Queensland Alumina Limited v Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Queensland Alumina Limited v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2025] QIRC 182

PARTIES:

Queensland Alumina Limited
Appellant

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
Respondent

CASE NO:

WC/2023/109

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

17 July 2025

HEARING DATES:

27 August 2024

28 August 2024

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Pratt IC

Gladstone

ORDERS:

1.     The appeal is dismissed.

2.     The decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator dated 7 July 2023 is confirmed.

3.    The Appellant is to pay the Respondent's cost of and incidental to the appeal on an agreed basis, and if no agreement can be reached, the parties are to be heard on costs.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – WORKERS' COMPENSATION – APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION REGULATOR – where the appellant appeals decision of the respondent setting aside WorkCover's rejection of and instead accepting a worker's claim for compensation – where key issue is whether the worker's injury arose out of or in the course of employment within the meaning of s 32(1) of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) – where appellant appeals decision on ground that injury did not arise out of, or in the course of, the worker's employment with the appellant – where, alternatively, appellant appeals decision on ground that injury was an exacerbation or aggravation of a pre-existing injury – where medical evidence showed that injury was a bucket handle meniscal tear – where medical evidence disputes whether the mechanism of injury compatible with pathology – consideration of s 32 of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) – where appellant argues that the injury could not have occurred during employment or been caused by the employment – where the respondent argues that the injury was one that did occur during employment and was caused by the employment – held that medical evidence consistent with the worker's evidence – held that worker's injury was a personal injury arising out of, or in the course of, employment – appeal dismissed.

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) s 531

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) s 32

Evans v The Queen (2007) 235 CLR 52

Gold Coast City Council v Simon Blackwood(Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2015] QIRC 125

Gardiner v Land Agents Board (1976) 12 SASR 458

Goldsmith v Sandilands (2002) 190 ALR 370

IMM v The Queen (2016) 257 CLR 300

King v Workers' Compensation Regulator (2019) 290 IR 380

Kostas v HIA Insurance Services Pty Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 390

Leigh v State of Queensland (Department of Education) [2025] QIRC 023

Leighton Contractors Pty Limited AND Q-COMP [2011] QIRComm 127

Polizzi v Commissioner of Police [No 2] [2017] WASC 166

Poochi and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [1979] AATA 64

QR Limited AND Q-COMP [2011] QIRComm 102

Rimland v State of Queensland (Department of Communities, Disability Services and Seniors) [2022] ICQ 9

R v War Pensions Entitlement Appeal Tribunal; Ex parte Bott (1933) 50 CLR 228

Self and Bishop…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland Alumina Limited v Workers' Compensation Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QIRC 182
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Queensland Alumina Limited appealed against a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator, which had confirmed a worker's claim for compensation. The primary issue was whether the worker's injury, a bucket handle meniscal tear, arose out of or in the course of employment. The appellant argued that the injury did not occur during employment and was not caused by the employment, or alternatively, that the injury was an exacerbation of a pre-existing condition. The respondent contended that the injury was a personal injury arising out of, or in the course of, the worker's employment.

The court considered the medical evidence provided by two orthopaedic surgeons, Dr Cooke and Dr Wheatley. Dr Cooke opined that it was highly unlikely that the worker's described mechanism of injury could result in the observed pathology, as such injuries typically occur secondary to a significant traumatic event and are usually accompanied by immediate and severe symptoms. In contrast, Dr Wheatley's evidence suggested that the injury could have occurred during employment and the displacement of the torn meniscus might have happened later, possibly due to a minor incident such as getting into bed.

The court found that the medical evidence was consistent with the worker's account of the events, and that the injury was indeed a personal injury arising out of, or in the course of, employment. The court concluded that the worker's claim for compensation was valid and dismissed the appeal.

The court further noted that Dr Cooke's conclusion was based on an incorrect assumption that the meniscus both tore and displaced simultaneously, while Dr Wheatley's evidence considered the possibility that the meniscus became displaced after it was torn. The court found Dr Wheatley's evidence more reliable and persuasive, as it aligned with the worker's symptoms and timeline of events.

