Prescott v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

PRESCOTT v LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD

[2012] SASCFC 145

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Peek and The Honourable Justice Blue)

21 December 2012

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - DUTIES AND LIABILITIES - SOLICITOR AND CLIENT - DEALINGS WITH CLIENT

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - TRUST ACCOUNTS - COSTS OWING TO SOLICITOR

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board laid a charge in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal alleging unprofessional conduct on the part of the appellant and the second respondent. The charge related to a matter in which the practitioners acted for several investors in relation to potential claims against professional advisors for losses suffered as a result of investments made in the Lateral Investors group of companies.  The charges alleged:

(a)     the appropriation of trust monies on seven occasions towards the firm's bills without the clients having been given the relevant bills and in one case contrary to the express terms of the retainer;

(b)     failure on three occasions to ensure that clients were provided with trust account statements showing appropriations within a reasonable time of the appropriations;

(c)     failure to ensure that separate trust ledger accounts were kept in respect of each client;

(d)     gross overcharging of clients on four occasions in respect of standard form letters sent to multiple addressees;

(e)     failure to maintain adequate communications with clients over the currency of the matter.

The Tribunal found the appellant and the second respondent guilty of unprofessional conduct in each respect as charged.  The Tribunal also found that the appellant gave deliberately false evidence in the proceedings before it.  It recommended that disciplinary proceedings be commenced against him in this Court.

The appellant appeals against the findings of unprofessional conduct and the recommendation that disciplinary proceedings be commenced in this Court.  The Board brings disciplinary proceedings seeking that the appellant's name be struck off the roll of legal practitioners.

Held:

Per the Court:

1.       The Board's allegations and the Tribunal's findings in relation to the six aspects of unprofessional conduct alleged were available on the face of the charge laid in the Tribunal (at [106]-[114]).

Observations about the appropriate form of charges laid in the Tribunal under the Act (at [100]-[104]).

2.       The Tribunal did not err in finding and correctly found that Mr Prescott was guilty of unprofessional conduct in each of the six respects alleged by the Board (at [173]-[182], [190], [197], [208], [226] and [239]).

3.       All of the conduct charged related to the same clients and the same matter. In these circumstances, it was appropriate for the Tribunal to consider the whole of the appellant's conduct to assess whether collectively it amounted to unprofessional conduct. The Tribunal correctly concluded that it did (at [241]).

4.       The Tribunal did not err in finding and correctly found that the appellant gave deliberately false evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prescott v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASCFC 145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal by Mr Prescott, a barrister and solicitor, against a finding of unprofessional conduct made by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board. The conduct in question related to Mr Prescott's involvement with the firm Townsends and later his own practice, Reynolds Prescott, and specifically his dealings with clients who had invested in the Lateral Investors Group. The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board had found Mr Prescott guilty of unprofessional conduct in relation to six charges, all of which stemmed from the same client matters.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Mr Prescott's conduct, when considered collectively, amounted to unprofessional conduct as defined by the relevant legislation. This involved examining his actions concerning client communications, the handling of trust accounts, the appropriation of client funds for legal costs, and the adequacy of his firm's record-keeping and client reporting. The court was required to determine if the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board had erred in its assessment of Mr Prescott's conduct and its classification as unprofessional.

The court reasoned that the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board had correctly considered all the charges collectively, as they all related to the same clients and the same legal matter. This approach allowed for a holistic assessment of Mr Prescott's professional behaviour. The court found that the Board's conclusion that Mr Prescott's conduct amounted to unprofessional conduct was justified, implying that the specific actions detailed in the case text, such as the appropriation of funds without proper client notification or authorisation, and the failure to provide timely and accurate trust account statements, fell below the expected standards of professional conduct for a legal practitioner.

