R v Elfar; R v Golding; R v Sander

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

R v Elfar; R v Golding; R v Sander [2017] QCA 149

PARTIES:

In CA No 214 of 2015:

R
v
ELFAR, Terrance
(appellant)

In CA No 215 of 2015:

R
v
GOLDING, Simon Charles
(appellant)

In CA No 211 of 2015:

R
v
SANDER, Holger
(appellant)

FILE NO/S:

CA No 214 of 2015
CA No 215 of 2015
CA No 211 of 2015
SC No 864 of 2011

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Appeals against Conviction

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane – Date of Convictions: 13 August 2015

DELIVERED ON:

11 July 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

13 February 2017

JUDGES:

Gotterson and Morrison and McMurdo JJA
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

In CA No 214 of 2015:

The appeal by Elfar against conviction be dismissed.

In CA No 215 of 2015:

The appeal by Golding against conviction be dismissed.

In CA No 211 of 2015:

The appeal by Sander against conviction be dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – JUDICIAL DISCRETION TO ADMIT OR EXCLUDE EVIDENCE – ILLEGALLY OBTAINED EVIDENCE – where the Australian Federal Police (AFP) received information from the United States Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) that a ship was sailing from South America containing narcotics, and had a planned rendezvous with an Australian vessel, the Mayhem of Eden, at an identified location – where AFP surveillance identified two ships about a quarter of a nautical mile apart near the location identified by the DEA – where the Mayhem of Eden was tracked back to a location at the Scarborough Marina – where two men were observed leaving the vessel, each with a large, heavy duffel bag – where one of the men, Golding, subsequently took the bags into a hire car, which was stopped and searched by the AFP – where the AFP officer cut open the duffel bag and it was found to contain blocks of cocaine – whether the AFP officers suspected, on reasonable grounds, that a thing relevant to an indictable offence was in the car – whether the AFP officers suspected, on reasonable grounds, that it was necessary to exercise the powers under s 3T Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) to prevent the drugs from being concealed, lost or destroyed – where the duffel bag was opened in non-compliance with s 3U Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) because it was cut open without giving the persons apparently in charge of the car the opportunity to open it – whether the evidence of the cocaine found within the car should have been excluded

CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – JUDICIAL DISCRETION TO ADMIT OR EXCLUDE EVIDENCE – ILLEGALLY OBTAINED EVIDENCE – where the Mayhem of Eden was searched, and cocaine seized, pursuant to a warrant – where the appellant contended that the evidence of the search and seizure should have been excluded because of events which preceded it – where members of the AFP Operational…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Elfar; R v Golding; R v Sander and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QCA 149
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The three appellants, Elfar, Golding, and Sander, each challenge their convictions on various grounds, including the admissibility of evidence obtained by the Australian Federal Police (AFP) and the legality of their examination by the Australian Crime Commission (ACC). The court must determine whether the evidence obtained from the car and the vessel Mayhem of Eden should have been excluded due to non-compliance with statutory requirements, whether the examination by the ACC prejudiced the appellants' right to a fair trial, and whether the search and seizure of the Edelweiss was within the Commonwealth's legislative power under the Constitution.

The court examines the legality of the AFP's actions in stopping the car and opening the duffel bag containing cocaine. It considers whether the AFP officers had reasonable grounds to suspect that a thing relevant to an indictable offence was in the car and that it was necessary to exercise their powers under the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) to prevent the drugs from being concealed, lost or destroyed. The court also assesses whether the officers complied with the statutory requirements when they cut open the duffel bag without giving the persons apparently in charge of the car the opportunity to open it. Furthermore, the court scrutinises the legality of the AFP's forced entry and search of the Mayhem of Eden, determining whether the AFP had reasonable suspicion that there were narcotics on the vessel.

The court evaluates the impact of the appellants' compulsory examination by the ACC on their right to a fair trial. It considers whether the unauthorised examination resulted in a miscarriage of justice, as argued by Elfar and Golding, and whether Sander's right to testify in his own defence was prejudiced by the ACC examination.

Finally, the court addresses the constitutional issue of whether the search and seizure of the Edelweiss was within the Commonwealth's legislative power under s 51(xxix) of the Constitution. It examines whether there is a required nexus or connection between Australia and the 'external affairs' which the law seeks to regulate and whether the provisions of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) satisfy any such requirement.