The court ordered that the appeal be dismissed, the decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator be confirmed, and the appellant pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator dated 7 July 2023 is confirmed.

3. The Appellant is to pay the Respondent's cost of and incidental to the appeal on an agreed basis, and if no agreement can be reached, the parties are to be heard on costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 8 May 2023, Mr Johnston applied for a review of WorkCover's decision and made submissions as to that application on 22 June 2023.[65] Then, on 17 July 2023, Dr Wheatley wrote to Dr Davari that:As you know, he was down in a ditch and was lifting heavy implements. When he extricated himself from the ditch, he felt something go in his right knee and had immediate pain.[66][65] ASOFC (n 3) paragraph 5(g)-(h); RSOFC (n 3) paragraph 22.[66] ASOFC (n 3) paragraph 5(i); RSOFC (n 3) paragraph 22.Medical evidence The medical evidence in this matter confirmed that a "bucket handle meniscal tear" resulted from a tear in the meniscus. Viewed from above, the meniscus is a C-shaped piece of cartilage inside the knee joint.[67] There are different ways that the meniscus can be torn. In layman's terms, a bucket handle tear of the meniscus is where a vertical tear around the base of the C-shape is long enough so that it becomes circumferential and a section becomes loose, but still attached at each end of the tear.[68] When that section becomes "displaced" from the rest of the meniscus it turns the C-shaped meniscus into something that resembles a bucket with the handle lifted away, with the torn section of meniscus being the 'handle' of the bucket.[69] This is the relevant part of an illustrative diagram that was received into evidence, as shown below in Figure 1: [67] T 1-7, ll 10-13.[68] T 1-7, ll 38-48; T 1-8, ll 1-8.[69] T 1-8, ll 5-7; T 2-36, ll 22-24; Photo 1 of Document 2 of the bundle tendered as Exhibit #1. Two orthopaedic surgeons gave evidence. Dr Cameron Cooke was called by the Appellant and Dr David Wheatley was called by the Respondent. In summary, Dr Cooke's opinion was that it was highly unlikely that walking across a floor would result in a bucket handle meniscal tear and that Mr Johnston's stated mechanism of injury is not compatible with the pathology.[70] As the Respondent observed in its submissions, Dr Cooke's opinion was that a displaced bucket-handle tear was an acute injury which occurs secondary to a significant traumatic event to the knee; that it is a substantial tear, which is typically a sports injury or seen in trauma patients after a high-energy injury.[71] Dr Cooke opined that such an injury would make it unlikely that Mr Johnston could have gone on to finish his shift in the manner described due to pain, inflammation and a lack of mobility to the joint.[72] It was on that basis that Dr Cooke's opinion was that the description Mr Johnston gave was very unlikely to have been the mechanism of injury.[70] T 1-10, ll 29-46; T 1-11, ll 1-8; T 1-13, ll 41-46; T 1-14, ll 19-26; T 1-15, 39-47; T 1-16, ll 28-47; T 1-17, ll 7-11.[71] T 1-10, ll 29-42; T 1-11, ll 3-16.[72] T 1-10, ll 39-41; T 1-13, ll 13-31. However, as the Respondent observes, Dr Cooke used the word "usually" in his report to describe how quickly the onset of symptoms like pain and immobility would be experienced in an injury like this. The Respondent noted that Dr Cooke conceded in cross examination that the word "typically" was perhaps more appropriate than "usually" because “in medicine nothing is 100 percent”.[73] Although making that concession, appropriately in my view, Dr Cooke maintained the opinion that it would be extremely unlikely that Mr Johnston's bucket handle tear injury occurred as Mr Johnston described it.[74] [73] T 1-12 ll 34-47; T 1-13 l 1; T 1-13 ll 32-33.[74] T 1-15, ll 39-47; T 1-16, ll 1-8.