Praljak v Department of Defence

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Praljak v Department of Defence [2021] FCA 1668

File number: QUD 233 of 2021
Judgment of: LOGAN J
Date of judgment: 14 December 2021
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – separate question – application for leave under s 46PO of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) – where applicant’s application to join the Australian Defence Forces refused on basis of medical ineligibility – where applicant claimed discrimination – whether either or each of s 53 or s 21A of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) allow for the discrimination subject of the application – where applicant has admitted permanent lower back condition and mental conditions – where evidence shows that all positions in Australian Defence Forces requires particular physical demands – where case has no merit – leave refused
Legislation:

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) ss 46PH, 46PO

Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) ss 21A, 53

Motor Accidents Act 1988 (NSW) s 52

Cases cited:

Catholic Education Office v Clarke (2004) 138 FCR 121

Eastman v Shamrock Consultancy Pty Ltd [2018] FCCA 3436

James v WorkPower Inc [2018] FCA 2083

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355

Salido v Nominal Defendant (1993) 32 NSWLR 524

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 37
Date of hearing: 14 December 2021
Counsel for the Applicant: The applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr JAS Ford
Solicitor for the Respondents: Norton Rose Fulbright

ORDERS

QUD 233 of 2021
BETWEEN:

ADRIAN PRALJAK

Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA DEPARTMENT OF DEFENCE

First Respondent

CAPTAIN JE NOONAN

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

LOGAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 DECEMBER 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave pursuant to s 46PO(3A) of the Australia Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) be refused.

2.Consequentially, the application be dismissed.

3.The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the application, to be fixed by a Registrar if not agreed.

4.The time within which any application for leave to appeal, if available, or the filing of a notice of appeal, if such right exists, be extended to Friday, 4 February 2022.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(REVISED FROM TRANSCRIPT)

LOGAN J:

  1. In H.R. Kilbourne’s work, Dr Johnson and War, the following exchange between Dr Johnson and his great companion, Boswell, is related:

    We talked of War. JOHNSON. “Every man things meanly of himself for not having been a soldier, or not having been at sea. ‘BOSWELL’. Lord Mansfield [Chief Justice of England] does not. ‘JOHNSON’. Sir, if Lord Mansfield were in a company of General Officers and Admirals who have been in service, he would shrink; he’d wish to creep under the table …  No, Sir, were Socrates and Charles the Twelfth of Sweden both present in any company, and Socrates to say, “Follow me, and hear a lecture in philosophy;”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Praljak v Department of Defence and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1668
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Praljak v Department of Defence concerns the applicant's claim of discrimination by the Defence Force in refusing his application to join the Australian Defence Forces due to medical ineligibility. The applicant alleged that this refusal constituted unlawful disability discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth). The applicant has admitted to having a permanent lower back condition and certain mental conditions. The court was required to determine whether the exemptions in sections 53 and 21A of the Disability Discrimination Act allow for the discrimination claimed by the applicant.

The court examined the inherent requirements of service in the ADF, which include the ability to perform arduous physical activities and to be deployed to dangerous operational environments at short notice. Given the applicant's permanent disabilities, particularly his fear of heights, claustrophobia, extreme anxiety, and lower back injury, the court found that these disabilities rendered him unable to meet the inherent requirements of service in the ADF. The court held that sections 53 and 21A of the Disability Discrimination Act apply to the subject matter of the applicant's complaint, thereby exempting the Defence Force's decisions from being considered unlawful discrimination. Consequently, the court refused the applicant's leave under section 46PO of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth), dismissed the application, and ordered the applicant to pay the respondents' costs.

The final orders of the court were as follows: leave pursuant to section 46PO(3A) of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) was refused; the application was dismissed; the applicant was ordered to pay the respondents' costs; and the time within which any application for leave to appeal, if available, or the filing of a notice of appeal, if such right exists, was extended to Friday, 4 February 2022.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave pursuant to s 46PO(3A) of the Australia Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) be refused.

2. Consequentially, the application be dismissed.

3. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the application, to be fixed by a Registrar if not agreed.

