Pilkington (Australia) Ltd v Minister for Justice and Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Pilkington (Australia) Ltd v Minister for Justice and Customs [2002] FCA 770

CUSTOMS AND EXCISE – Anti-dumping – Determination of whether goods exported to Australia had been dumped or whether goods imported in the future might be dumped – Whether Minister ought to have taken into account up to date information including information concerning the conduct of exporters after the expiration of the investigation period – Whether Minister, in deciding whether to issue dumping notices, limited to considering information contained in report of Chief Executive Officer of Australian Customs Service.

Customs Act 1901 (Cth) ss 269TACB, 269TB(1), 269TC(4), 269TDAA(2) and (3), 269TEA, 269TG, 269ZZ, 269ZZK

Anti-Dumping Authority v Deggussa AG (1994) 52 FCR 414 considered

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 referred to

PILKINGTON (AUSTRALIA) LTD v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND CUSTOMS AND PT ASAHIMAS FLAT GLASS TBK

N 1092 of 2001

MOORE J
18 JUNE 2002
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1092 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

PILKINGTON (AUSTRALIA) LTD
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND CUSTOMS
FIRST RESPONDENT

PT ASAHIMAS FLAT GLASS TBK
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 JUNE 2002

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The application be dismissed.
  2. The applicant pay the respondents' costs.

Note:         Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1092 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

PILKINGTON (AUSTRALIA) LTD
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND CUSTOMS
FIRST RESPONDENT

PT ASAHIMAS FLAT GLASS TBK
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE:

18 JUNE 2002

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. This is an application by Pilkington (Australia) Limited ("Pilkington") under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) and the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) seeking judicial review of a decision (or several parts of a decision) of the Minister for Justice and Customs ("the Minister") under the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) ("the Act"). The decision was made on or about 28 May 2001. It dealt with an application by Pilkington made on 17 November 1999 alleging that clear float glass of various nominal thicknesses ("the glass") exported from Indonesia was being dumped in Australia. Two Indonesian exporters allegedly dumping the glass were Asahimas Float Glass Tbk ("Asahimas") and PT Muliaglass ("Muliaglass"). Before setting out the background it is convenient to describe, in outline, the legislative scheme under which the Minister made his contentious decision.

    Legislation in outline

  2. Part XVB of the Act contains a scheme for investigating complaints of dumping of goods in Australia and determining measures to be taken in relation to prior dumping and to prevent the dumping of goods in the future. The following analysis of the legislative scheme focuses principally on the mechanism for considering and resolving an application of the type presently under consideration. That is, a complaint by an Australian manufacturer about the dumping of goods exported from another country.

  3. An…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pilkington (Australia) Ltd v Minister for Justice and Custom... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 770
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pilkington (Australia) Ltd brought a case against the Minister for Justice and Customs, alleging that the Minister's decision to take no action against Asahimas and limited action against Muliaglass resulted from the Minister's failure to consider up-to-date material. This material was relevant to whether Asahimas had been dumping glass and might do so in the future, and whether Muliaglass had dumped and might dump glass more extensively than had been identified in the investigation. Pilkington based its case on the decision of the Full Court in Anti-Dumping Authority v Deggussa AG, where the court held that the Anti-Dumping Authority and the Minister must consider up-to-date material when determining whether goods have been dumped.

The court had to decide whether the requirement in the legislative scheme for the investigating and recommending body to consider up-to-date material, as established in Anti-Dumping Authority v Deggussa AG, had survived amendments to the scheme, in particular, the introduction of s 269TACB. The court considered the operation of the legislative scheme in the present case, which created an administrative scheme for determination by the Minister of whether goods have been, or may be, dumped and if so, what steps should be taken to protect Australian industry. The scheme contained several timelines in which specified steps were to be taken, and the second reading speech introducing the Customs Legislation (Anti-Dumping Amendments) Bill 1998 emphasised the importance of completing investigations as soon as practicable.

