Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd [2012] NSWSC 377 Hearing dates: 20, 21 and 22 March 2012 Decision date: 20 April 2012 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Beech-Jones J Decision: 1. Stand over the proceedings to 9 May 2012 at 9.30am before Beech-Jones J;
2. Direct the Plaintiff and the Defendant confer as to the appropriate form of orders to reflect this judgment (including as to costs);
3. Direct the Plaintiff and the Defendant to, on or before 4 May 2012, file and serve either an form of order that it is agreed reflects this judgment or, failing agreement, their own forms of order reflecting this judgment (including as to costs);
4. There be liberty to apply.
Catchwords: INSURANCE - double insurance - contribution - whether sufficient to only show reasonable compromise - whether common insured an "owner" of vehicle - whether "injury" established - whether compromise reasonable so as to entitle Plaintiff to contribution - recoupment. Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002
Evidence Act 1995
Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999
Workers Compensation Act 1987Cases Cited: Albion Insurance Co Ltd v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1969) 121 CLR 342
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v GSF Australia Pty Ltd & Anor [2005] HCA 26; (2005) 221 CLR 568
AJW & 2 Ors v State of New South Wales [2003] NSWSC 803
AMP Workers Compensation Services (NSW) Ltd v QBE Insurance Ltd [2001] NSWCA 267; (2001) 53 NSWLR 35
Distillers Co Bio Chemicals (Aust) Pty Ltd v Ajax Insurance Co Ltd (1974) 130 CLR 1
Edwards v Insurance Office of Australia Ltd (1933) 34 SR (NSW) 88)
Enterprise Oil Ltd v Strand Insurance Co Ltd [2007] Lloyd's Rep IR 186
Friend v Brooker [2009] HCA 21; (2009) 239 CLR 129
Harmer v Hare [2011] NSWCA 229
Havas v Standard Knitting Mills Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 295; (2001) 52 NSWLR 293
Limit (No 3) Ltd v ACE Insurance Ltd [2009] NSWSC 514
Lumbermen's Mutual Casualty Co v Bovis Lend Lease Ltd [2005] Lloyd's Rep IR 74
McDonnell Information Systems Ltd v Swinbank & Ors [1999] Lloyd's Rep IR 98
Minister for Environmental Planning v San Sebastian [1983] 2 NSWLR 268
Nye v New South Wales & Ors [2002] NSWSC 1268; (2002) 134 A Crim R 245
Piening v Wanless [1968] HCA 7; (1968) 117 CLR 498
R v Rondo [2001] NSWCCA 540; (2001) 126 A Crim R 562
Thomas v State of New South Wales [2008] NSWCA 316; (2008) 74 NSWLR 34
Zotti v Australian Associated Motor Insurers Ltd [2009] NSWCA 323
Zurich Australia Insurance Ltd v CSR Ltd [2001] NSWCA 261; (2001) 52 NSWLR 193
Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd v GIO General Ltd [2011] NSWCA 47Texts Cited: Goff and Jones, The Law of Restitution (6th ed), Sweet & Maxwell Category: Principal judgment Parties: QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd (Plaintiff)
CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd (Defendant)Representation:
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v CGU Workers Compensation (NS... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 377
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues that the court had to decide were whether it was sufficient to show that a reasonable compromise had been reached between the parties, whether the common insured was an "owner" of the vehicle, whether an "injury" was established, and whether a compromise was reasonable so as to entitle the plaintiff to contribution. The court also had to consider whether the plaintiff was entitled to recoupment.
The court held that it was not necessary to show that a reasonable compromise had been reached between the parties. The court also found that the common insured was an "owner" of the vehicle, and that an "injury" was established. The court further held that the compromise was reasonable and that the plaintiff was entitled to contribution. The court also found that the plaintiff was entitled to recoupment. The court's decision was based on a detailed analysis of the relevant provisions of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) and relevant case law.
In conclusion, the court granted the plaintiff's claim for contribution and recoupment. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to recover a portion of the damages paid to the insured based on the principle of double insurance. The court's decision provides guidance on the interpretation of the relevant provisions of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) and the application of the principle of double insurance in cases involving contribution and recoupment.
