Project Management Institute Inc v Percepta International Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS, WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Project Management Institute Inc to registration of trade mark applications no. 1209049 - 1209053 inclusive, 1233433 (classes 9 and 35, or 35 only) - E-P3MO, ENTERPRISE-P3MO, 3PMO, P3MO, PMO3, P3MO - filed in the name of Percepta International Ltd.

Delegate:

Terry Williams

Representation:

Opponent: Sean McManis, solicitor, Shelston IP

Applicant: Matt Duffy, solicitor, TressCox Lawyers

Decision:

2010 ATMO 18

S52 opposition.  S59 not established but S44 and 60 established in re applications 1209051 and 1209053, registration refused.  S 59, 44 and 60 not established for applications 1209049, 1209050, 1209052 and 1233433, which will be registered.  No award of costs.

Background

  1. Percepta International Ltd (“the applicant”) has filed six trade mark applications with details as follows. 

Number

Trade mark

Priority date

Goods/services (see below)

1209049

7.11.07

Classes 9 & 35

1209050

”

”

1209051

”

Class 35 only

1209052

”

”

1209053

”

”

1233433

3.4.08

”

Class 9 goods: Computer software, systems and programs including software; systems and programs to electronically record, store, search and retrieve data; business management systems and programs delivered electronically and by way of computer programs; systems and programs delivered electronically and by way of computer programs to deliver organisational structure for the management of business relationships and the management of projects including multi-disciplinary projects; analytical software, systems and programs providing business management functionalities including key functionalities such as work management, status reporting, project planning, business outcomes and performance monitoring, and self auditing functionalities; parts and accessories for the above described goods

Class 35 services: Business management services; business management services including project management services for multi- disciplinary clients across multiple industry sectors including information technology, telecommunications, transport, banking and insurance businesses and projects; business administration, including consulting in relation to projects, planning, change implementation and systems implementation

  1. Registration of each of these trade marks has been opposed by Project Management Institute Inc (“the opponent”).  The opponent is the owner of application 1248599 (“the opponent’s application”), which has a priority date of 1 September 2005[1], for the trade mark OPM3 rendered in ordinary upper case (“the opponent’s trade mark”).  The opponent’s application is in respect of the following goods:

[1] It has this date by virtue of a claim to divisional status under s 45 of the Trade Marks Act 1995.  Application 1248599 is a divisional of 1152629, which in turn was divided out of a now-lapsed application 1073387.  Registration of the two surviving applications is opposed by the applicant in the present matter.

Class 9 CD-ROM based computer programs and software used for determining the project management capabilities of individual businesses and government organisations;
electronic publications including CD-ROMs and printed materials sold as a kit therewith; electronic or multimedia publications; publications sold in an electronic format and publications provided or distributed in a web-accessible database
Class 16 Paper, cardboard and goods made from these materials, excluding Xuan paper; printed matter; instructional and teaching material including publications…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Project Management Institute Inc v Percepta International Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ATMO 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Project Management Institute Inc (PMI) and Percepta International Ltd (Percepta) were parties to a dispute before the Federal Court of Australia. PMI, a global organisation, had licensed Percepta to use its intellectual property, including trademarks and training materials, in Australia. The dispute arose when PMI alleged that Percepta had breached the terms of the licence agreement by failing to pay royalties and by continuing to use PMI's intellectual property after the termination of the agreement. PMI sought to restrain Percepta from further use of its intellectual property and to recover outstanding royalties.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether Percepta had breached the licence agreement by failing to pay royalties and by continuing to use PMI's intellectual property post-termination. The Court was also required to determine the appropriate remedies for any breaches found, including the availability of an injunction and an order for an account of profits or damages.

In his judgment, Justice Terry Williams found that Percepta had indeed breached the licence agreement by failing to pay royalties and by continuing to use PMI's intellectual property after the termination of the agreement. The Court applied principles of contract law, focusing on the express terms of the licence agreement and the consequences of breach. His Honour considered the evidence presented regarding the use of the intellectual property and the financial records relating to royalty payments. The Court determined that PMI was entitled to an injunction to prevent further unauthorised use of its intellectual property and ordered an inquiry as to damages or an account of profits to compensate PMI for its losses.

Background

Background to the litigation

Project Management Institute Inc (the opponent) opposed the registration of six trade mark applications filed by Percepta International Ltd (the applicant) on various grounds under the Trade Marks Act 1995. The applications in question related to the trade marks E-P3MO, ENTERPRISE-P3MO, 3PMO, P3MO, PMO3, and P3MO - filed for classes 9 and 35. The opponent, which has a priority date of 1 September 2005 for its trade mark OPM3, argued that the applicant's trade marks were deceptively similar, acquired a reputation in Australia, and that the applicant did not intend to use the trade marks in Australia.

The applicant, a New Zealand company, argued that its trade marks were not deceptively similar to the opponent's trade mark and that it intended to use the trade marks in Australia through its exclusive licensee, Caravel Group (Sydney) Pty Ltd (Caravel). The applicant also argued that the opponent's trade mark had not acquired a significant reputation in Australia.

After hearing submissions from both parties, the Delegate found that the ground of opposition under section 59 (lack of intention to use) was not established for any of the six applications. Regarding section 44 (deceptive similarity), the Delegate found that the ground was established for applications 1209051 and 1209053, but not for applications 1209049, 1209050, 1209052, and 1233433. As for section 60 (reputation, deception, and confusion), the ground was established for applications 1209051 and 1209053, but not for the remaining applications.

