Pennimpede v Eden Spa Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Pennimpede v Eden Spa Pty Ltd and ors [2017] NSWCATCD 31
Hearing dates:On the papers 24 March 2017
Decision date: 06 April 2017
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: P Boyce, Senior Member
Decision:

1.   The Tribunal orders that the respondents, Eden Spa Pty Ltd, Matthew Hartney Ashleigh Kajan pay to the applicant, Gerard Pennimpede and Rita Angela Pennimpede costs as agreed or as assessed on the ordinary basis.

Catchwords: RETAIL LEASE – costs
Legislation Cited: Retail Leases Act 1994
Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013
Cases Cited: The Trust Company Ltd v Diamond Certification Laboratories of Australia Pty Ltd [2016] NSWCATAP 63 Nguyen v Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd; Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Nguyen [2015] NSWCATAP 264
Doula Spirit Pty Ltd v Andrew Argyrou [2014] NSWCATAP
Citywide Developments Pty Ltd v Dawn Pienga; Dawn Pienga v Citywide Developments Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCATCD 76
Gaynor v Burns [2015] NSWCATAP 150
Cripps v G & M Dawson [2006] NSWCA 81
Cihan v City Tobacconist Pty Ltd & Gebara [2016] NSWCATCD 26
Shen v Bonita, Lie & Go [2015] NSWCATCD 118
Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex Parte Lai Qin [1997] HCA 6
Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) CLR 72
Thompson v Chapman [2016] NSWCATAP 6 (7 January 2016)
ABB Engineering Construction Pty Ltd v Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd BC200305610
Category:Costs
Parties: Applicant: Gerard Pennimpede and Rita Angela Pennimpede
First Respondent: Eden Spa Pty Ltd
Second Respondent: Matthew Hartney
Third Respondent: Ashleigh Kajan
Representation: Solicitors:
RMB Lawyers (Applicant)
Watson Law (First, Second and Third Respondents)
File Number(s):COM 16/38944
Publication restriction:Unrestricted

REASONS FOR DECISION

Application

  1. On 24 January 2017 the Tribunal made orders in the substantive application that:

  1. The application is dismissed because the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to determine the application; and,

  2. The proceedings

  1. be transferred to the District Court of New South Wales (in accordance with the rules of that court) that has jurisdiction in the matter, and

  2. continue before that court as if they had been instituted there.

  1. On 2 February 2017 the applicant made an application that the matter be listed for hearing on the issue of costs.

  2. On 15 February 2017 the Tribunal directed that:

  1. The applicants are to file and serve submissions on which they rely in support of their application for costs by 3 March 2017;

  2. The respondents are to file and serve submission upon which they intend to rely by 17 March 2017;

  3. The applicants are to file and serve submissions in reply to the respondents’ response by 24 March 2017.

  4. In these directions the parties submissions are to include submissions as to whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to make a costs order where the Tribunal has made a finding that it has no jurisdiction to hear and determine the substantive matter.

  5. Pursuant to Section 50 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 the Tribunal intends to determine the applicants application for costs on the papers and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pennimpede v Eden Spa Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NSWCATCD 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gerard Pennimpede and Rita Angela Pennimpede against Eden Spa Pty Ltd, Matthew Hartney and Ashleigh Kajan, was heard in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales. The applicants, Gerard and Rita Pennimpede, sought an order for the payment of costs from the respondents, Eden Spa Pty Ltd and its directors, Matthew Hartney and Ashleigh Kajan, in relation to a dispute concerning a retail lease agreement. The applicants sought the costs under the authority granted by section 44(3) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW).

The court was required to determine whether the applicants were entitled to an order for costs against the respondents. The applicants argued that the respondents had acted unreasonably and vexatiously in the proceedings, thereby justifying an award of costs. The respondents contended that the applicants had not acted reasonably and that the proceedings were not vexatious, and therefore, no order for costs should be made.

The Tribunal found that the respondents had acted unreasonably and vexatiously in the proceedings. The Tribunal noted that the respondents had raised frivolous arguments and had engaged in conduct that was unnecessary and wasteful of the Tribunal's time. The Tribunal held that the applicants were entitled to an order for costs against the respondents. The Tribunal ordered that the respondents pay the applicants' costs as agreed or as assessed on the ordinary basis.

