Plaintiff M7/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GORDON J

PLAINTIFF M7/2021  PLAINTIFF

AND

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS  DEFENDANT

Plaintiff M7/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs

[2021] HCA 14

Date of Hearing: 30 March 2021
Date of Judgment: 15 April 2021

M7/2021

ORDER

1.Pursuant to s 486A(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), the period within which an application may be made for a remedy to be granted in relation to a decision made by a delegate of the defendant on 12 June 2020 is extended to 29 January 2021.

2.Pursuant to r 4.02 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth), the time fixed by rr 25.02.1 and 25.02.2(b) be enlarged in respect of this application.

3.A writ of certiorari issue to quash the decision made by a delegate of the defendant on 12 June 2020 to refuse to grant the plaintiff a protection visa.

4.A writ of mandamus issue directed to the defendant requiring the defendant to determine the plaintiff's application for a protection visa according to law.

5.The defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to the application.

Representation

N P Karapanagiotidis for the plaintiff (instructed by Asylum Seeker Resource Centre)

C L Symons for the defendant (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GORDON J.   The plaintiff seeks constitutional writs, a writ of certiorari and other relief in respect of a decision made by a delegate of the defendant, the Minister for Home Affairs ("the delegate"), on 12 June 2020 to refuse to grant the plaintiff a protection visa ("the impugned decision"). The plaintiff claimed protection on the basis that he feared persecution in Pakistan on account of his homosexuality. The plaintiff claimed, among other things, that he left Pakistan because he faced torture and violence from his family as a result of his homosexuality; that he had been beaten publicly by his father in Pakistan and that his father has threatened to kill him if he returns; and that he cannot relocate to another area of Pakistan because there is no safe area for members of the LGBT community, who can be whipped or stoned to death under Islamic law in Pakistan.

  2. In the impugned decision, the delegate made a finding, among others, that the evidence, including "open source social media", did not support the view that the plaintiff was a known homosexual in Pakistan. The plaintiff's principal complaint is that the delegate failed to comply with s 57 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) because the delegate failed to disclose the open source social media or provide particulars of that information to the plaintiff to enable him to understand why that information was relevant to consideration of his application for a protection visa. The plaintiff submitted that the delegate's failure to comply with s 57 of the Migration Act thereby denied him the opportunity to ascertain the relevant issues and denied him the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plaintiff M7/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] HCA 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Plaintiff M7/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs*, the plaintiff, a citizen of Pakistan, sought a protection visa on the grounds of feared persecution due to his homosexuality. The delegate of the Minister refused the visa, finding that evidence, including "open source social media," did not support the plaintiff's claim of being known as homosexual in Pakistan. The matter came before Gordon J of the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issue was whether the Minister's delegate had complied with section 57(2) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth). Specifically, the court had to determine if the delegate had failed to provide the plaintiff with particulars of the "relevant information" derived from open source social media, and whether this failure prevented the plaintiff from understanding why the information was relevant to his protection visa application and from providing a meaningful response.

Gordon J reasoned that the open source social media information, which included details from the plaintiff's Facebook activity and dating applications, constituted "relevant information" under section 57(1) of the *Migration Act*. The delegate's failure to disclose the substance of this information or provide sufficient particulars to enable the plaintiff to understand its relevance and comment upon it meant that section 57(2) had not been complied with. The court applied the principle that a party must be afforded a reasonable opportunity to respond to adverse information that is material to their application.

Consequently, the High Court ordered that a writ of certiorari issue to quash the delegate's decision to refuse the protection visa. A writ of mandamus was also ordered, directing the Minister to determine the plaintiff's protection visa application according to law. The court also extended the time for the plaintiff to seek relief and ordered the Minister to pay the plaintiff's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 486A(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), the period within which an application may be made for a remedy to be granted in relation to a decision made by a delegate of the defendant on 12 June 2020 is extended to 29 January 2021.

2. Pursuant to r 4.02 of the High Court Rules 2004 (Cth), the time fixed by rr 25.02.1 and 25.02.2(b) be enlarged in respect of this application.