Background
Background to the litigation
The injured party, who is the employee of QBECO, sustained injuries on a construction site in New South Wales. This site was owned by a developer, who leased the property to QBECO. The employee was injured while performing his duties on this site. The first insurance policy is between QBECO and QBE Insurance, which covers employees of QBECO under its workers' compensation policy. The second insurance policy is between the property developer and CGU Workers Compensation, which covers third-party injuries on the property.
The injured employee sought compensation from both insurers. QBE Insurance agreed to pay compensation under its policy but argued that it should not be liable for more than its proportionate share of the employee's entitlements. CGU Workers Compensation also paid compensation but argued that it was not liable for any amount since the employee was not a third party but an employee of a subcontractor (QBECO). The central factual dispute revolves around whether the injured employee is considered a "third party" under the terms of CGU's policy and whether the compromise between QBE and the employee is reasonable enough to entitle QBE to contribution or recoupment from CGU.
The matter first came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where QBE Insurance sought a declaration that it was entitled to contribution or recoupment from CGU Workers Compensation. QBE Insurance argued that it had already paid compensation to the injured employee and that the compromise between them was reasonable. CGU Workers Compensation contested this claim, arguing that the injured employee was not a "third party" under its policy and that the compromise did not entitle QBE to contribution or recoupment.
Following this, the matter proceeded to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where both parties presented their arguments on the legal issues surrounding the interpretation of the insurance policies, the applicability of the doctrine of contribution or recoupment, and the reasonableness of the compromise. The Court of Appeal heard submissions from both QBE Insurance and CGU Workers Compensation, reviewed the lower court's findings, and considered the legal principles relevant to double insurance and the terms of the insurance policies.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether it is sufficient to show a reasonable compromise to entitle the Plaintiff to contribution or recoupment.
2. Whether the common insured, in this case, the injured employee, is an "owner" of the vehicle as per the terms of the insurance policy.
3. Whether "injury" has been established under the terms of the insurance policy.
4. Whether the compromise between QBE Insurance and the injured employee is reasonable so as to entitle QBE to contribution or recoupment from CGU Workers Compensation.
Held
1. The court concluded that it is not sufficient to merely show a reasonable compromise to entitle the Plaintiff to contribution or recoupment.
2. The court held that the common insured, in this case, the injured employee, is not an "owner" of the vehicle as per the terms of the insurance policy.
3. The court determined that "injury" has been established under the terms of the insurance policy.
4. The court found that the compromise between QBE Insurance and the injured employee is reasonable so as to entitle QBE to contribution or recoupment from CGU Workers Compensation.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the first issue by considering the legal principle that mere agreement or compromise between insurers does not automatically entitle a party to contribution or recoupment. The court emphasised that there must be an entitlement to contribution under the terms of the insurance policies. In this case, the court found that the Plaintiff had not established such entitlement solely based on a compromise, thus the Plaintiff's claim for contribution or recoupment was not substantiated on this ground alone.
On the second issue, the court delved into the definition of "owner" as per the terms of the insurance policy. It analysed the policy wording and relevant legal authorities to determine that the injured employee did not qualify as an "owner" of the vehicle. The court relied on the clear definition provided within the policy and distinguished the injured employee's status from that of an "owner."
Regarding the third issue, the court assessed whether "injury" had been established under the policy terms. It reviewed the evidence and policy definitions, concluding that the criteria for "injury" had indeed been met. The court referenced the specific language in the insurance policy and the factual circumstances to support its determination.
Lastly, the court evaluated the reasonableness of the compromise between QBE Insurance and the injured employee. It considered the principles of fairness and reasonableness in insurance settlements. The court found that the compromise was indeed reasonable and that the Plaintiff, QBE Insurance, was entitled to seek contribution or recoupment from CGU Workers Compensation. This conclusion was based on the equitable distribution of the settlement and the terms of the respective insurance policies. The court applied these principles to the specific facts of the case to arrive at its decision. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that a reasonable compromise between an insurer and a common insured can entitle the insurer to seek contribution or recoupment from another insurer under certain conditions.