POPOVIC & ORS v TANASIJEVIC & ORS (NO 6)
[2000] SASC 186
OLSSON J On 31 March 2000 I published reasons setting out my detailed findings of fact and my fundamental conclusions on the evidence led at trial in this matter (Popovic & Ors v Tanasijevic & Ors (No 5) [2000] SASC 87) (“the reasons”). I then adjourned the proceedings to enable counsel to consider those findings.
When the matter subsequently came before me for the pronouncing of a formal order in light of my reasons, the parties were at odds as to the proper format of that order. Mr Sallis, of counsel for the plaintiffs, had produced very lengthy minutes which, in effect, sought many and varied declarations reflecting findings made in my published reasons. Mr Ross-Smith, of counsel for the defendants, objected to that draft, inter alia, on the basis that many of the proposed declarations were, in form, not declarations of right, but declarations of fact. I expressed agreement with that contention and declined to accede to the draft minutes.
I have now received full written and oral submissions from the parties concerning the form in which the order should be expressed. The present, supplementary reasons address those aspects.
It will be recalled that, in the reasons, I concluded that the affairs of the SCWA had, within the meaning of s61 of the Associations Incorporation Act 1985, been conducted in a manner that was oppressive to its members and contrary to the interests of the members as a whole.
I arrived at those conclusions upon multiple bases. In the broad, and without now seeking to be fully definitive, I based my conclusions on findings that:-
The defendants had caused an amended Constitution and Rules to be registered with the Corporate Affairs Commission, which purported to evidence significant changes to eligibility for membership of the SCWA and of the mode of composition and election of its committee of management, when that Constitution and Rules had not lawfully been adopted by the membership of the SCWA; and
There had been gross departures from the proper and lawful administration of the affairs of the SCWA.
I accepted that, at relevant times:-
The committee of management of the SCWA had, in effect, abdicated its responsibilities and permitted the defendant Tanasijevic to enter into the various financial transactions adverted to earlier in the reasons and to direct the making of payments not for the direct purposes or in the interests of the SCWA, without the authority of either a general or specific resolution of the committee;
Meetings of the SCWA had not been lawfully convened or purported meetings had not been convened at all, nor resolutions lawfully passed, as recited in the reasons;
Amendments to the Constitution and Rules of the SCWA had been registered when it was patent that they had not lawfully been passed;
Purported committees had been “elected” in contravention of the Constitution and Rules of the SCWA
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Popovic v Tanasijevic & Ors (No 6) No. Scgrg-96-279 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 186
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the evidence and concluded that the affairs of the SCWA had been conducted in a manner that was oppressive to its members and contrary to their interests. The defendants had unlawfully altered the Constitution and Rules of the SCWA, failed to maintain proper records, and allowed ineligible members to participate in the association's affairs. The court found that the only practical method of correcting the SCWA's Constitution and Rules was by making an appropriate order under the relevant legislation. The court also considered the findings regarding the membership of the SCSA and the committee of management of the SCWA, but noted that making formal declarations of right regarding these matters was inappropriate as the SCSA and its members were not parties to the proceedings.
The court ultimately decided that the plaintiffs were legally entitled to the declarations and orders they sought, based on the findings of fact and conclusions reached. The court acknowledged the practical concerns regarding the proposed order but concluded that it was necessary to revert to the original constitutional structure of the SCWA to address the oppression identified. The court also rejected the defendants' argument that the claim of one of the plaintiffs should be dismissed, finding that it was not necessary to reach a final conclusion on the plaintiff's standing in the matter.
The final orders of the court included declarations regarding the invalidity of the currently registered Constitution and Rules of the SCWA, the status of the personal plaintiffs, and the need to regularise the SCWA's affairs. The court also made an order to allow for the replacement of the unlawfully registered Constitution and Rules with a new and appropriate set of rules, taking into account the findings of fact and the need for a workable constitutional structure. The court emphasised that while it had misgivings about the practical implications of the proposed order, it was necessary to adhere to the legal entitlement of the plaintiffs based on the findings of the court.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: OLSSON J