Peter White v Asciano Services Pty Ltd t/as Pacific National

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read
[2015] FWC 7466
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s 394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Peter White
v
Asciano Services Pty Ltd t/as Pacific National
(U2015/3912)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAMS

SYDNEY, 30 OCTOBER 2015

Termination of employment – Train Driver Trainer dismissed for serious misconduct – application for an unfair dismissal remedy – alleged serious safety breaches by applicant – alleged breaches of employer’s policies, procedures and Code of Conduct – allegations regarded as ‘reckless violation’ of employer’s policies and procedures – two person train operation between Broken Hill and Parkes – two primary reasons for dismissal – leaving Co-Driver behind – speeding – other minor allegations not determinative – use of on-board toilet while train in motion – custom and practice at Parkes depot – breaches of policies and procedures by Co-Driver – failure to ensure safety of Co-Driver – applicant unaware Co-Driver left the train – speeding on numerous occasions – culpability of Co-Driver – data logger records disclose numerous instances of speeding – investigation of allegations – applicant’s failure to acknowledge any wrongdoing or responsibility – whether there was a valid reason for dismissal – first allegation not made out – second allegation proven as a ‘one off’ incident – mitigating circumstances – criticism of employer’s investigation – no issue of witness credit – inconsistent treatment – no previous disciplinary history in 9½ years – contrition and acknowledgement of responsibility – remedy of reinstatement sought –reinstatement not impractical – loss of trust and confidence not established – significant discount of lost remuneration due to conduct of applicant – imperative of compliance with safety policies and procedures – reinstatement, continuity of service, partial lost remuneration – orders made.

[1] Mr Peter White (the ‘applicant’) was employed as a Train Driver Trainer by Asciano Services Pty Ltd t/as Pacific National (the ‘respondent’). The applicant commenced employment on 21 November 2005 and was employed under the terms of the Pacific National Bulk Rail Enterprise Agreement 2013 (the ‘Agreement’) on a base salary of $77,551 per annum. The applicant was dismissed for misconduct following a serious safety incident on 24 November 2014 en route between Broken Hill and Parkes in New South Wales when the applicant was the Train Driver with Ms Mel Burton as his Co-Driver. In the applicant’s termination letter dated 24 February 2015, the respondent set out the specific allegations against the applicant as follows:

    ‘Employment with Asciano Services Pty Ltd trading as Pacific National

    We have received and considered your response to the allegations put to you regarding the serious safety incident that occurred late last year and which was the subject of investigation by Pacific National which uncovered numerous and varied breaches of procedures designed to keep employees and assets safe.

    Termination of Employment
    Pacific National has given serious consideration to all of the information collected during the investigation as well as your responses to the serious allegations put to you and decided to terminate your employment.

    In Pacific National’s view, your…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peter White v Asciano Services Pty Ltd t/as Pacific National and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FWC 7466
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Peter White v Asciano Services Pty Ltd t/as Pacific National involved a dispute over the termination of employment of the applicant, Peter White, who was dismissed for alleged serious misconduct. The matter was heard in the Fair Work Commission, with the Commission being required to determine whether the dismissal was unfair.

The central legal issues for the Commission to resolve were whether Mr White was dismissed for a valid reason, specifically if the employer could establish that the termination was due to serious misconduct, and if the employer’s investigation was conducted properly. Additionally, the Commission needed to consider whether the remedy of reinstatement was appropriate, given the employer’s loss of trust and confidence in Mr White.

The Fair Work Commission found that while the employer had established that Mr White had left his Co-Driver behind and had sped on a number of occasions, these were not sufficient to establish serious misconduct warranting dismissal. The Commission found that Mr White was unaware that his Co-Driver had left the train, and the speeding incidents were not as severe as alleged. The Commission also noted that Mr White had no previous disciplinary history and had shown contrition. Despite this, the Commission found that the employer’s investigation had shortcomings and was inconsistent with how other breaches were handled. Ultimately, the Commission determined that reinstatement was not impractical, and while there was a loss of trust and confidence, it was not so severe as to preclude reinstatement. The employer was ordered to reinstate Mr White, provide continuity of service, and pay partial lost remuneration, with a significant discount due to Mr White’s conduct.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established