The court concluded that the particular requirement in the legislative scheme revealed in Anti-Dumping Authority v Deggussa AG for at least the investigating and recommending body to consider up-to-date material had not survived amendments to the scheme, in particular, the introduction of s 269TACB. The court dismissed Pilkington's application and ordered that the applicant pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondents' costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MOORE J
The gravamen of the complaint of Pilkington in these proceedings was that these facts reveal the decision of the Minister to take no action against Asahimas and limited action against Muliaglass arose from the Minister's failure to take into account up to date material. Up to date material was raised with the Minister and the material bore upon the question of whether Asahimas had been dumping glass and might dump glass in the future and whether Muliaglass had dumped and might dump glass more extensively than had been identified in the investigation undertaken during the investigation period.The judgment of the Full Court in Deggussa AG The case advanced by Pilkington was substantially based on the decision of the Full Court in Anti-Dumping Authority v Deggussa AG (1994) 52 FCR 414. In that matter the first respondent ("the German supplier") supplied sodium cyanide to the Australian importer. In 1990, three Australian producers of sodium cyanide applied for the publication of dumping duty notices on the basis that the German supplier had been dumping sodium cyanide in the Australian market. Customs investigated the matter and a "normal value report" was produced based on the price the German supplier had sold 10,000 tonnes of sodium cyanide in Germany on 4 April 1990. A further sale between the same parties occurred in Germany on 27 January 1991 at a new and reduced price. An Australian representative of the German supplier informed Customs of the second transaction and the lower price. Two further sales took place in June 1991 in Germany between the same parties at the lower price. At this time both Customs and the Anti Dumping Authority (“ADA”) had a role under the Act in dealing with allegations of dumping. The decisions under challenge in those proceedings were decisions of the ADA and the Minister. The ADA had recommended to the Minister to impose anti-dumping measures in relation to sodium cyanide exported to Australia from Germany and the Minister decided to impose those measures. Both Customs and the ADA played a role in that matter though it is sufficient for the purposes of the present analysis to treat the relevant conduct of the investigating officers as the conduct of Customs. An issue arose between the Australian representative of the German supplier and the investigating officers whether the more recent sales at the lower price should be ignored in ascertaining the normal value of the goods. Ultimately both ADA and the Minister acted on the basis that sales on and after 19 January 1991 would be excluded from consideration notwithstanding they were conceded to be "relevant" in the sense that they were made "in the ordinary course of trade for home consumption" and were "arm's length transactions". These familiar concepts were then embodied in s 296TAC of the Act which identified the means of determining "normal value" and read:“(1) Subject to this section, for the purposes of this Part, the normal value of any goods exported to Australia is the price paid for like goods sold in the ordinary course of trade for home consumption in the country of export in sales that are arms length transactions by the exporter or, if like goods are not so sold by the exporter, by other sellers of like goods.(2) Subject to this section, where the Minister:(a) is satisfied that:(i)by reason of the absence of sales that would be relevant for the purpose of determining a price under subsection (1); or(ii)by reason that the situation in the relevant market is such that sales in that market that would otherwise be relevant for the purpose of determining a price under subsection (1) are not suitable for use in determining such a price;the normal value of goods exported to Australia cannot be ascertained under subsection (1); or(b)is satisfied, in a case where like goods are not sold in the ordinary course of trade for home consumption in the country of export in sales that are arms length transactions by the exporter, that it is not practicable to obtain, within a reasonable time, information in relation to sales by other sellers of like goods that would be relevant for the purpose of determining a price under subsection (1);the normal value of the goods for the purposes of this Part is:(c)except where paragraph (d) applies, the sum of:(i)such amount as the Minister determines to be the cost of production or manufacture of the goods in the country of export; and(ii)on the assumption that the goods, instead of being exported, had been sold for home consumption in the ordinary course of trade in the country of export:(A)such amounts as the Minister determines would be the delivery charges and other costs necessarily incurred in that sale; and(B)subject to subsection (13), an amount calculated in accordance with such rate, if any, as the Minister determines would be the rate of profit on that sale; or(d)where the Minister so directs, the price determined by the Minister to be representative of the price paid for like goods sold in the ordinary course of trade in the country of export for export to a third country, being sales that are arms length transactions.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MOORE J

If the provisions of the Act considered by the Full Court were still in force, then Pilkington would probably have a comparatively firm basis for arguing that, at least in principle, the failure of the Minister in the present matter to take into account up to date material involved error. I am, for the moment, putting to one side submissions made by counsel for the Minister that first, the material relied on by Pilkington both at the time and now in these proceedings, was not of a character that would have required its consideration by the Minister even if up to date material had to be considered and secondly, there was no general obligation on Customs or the Minister to make inquiries to secure up to date material. However, the issue raised in these proceedings is whether the particular requirement in the legislative scheme revealed in Anti-Dumping Authority v Deggussa AG for at least the investigating and recommending body to consider up to date material, has survived amendments to the scheme and, in particular, the introduction of s 269TACB. I turn now to consider these matters.The operation of the legislative scheme in the present case As already discussed in outline, Part XVB of the Act (and in particular Divisions 1, 2 and 3) creates an administrative scheme for determination by the Minister of whether goods have been, or may be, dumped and if so, what steps should be taken to protect Australian industry. That scheme contains several timelines in which specified steps are to be taken. The Chief Executive Officer has 20 days to consider the application. If it is not rejected, a public notice is given which, in effect, puts in train a process which would ordinarily result in a report to the Minister within 155 days of the date of the public notice. Submissions may be called concerning the notice which are to be provided 40 days or less after the notice is published. Within the 155 days (though it can be extended) there are other timelines for other critical events. After 60 days from the date of the public notice, the there can be a preliminary affirmative determination and securities taken or undertakings proffered. A statement of essential facts is prepared within 110 days of the notice. The scheme allows for comments being made by interested parties on the statement within a further 20 days. These various provisions point to a clear legislative intention that the investigation is to be a timely one. So much is also apparent from the second reading speech introducing the Customs Legislation (Anti-Dumping Amendments) Bill 1998 which introduced the scheme for assessing allegations of dumping as it operated in the present case. The Minister said:“In formulating these reforms the government recognised that anti-dumping and countervailing investigations and reviews can be disruptive for all interested parties. Investigations may give rise to trade chilling effects, which are to the detriment of exporters, importers and consumers alike. Australian industry views such investigations as creating uncertainty within the marketplace which may delay investment decisions thereby retarding their economic development and overall efficiency. The Government accepts that it is in the best interests of all parties for these investigations and reviews to be completed as soon as is practicable. It is convinced that its proposed reforms have struck a balance between, on the one hand, the desirability of speedily resolving investigations and, on the other, doing so in a manner which is not only consistent with our WTO obligations but in certain respects exceeds those obligations.However, this balance can only be maintained if all interested parties are subject to a discipline which requires that if they wish to participate in the investigation or review process they must ensure that their submissions are lodged promptly. Therefore, at various milestones throughout the investigation or review process the Government’s reforms confer a power upon the relevant decision maker to disregard any submissions which are received after specified periods, if there is insufficient time remaining for their proper consideration. Without such powers, the statutory deadlines would neve be met and the balance which such deadlines are designed to preserve would be undermined.”Mention should be made of Article 5.10 of the Agreement on implementation of Article VI of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994 which provides in relation to investigations into complaints of dumping:“Investigations shall, except in special circumstances, be concluded within one year, and in no case more than 18 months, after their initiation.”