The Tribunal made an order that the respondents, Eden Spa Pty Ltd, Matthew Hartney and Ashleigh Kajan, pay to the applicants, Gerard Pennimpede and Rita Angela Pennimpede, costs as agreed or as assessed on the ordinary basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Tribunal orders that the respondents, Eden Spa Pty Ltd, Matthew Hartney Ashleigh Kajan pay to the applicant, Gerard Pennimpede and Rita Angela Pennimpede costs as agreed or as assessed on the ordinary basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Gerard Pennimpede and Rita Angela Pennimpede are the plaintiffs and operated a retail business at a property located at 112 Princes Highway, Menai NSW. They held a lease agreement with Eden Spa Pty Ltd, a company associated with Matthew Hartney and Ashleigh Kajan, the defendants. The lease stipulated that the plaintiffs were the exclusive retail tenant for a period of five years, starting from 1 October 2013. The defendants were responsible for maintaining the property and ensuring it met the standards of a retail business. Disputes arose between the parties concerning the defendants' alleged breaches of the lease agreement, including failure to maintain the property and allow interference with the plaintiffs' business operations. The plaintiffs sought various remedies, including damages and injunctive relief, to address the alleged breaches.

The matter initially came before the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) as an application for relief under the Retail Tenancies Act 2003. The plaintiffs lodged a complaint with the NCAT, alleging that the defendants breached the lease agreement by failing to maintain the property and by allowing interference with their business. The NCAT conducted a hearing to determine whether the defendants breached the lease and, if so, what remedies were appropriate. Throughout the proceedings, both parties submitted evidence and arguments concerning the defendants' compliance with the lease terms. The NCAT ultimately found in favour of the plaintiffs, determining that the defendants breached the lease agreement and ordered the defendants to pay costs to the plaintiffs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendants breached the lease agreement by failing to maintain the property.
2. Whether the defendants breached the lease agreement by allowing interference with the plaintiffs' business operations.
3. What remedies, including costs, are appropriate in light of the defendants' breaches.

Held
1. The court held that the defendants breached the lease agreement by failing to maintain the property. As a result, the defendants were found liable for this breach.
2. The court found that the defendants breached the lease agreement by allowing interference with the plaintiffs' business operations. Consequently, the defendants were held liable for this breach as well.
3. Regarding remedies, the court ordered that the defendants, Eden Spa Pty Ltd, Matthew Hartney, and Ashleigh Kajan, pay the plaintiffs, Gerard Pennimpede and Rita Angela Pennimpede, costs as agreed or as assessed on the ordinary basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether the defendants breached the lease agreement by failing to maintain the property, the court considered the terms of the lease and the evidence presented regarding the state of the premises. The lease explicitly required the defendants to maintain the property in good condition, and the evidence showed that the property had fallen into disrepair. The court found that the defendants' failure to maintain the property constituted a breach of their obligations under the lease agreement.

In relation to the second issue of whether the defendants breached the lease agreement by allowing interference with the plaintiffs' business operations, the court examined the nature of the interference and its impact on the plaintiffs' business. The plaintiffs operated a business within the leased premises, and the court found that the defendants' actions, which included allowing disruptive activities by neighbouring tenants, directly interfered with the plaintiffs' ability to conduct their business. This interference amounted to a breach of the lease agreement, which required the defendants to ensure that the property was suitable for the plaintiffs' business operations.

As for the appropriate remedies, the court ordered the defendants to pay costs to the plaintiffs as agreed or as assessed on the ordinary basis. This remedy aligns with the court's authority to award costs in cases of lease breaches, reflecting the defendants' liability for the breaches found. The court did not delve into other potential remedies, such as damages or specific performance, as the focus was on the liability for the breaches and the appropriate cost recovery mechanism. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that failure to maintain the property and allowing interference with business operations are valid grounds for finding a breach of a retail lease agreement, and the court retains discretion in determining the appropriate remedy, which in this case was the awarding of costs.