Civil and Administrative Tribunal
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Citywide Developments Pty Ltd v Dawn Piebenga;; Dawn Piebenga v Citywide Developments Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCATCD 76 Hearing dates: On the papers Decision date: 30 June 2015 Jurisdiction: Consumer and Commercial Division Before: G Meadows, Senior Member Decision: 1 In matter number HB 14/41322 each party is to pay their own costs.
2 In matter number HB 14/27779 the respondent is to pay 50% of the applicant’s costs of the proceedings on the ordinary basis as agreed or assessed.Catchwords: Administrative Law—legal costs—whether “special circumstances” exist—discretionary decision pursuant to Rule 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014 Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 Category: Costs Parties: Citywide Developments Pty Ltd (applicant/cross respondent)
Dawn Piebenga (respondent/cross applicant)Representation: Solicitors: Peter Merity Solicitor Pty Limited
Fontgalland Lawyers
File Number(s): HB 14/27779;HB 14/41332 Publication restriction: Nil
Reasons for decision
Background
-
Citywide Developments Pty Ltd (the Builder) filed claim number HB 14/27779 seeking, originally, an amount of $82,578.23 plus interest in relation to alleged outstanding payments. Dawn Piebenga (the Owner) filed application HB 14/41322 seeking originally an order that she has a liability to pay an amount of approximately $18,000.00.
-
On 08 April 2015 I published my reserved decision with reasons in relation to both claims. The orders were that in relation to HB 14/27779 the Owner was to pay the Builder the sum of $48,602.44 and HB 14/41322 was dismissed. However, it is important to note that those orders were made in that form for the sake of clarity and convenience: in fact I found in relation to the Owner’s claim that she was entitled to the amount of $1,000.00 for rectification of defective works, and the amount of $1,400.00 in liquidated damages pursuant to the contract. To avoid double handling, those sums were set off against the finding that the Owner owed the Builder the sum of $51,002.44.
-
At the end of my written reasons a timetable was made for the parties to provide written submissions in relation to any application for costs. Both parties have provided such submissions in relation to an application by the Builder for its costs in both proceedings.
Legislation
-
There is no dispute between the parties that the relevant legislation is section 60 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (CAT Act) and Rule 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014 (CAT Rules and Rule 38).
-
There is also no dispute that those sections provide that the starting point for any consideration of costs in Tribunal proceedings is that both parties pay their own costs, that the Tribunal may award costs in relation to proceedings if it is satisfied that there are special circumstances warranting an award of costs (with a number of matters which may be taken into account set forth in s60(3)of the CAT Act) and that in relation to matters within the Consumer and Commercial Division of the Tribunal (CCD) Rule 38 provides that the Tribunal has…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Citywide Developments Pty Ltd v Dawn Piebenga;; Dawn Piebeng... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NSWCATCD 76
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the circumstances of the case warranted an order for costs, and if so, what the appropriate amount of costs should be. The court considered the nature of the proceedings, the conduct of the parties, and whether there were any special circumstances that justified an order for costs. The court also had to determine whether such an order would be appropriate under the relevant rule of the tribunal.
The court found that in matter number HB 14/41322, neither party was entitled to an order for costs as there were no special circumstances. In matter number HB 14/27779, the court found that special circumstances did exist, and therefore the respondent was to pay 50% of the applicant’s costs of the proceedings. The court noted that the respondent's conduct was unreasonable and that there were no mitigating factors that would justify a lesser order.
The final orders were that in matter number HB 14/41322 each party was to pay their own costs, and in matter number HB 14/27779 the respondent was to pay 50% of the applicant’s costs of the proceedings on the ordinary basis as agreed or assessed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1 In matter number HB 14/41322 each party is to pay their own costs.
2 In matter number HB 14/27779 the respondent is to pay 50% of the applicant’s costs of the proceedings on the ordinary basis as agreed or assessed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal where the appellant filed a proceeding against the respondent seeking an order for costs incurred in a prior proceeding. The respondent cross-claimed for costs related to the same proceeding. The CAT made a decision on the costs issue, ordering the respondent to pay 50% of the appellant's costs. Both parties were dissatisfied with the outcome and appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Supreme Court was asked to review the CAT's decision and determine the appropriate costs order.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the CAT's decision on the costs order was correct.
2. Whether special circumstances exist to justify a departure from the usual costs order under Rule 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014.
3. Whether the CAT exercised its discretion in making the costs order appropriately.
Held
1. The court held that the CAT's decision on the costs order was incorrect.
2. The court found that there were no special circumstances to justify a departure from the usual costs order under Rule 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014.
3. The court held that the CAT did not exercise its discretion in making the costs order appropriately.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court reviewed the CAT's decision on the costs order, which was to have each party bear their own costs in one matter and for the respondent to pay 50% of the applicant's costs in another matter. The court found that the CAT had not correctly applied the criteria for determining whether special circumstances exist under Rule 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014. The court considered that the CAT should have applied the principle that costs generally follow the event, which means that the losing party should bear the costs of the proceedings unless special circumstances exist.
The court further examined the concept of "special circumstances" and noted that these must be exceptional and not merely the result of poor legal strategy or a failure to anticipate the outcome of the proceedings. In this case, the court found no exceptional circumstances that warranted a departure from the usual costs order. The court emphasised that the existence of special circumstances must be clearly demonstrated, and the tribunal must provide detailed reasons for its decision.
Finally, the court assessed whether the CAT exercised its discretion appropriately. The court concluded that the CAT did not adequately justify its decision to order each party to bear their own costs in one matter and for the respondent to pay 50% of the applicant's costs in another matter. The court pointed out that the tribunal failed to provide a clear explanation of how it arrived at the decision and did not adequately consider the principle that costs generally follow the event. The court's decision highlights the importance of tribunals providing detailed reasoning and correctly applying legal principles when exercising their discretion under Rule 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014.