The court concludes that the evidence obtained from the car and the vessel should not have been excluded due to non-compliance with statutory requirements. It finds that the appellants' compulsory examination by the ACC did not result in a miscarriage of justice and did not prejudice their right to a fair trial. Moreover, the court holds that the search and seizure of the Edelweiss was within the Commonwealth's legislative power under s 51(xxix) of the Constitution.

In CA No 214 of 2015: The appeal by Elfar against conviction be dismissed.
In CA No 215 of 2015: The appeal by Golding against conviction be dismissed.
In CA No 211 of 2015: The appeal by Sander against conviction be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

In CA No 214 of 2015:

The appeal by Elfar against conviction be dismissed.

In CA No 215 of 2015:

The appeal by Golding against conviction be dismissed.

In CA No 211 of 2015:

The appeal by Sander against conviction be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

None of the appellants criticises the summing up or argues that the verdict was unreasonable. The verdicts are challenged upon arguments that certain evidence was unlawfully obtained and ought not to have been admitted, that the prosecution did not make proper disclosure and that the indictment ought to have been permanently stayed because, before the trial, the appellants had been compulsorily but unlawfully examined about the relevant events. It is convenient to set out the facts before more precisely describing the grounds of appeal and considering the arguments.The facts On 3 August 2010, a boat called the Edelweiss sailed from Panama City, south to the coast of Ecuador, and then west across the Pacific. By 8 October 2010, it was about 320 nautical miles off the Australian east coast. On 7 October 2010, the Australian Federal Police (AFP) received information that a vessel carrying a large quantity of narcotics was sailing towards Australia in order to meet another vessel, to which it would transfer its cargo at sea. The information was provided by the Drug Enforcement Agency (the DEA), a law enforcement agency of the United States government. The DEA informed the AFP that this rendezvous was expected to occur at a position, defined by certain coordinates, on the evening of 8 October 2010. The DEA subsequently provided an updated expected date and time for the meeting. On the basis of that information, the AFP, together with the Australian Customs and Border Protection Service, conducted surveillance flights in the region of the anticipated rendezvous. On the night of 8 October 2010, one of these aircraft identified two vessels approximately two miles apart and sailing towards each other. At about 2.00 am on the morning of 9 October 2010, an aircraft relocated the two vessels, which were then about a quarter of a nautical mile apart and not far from where they had been seen earlier. Digital imagery identified one of the vessels as a sloop with the name Mayhem of Eden (which I will call the Mayhem). From then, the location of the Mayhem was tracked by the AFP and other agencies as it sailed towards the Australian coast until, early on the morning of 12 October 2010, it was observed entering Moreton Bay and mooring off the Scarborough Marina. On board the Mayhem were the appellants Elfar and Golding. The Mayhem was registered to a company of which Elfar was a director. It had sailed from Port Macquarie in early October 2010, where Elfar had paid for mooring and fuel at the Port Macquarie Marina. At about 7.40 am on the morning of 12 October 2010, Elfar and Golding were seen by AFP and Customs officers leaving the Mayhem in a tender to go to the marina, where they booked a berth. At about 11.00 am, the Mayhem entered the Scarborough boat harbour and tied up at the berth. Half an hour later, Elfar and Golding were observed as they disembarked. Each was carrying a large, heavy duffel bag. They left the marina by taxi, after placing the two bags in the boot, at 11.45 am.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

