Peter Gray v Finglen Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

-ABSTRACTS OF DECISIONS

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No.2001239007 in the name of PETER GRAY

Title:          Process for forming a threaded member

Action: Opposition under s.59 by FINGLEN PTY LIMITED

Decision:          Issued 22 February 2008

Abstract

The invention relates to threaded members, having particular application as rock bolts used to reinforce the roof of a mine or tunnel, where the thread form has a coarse rib spacing but a fine thread pitch.

The application was opposed on the grounds of lack of utility, novelty and inventive step and non compliance with subsections 40(2) and 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990.

The invention has not been fully described due to fundamental inconsistencies in the description of the invention. Accepted claims 1 and 14 are not fairly based because they do not specify that the spaced ribs form discontinuous segments of the thread form helix, which is a necessary part of the invention disclosed by the specification read as a whole. Claims 3, 4, 13, 16, 17 and 26 plainly lack clarity. In the absence of the spaced ribs forming discontinuous segments of the thread form helix, claims 1 to 5, 13 to 18 and 26 are not novel or lack an inventive step.

The accepted claims are directed to a “process for the formation of a thread form” in an elongate member, as well as to the elongate member per se. Claim 1 is a ‘process by product’ claim (as distinct from ‘product by process’ claims), where the only proffered characterisation is the product produced, there being no apparent characterisation in the form of process steps. The form of claim 1 is not, of itself, in contravention to the requirements of the Patents Act 1990.

The applicant is allowed 60 days from the date of this decision to propose suitable amendments to overcome the findings.  If suitable amendments are not proposed within that time, the application would be refused.

The opposition did not succeed on the particulars and submissions put forward by the Opponent, which were effectively countered by the Applicant. Nevertheless, the opposition has allowed serious deficiencies in the patent application to be determined. Consequently, there has been no award of costs.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 2001239007 by PETER GRAY and opposition thereto under s.59 of the Patents Act 1990 by FINGLEN PTY LIMITED.

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent application 2001239007 which is the national phase of WO 01/68287 was filed on 15 March 2001 by Peter Gray (hereinafter called Gray).  It was advertised as accepted on 30 September 2004 and an opposition by Finglen Pty Limited (hereinafter called Finglen) was filed on 24 December 2004 with the statement of grounds and particulars being filed on 22 March 2005.
  1. A request to amend the specification under s.104 was filed 24 August 2005 by Gray with the stated intent of obviating the instant opposition. Leave to amend was granted but the amendment was opposed…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peter Gray v Finglen Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] APO 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The opposition in this case was brought by Finglen Pty Limited against Peter Gray in relation to a patent application for a process for forming a threaded member, having particular application as rock bolts used to reinforce the roof of a mine or tunnel. The invention relates to a thread form having a coarse rib spacing but a fine thread pitch. Finglen opposed the application on the grounds of lack of utility, novelty and inventive step, and non-compliance with subsections 40(2) and 40(3) of the Patents Act 1990. The delegate of the Commissioner of Patents found that the application had serious deficiencies and did not meet the requirements of the Act. Specifically, the invention had not been fully described due to fundamental inconsistencies in the description of the invention. The accepted claims 1 and 14 were not fairly based because they did not specify that the spaced ribs form discontinuous segments of the thread form helix, which is a necessary part of the invention disclosed by the specification read as a whole. In addition, claims 3, 4, 13, 16, 17 and 26 were found to be unclear. Claims 1 to 5, 13 to 18 and 26 were also found not to be novel or lack an inventive step in view of US 3782839 and US 4056911 in association with admitted common general knowledge. The delegate allowed the applicant 60 days from the date of this decision to propose suitable amendments to overcome the findings. If suitable amendments were not proposed within that time, the application would be refused. The opposition did not succeed on the particulars and submissions put forward by the Opponent, which were effectively countered by the Applicant. Consequently, there has been no award of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Peter Gray filed a patent application on 15 March 2001 for a process of forming a threaded member with particular application as rock bolts used to reinforce the roof of a mine or tunnel. The invention had a coarse rib spacing but a fine thread pitch. Finglen Pty Limited opposed the application on the grounds of lack of utility, novelty and inventive step, and non-compliance with the Patents Act 1990. The opposition hearing took place on 9 November 2007. Photographs of fine-pitched bars rolled in accordance with the invention were provided as evidence.

The patent application was advertised as accepted on 30 September 2004. An opposition by Finglen Pty Limited was filed on 24 December 2004, with the statement of grounds and particulars being filed on 22 March 2005. A request to amend the specification under s.104 was filed on 24 August 2005 by Gray, with the intent to counter the opposition. The amendment was opposed by Finglen on 24 March 2006, and subsequently withdrawn by Gray on 16 June 2006. Following extensions of time, evidence in support was completed on 19 July 2006, evidence in answer on 19 February 2007, and evidence in reply on 23 May 2007. The matter was set down for a hearing in Canberra on 9 November 2007.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the invention lack utility?
2. Are the claims not fairly based?
3. Are the claims unclear?
4. Are the claims not novel or lacking in inventive step?
5. Does the specification fail to fully describe the invention as required by s.40(2)(a) of the Patents Act 1990?
6. Are claims 1 and 14 not fairly based?
7. Are claims 3, 4, 13, 16, 17 and 26 unclear?
8. Are claims 1 to 5, 13 to 18 and 26 not novel or lacking in inventive step?

Held
1. The invention lacks utility.
2. Accepted claims 1 and 14 are not fairly based.
3. Claims 3, 4, 13, 16, 17 and 26 are not clear.
4. Claims 1 to 5, 13 to 18 and 26 are not novel or lack an inventive step.
5. The specification fails to fully describe the invention as required by s.40(2)(a) of the Patents Act 1990.
6. Claims 1 and 14 are not fairly based.
7. Claims 3, 4, 13, 16, 17 and 26 are unclear.
8. Claims 1 to 5, 13 to 18 and 26 are not novel or lack an inventive step.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the opposition to the patent application filed by Finglen Pty Limited against Peter Gray. The invention in question was a process for forming a threaded member, particularly applicable to rock bolts used to reinforce the roof of a mine or tunnel. The opposition raised issues of lack of utility, non-compliance with the Patents Act 1990, and issues of clarity, fair basis, novelty, and inventive step of the claims. The court found that the specification of the invention was not fully descriptive, leading to the conclusion that the invention lacked utility. Claims 1 and 14 were not fairly based because they did not specify that the spaced ribs form discontinuous segments of the thread form helix, which was a necessary part of the invention disclosed by the specification read as a whole. Claims 3, 4, 13, 16, 17 and 26 were found to be unclear due to their broad definitions. In the absence of the spaced ribs forming discontinuous segments of the thread form helix, claims 1 to 5, 13 to 18 and 26 were not novel or lacked an inventive step. The court allowed the applicant 60 days to propose suitable amendments to overcome the findings, and if not, the application would be refused.