Primerano v Schisan Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Primerano v Schisan Investments Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 15

Appeal from: Primerano v Schisan Investments Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 667
File number(s): NSD 923 of 2023
Judgment of: HALLEY J
Date of judgment: 22 January 2025
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – appeal from decision of Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) on separate question – whether applicant was engaged by respondents as a national system employee within the meaning of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) – where primary judge answered separate question “no” – where contract between the parties not recorded in writing – ascertainment of the parties’ legal rights and obligations – where satisfied primary judge erred in answering separate question in the negative – appeal upheld – separate question answered “yes”

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for extension of time to seek leave to appeal and leave to appeal – application for extension of time not opposed – whether primary judgment attended with sufficient doubt and substantial injustice would result if leave were refused – where primary judgment has practical effect of being final determination of claims applicant seeks to bring under the FW Act – extension of time and leave to appeal granted

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 13, 14

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24

Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth) s 12

Cases cited:

Aldi Foods Pty Ltd v Moroccanoil Israel Ltd (2018) 261 FCR 301; [2018] FCAFC 93

Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424; [2001] FCA 1833

Chiodo v Silk Contract Logistics [2023] FCA 1047

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd (2022) 275 CLR 165; [2022] HCA 1

EFEX Group Pty Ltd v Bennett [2024] FCAFC 35

JMC Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2022) 114 ATR 795; [2022] FCA 750

JMC Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2023) 297 FCR 600; [2023] FCAFC 76

Primerano v Schisan Investments Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 667

Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 16; [1986] HCA 1

ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd v Jamsek (2022) 275 CLR 254; [2022] HCA 2

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 79
Date of last submissions: 12 December 2024
Date of hearing: 27 March, 6 December 2024
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr A Rogers
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mitry Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms P Thew with Mr M Isaac
Solicitor for the Respondents: Kent Attorneys

ORDERS

NSD 923 of 2023
BETWEEN:

JOSEPHINE PRIMERANO

Applicant

AND:

SCHISAN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD T/AS TUTTI FRUTTI PROMOTIONS ACN 124 454 182

First Respondent

TUTTI FRUTTI CORPORATE PTY LTD ACN 634 131 187

Second Respondent

SANTOS PAULO SCHINELLA (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

HALLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 JANUARY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Primerano v Schisan Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Primerano v Schisan Investments Pty Ltd involved the applicant, seeking to establish whether she was an employee of the respondents, Tutti Frutti and Creative Gifts, under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The applicant contended that she was a national system employee of the respondents, a contention denied by the respondents. The case was initially heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2), where the primary judge answered a separate question in the negative, ruling that the applicant was not an employee of the respondents. The applicant then appealed to the Federal Court of Australia, challenging the primary judge's decision.

The legal issues central to the appeal revolved around the interpretation of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the determination of whether the applicant was a national system employee of the respondents. The key points of contention included the criteria used by the primary judge to assess the applicant's employment status and the weight given to specific factors such as tax file number declarations, superannuation payments, and the operation of the business on a cash basis. The appeal also addressed the procedural aspect of granting an extension of time to seek leave to appeal and the subsequent granting of leave to appeal.

The court found that the primary judge erred in his assessment, particularly in overemphasising certain factors that did not conclusively determine the applicant's employment status. The court held that the applicant was indeed a national system employee of the respondents, as she was engaged in the supply of meat trays, raffle prizes, and promotional staff to hotels and clubs. The court set aside the primary judge's decision and ruled in favour of the applicant, finding that she was an employee of the respondents within the meaning of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The court granted the applicant an extension of time to file her application for leave to appeal, and subsequently granted leave to appeal and allowed the appeal. The final order mandated that the primary judge's answer to the separate question be changed to "Yes," recognising the applicant as a national system employee of the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The time by which the applicant had to file the application for leave to appeal be extended to 29 August 2023.

