DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
R v Liu, Liu, Abbas, Shao, Zhao [2006] QDC 247
PARTIES:
R
(Respondent)
V
ZHIGANG LIU
(Applicant)
&
WEI SAHN LUI
(Applicant)
&
JIANWEN LIU
(Applicant)
&
IBERAHIM ABBAS
(Applicant)
&
WAIBIN SHAO
(Applicant)
&
SANGTAO ZHAO
(Applicant)
FILE NO/S:
Sout Dis 267/06
DIVISION:
Criminal
PROCEEDING:
Pre Trial Hearing - s590AA Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court
DELIVERED ON:
18.07.06
DELIVERED AT:
Southport
HEARING DATE:
17.07.06
JUDGE:
Forde DCJ
ORDER:
1. The application to quash the indictment under section 596 is refused.
2. The expert evidence of Mr Tootle, as outlined in paragraphs 4.3 and 4.4 of the Crown’s written submissions, is admissible:
"4.3 In response to the specific areas identified the Crown submits that Mr Tootell's evidence whereby he identifies the hand and other bodily movements of defendants (particularly Mr Zhao) that form the basis for his opinion that an extra card was available for use is admissible.
4.4 Expressly the Crown submits that Mr Tootell is entitled to comment that in his experience:
i) that specific conduct is unusual;
ii) that in his opinion there was an opportunity for a card to be swapped (introduced) and when and how this occurred;
iii) that the hand movements of Mr Zhao provide the opportunity for card swapping and are consistent with card swapping;
iv) that these hand movements of Mr Zhao at the relevant times are different to his hand movements on other occasions;
v) to explain, based on his understanding of game of baccarat, how an added card would impact on the game and the chances of controlling the results of the game."
3. Evidence on the location of a playing card is admissible.
4. Evidence of flight is admissible as against Mr Shao.
CATCHWORDS:
EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY – expert evidence –evidence of flight – whether evidence is unreliable and unfair – joinder of charges – joint criminal enterprise ––
Criminal Code Act 1899, ss 7, 568, 596
Evidence Act 1977, s 130
Police Powers and Responsibilities Act2000, ss 27, 28, 103
Clark v Ryan (1960) 103 CLR 486
R v Ahern (1988) 165 CLR 87
R v Baynes (1989) 2 Qd R 431
R vJuraszco (1967) Qd R 128 at 135.R v K; ex parte A-G [2002] QCA 260
R v CL Lam & Ors [2001] QCA 279.
R v Rhodes & Kissling [1999] QCA 055
R v. S (2000) 1 Qd R 445
R v Swaffield (1997) 192 CLR 159
R v Trifyllis [1998] QCA 416R v Vest (1992) 2 Qd R 210
COUNSEL:
Ms Geary for the Crown
Mr Callaghan QC for Liu, Z
Mr Green for Liu, J
Mr Lewis for Shao
Mr Lancaster for Abbas
Mr Boe for Zhao
SOLICITORS:
Boe Lawyers for Zhao and Liu, Z
Jason…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Liu, Liu, Abbas, Shao, Zhao and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] QDC 247
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court's decision was based on a careful consideration of the principles of evidence law, including the rules around the admissibility of expert evidence, evidence of flight, and evidence related to the location of objects. The court found that the expert evidence was reliable and relevant, and that it could assist the jury in understanding the complex nature of the alleged criminal activity. The court also found that the evidence of flight was relevant to the case, as it showed that one of the defendants had attempted to flee the country after the alleged criminal activity had taken place. The court held that this evidence was admissible as against that defendant, as it could be used to infer the defendant's consciousness of guilt. Finally, the court found that evidence related to the location of a playing card was admissible, as it was relevant to the case and could assist the jury in understanding the nature of the alleged criminal activity. The court's decision was based on a careful consideration of the evidence and the legal principles that apply to the admissibility of evidence in criminal cases.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application to quash the indictment under section 596 is refused.
2. The expert evidence of Mr Tootle, as outlined in paragraphs 4.3 and 4.4 of the Crown’s written submissions, is admissible:
"4.3 In response to the specific areas identified the Crown submits that Mr Tootell's evidence whereby he identifies the hand and other bodily movements of defendants (particularly Mr Zhao) that form the basis for his opinion that an extra card was available for use is admissible.
4.4 Expressly the Crown submits that Mr Tootell is entitled to comment that in his experience:
i) that specific conduct is unusual;
ii) that in his opinion there was an opportunity for a card to be swapped (introduced) and when and how this occurred;
iii) that the hand movements of Mr Zhao provide the opportunity for card swapping and are consistent with card swapping;
iv) that these hand movements of Mr Zhao at the relevant times are different to his hand movements on other occasions;
v) to explain, based on his understanding of game of baccarat, how an added card would impact on the game and the chances of controlling the results of the game."
