QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v Lumley General Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No 3820 of 2008

QBE INSURANCE (AUSTRALIA) LIMITED (ACN 003 191 035)

Appellant

v

LUMLEY GENERAL INSURANCE LIMITED (ACN 000 036 279) Respondent

---

JUDGES:

NEAVE and DODDS-STREETON JJA and KYROU AJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

5 May 2009; Supplementary Submissions received on 6 and 7 May 2009

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

4 June 2009

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2009] VSCA 124

JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM:

[2008] VSC 216 (Pagone J)

---

INSURANCE – Contribution between insurers – Separate policies taken out by head contractor and sub-contractor each covering both head contractor and sub-contractor – Damage caused by negligence of sub-contractor – Head contractor’s insurer pays for the damage – Whether payment made on behalf of head contractor or sub-contractor – Sections 48, 54 and 76, Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth).

INSURANCE – Principles relating to contribution between insurers – Rationale and purpose of principles – Double insurance – Whether time for determining existence of double insurance is the time of the incident giving rise to a liability or a loss – Whether subsequent events can affect contribution rights.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors

For the Appellant

For the Respondent

Mr M F Wheelahan SC with Mr T R Messer

Mr G G McArthur SC with Mr T J Scotter

Hall & Wilcox

DLA Phillips Fox

NEAVE JA
DODDS-STREETON JA
KYROU AJA:

Introduction and summary

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of a judge of the Trial Division ordering the appellant, QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited (‘QBE’), to make contribution to the respondent, Lumley General Insurance Limited (‘Lumley’), in respect of a payment made by Lumley under its insurance policy for a liability that was also insured by QBE.[1] 

  1. The payment was in respect of a liability to Dabserv Pty Ltd (‘Dabserv’) for damage caused to its fit-out at 600 Bourke Street, Melbourne by the negligence of Commercial Interiors Australia Pty Ltd (‘Commercial Interiors’).  Commercial Interiors was a sub-contractor of Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd (‘Probuild’), the head contractor for the fit-out works. 

  1. Probuild was insured with Lumley.  The Lumley policy also covered Probuild’s sub-contractors, including Commercial Interiors.  Commercial Interiors was insured with QBE.  The QBE policy also covered ‘principals’ of Commercial Interiors, including Probuild.

  1. This appeal involves a consideration of the principles governing contribution between insurers where there is double insurance and whether, in the circumstances of this case, Lumley was entitled to contribution from QBE. 

  1. For the reasons that follow, we have decided that the trial judge correctly held that Lumley was entitled to contribution from QBE and that the appeal should be dismissed.

Facts

  1. The hearing below was conducted on the basis of an agreed statement of facts and an agreed book of documents, without any oral evidence.  The appeal before us also proceeded on the basis of the agreed statement of facts and book of documents.  The following summary of the facts is based on those materials.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v Lumley General Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] VSCA 124
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v Lumley General Insurance Ltd concerned a dispute between two insurers over the issue of contribution following a payment made by one insurer to a head contractor for damage caused by the negligence of a sub-contractor. The head contractor had obtained insurance from QBE, while the sub-contractor had insured with Lumley. Each policy covered both the head contractor and the sub-contractor. QBE made a payment to the head contractor for the damage caused by the sub-contractor's negligence, and subsequently sought a contribution from Lumley. The central legal issue was whether the payment made by QBE was on behalf of the head contractor or the sub-contractor, and what the effect of this was on the right to contribution under the Insurance Contracts Act 1984.

The court had to determine the appropriate time at which to assess whether there was double insurance, and whether subsequent events could affect the insurers' rights to contribution. The court held that the relevant time for determining whether there was double insurance was the time of the incident giving rise to the liability or loss, not at the time of the payment. The court also held that subsequent events could not affect the insurers' rights to contribution, as this would undermine the principle of indemnity in insurance contracts. The rationale and purpose of the principles of contribution between insurers was to prevent an insured party from recovering more than their actual loss, and to ensure that insurers do not bear an unfair share of the insured's loss.

The court found that QBE's payment to the head contractor was made on behalf of the sub-contractor, and that Lumley was therefore entitled to contribution from QBE. The court held that the principles of contribution applied equally to policies of double insurance, and that Lumley was entitled to a contribution from QBE in proportion to the extent of its policy's coverage of the sub-contractor's liability. The court also held that the subsequent events, including the payment made by QBE, did not affect Lumley's right to contribution. The court made an order for QBE to pay Lumley a contribution in proportion to the extent of its policy's coverage of the sub-contractor's liability.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established