Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Ardalich

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Full Court: Application)

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v ARDALICH

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Acting Chief Justice Perry, The Honourable Justice Duggan and The Honourable Justice Anderson)

16 December 2005

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - REMOVAL OF NAME FROM ROLL

Application by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board to remove the name of a practitioner from the Roll of Practitioners - defendant had been found guilty by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal ("the Tribunal") of unprofessional conduct in his dealings with clients over a long period of time - conduct involved failing to deal properly with trust monies, including fraudulent conversion of trust monies, delay in complying with clients' instructions, knowingly creating a false document, failing to co-operate with the Board in its investigations and practising the profession of the law while suspended - observations as to appropriate approach to be adopted by the Tribunal where allegations of criminal conduct made against a practitioner - relevance of mental illness - order made striking practitioner from the Roll.

Legal Practitioners Act 1982 s 5(1), s 84(7) and s 89(2)(d); Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 Part 8A, referred to.
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Phillips (2001) 83 SASR 467; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Condon (unreported) Full Court, 3 November 2004, judgment No [2004] SASC 346; Jordan v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (1998) 198 LSJS 434; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Fletcher (unreported) Full Court, 30 September 2005, judgment No [2005] SASC 382; A Solicitor v Council of the Law Society of New South Wales (2003) 216 CLR 253; NSW Bar Association v Cummins (2001) 52 NSWLR 279; In re Davis (1947) 75 CLR 409; Ziems v Prothonotary of the Supreme Court (NSW) (1957) 97 CLR 279, considered.

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v ARDALICH
[2005] SASC 478

Full Court:  Perry ACJ, Duggan and Anderson JJ

  1. PERRY ACJ. This is an application by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (“the Board”) for an order pursuant to s 89(2)(d) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (“the Act”) that the name of the respondent, Alexander Ardalich, a legal practitioner (“the practitioner”) be struck off the Roll of Legal Practitioners.

  2. The application is based upon reports made by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) following an inquiry by the Tribunal, in which the Tribunal found the practitioner to have been guilty of unprofessional conduct.

  3. The Tribunal had before it a charge laid by the Board relating to a number of transactions which, with one exception, occurred in the course of the conduct by the practitioner of his practice during the period between 4 January 1996 and 7 August 1998. The exception is that one of the counts included in the charge alleged unreasonable delay in carrying out instructions to obtain a grant of probate between March 1992 and August 1998.

  4. The charge comprised in all some 29 counts, of which the Tribunal found the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Ardalich and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 478
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board applied to the Supreme Court of Queensland to remove a lawyer's name from the Roll of Practitioners. The Board alleged that the practitioner was guilty of unprofessional conduct over a period of time, including fraudulent conversion of trust monies, delay in complying with clients' instructions, knowingly creating a false document, failing to cooperate with the Board's investigations, and practising law while suspended. The practitioner was acquitted of criminal charges due to mental incompetence but was found guilty of unprofessional conduct by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal.

The legal issues before the court were whether the practitioner's conduct constituted professional misconduct, and if so, whether the appropriate sanction was to remove the practitioner's name from the Roll of Practitioners. The court considered whether the Tribunal's findings were supported by the evidence, and whether the practitioner's mental illness was a mitigating factor.

The court found that the Tribunal's findings of professional misconduct were supported by the evidence, and that the practitioner's mental illness was a mitigating factor but did not excuse the seriousness of his conduct. The court held that the practitioner's conduct was serious and extended over a significant period of time, and that the only appropriate sanction was to remove the practitioner's name from the Roll of Practitioners. The court emphasised the importance of maintaining public confidence in the legal profession and the need to protect clients from practitioners who engage in unprofessional conduct.

The court made an order striking the practitioner's name from the Roll of Practitioners. The court noted that the order was not intended to punish the practitioner but to protect the public and maintain the integrity of the legal profession. The court also noted that the order was not a criminal conviction and did not prevent the practitioner from seeking to be readmitted to the Roll of Practitioners in the future, subject to satisfying the Board of his fitness to practise.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Ardalich revolves around the application by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board to remove the name of a lawyer from the Roll of Practitioners. The lawyer, identified as Ardalich, was found guilty by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal of numerous acts of unprofessional conduct spanning from 1996 to 1998. The misconduct included fraudulent conversion of client trust monies, significant delays in attending to client affairs, creation of false documents to cover up his actions, and failure to cooperate with the Board’s investigations. His professional misconduct continued even after he was suspended from practising law. Despite being acquitted of related criminal charges due to mental incompetence, the Tribunal concluded that his actions amounted to unprofessional conduct. The Tribunal’s findings were corroborated by reports which detailed Ardalich’s persistent and varied instances of misconduct over the years.

Further, the Tribunal examined the relevance of Ardalich’s mental illness as a mitigating factor, but ultimately found his conduct to be too serious to be met with any penalty short of striking his name from the Roll. The Tribunal also noted that while Ardalich’s mental condition played a role, it did not excuse his repeated and deliberate breaches of professional standards. The misconduct involved substantial sums of money, and the Tribunal’s reports emphasized the seriousness and extent of Ardalich’s actions over a significant period. The court held that the Tribunal’s findings warranted the severe measure of removal from the Roll of Practitioners. The court found that the gravity of the misconduct, coupled with the length of time over which it occurred and the substantial financial implications, justified the decision to strike Ardalich’s name from the Roll.