3. A writ of certiorari issue to quash the decision made by a delegate of the defendant on 12 June 2020 to refuse to grant the plaintiff a protection visa.

4. A writ of mandamus issue directed to the defendant requiring the defendant to determine the plaintiff's application for a protection visa according to law.

5. The defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

As these reasons will explain, in relation to the open source social media information, the delegate did fail to comply with s 57 of the Migration Act. The plaintiff should be granted the extension of time he seeks to prosecute his application for relief in this Court and, consistent with that application, a writ of certiorari should issue to quash the impugned decision and a writ of mandamus should issue to compel the Minister to consider and determine the application according to law. Facts and background The facts are not in dispute. The plaintiff is a citizen of Pakistan. On 22 November 2015, the plaintiff travelled to Australia by plane as the holder of a subclass 573 Student Higher Education visa. On 21 February 2017, that visa was cancelled. On 23 March 2018, the plaintiff applied for a protection visa, claiming he left Pakistan because, among other things, he faced torture and violence from his family as a result of his homosexuality. Some two years later, on 25 February 2020, the plaintiff was interviewed by a delegate of the Minister. An unofficial transcript of that interview was in evidence. Both parties relied on the transcript. In order to address the plaintiff's review grounds, it is necessary to set out particular aspects of that interview concerning what might be described as "open source social media". After the plaintiff was asked during his interview, "[a]re you on Facebook?", and the plaintiff said "[y]es", the transcript then records the following exchange:"DO: Did you get married in April 2015?A: Sorry?DO: Did you get married in April 2015?A: No I never got married.DO: So what's this occasion, can you see that? [Delegate shows [the plaintiff] something]A:Yeah, yeah it's a function called Mehndi – so it was my friend's brother's Mehndi.DO:What is celebrated? What is Mehndi? What are you celebrating there? Why are people congratulating you?A:It's the night, it's the night before marriage, one night before marriage night. So it was my, my friend's brother's Mehndi function.DO: Yeah and so what was the friend's brother's name?A:It's uh ... my friend's name is [E].DO:Who was the person getting married?A:No it's not the person getting married, the person who was getting married, the person who was getting married – his nickname was [B] but I remember his, his full name um ... is [A], [A], the person who was getting married." The delegate later asked the plaintiff whether he was in contact with a previous partner on social media – "on Facebook or Insta or anything like that? Snapchat?" The plaintiff responded "[n]o". In relation to his family, the following exchange between the plaintiff and the delegate took place:"DO:Alright so who knows that you're gay in your family?A: My whole family.DO: Everyone?A: Yeah.DO: So father, mother?A: Yeah and my siblings.DO:Your mother never knew before? When did she first know then, when you were 17?A: Yes.DO: But you're still friends with them on Facebook.A: Yes.DO:So why is that? You're friends with them. You say that you don't talk to any of your family, but that's not true. You do talk to them on Facebook.A:I talk to, I talk to my siblings and my mother, because they never, they never beated me.DO: So they've got no problem with you, have they?A:They don't have like, they don't, they don't want me to, because of, because of my father, they don't tell my father that we are, that we are talking to him.DO:So you're saying that your family are supportive, besides your father. That your mother is, and your brothers – I think you've got 2 brothers haven't you – and a sister, they all support you.A: They don't support me in a way like that 'we want you in our family back'. They don't, they don't support me in a way like that. They only, they only talk to me because I, like, I'm their blood relation, that's why they only talk to me.DO: Well they're not obliged to talk to you on Facebook and to like pictures you've put there and to make little comments saying, you know 'Ma'shallah Bro' and all this sort of thing. They're not obliged to do that, no one is.A:Yeah I know but I never replied to their comments and stuff like that."The plaintiff also volunteered that he remained in occasional contact with a former partner via Facebook and referred to a dating application he had used called "Whisper".

Decision

Reasons for decision

GORDON J
Issues
1. Did the defendant fail to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) by not disclosing open source social media information to the plaintiff, and providing particulars that would enable the plaintiff to understand why it was relevant to his protection visa application?
2. Is open source social media information considered "relevant information" within the meaning of s 57(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)?
3. Was the failure to disclose open source social media information and provide particulars to the plaintiff a breach of natural justice principles?
4. Does the failure to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) render the delegate's decision to refuse the plaintiff's protection visa application legally invalid?

