by the jury on different bases in the case against each accused. The court concluded that the interests of justice did not require a separate trial for Candace Martin, as there was a substantial body of admissible evidence against both accused, and the evidence against Candace Martin was not significantly prejudiced by being tried jointly with her husband. The ratio decidendi of this case is that silence or failure to rebut an inference does not automatically constitute an admission of guilt, and the specific context and circumstances must be considered. Additionally, the court's decision not to order a separate trial highlights the importance of the strength of the evidence against the accused and the potential for prejudice in determining the interests of justice.