The matter before the court was an application by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board to remove the name of a practitioner from the Roll of Practitioners. This application followed the practitioner being found guilty by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal of multiple instances of unprofessional conduct. These included fraudulent conversion of trust monies, delays in complying with client instructions, creation of false documents, failure to co-operate with the Board's investigations, and continuing to practice law while suspended. The Tribunal's findings were based on extensive evidence and reports submitted by the Board, which detailed the practitioner's misconduct over a period spanning from 1996 to 1998. Although the practitioner was acquitted of related criminal charges due to mental incompetence, the Tribunal concluded that his conduct could still amount to professional misconduct. The court considered the recommendations of the Tribunal, along with its own discretion in disciplinary matters, leading to the decision to strike the practitioner from the Roll. This case illustrates the court's role in upholding professional standards and ensuring the integrity of the legal profession.

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRY ACJ DUGGAN J ANDERSON J
While the practitioner’s mental illness was a mitigating factor, he submitted, in effect, that the offending conduct was too serious to be met with by anything short of an order striking the practitioner off the Roll.Conclusion There can be no doubt, having regard to the terms of the reports furnished by the Tribunal, that the practitioner was guilty of professional misconduct in the course of his practice between 1996 and 1998. The misconduct took a variety of forms, and included a number of separate acts of fraudulent conversion of monies held in his trust account; inordinate delay in attending to his clients’ affairs; and creating false documents designed to conceal his conduct. Although he was acquitted of the criminal charges by reason of mental incompetence, for the reasons which I have given, the practitioner’s conduct in connection with those alleged offences was nonetheless capable of amounting to unprofessional conduct:… even though conduct was not engaged in directly in the course of professional practice, it may be so connected to such practice as to amount to professional misconduct. Furthermore, even where it does not involve professional misconduct a person’s behaviour may demonstrate qualities of a kind that require a conclusion that a person is not a fit and proper person to practise.[7][7] A Solicitor v Council of the Law Society of New South Wales (2003) 216 CLR 253 per Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow, Kirby and Callinan JJ at 267 citing NSW Bar Association v Cummins (2001) 52 NSWLR 279 at 291 [66], In re Davis (1947) 75 CLR 409 and Ziems v Prothonotary of the Supreme Court (NSW) (1957) 97 CLR 279 at 298. If it was necessary to do so, I would also have regard to the practitioner’s misconduct involved in the offences of forgery and uttering which occurred in March and April 1999 and which were dealt with in the District Court. This Court is not bound to have regard only to the report of the Tribunal. Disciplinary proceedings are proceedings sui generis. They are not adversarial in nature.[8] The Court is not limited to any issue struck between the parties and is not bound to consider the case simply on the basis on which it may have been presented.[8] Jordan (supra) per Doyle CJ at [32]. Of course, that is subject to the requirements of natural justice which oblige the Court to afford a proper opportunity to the parties to be heard as to any matter arising in the proceedings which could affect the outcome of them. That we might take that course was not a matter which was argued on the hearing of the application. Given that the matters which were relied on by the Board in pursuing the application are of sufficient gravity to warrant striking off, I do not think it necessary to have regard further to the matters dealt with in the District Court. Given the seriousness of the practitioner’s conduct and the fact that it extended over a not inconsiderable period of time, and allowing also for the fact that substantial sums of money were involved in many of the transactions, I am of the view that the only proper course for this Court to take is to make the order sought.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRY ACJ, DUGGAN J, ANDERSON J

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (Board) applied for the removal of a practitioner's name from the Roll of Practitioners, citing extensive professional misconduct. The court considered whether the Board had established sufficient grounds for removal, acknowledging the practitioner's mental illness as a mitigating factor but ultimately finding the misconduct too serious to warrant any other penalty. The practitioner's misconduct included fraudulent conversion of trust monies, significant delays in client matters, and the creation of false documents to cover up his actions. These actions were deliberate and spanned over several years, indicating a pattern of unprofessional conduct.

In assessing the weight of the practitioner's mental illness, the court noted it as a mitigating factor but determined that it did not absolve the practitioner of the serious nature of his misconduct. The court relied on previous cases that underscored the seriousness of professional misconduct, such as "A Solicitor v Council of the Law Society of New South Wales," where it was held that even behaviour outside direct professional practice could amount to professional misconduct if connected to the profession. The court's decision aligned with the principle that a practitioner must demonstrate fitness to continue practising, regardless of their mental health status.

The court found the misconduct, including fraudulent conversion of trust monies and delays in client instructions, amounted to professional misconduct. This conclusion was drawn from the Tribunal's findings and the practitioner's actions, which were deliberate and spanned several years. The practitioner's acquittal on related criminal charges due to mental incompetence did not shield him from the Tribunal's findings of unprofessional conduct. The court emphasized that professional misconduct could stem from conduct connected to legal practice, even if not directly engaged in the course of professional duties.

Regarding the practitioner's conduct in connection with alleged criminal offences, the court ruled that despite the acquittal due to mental incompetence, the conduct could still be considered unprofessional. The court referred to cases like "NSW Bar Association v Cummins," which held that behaviour demonstrating unfitness to practice could lead to a finding of unprofessional conduct. The practitioner's actions, including forgery and uttering, were connected to his professional practice and thus constituted unprofessional conduct.

The court clarified that while disciplinary proceedings are not adversarial, they are not entirely unrestricted in scope. The court can consider matters outside the Tribunal's report if necessary, provided natural justice is observed. The court found that the matters presented by the Board were grave enough to warrant removal from the Roll without needing to consider additional offences dealt with in the District Court. The seriousness of the misconduct, the extended period over which it occurred, and the substantial sums involved all contributed to the court's decision to strike the practitioner off the Roll.