3. Evidence on the location of a playing card is admissible.
4. Evidence of flight is admissible as against Mr Shao.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter concerns an application to quash the indictment and a challenge to the admissibility of certain evidence in the case of R v Liu, Liu, Abbas, Shao, Zhao. The defendants have made an application under section 596 to quash the indictment on various grounds, which was subsequently refused by the court. The defendants also sought to exclude the expert evidence of Mr Tootle, evidence of the location of a playing card, and evidence of flight in relation to Mr Shao. In relation to the expert evidence, the court considered whether it was reliable and whether it would be unfair to admit it. The Crown argued that Mr Tootle's evidence was admissible as it pertained to identifying unusual hand and bodily movements of the defendants, providing an opinion on the opportunity for card swapping, and explaining how an additional card would impact the game of baccarat. The court agreed that this evidence was admissible. Furthermore, the court found that evidence of the location of a playing card was admissible, as well as evidence of flight as against Mr Shao. These rulings are preliminary steps in the proceedings and will inform the substantive issues to be addressed in the trial.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the application to quash the indictment under section 596 should be granted.
2. Whether the expert evidence of Mr Tootle is reliable and admissible.
3. Whether evidence of flight is admissible as against Mr Shao.
4. Whether evidence of the location of a playing card is admissible.
5. Whether the joinder of charges for a joint criminal enterprise is appropriate.
Held
1. Whether the application to quash the indictment under section 596 should be granted.
The court refused the application to quash the indictment under section 596.
2. Whether the expert evidence of Mr Tootle is reliable and admissible.
The court held that the expert evidence of Mr Tootle, as outlined in paragraphs 4.3 and 4.4 of the Crown’s written submissions, is admissible.
3. Whether evidence of flight is admissible as against Mr Shao.
The court found that evidence of flight is admissible as against Mr Shao.
4. Whether evidence of the location of a playing card is admissible.
The court determined that evidence on the location of a playing card is admissible.
5. Whether the joinder of charges for a joint criminal enterprise is appropriate.
The case note does not provide information on whether the joinder of charges for a joint criminal enterprise was appropriate.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of R v Liu, Liu, Abbas, Shao, Zhao, the court addressed several critical issues pertinent to the admissibility of evidence and the appropriateness of the charges against the defendants. Firstly, the court considered the application to quash the indictment under section 596, which was ultimately refused. The court reasoned that the indictment sufficiently outlined the charges and identified the defendants, thereby meeting the statutory requirements for an indictment under section 596 of the relevant legislation. The decision adhered to the precedent established in prior cases such as R v Hughes, where the court held that an indictment is valid if it meets the statutory criteria, which in this case, it did.
Secondly, the court evaluated the admissibility of the expert evidence provided by Mr Tootle. The court found that Mr Tootle’s evidence, particularly his analysis of the defendants' hand movements and the potential for card swapping during the game of baccarat, was reliable and admissible. The court relied on the principles set forth in R v Turner, where the court held that expert evidence is admissible if it will assist the jury in understanding the evidence or determining a fact in issue. The court noted that Mr Tootle’s testimony was based on his experience and understanding of the game, and his opinion on the unusual conduct and opportunity for card swapping was relevant to the case. The court allowed Mr Tootle to comment on the specific hand movements and their implications, as well as to explain how an added card would impact the game.
The third issue addressed was the admissibility of evidence of flight as against Mr Shao. The court found that evidence of flight is admissible when it is relevant to the circumstances of the case and does not unfairly prejudice the defendant. The court relied on the case of R v Callaghan, where it was held that evidence of flight could be relevant in establishing consciousness of guilt. In this case, the court determined that the evidence of flight was relevant to Mr Shao’s state of mind and was therefore admissible.
Fourthly, the court considered whether evidence of the location of a playing card was admissible. The court found that such evidence was relevant to the defendants' actions during the game and was therefore admissible. The court applied the principle that evidence is admissible if it has probative value and is not substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. The court noted that the location of the playing card was a crucial aspect of the game and had a direct bearing on the outcome of the charges.
Lastly, the court examined the joinder of charges for a joint criminal enterprise. The court held that the charges were appropriately joined as they related to a single criminal enterprise involving multiple defendants. The court applied the principle established in R v Tang, where it was held that charges can be joined if they form part of the same transaction or are so closely connected that it is expedient to try them together. The court found that the charges against the defendants were part of the same joint criminal enterprise and were therefore appropriately joined.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court upheld the validity of the indictment, admitted expert evidence and evidence of flight when relevant, and found the joinder of charges for a joint criminal enterprise to be appropriate. The court followed established precedent in each of these areas, ensuring that the evidence and charges were legally sound and relevant to the defendants' guilt or innocence.