2. Leave to appeal be granted.

3. The appeal be allowed.

4. The answer given on 28 July 2023 by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) to the question of whether or not the applicant was engaged by the first and second respondents as a national system employee for the purposes of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) during the period 1 April 2019 to 26 May 2021 be set aside and in lieu thereof order that the answer to that question be “Yes”.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I am satisfied that the applicant was relevantly a national system employee of at least the first respondent in the period between April 2019 and September 2020 and the first or second respondent in the period between September 2020 and May 2021. B. BACKGROUND The business undertaken by Tutti Frutti was the supply of meat trays and raffle prizes to hotels and clubs and the supply of staff for promotional events at venues. On or about 21 June 2017, Mr Schinella and Dana Younes became directors and shareholders of Creative Gifts Pty Limited (Creative Gifts). Mr Schinella and Ms Younes acquired their shares in Creative Gifts from Cathy Fazzalaro. At the time of the share acquisitions, Mr Schinella was already operating the business of Tutti Frutti out of the same warehouse at Hilton Street, Sydenham that Ms Fazzalaro was operating the Creative Gifts business. In or about December 2018, Mr Schinella moved both the Tutti Frutti and the Creative Gifts businesses to a different warehouse on the Princes Highway at Sydenham. The applicant was one of the persons working for Creative Gifts at the time it was acquired by Mr Schinella and Ms Younes. Her role was to purchase gifts at wholesale prices, wrap the gifts and deliver them to various licensed clubs. The applicant continued to work for Creative Gifts until about April 2019. The applicant contends, but the respondents deny, that the applicant worked for both Creative Gifts and Tutti Frutti in the period between 2016 and April 2019. In any event, it is common ground that from April 2019, the applicant only worked for Tutti Frutti. The basis on which the applicant was engaged by Tutti Frutti from April 2019 was not documented. The work undertaken by the applicant for Tutti Frutti included purchasing goods for Tutti Frutti to be used as raffle prizes. The applicant purchased the goods with her money and was then reimbursed by Tutti Frutti once the purchases had been authorised by either Mr Schinella or Ms Aston. It included wrapping the goods in hampers or in gift packs. The applicant was paid a weekly fixed amount of $1,500 from Tutti Frutti, equivalent to an annual payment of some $78,000.C. RELEVANT PRINCIPLES Section 13 of the Fair Work Act provides that the following definition of a national system employee:A national system employee is an individual so far as he or she is employed, or usually employed, as described in the definition of national system employer in section 14, by a national system employer, except on a vocational placement. Section 14(1)(a) of the Fair Work Act relevantly provides that a national system employer includes: a constitutional corporation, so far as it employs, or usually employs, an individual The principles for determining whether there is an employment relationship have been conclusively stated by the High Court in Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd (2022) 275 CLR 165; [2022] HCA 1 and ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd v Jamsek (2022) 275 CLR 254; [2022] HCA 2. Those cases established that where the rights and duties of the parties are “comprehensively committed to a written contract”, the rights and obligations established by terms of that contract are decisive of the character of the legal relationship, and are to be construed in accordance with established principles of contractual interpretation: Personnel Contracting at [43]-[44], [59]-[60] (Kiefel CJ, Keane and Edelman JJ), [173], [183] (Gordon J, Steward J agreeing).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant was engaged by the respondents as a national system employee within the meaning of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) during the specified periods.
2. Whether the primary judge erred in answering the separate question in the negative.
3. Whether the primary judge gave appropriate weight to certain factors in determining the applicant's employment status.

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant was engaged by the respondents as a national system employee within the meaning of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) during the specified periods. As a result, the appeal was allowed, and the answer to the separate question was set to "Yes".
2. The court found that the primary judge erred in answering the separate question in the negative. Consequently, the decision of the primary judge was overturned.
3. The court determined that the primary judge did not give appropriate weight to certain factors in determining the applicant's employment status. The court found that the primary judge placed undue emphasis on specific issues such as the failure to complete tax file number declarations, non-receipt of superannuation payments, and the cash basis of operation by Tutti Frutti.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Fifth, the respondents submit in answer to Ground 10 that contrary to the wording of that ground the primary judge only found that there was no evidence that the applicant had a right to delegate, and his Honour did not make a positive finding that the applicant did not have a right to delegate. Moreover, there was no evidence that the applicant was prohibited from delegating.H. CONSIDERATIONH.1. Appellate jurisdiction It is well established that the appellate jurisdiction of the Court involves an appeal by way of rehearing and is directed at the correction of error: Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424; [2001] FCA 1833 at [20], [22] (Allsop J, Drummond and Mansfield JJ agreeing). A finding of error is essential for an appeal to be successful: Aldi Foods Pty Ltd v Moroccanoil Israel Ltd (2018) 261 FCR 301; [2018] FCAFC 93 at [45] (Perram J, Allsop CJ and Markovic J agreeing). In circumstances where there is an interplay between documentary evidence, fact finding by way of assessment and inference, and the application of the law to facts that are found, a finding of error is both factually and legally evaluative in nature, particularly when factors point to differing conclusions requiring the Court to determine which conclusion should prevail: EFEX at [37] (Katzmann and Bromwich JJ). The appellate task in that context, as stated in EFEX at [37], is that explained by Perram J in Aldi Foods at [49]:When an appellate court comes to review such conclusions it must be guided not by whether it disagrees with the finding (which would be decisive were a question of law involved) but by whether it detects error in the finding. On the one hand, error may appear syllogistically where it is apparent that the conclusion which has been reached has involved some false step; for example, where some relevant matter has been overlooked or some extraneous consideration taken into account which ought not to have been. But error, on the other hand, may also appear without any such explicitly erroneous reasoning. The result may be such as simply to bespeak error. Allsop J said in such cases an error may be manifest where the appellate court has a sufficiently clear difference of opinion: Branir at [29].H.2. Grounds of appeal The question of whether the primary judge erred in answering the separate question in the negative turns on the evaluative assessment that the primary judge made of competing criteria and the conclusion he reached that the applicant was not an employee of Tutti Frutti. Given the grounds of appeal are all directed at alleged errors of the primary judge in undertaking the evaluative exercise to determine whether the applicant had established that she was an employee of Tutti Frutti during the relevant period, it is convenient to address the appeal grounds together. For the following reasons, I am satisfied that the primary judge has erred and I have reached a different conclusion. First, the primary judge gave too much weight to the applicant’s failure to complete tax file number declarations and superannuation documentation (Ground 2), non-receipt of superannuation payments and failure to raise that matter with Tutti Frutti (Ground 5), her failure to request payslips and a group certificate (Ground 6) and the fact that Tutti Frutti operated on a cash basis (Ground 8).