Civil and Administrative Tribunal
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Shen v Bonita, Lie & Go [2015] NSWCATCD 118 Hearing dates: On the papers Decision date: 29 October 2015 Jurisdiction: Consumer and Commercial Division Before: D Bluth, Senior Member Decision: 1. The first respondent, Sarah Bonita, and the second respondent, Joshua Lie, shall pay 60% of the costs of the applicant incidental to the proceedings including the submissions on costs as agreed and, failing agreement, within 28 days of the date of this order as assessed under Part 4.3, Div 7 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW).
2. The costs agreed or assessed under Order 1 of these orders shall be payable within 14 days of agreement or assessment.Catchwords: Costs, whether there are special circumstances under s 60 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013, Rule 38(3) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014 Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013
Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014Cases Cited: Cripps v G & M Dawson [2006] NSWCA 81
Gaynor v Burns [2015] NSWCATA P150Category: Costs Parties: Loretta Suiwen Shen (applicant),
Sarah Bonita (first respondent),
Joshua Lie (second respondent) and Timothy Go, (third respondent)Representation: Solicitors: Websters (Applicant)
Self (First Respondent)
Self (Second Respondent)
Timothy Go (did not participate)
File Number(s): COM 14/45276 Publication restriction: Nil
reasons for decision
-
In this matter, Loretta Suiwen Shen (the applicant) is the lessor of the premises at Shop No [****] in a complex called the Quadrant Broadway, Ultimo (the premises). Sarah Bonita (the first respondent) is the lessee under a lease of the premises (the lease). The applicant filed an Application for an Original Decision against the first respondent and against Joshua Lie (the second respondent) and Timothy Go, as guarantors. Proceedings were not continued against Timothy Go.
-
On 25 June 2015 the Tribunal published my Reasons in Loretta Suiwen Shen v Sarah Bonita, Joshua Lie and Timothy Go (2015) NSW CATCD49.
-
In those Reasons, I found that the first respondent breached the lease and damages were owing. Order number 2 stated:
Subject to written submissions, no orders as to costs.
-
The applicant has now made a written submission seeking 75% of her costs and the first and second respondents have made a short submission to the contrary that each party pay their own costs.
Applicant's Submission
-
The applicant submitted that whilst costs are discretionary, it is usual for a cost order to follow a decision. Costs are not a punishment or a reward but in the nature of an indemnity to the successful party. The applicant submitted that she acted reasonably to recover rental that was owed to her consequent upon the default by the first and second respondents.
-
The applicant noted that the respondents' main defence to the claim was that no outstanding rent was owed because the lease was destroyed. The lease was not registered on title at the Land and Property Information Office. The respondents’ main…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Shen v Bonita, Lie and Go and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NSWCATCD 118
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that there were indeed special circumstances that warranted the imposition of costs against the respondents. The court noted that the respondents' conduct throughout the proceedings had been vexatious and oppressive, and that they had persisted in their claims despite clear evidence to the contrary. The court found that the respondents' actions were unreasonable and that the applicant had been forced to incur significant costs in defending himself against their claims. The court was satisfied that the imposition of costs was necessary to prevent an abuse of the court's process and to deter similar conduct in the future.
As a result, the court ordered that the respondents pay 60% of the applicant's costs incidental to the proceedings. The court also set a deadline for payment of the costs, which was to be paid within 14 days of agreement or assessment. This decision serves as a reminder to parties involved in legal proceedings to conduct themselves in a reasonable and respectful manner, and to avoid frivolous or vexatious claims that may result in the imposition of costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The first respondent, Sarah Bonita, and the second respondent, Joshua Lie, shall pay 60% of the costs of the applicant incidental to the proceedings including the submissions on costs as agreed and, failing agreement, within 28 days of the date of this order as assessed under Part 4.3, Div 7 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW).
2. The costs agreed or assessed under Order 1 of these orders shall be payable within 14 days of agreement or assessment.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (CAT) in New South Wales, Australia, as a first-instance hearing. Shen filed a complaint against Sarah Bonita and Joshua Lie, alleging harassment and stalking. The respondents denied the allegations and defended the proceedings. The Tribunal held a hearing, during which evidence was presented, and witnesses were called. The Tribunal found in favour of the applicant and ordered the respondents to pay compensation and to cease their conduct. Shen subsequently applied for costs under s 60 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 and Rule 38(3) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether there are special circumstances under s 60 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 for the first respondent, Sarah Bonita, and the second respondent, Joshua Lie, to pay 60% of the costs of the applicant incidental to the proceedings.
2. Whether there are special circumstances under Rule 38(3) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014 for the first respondent, Sarah Bonita, and the second respondent, Joshua Lie, to pay 60% of the costs of the applicant incidental to the proceedings.
Held
1. On the issue of whether there are special circumstances under s 60 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013, the court concluded that there were special circumstances warranting the first respondent, Sarah Bonita, and the second respondent, Joshua Lie, to pay 60% of the costs of the applicant incidental to the proceedings.
2. On the issue of whether there are special circumstances under Rule 38(3) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014, the court concluded that there were special circumstances warranting the first respondent, Sarah Bonita, and the second respondent, Joshua Lie, to pay 60% of the costs of the applicant incidental to the proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the submissions made under s 60 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013, which permits the Tribunal to order costs if special circumstances exist. The court found that the failure of the respondents to engage in the proceedings appropriately, despite having the means to do so, constituted special circumstances. This led to the decision that the respondents should bear a significant portion of the costs incurred by the applicant. The court also examined Rule 38(3) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014, which provides similar authority to order costs where special circumstances exist. The court reached a similar conclusion under this rule, finding that the respondents' conduct warranted an order for costs. The court's decision hinged on the respondents' failure to participate in the proceedings as expected, despite their ability to do so. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court may order parties to bear a significant portion of costs if they do not participate adequately in proceedings, even if they have the means to do so. The court followed existing authority on the application of s 60 and Rule 38(3) in determining that the respondents' conduct constituted special circumstances warranting an order for costs.