R v Hill No. Sccrm-99-129 Judgment No. S359

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

R v HILL
[1999] SASC 359

Court of Criminal Appeal:  Millhouse, Duggan and Lander JJ

1 MILLHOUSE J.  Appeal from conviction for murder.
2 The appellant in the course of a domestic argument with his wife shot her in the forehead at short range with a revolver.
3 His daughter, Sharon Tytler (whom the Crown called) gave evidence that he was at the time talking to her on the telephone - or rather each was yelling at the other over the telephone - when he said, "I've shot her.  I've shot her."  Earlier in the call Miss Tytler had heard "Joan" her father's wife, talking in the background.
4 There are a number of grounds of appeal complaining of the summing up not sufficiently or appropriately putting the defence case, of the directions on voluntariness, provocation and self defence and so on.  There is one other ground, though, not at all connected with the conduct of the hearing which is quite decisive.
5 According to an affidavit which we received without opposition from Mr Paul Rofe QC, the Director of Public Prosecutions, Miss Tytler had, between 1984 and 1990 run "Cleopatra's" brothel at Norwood.  Nothing particularly remarkable about that.  It didn't come out during the trial, nor was it relevant to the issues.
6 Unfortunately, however one of the jurors, No. 143, had been a client!  He actually was the foreman of the jury!
7 These are paragraphs from the affidavit:-
"7.  The brothel staff had an arrangement with taxi drivers in Adelaide that when a driver introduced a customer to the brothel he would be paid a 'spotter's' fee of five or ten dollars.  That would be in addition to the taxi fare.

  1. I recognised 'Vass' as one of the taxi drivers that used to bring customers to my brothel in Norwood.

  2. Some taxi drivers would take their money immediately, whereas other taxi drivers would build up credit and then come in and see one of the prostitutes.
    10.  I clearly remember 'Vass' attending the brothel on three to four occasions.
    11.  On two occasions I had sexual relations with 'Vass'.
    12.  The man I know as 'Vass' was the Foreman of the jury.
    13.  I joked with my father Ronald Gordon Hill during the trial that I recognised one of the jurors as a taxi driver.  I did not say it seriously and my father did not take me seriously.
    14.  I did not tell my father that I actually knew one of the jurors.
    15.  Several hours after my father was convicted on the 16th June 1999 I telephoned my father's solicitors Mangan Ey & Associates Pty Ltd and spoke to Mr Heath Barklay about the prospects of appeal and during that conversation I raised whether me knowing 'Vass' was relevant as an appeal point.
    16.  I did not advise my father's legal advisers earlier about 'Vass' as I did not think the matter was important. ..."
    8 We received also affidavits from the appellant and from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Hill No. Sccrm-99-129 Judgment No. S359 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 359
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves an appeal by the appellant against his conviction for the murder of his defacto wife. The appellant claimed that the shooting was accidental, stating that he had cocked the gun to frighten the victim but it went off by accident. The central issue in the appeal was whether the appellant's conviction should be quashed due to an undisclosed relationship between the foreman of the jury and the appellant's daughter, a key prosecution witness. Other issues included whether the trial judge adequately explained the concept of voluntariness to the jury and whether the summing-up appropriately covered the defence case.

The court examined the relationship between the foreman and the appellant's daughter, who had sexual relations with him approximately ten years prior to the trial. The court noted that the foreman did not disclose this relationship and it was only brought to light through an affidavit after the trial. The court applied the test from Webb and Hay v The Queen, considering whether a fair-minded and informed member of the public would have a reasonable apprehension of bias. The court concluded that the relationship and the foreman's knowledge of the witness's past did not necessarily lead to a reasonable apprehension of bias, especially since the witness's credibility was not contested and her evidence supported the appellant's version of events.

Regarding the summing-up, the court acknowledged some initial misdirections by the trial judge but found that subsequent clarifications were sufficient to correct any potential misunderstandings. The court also reviewed other grounds of appeal concerning the summing-up and found them to be without merit.

Ultimately, the court decided to dismiss the appeal, quash the conviction, and order a new trial due to the undisclosed relationship, which created a reasonable apprehension of bias. The court emphasized the importance of impartiality and the appearance of justice in maintaining public confidence in the judicial system.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DUGGAN J LANDER J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DUGGAN J, LANDER J

Full text does not contain this section.