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The only real conclusion that I can draw from the evidence is that Mr Johnston tore his meniscus during his shift between 8 and 9 March 2023 and then the torn segment of the meniscus displaced sometime after finishing work but before the next shift on 9 March 2023. The evidence proves that Mr Johnston was able to work after experiencing the 'pop', albeit with some pain, and then later had considerable pain and immobility after waking up the next day. Such symptoms are consistent with the medical evidence before me. That is, that a bucket handle meniscus tear, where the meniscus initially tears but is not displaced, causing mild pain with minimal effect on mobility at the time, only causes considerable pain and immobility once it later becomes displaced through some subsequent, and possibly innocuous, event.Conclusion Accordingly, I find that Mr Johnston's injury was caused by the work he was carrying out on 8 and 9 March 2023. I am therefore satisfied that the injury sustained constituted an injury within the meaning of that term as it appears in s 32 of the WRC Act. For the foregoing reasons, I conclude that Mr Johnston's claim is one for compensation. The appeal is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent argues that the Dr Wheatley's conclusions should be preferred over Dr Cooke's. In support of this argument, the Respondent puts forward what is, in my view, a critical point: Dr Cooke's conclusion was based on the incorrect assumption that Mr Johnston's meniscus both tore and displaced all at once. The Respondent posits that Dr Cooke did not consider the possibility that the meniscus became displaced sometime well after it was torn. The Respondent submits that Dr Wheatley's evidence did consider that possibility and so his evidence should be preferred. The Respondent submits Dr Wheatley's evidence was that Mr Johnston could have continued to work had the meniscus torn but then later, sometime after working, become displaced. Dr Wheatley's evidence was that the displacement of the meniscus could have occurred doing something as innocuous as getting into bed[106]. The Respondent submits that, in light of Dr Wheatley's evidence, a bucket handle meniscus tear occurred consistently with the evidence of Mr Johnston's symptoms and, importantly, occurred during the shift between 8 and 9 March 2023. [106] T 2-41, ll 18-20. Consideration In making findings of fact, I am of the view that the Commission must assess the evidence in the following way. The Commission is not bound by the rules of evidence and may determine what evidence it accepts.[107] The Commission also must not depart from the rules of evidence except in the clearest of cases where the interests of justice require doing so.[108] The principles that guide the Commission through the rules of evidence are relevance, probity and reliability.[109] Relevance is a binary decision; the evidence either does or does not tend to prove a fact.[110] Probity, or the probative value of evidence, is the extent to which relevant evidence does prove a fact in light of the entirety of the evidence.[111] Reliability describes the extent to which the evidence is trustworthy.[112][107] IR Act (n 104) s 531, Rimland (n 89) [31].[108] King (n 92) [16], [25].[109] Self and Bishop (n 95) [71]; Rimland (n 89) [31]; Leigh (n 103) [123]-[125].[110] Goldsmith (n 97) [31]; Smith (n 99) [6].[111] IMM (n 100) [44]; Evans (n 101) [177].[112] Evans (n 101) [82].Findings on the nature of the work There was disagreement between the parties on several aspects of the nature of the work. The number of breaks Mr Johnston had, how much flumes weighed, how long the workers jackhammered for on each occasion, and how the workers described the flumes, were all issues raised by the parties. In the hearing, too, there was a great deal of probing about who did what and for how long during tank movements. But what was not in dispute, and what is really the relevant part of the nature of the work to this matter, is that Mr Johnston was carrying out physically onerous work right up until, while taking a short walk, he first noticed the onset of some symptoms. That was, in his words, when he felt a "pop" in his knee and experienced some instability. On the evidence, I find that Mr Johnston was climbing ladders in and out of cramped working areas, crouching and "crab walking" on slippery surfaces whilst jackhammering with his knee in contorted positions. He was also engaged in manoeuvring and lifting in an out of the flume pits the blinds, which weighed somewhere between 40 and 50 kg, I accept. It is undoubtedly relevant and of probative value that Mr Johnston undertook physically onerous work. Findings on the medical evidence