PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2020] FCA 685

Appeal from: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd (Remedies) [2019] FCA 786
File number: NSD 1011 of 2019
Judge: YATES J
Date of judgment: 21 May 2020
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for stay of appeal until further order – in circumstances where appellant has failed to comply with an order of the Court to pay pecuniary penalties – the power of the Court to control its own proceedings – power to grant a stay of proceedings – whether contempt demonstrated
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 124, 129, 601CD

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 25(2B)(ab), 28, 31

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 42.12

Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth) s 3(1)

Cases cited:

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Limited (Receivers Appointed) (1985) 2 NSWLR 685

Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union v Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 98

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd (Remedies) [2019] FCA 786; 370 ALR 637

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited [2019] FCA 964; 138 ACSR 42

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v World Netsafe Pty Ltd (No 3) [2003] FCA 159; 127 FCR 542

Bond Corporation Pty Limited v Thiess Contractors Pty Limited (1986) 14 FCR 193

Foster v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2014] FCA 240; 219 FCR 563

Hadkinson v Hadkinson [1952] P 285

Hughes Motor Service Pty Ltd v Wang Computer Pty Ltd (1978) 35 FLR 346

Hwang v Lawrie [2013] QCA 204; [2014] 1 Qd R 562

Jorgensen v Fair Work Ombudsman [2019] FCAFC 113; 371 ALR 426

Kazal v Thunder Studios Inc (California) [2017] FCAFC 111; 256 FCR 90

KP Cable Investments Pty Ltd v Meltglow Pty Ltd (1995) 56 FCR 189

Louis Vuitton Malletier SA v Design Elegance Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 83; 149 FCR 494

Metcash Trading Ltd v Bunn (No 5) [2009] FCA 16

Muller v Fencott (1981) 53 FLR 184

Powerflex Services Pty Ltd v Data Access Corp (1996) 67 FCR 65

PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2011] FCAFC 52; 192 FCR 393

PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (Penalty Stay Application) [2019] FCA 1317

Siminton v Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (No 3) [2008] FCAFC 89; 168 FCR 140

Stokes (by a tutor) v McCourt [2013] NSWSC 1014

Trade Practices Commission v Manfal Pty Limited (1990) 27 FCR 284

Young v Jackman (1986) 7 NSWLR 97

Date of hearing: 2 March 2020
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Economic Regulator, Competition and Access
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 63
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr T Brennan
Solicitor for the Appellant: Norton White
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J A Halley SC and Ms H Younan
Solicitor for the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consume... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 685
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd has applied for a stay of appeal proceedings due to its failure to comply with a pecuniary penalty order issued by the Court. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) opposes the stay. The penalties were due on 27 June 2019, but Garuda did not make the payment. After further correspondence, it became clear that Garuda was not going to comply with the penalty order. Garuda argued that its failure to comply was not due to an inability to pay, but rather a decision not to comply with the Court’s order. The ACCC understood this as an indication that Garuda had made a conscious decision not to comply with the Court’s order.

The legal issues before the court involved the power of the Court to control its own proceedings and whether Garuda's failure to comply with the pecuniary penalty order constituted contempt. Garuda argued that it is a separate entity of Indonesia, and under Indonesian law, the Indonesian Government might not be able to authorise the payment of moneys that would compromise Garuda's purpose or ability to benefit the Indonesian public. The court needed to determine whether Garuda had the legal capacity to comply with the pecuniary penalty order and if there was any evidence to suggest that Garuda had the practical capacity to comply with the order.

The court dismissed Garuda's amended interlocutory application for a stay of appeal proceedings. It found that Garuda's failure to comply with the pecuniary penalty order constituted contempt. The court also granted Garuda leave to amend its notice of appeal by adding a ground of appeal that the Court had erred by including the words "within 28 days" in the penalty order. The ACCC was ordered to pay Garuda's costs of the interlocutory application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondent’s amended interlocutory application dated 28 October 2019 (the interlocutory application) be dismissed.

2. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the interlocutory application.

3. Leave be granted to the appellant to amend its notice of appeal dated 25 June 2019 by adding the following ground of appeal:

The Court erred by exceeding the power conferred on the Court by including in order 1 the words “within 28 days”.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The application for the stay is opposed.BACKGROUND As ordered, the penalties were due to be paid on or before 27 June 2019. On 17 June 2019, the Commission’s solicitor, the Australian Government Solicitor (the AGS), wrote to Garuda’s solicitors, Norton White, informing them of the account into which the penalties were to be paid. Payment was not made by the due date. Consequently, the AGS wrote to Norton White on 1 July 2019 drawing attention to the non-payment and seeking, in effect, an explanation. On 3 July 2019, Norton White responded, saying that the AGS’s letter had been forwarded to Garuda in Indonesia. After further correspondence from the AGS, Norton White informed the AGS that those with responsibility for processing the payment of the penalties understood that Garuda was required to inform the Indonesian Ministry for State Enterprises of the pecuniary penalty order and to “await the direction of the Ministry”. Norton White said: This situation arises because Garuda, as the national carrier for Indonesia, is subject to control by the Indonesian government and its position under Indonesian law. The penalty has become a matter of significance to Garuda and also the Indonesian Government, to the extent that the issue of the Court’s orders has been raised at the highest inter-government level. The Commission understood this response as indicating that Garuda’s failure was not due to any incapacity or inability to pay but, rather, a decision not to comply with the Court’s pecuniary penalty order. On 10 July 2019, the AGS informed Norton White of this understanding, saying: In our view the position concerning breach of the Court’s order needs to be regularised as soon as possible, either by complying with the order or seeking to have the order stayed. We note that we do not accept and could not submit that the basis for non-compliance set out in your letter could properly ground a stay application. We consider these issues have already been decided adversely to your client, including by the High Court. We think the way forward is to list the matter as soon as possible so that you can inform the Court of the position your client has adopted and to seek such order or variation as your client considers might be appropriate. … Garuda took issue with the fact that its failure to pay the penalties involved a decision not to comply with the Court’s order. On the same day, Norton White wrote to the AGS stating that if the Commonwealth or the Commission intended to take a step in respect of the enforcement of the pecuniary penalty order, then this should be done by formal application. Norton White also foreshadowed that Garuda might make an application to stay the pecuniary penalty order pending its appeal. They said, however, that Garuda was not then in a position to make such an application. On 12 July 2019, the primary proceeding was re-listed before the primary judge, Perram J, for case management of a number of matters, at the Commission’s request. One issue that was raised was Garuda’s failure to comply with the pecuniary penalty order and whether Garuda intended to apply for a stay of that order. At that hearing, Garuda maintained that it was not in a position to apply for a stay. Moreover, Garuda’s counsel presaged that its case might not be one: …where a stay will be at all appropriate, but where the questions will be how far this Court’s writs run and what the effect is, so that – and I don’t put it that the effect of the law or what’s happening in Jakarta at the moment is such that this corporation can’t make a payment, but it may be. Now, if it is, then this Court’s order won’t have any effect of authorising the making of the payment, but there may be very significant issues that arise on an enforcement context.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this connection, Garuda points to the fact that it is a foreign registered company under s 601CD of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act). Sections 124 (powers and capacities of the company) and 129 (presumptions when dealing with the company) of the Corporations Act do not apply to it. It is an agency or instrumentality of the Republic of Indonesia and, hence, a “separate entity” within the meaning of s 3(1) of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth): PT Garuda Indonesia Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2011] FCAFC 52; 192 FCR 393. In that case, Rares J (with whom Lander and Greenwood JJ agreed at [49]) said (at [169] – [171]):169Here, however, it is difficult to see what other purpose Indonesia could have had in incorporating, directly owning 95.5% of, and investing in Garuda, unless it wanted such an airline to conduct the very enterprise it did, and continues to, conduct. Indonesia was the shareholder of almost all of Garuda’s issued capital. Two perseros owned the balance, but there was no evidence as to whether those two perseros were wholly or majority State owned. Even if 49% of each of the two minority perseros was owned by third parties, about 98% of Garuda would be owned by Indonesia. All the shareholders in both Garuda and its two minority perseros were governed by Law No 19, including their purpose and objective as a BUMN under Art 2(1)(c) of “benefit[ing] the public by providing high-quality and satisfactory … services fulfilling the needs of the people”.170Indonesia had ultimate control over the boards of directors and commissioners because of its beneficial ownership of all, or almost all, the shares in Garuda. It is a State owned airline, established on a corporate model, under Law No 19 for State owned companies: cf SGH 210 CLR at 70-71 [23]-[26], 73 [32]; NRMA 55 FCR at 472E-478G. Even though Indonesia did not claim immunity through its Ambassador or a Minister, the compelling inference on the whole of the evidence is that Garuda is an agency or instrumentality of that State. Garuda is the means by which Indonesia carried on the business of an airline. That is the end or purpose for which Indonesia used Garuda: cf State Bank 174 CLR at 231-232.171It follows that Garuda was and, at all the times in which its conduct is complained of by the Commission, has been a separate entity of Indonesia. In oral submissions, Garuda’s counsel described it as a limited purpose, public entity controlled by the Indonesian Government and submitted that there is a real question whether, under Indonesian law, the Indonesian Government could properly authorise payment of moneys which would compromise Garuda’s purpose or ability of benefiting the Indonesian public by providing “high-quality and satisfactory services justifying the needs of the people”. Garuda submits that this question – which goes to its legal capacity to comply with the pecuniary penalty order – has not been explored in this application by the Commission. Further, there is no evidence before the Court to suggest that, up to 23 August 2019 (the date to which compliance with the pecuniary penalty order was extended), Garuda had the practical capacity to comply with the pecuniary penalty order. Garuda submits that the fact that the Commission has not taken steps to enforce the pecuniary penalty order reveals the Commission’s understanding of Garuda’s capacity to comply.