Held
1. The court held that the defendant failed to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) by not disclosing open source social media information to the plaintiff, and providing particulars that would enable the plaintiff to understand why it was relevant to his protection visa application. The result was that the court found the defendant in breach of this requirement.

2. The court held that open source social media information is considered "relevant information" within the meaning of s 57(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The court found that such information can be pertinent to an application for a protection visa.

3. The court held that the failure to disclose open source social media information and provide particulars to the plaintiff was a breach of natural justice principles. The court found this to be the case and highlighted the importance of providing sufficient information to allow for meaningful response.

4. The court held that the failure to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) does not necessarily render the delegate's decision to refuse the plaintiff's protection visa application legally invalid. However, in this case, the failure was a significant factor in the court's decision to quash the decision and order a new consideration of the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GORDON J

In the Plaintiff M7/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs case, the court found that the defendant, a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs, failed to comply with section 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The court held that the delegate did not disclose open source social media information to the plaintiff and did not provide particulars that would enable the plaintiff to understand why it was relevant to his protection visa application. The court concluded that the failure to disclose open source social media information and provide particulars to the plaintiff was a breach of natural justice principles. The court held that open source social media information is considered "relevant information" within the meaning of s 57(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The court held that the failure to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) rendered the delegate's decision to refuse the plaintiff's protection visa application legally invalid.

The court found that the delegate did not disclose open source social media information to the plaintiff and did not provide particulars that would enable the plaintiff to understand why it was relevant to his protection visa application. The court held that the delegate's failure to disclose open source social media information and provide particulars to the plaintiff was a breach of natural justice principles. The court held that the principles of natural justice require that a person be given an opportunity to meaningfully respond to any information that may adversely affect their case. The court held that the delegate's failure to disclose open source social media information and provide particulars to the plaintiff denied the plaintiff the opportunity to meaningfully respond to the information.

The court held that open source social media information is considered "relevant information" within the meaning of s 57(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The court held that the meaning of "relevant information" is not limited to information that is directly related to the applicant's claim for a protection visa. The court held that information that may indirectly affect the applicant's claim for a protection visa is also considered "relevant information". The court held that open source social media information may indirectly affect the applicant's claim for a protection visa by providing evidence that the applicant's sexual identity is known in their country of origin.

The court held that the failure to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) rendered the delegate's decision to refuse the plaintiff's protection visa application legally invalid. The court held that s 57(2) required the delegate to give particulars of "relevant information" to the plaintiff to ensure, as far as reasonably practicable, the plaintiff understood why it was relevant, and invite the plaintiff to comment. The court held that the delegate's failure to disclose open source social media information and provide particulars to the plaintiff was a failure to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The court held that the failure to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) rendered the delegate's decision to refuse the plaintiff's protection visa application legally invalid.

The court distinguished the case of Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS [2013] HCA 35; 251 CLR 420, where the High Court held that the failure to disclose information to an applicant for a protection visa did not necessarily render the decision to refuse the applicant's visa application legally invalid. The court held that the case of Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS was distinguishable because the High Court did not consider whether the failure to disclose information to the applicant was a breach of natural justice principles. The court held that the failure to disclose open source social media information and provide particulars to the plaintiff was a breach of natural justice principles and, therefore, rendered the delegate's decision to refuse the plaintiff's protection visa application legally invalid.

In conclusion, the court found that the delegate did fail to comply with s 57 of the Migration Act. The court held that the failure to disclose open source social media information and provide particulars to the plaintiff was a breach of natural justice principles and rendered the delegate's decision to refuse the plaintiff's protection visa application legally invalid. The court held that open source social media information is considered "relevant information" within the meaning of s 57(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The ratio decidendi of the case is that the failure to comply with s 57(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) by not disclosing open source social media information to the plaintiff, and providing particulars that would enable the plaintiff to understand why it was relevant to his protection visa application, is a breach of natural justice principles and renders the decision to refuse the plaintiff's protection visa application legally invalid.