But Elfar and Golding also argue that their convictions should be quashed upon the basis of their having been required to give evidence before an examiner of the Australian Crime Commission (the ACC), having been already been charged with this offence. These examinations occurred on 22 October 2010 (Golding) and 28 October 2010 (Elfar). In X7 v Australian Crime Commission,[1] it was held that the Australian Crime Commission Act 2002 (Cth) (the ACC Act) did not authorise an examiner to require a person charged with a Commonwealth indictable offence to answer questions about the subject matter of that offence. For Elfar and Golding, it is argued that, irrespective of the strength of the prosecution case, the consequence of those examinations was that there was such a defect in the process of the trial that their convictions resulted from a miscarriage of justice. A related complaint is that the prosecution did not disclose material which was relevant to “the extent to which the content of the ACC hearings had been disseminated” and to a question of “which Customs officers and AFP agents were present at the ACC hearings of each of the appellants”.[1](2013) 248 CLR 92Evidence from the car In a pre-trial ruling, conducted under s 590AA of the Criminal Code (Qld), Ann Lyons J was asked to exclude, relevantly for the present appeals, evidence obtained from the search of the Corolla, evidence obtained from the search of the Mayhem and evidence of the items seized during the search of the Edelweiss. Those and other applications[2] occupied five days, resulting in a reserved judgment delivered in December 2012.[2]A successful application to exclude evidence of information provided by Elfar to an AFP officer and an unsuccessful application to exclude the confession of Serna (then a co-accused). The evidence obtained from the car was challenged on the basis that there had been no power in the AFP officers to stop the car and no power to cut open the bag in which cocaine was then found. Those arguments called for a consideration of the evidence against the powers and requirements prescribed by s 3T and s 3U of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). Section 3T provides as follows:“(1)This section applies if a constable suspects, on reasonable grounds, that:(a)a thing relevant to an indictable offence is in or on a conveyance; and(b)it is necessary to exercise a power under subsection (2) in order to prevent the thing from being concealed, lost or destroyed; and(c)it is necessary to exercise the power without the authority of a search warrant because the circumstances are serious and urgent.(2)The constable may:(a)stop and detain the conveyance; and(b)search the conveyance and any container in or on the conveyance, for the thing; and(c)seize the thing if he or she finds it there.(3)If, in the course of searching for the thing, the constable finds another thing relevant to an indictable offence or a thing relevant to a summary offence, the constable may seize that thing if he or she suspects, on reasonable grounds, that:(a)it is necessary to seize it in order to prevent its concealment, loss or destruction; and(b)it is necessary to seize it without the authority of a search warrant because the circumstances are serious and urgent.(4)The constable must exercise his or her powers subject to section 3U.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

I would order that in CA 211 of 2015, the appeal by Sander against conviction be dismissed.Publication of this judgment On 1 and 29 November 2016, Judges of this Court made orders to facilitate the provision of transcripts of the examinations by the ACC of Elfar and Golding to their lawyers for the purposes of their appeals. On each of those dates it was ordered that an unredacted copy of the ultimate judgments in their appeals be provided to the parties and their lawyers, but that the judgments as published have redacted from them anything which disclosed the content of those transcripts. No similar order was made or sought in Sander’s appeal. As I have discussed, the content of the evidence of Elfar and Golding in their examinations was before this Court when their appeals were argued, but not that of Sander’s evidence to the ACC. The parties were directed to provide written submissions as to whether any such redaction should remain in the published reasons for judgment. The respondent, with the concurrence of the Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission (formerly the ACC), seeks no redaction. Similarly, neither Golding nor Elfar seeks any redaction. In those circumstances, the orders made in their appeals for the redaction of any part of the judgment disclosing the content of their examination transcripts should be set aside. However, the appellant Sander now says that “his name should be redacted from the judgment”. On his behalf it is submitted that the disclosure, within this Court’s reasons for judgment, of the fact of his examination, could become the subject of speculation within the prison community, potentially exposing him to a risk of violence from other prisoners. This submission, which is not the subject of evidence, implies that other prisoners might consider that Sander gave evidence to the ACC which assisted in the prosecution of another offender. As I have discussed above, what Sander said when he was examined by the ACC remains unknown. What is known is that he testified before the ACC only under compulsion and that, as I have noted, he declined to be interviewed by police. More generally, there is nothing which indicates that anything which Sander may have said, when compulsorily examined, provided any assistance in the investigation or prosecution of another offender. The contrary is indicated by the trial judge’s remarks when sentencing Sander. Anyone reading this judgment could not believe that Sander may have cooperated with the authorities in any way, let alone as an informant. The submission for Sander does not refer to any legal impediment to the publication of the judgment in his name. The starting point, of course, is that the ultimate disposition of his prosecution should be a matter of public record and be able to be publicly reported. An order which prohibits that publication should only be made for some established reason. I am unpersuaded that there is such a reason in his case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.