Ultimately, the court dismissed Mr Prescott's appeal, upholding the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board's finding of unprofessional conduct. The court indicated that it would proceed to hear submissions regarding the appropriate orders to be made in the disciplinary proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This exhaustive definition of “unprofessional conduct” applies to that component of the conduct the subject of count 4 which relates to the period between February 1999 and October 2000.Background facts Mr Prescott was admitted as a barrister and solicitor of this Court in 1979. Between 1979 and 1996, he worked as an employed solicitor successively in five law firms. He commenced as an employed solicitor (senior associate) with Townsends in 1997 and became a principal of that firm[11] on 1 July 1998. The other principals were Mr Townsend, Mr Prescott and Mr Allen as at 1 July 1998.[11] Shareholder in and director of the company but designated “partner”. Mr Reynolds was admitted as a barrister and solicitor of this Court in 1991. He worked as an employed solicitor with the predecessor firm of Townsends and became a principal of that firm in 1995. In October 1998, Mr Prescott and Mr Reynolds left Townsends to establish their own practice known as Reynolds Prescott. They dissolved that partnership in August 2000.The Lateral Investors Group Directors of companies in the group included Jim McDonnell, Ian Westcott and Darren Brown. The Group promoted a system known as FIDM, which invested in the futures market and reputedly produced a return variously represented to investors at between 20 and 40 per cent per annum. Approximately 60 family groups in South Australia invested in or through the Group. They included the Schilling, Schubert and Fuss families. Most of those investors were introduced by Mr Askwith, who had an association of some type (never apparently ascertained) with Bird Cameron. In the case of the Schilling, Schubert and Fuss families (from whom witness statements were taken by ASIC in the presence of Mr Prescott), Mr Askwith introduced each family to one or more of the three directors of the Group. The director or directors made representations to the families in the presence of Mr Askwith. They represented that at least 70 per cent of invested funds were deposited with a bank and up to 30 per cent were invested in the FIDM system. The Fuss family invested $185,000 in or with the Lateral Investors Group. These representations were made from late 1995 to early 1996 onwards. Mr Askwith made no representations himself. Approximately 350 Victorian families made investments in or through the Lateral Investors Group. It appears that many of them made investments after receiving advice from a professional investment advisor (there being several different advisors depending on the family). An unknown number of New South Wales and Queensland families also made investments in or through the Lateral Investors Group. In November 1997, the Lateral Investors Group collapsed. The principal companies were placed in liquidation.Instructions to Townsends In December 1997, the Schuberts were referred to Townsends for legal advice concerning their lost investment. Mr Reynolds opened a file in the name of Mr and Mrs Schubert and transferred the file to Mr Prescott, although he retained a supervisory role and undertook some limited work from time to time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Reynolds testified that he relied on employed solicitors, including Mr Prescott, to follow the practice he described. Mr Reynolds testified that it was also the obligation of the solicitor who had the conduct of the file to send out the trust account statements.Mr Reynolds’ evidence Mr Reynolds gave evidence that he did not requisition the trust cheque, which Mr Townsend signed, to pay the first of Townsend’s bills in the Lateral Investors matter. Mr Reynolds denied that he directed Mr Prescott to cause the payment to be made and that he signed the requisition for the first appropriation on 9 March 1998. He explained that, if he had signed the requisition, he would also have signed the cheque. Mr Reynolds testified that he may have become aware of the payment of the bill on reading the green book. With respect to the appropriation of 5 June 1998, Mr Reynolds testified that he did not ask Mr Prescott to prepare the requisition. On Mr Reynolds’ evidence, it came to him in accordance with the ordinary office practice. Mr Reynolds denied that there was an office practice whereby he gave verbal approval before requisitions were prepared. Mr Reynolds’ evidence was that his practice was to sign the trust cheque after confirming that there were sufficient funds in trust to meet the cheque. Mr Reynolds testified that he was first alerted to the absence of trust account statements in July 1998, shortly before he went on leave. Mr Reynolds’ last working day before taking leave was Friday, 23 July 1998. The drafts are dated 22 July 1998. Mr Reynolds thought it probable that he noticed that trust account statements had not been sent when he was considering a requisition to make a further payment of the firm’s legal costs out of the trust account. In considering such a requisition, his practice was to review the trust ledger card. Mr Reynolds thought it was likely that on doing so he saw that the trust deposits of some clients had been appropriated to pay several different bills. The use of the Hartman trust money to pay the Townsends bills F98996 and F98566 on 9 March 1998 and 29 May 1998 respectively and the Harvey Buck disbursement is an example of the multiple appropriations which may have caught Mr Reynolds’ attention. The use of the Edwards trust money is another. Mr Reynolds testified that he looked for the trust account statements to see how those appropriations had been recorded. Mr Reynolds testified that, when he discovered that no trust account statements had been prepared, he drafted trust account statements to address the previous appropriations and the requisition with which he was dealing. Mr Reynolds testified that the draft trust statements he prepared were not authorities for the transfer of the money from trust into firm. Mr Reynolds reaffirmed that it was the requisition slip which authorised the accounts manager to prepare a trust cheque. It is possible that both the absence of trust account statements and the availability of trust funds to make a further payment of Townsend’s bills came to Mr Reynolds’ attention when he considered the requisition of 21 July 1998 to reimburse the firm for Mr Prescott’s travel expenses. It is also possible that Mr Prescott informed Mr Reynolds, by sending through a requisition or telling him, that further payments had been made into the Lateral Investors’ trust account during June and July and that there were funds available to pay Townsends’ bills. Either way, they are likely to have discussed making a further appropriation. The objective facts