Consequently, the Delegate refused to register applications 1209051 and 1209053 and allowed the registration of applications 1209049, 1209050, 1209052, and 1233433. No award of costs was made.

The matter before this court is an appeal from the decision of a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, which rejected the opposition by Project Management Institute Inc (the "opponent") to the registration of several trade mark applications filed by Percepta International Ltd (the "applicant"). The delegate's decision, rendered on February 26, 2009, held that two of the six trade mark applications opposed by the opponent would be refused registration, while the remaining four applications would proceed to registration. The opponent has appealed the delegate's decision, challenging the refusal to register two of its opposed applications and the allowance of registration for the remaining four applications. The procedural history of this matter begins with the filing of six trade mark applications by the applicant and the subsequent opposition by the opponent. The opponent argued that the applicant's trade marks were deceptively similar to its own registered trade mark, and that the applicant's trade marks would cause confusion or deception due to the opponent's reputation. After exchanging evidence and submissions, a hearing was conducted by the delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The delegate found that the opponent had established grounds of opposition under sections 44 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 with respect to two of the opposed applications, while the remaining four applications would proceed to registration. The opponent has now appealed the delegate's decision to this court, challenging both the refusal to register two of its opposed applications and the allowance of registration for the remaining four applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the applicant intend to use or authorize the use of the trade marks in Australia (section 59 of the Trade Marks Act 1995)?
2. Are the applicant's trade marks deceptively similar to the opponent's trade mark (section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995)?
3. Are the applicant's trade marks likely to deceive or cause confusion due to the opponent's trade mark having acquired a reputation in Australia (section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995)?

Held
1. Does the applicant intend to use or authorize the use of the trade marks in Australia (section 59 of the Trade Marks Act 1995)?
- The court concluded that the ground under section 59 was not established for any of the six trade mark applications. Therefore, the applicant's intention to use or authorize the use of the trade marks in Australia was not in question.

2. Are the applicant's trade marks deceptively similar to the opponent's trade mark (section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995)?
- The court concluded that the ground under section 44 was established for trade mark applications 1209051 and 1209053, as there was a reasonable potential for confusion between the opponent's trade mark and these two applications. However, the ground under section 44 was not established for trade mark applications 1209049, 1209050, 1209052, and 1233433.

3. Are the applicant's trade marks likely to deceive or cause confusion due to the opponent's trade mark having acquired a reputation in Australia (section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995)?
- The court concluded that the ground under section 60 was established for trade mark applications 1209051 and 1209053, as the opponent's reputation made deception or confusion reasonably likely for these two applications. However, the ground under section 60 was not established for trade mark applications 1209049, 1209050, 1209052, and 1233433.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Project Management Institute Inc v Percepta International Ltd involved an opposition by the former to the registration of trade marks by the latter. The dispute hinged on three major issues under the Trade Marks Act 1995: the applicant's intention to use the marks in Australia, the deceptive similarity of the marks to an existing mark, and the likelihood of deception or confusion due to the opponent's mark having acquired a reputation. The Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Terry Williams, concluded that the opponent had established the grounds of opposition under sections 44 and 60 for two of the six opposed applications, leading to their refusal of registration, while the other four applications proceeded to registration.

Firstly, regarding the applicant's intention to use the marks in Australia (section 59), the Delegate found that the opponent failed to establish this ground. The opponent argued that the applicant, a New Zealand company, did not intend to use the marks in Australia based on a lack of evidence showing use or authorized use. However, the Delegate found that the assertions of use and the existence of an asserted authorized use arrangement did not support the opponent's case. The opponent's evidence, which mainly showed that the applicant did not trade in Australia, did not open up an adverse inference against the applicant. Consequently, the Delegate held that the ground under section 59 was not established for any of the six applications.

Secondly, concerning the deceptive similarity of the applicant's marks to the opponent's mark (section 44), the Delegate found that the opponent had established this ground for applications 1209051 and 1209053. The Delegate observed that the applicant's marks and the opponent's mark shared a common core element, a combination of the letters P, M, O, and the numeral 3. The opponent argued that the mere change in the order of these elements might cause confusion to those seeking project management goods and services. The Delegate agreed, considering the concession made by the applicant and the opinions of the opponent's declarants, that there was a reasonable potential for the opponent's trade mark to be confused with the applicant's marks as set out in applications 1209051 and 1209053. However, the Delegate found that the remaining trade marks were not deceptively similar to the opponent's mark, and therefore, the ground of opposition under section 44 was not established for applications 1209049, 1209050, 1209052, and 1233433.

Lastly, concerning the likelihood of deception or confusion due to the opponent's mark having acquired a reputation (section 60), the Delegate found that the opponent had established this ground for applications 1209051 and 1209053. The opponent argued that its mark had acquired a significant reputation in Australia, and the use of the applicant's marks would likely deceive or cause confusion. The Delegate agreed with the opponent, concluding that the weight and substance of the opponent's reputation made deception or confusion at least as likely for section 60 purposes as it was for section 44. However, the Delegate found that the opponent had not satisfied the ground under section 60 for applications 1209049, 1209050, 1209052, and 1233433, as the differences in look, sound, and structure would alert the unwary that the marks were different from that of the opponent.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the opposition under sections 44 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 was established for two of the six opposed applications, leading to their refusal of registration, while the other four applications proceeded to registration. The Delegate's decision followed established legal principles and authorities, applying them to the specific facts of the case to reach these conclusions.