4. The time within which any application for leave to appeal, if available, or the filing of a notice of appeal, if such right exists, be extended to Friday, 4 February 2022.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is helpful in understanding the occasion for the institution of proceedings to identify with precision why it was that the Australian Defence Force, via Captain Noonan, refused, and will hereafter refuse, to recruit Mr Praljak. The President’s delegate stated:Reasons for my decision The DDA makes it unlawful to discriminate against individuals on the ground of disability in the area of employment, including in arrangements made for the purpose of determining who should be offered employment and in determining who should be offered employment.However, the DDA also contains exemptions which say that in specific situations, treating a person differently because of their disability in employment will not be unlawful discrimination.You claim that the 2018, 2019 and 2020 decisions regarding your unsuitability for military service and the decision to ‘permanently withdraw’ your application for service on the basis that Defence formed the view that ‘due to your permanent disabilities you are and will continue to be unfit for service’, amount to unlawful disability discrimination.However, I consider that the exemptions in sections 53 and/or 21A of the DDA apply to the subject matter of your complaint. Section 53 says that it is not unlawful to discriminate against a person on the ground of his or her disability in connection with employment in the ADF in a position involving the performance of combat duties, combat-related duties or peacekeeping service.The term ‘combat duties’ is defined in the Disability Discrimination Regulations 2019 (Cth) as duties which require or are likely to require a person to commit, or participate directly in the commission of, an act of violence in the event of armed conflict. The term ‘combat-related duties’ is defined as duties which require, or are likely to require, a person to undertake training or preparation for, or in connection with, combat duties and/or work in support of a person performing combat duties.I consider that the positions you have identified when applying to the ADF (including Legal Officer – Royal Australian Navy Full Time, Legal Officer – Australian Army Full Time, Legal Officer – Australian Army Full Time, Chef (Cook) – Royal Australian Air Force Full Time, Chef (Maritime Logistics Chief) – Royal Australian Navy Full Time and Aviation ground Crew (Ground Crew Aircraft Support) – Australian Army Full Time) would all satisfy the definition of ‘combat related duties’ as set out above. Therefore, I consider that section 53 applies to the subject matter of your complaint with the effect that decisions made to decline and/or permanently withdraw your applications for entry into the ADF because of your disabilities would not be unlawful.If I am incorrect about the application of section 53 to your complaint, I also consider that Section 21A of the DDA applies. Section 21A says that it is not unlawful to discriminate against a person on the ground of their disability if the discrimination relates to particular work and because of the disability the aggrieved person, the aggrieved person would be unable to carry out the inherent requirements of the particular work even if reasonable adjustments are made for the person.The information before the Commission supports that an inherent requirement of service in the ADF is that all candidates must be able to meet minimum requirements for entry. These minimum requirements appear to include the ongoing ability to participate in and undertake (whether in training, on exercise or on deployment), arduous physical activity ‘including sustained load carrying, marching, running, and other physical training activities’. It also appears from information before the Commission, including the MILPERSMAN and repeated correspondence to you from Defence regarding your applications and appeals, supports that it is an inherent requirement of service in the ADF that a person is able to be deployed to or near war zones and dangerous operational environments at short notice. It also appears to be The information before me indicates that since 2018 you have been consistently advised that your disabilities are ‘incompatible’ with the requirements of service in the ADF as you have been unable on successive occasions to meet the minimum requirements for entry in the ADF because of your disabilities. It is noted that in his 2019 letter to you the Director General Defence Force Recruiting advised that your ‘disabling fear of heights and claustrophobia’, resulting in an inability to work at height and/or in enclosed spaces as well as work in multi-level buildings ‘is not compatible with service life’. In that same letter you were also advised that your disc degenerative changes mean that the changes in your spine have a “high likelihood of becoming aggravated as a result of this activity [load, carrying, marching, running and other physical activity] rendering your physically incapacitated and unable to complete tasks…as a result, this diagnosis precludes you from entry into the ADF”.Finally, you were also advised that should you have a desire to contribute to defence capability, you may wish to pursue a career within the Australian Public Service.Throughout 2020 you were also informed, as a result of your applications and subsequent appeals, that your permanent disabilities are considered to be incompatible with military service. On 28 September 2020, Dr Kotie Ras wrote to you confirming that your back condition makes you permanently unfit for military service. It appears that you then continued to write to Defence, including on 11 November 2020. In that correspondence you request, ‘on special grounds’ a fulltime employment role for yourself within the ADF.It appears that Captain Noonan’s letter to you dated 13 November 2020 was in response to your 11 November 2020 correspondence referred to above, as well as reflective of the numerous previous decisions and letters to you from members of the ADF advising you that your disabilities are not compatible with military service.In the letter to you dated 13 November 2020, Captain Noonan advises you of the following: “In light of your permanent disability due to ‘vertigo, acrophobia, claustrophobia, extreme anxiety and lower back injury’ I find that you are, and will continue to be, permanently unfit for military service. As such, I have directed that your application for entry into the Australian Defence Force be permanently withdrawn. This has been noted on your recruiting dossier, and is an enduring direction”.I do not consider Captain Noonan’s letter amounts to unlawful disability discrimination in the context of your having already been advised on repeated occasions (both by first instance decisions and on appeal) that your permanent disabilities are not compatible with military service.Given the unique nature of employment in the ADF (including the minimum entry requirements for service and training and deployment requirements), and the restrictions you have as a result of your fear of heights and claustrophobia (including the medications you are required to take) and your multilevel degenerative spine condition, I consider it to be arguable that your disabilities mean that you are unable to perform the inherent requirements of a role within the ADF.I appreciate that this may be very disappointing for you. However, on the basis of the information before me, I consider that sections 53 and 21A of the DDA apply with the effect that the decisions made in relation to your applications for service within the ADF are not unlawful.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established