Decision

Reasons for decision

All of the conduct charged related to the same clients and the same matter. In these circumstances, it was appropriate for the Tribunal to consider collectively Mr Prescott’s conduct in the six various respects to assess whether collectively it amounted to unprofessional conduct. The Tribunal correctly concluded that it did. Conclusion We dismiss Mr Prescott’s appeal. We will proceed to hear submissions on appropriate orders under section 89 in the disciplinary proceedings.Appendix A

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 11 March, Townsends drew a cheque on its trust account for $140 payable to its Victorian agents. The trust cheque requisition to initiate this payment was signed by Mr Prescott. No bill for that disbursement was sent to any of Townsends’ clients.Exploration of external funding Between December 1997 and May 1998, no substantive work was undertaken by way of investigation of the potential claim against investment advisors or otherwise. Such steps as were taken were limited to exploring internal and then external litigation funding. No report was sent to clients or investors at the end of February, March or April. They were not informed that only seven investors had contributed approximately $15,000, no substantive work had been undertaken, or that the contributions which had been made had been applied to charges for steps taken to the end of January.Contribution by the Schillings On 29 May, the Schillings contributed $20,000 as a first instalment which was credited to the trust account ledger in the name of Mr and Mrs Schubert. On 29 May, Mr Prescott sent a standard letter in common form to 278 Victorian investors. He explained the delays since his initial letter (11 February) as being due to unsuccessful efforts to gain external funding (thwarted by maintenance and champerty). He said that, while there was some prospect of a change in the law, it was very important to progress the matter and conduct the necessary investigation without further delay. He enclosed Terms of Engagement and a Schedule and in this respect his letter was similar to the 29 January letter to South Australian investors. The Terms of Engagement and letter did not address the matters identified at [33] above which had not been addressed in the 29 January letter to South Australian investors.June appropriations On 29 May, Mr Prescott prepared a bill addressed to “Lateral Investors” for work undertaken between March and May. The bill was $11,957.62 for professional fees and a total of $12,298.32. On 5 June, a cheque was drawn on Townsends’ trust account for $22,461.65 and paid into the general account. The cheque was used to pay the February bill and almost all of the May bill. The principal source of the funds used was the contribution of $20,000 made by the Schilling family on 29 May. The trust cheque requisition was completed by a Townsends secretary, Ms Campbell, and she wrote Mr Prescott’s initials on it but it was not signed. Mr Reynolds filled in the amount and signed the trust cheque. There is a dispute as to who caused or was involved in this trust transfer, to which we return later. There is no dispute that Townsends’ February and May bills had not been sent to the clients who had deposited those moneys into Townsends’ trust account or indeed any of the investors. June to July On 9-10 June, 18 June and again on 25 June, Mr Prescott travelled to Coonalpyn to take statements from the Schilling family. Mr Reynolds accompanied Mr Prescott on some or all of those trips. Mr Prescott attended at an interview by ASIC of Mr Fuss on 23 June and of the Schuberts on 26 June.