Patterson v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Patterson v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) (No. 2) [2024] QIRC 287

PARTIES:

Patterson, Gail
Appellant

v

State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)

Respondent

CASE NO:

PSA/2024/47

PROCEEDING:

Public Sector Appeal – Disciplinary Decision

DELIVERED ON:

6 December 2024

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Pratt IC

On the papers

ORDERS:

The orders contained in paragraph [123] of these reasons for decision.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – APPEAL – PUBLIC SECTOR PUBLIC SECTOR – EMPLOYEES AND SERVANTS OF THE CROWN GENERALLY – appeal against a disciplinary action decision – appeal against a disciplinary finding decision – appeal against disciplinary action decision lodged within 21-day limitation period – appeal against the disciplinary finding decision lodged out of time – whether extension of time should be granted – extension of time allowed – consideration of the connection between disciplinary action and disciplinary finding decisions – consideration of the prospects of success generally – consideration of the prospects of success with respect to the disciplinary finding decision – where the appeal of the disciplinary finding decision is allowed – where the appeal of the disciplinary finding decision is set aside and substituted – held that the Appellant did not engage in misconduct pursuant to s 91(1)(b) of the Public Sector Act 2022 – where the appeal of the disciplinary action decision is allowed – where the disciplinary action decision is set aside – where it is held that no disciplinary action be imposed – appeal allowed

LEGISLATION:

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) s 38
Corrective Services Act2006 (Qld) s 143
Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ss 562B, 564
Public Sector Act 2022 (Qld) ss 91, 129, 131, 132

CASES:

Borkowski v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)  [2021] QIRC 330
Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34

Bruce Anthony Piggott v State of Queensland [2010] ICQ 35

Cahill v State of New South Wales (Department of Community Services) (No. 4) [2008] NSWIRComm 201
Colebourne v State of Queensland (Queensland Police Service) (No. 2) [2022] QIRC 16
Coleman v State of Queensland (Department of Education) [2020] QIRC 32.
Condon v State of Queensland (Queensland Health) [2023] QIRC 23
Cullen v State of Queensland (Queensland Health) [2021] QIRC 258
Gibson v State of Queensland (Queensland Health) [2024] QIRC 90
Gurdler v State of Queensland (Queensland Health) [2024] QIRC 213
Hunt v State of Queensland (Department of Agriculture and Fisheries) [2022] QIRC 162
Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen [1984] FCA 176
Johnston & Ors v Carroll (Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service) & Anor; Witthahn & Ors v Wakefield (Chief Executive of Hospital and Health Services and Director General of Queensland Health); Sutton & Ors v Carroll (Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service) [2024] QSC 2
Magor v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) [2022] QIRC 35
Mathieu v Higgins [2008] QSC 209
O'Hearn v State of Queensland (Queensland Health) [2023] QIRC 283
Pflaum v State of Queensland (Department of Education) [2024] QIRC 50
Pillai v Messiter (No. 2) (1989) 16…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Patterson v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Servi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QIRC 287
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Patterson v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) (No. 2) involved an appeal against disciplinary actions taken by the State of Queensland against the appellant, Patterson. The dispute centred on whether Patterson had engaged in misconduct by using unnecessary force against a prisoner. The appeal was heard in the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission, Industrial Registry. The primary issues before the court were whether the appeal against the disciplinary action decision was lodged within the 21-day limitation period and whether an extension of time should be granted for the appeal against the disciplinary finding decision.

The court found that while the appeal against the disciplinary action decision was lodged within the stipulated time frame, the appeal against the disciplinary finding decision was lodged out of time. However, the court allowed the extension of time based on several factors. These factors included the connection between the disciplinary action and finding decisions, the prospects of success generally, and the merits of the substantive application. Notably, the court emphasised that special circumstances need not be shown, but an acceptable explanation for the delay and fairness in extending time were critical. The court also considered the prejudice to the respondent and fairness as between the applicant and others in a similar position.

The court allowed the appeal of the disciplinary finding decision, setting it aside and substituting it with a finding that Patterson did not engage in misconduct. Consequently, the appeal of the disciplinary action decision was also allowed, and the disciplinary action decision was set aside, with no disciplinary action imposed. The court's final orders were detailed in paragraph [123] of the reasons for decision, reflecting the outcomes of the appeals.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders contained in paragraph [123] of these reasons for decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Cullen, his Honour also set out some lodestars taken from the judgement of Wilcox J in Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen:[22](a) special circumstances need not be shown, but an applicant for extension must show an acceptable explanation for the delay and that it is fair and equitable in the circumstances to extend time;(b) action taken by the applicant, other than by making an application under the relevant Act, is relevant to the consideration of the question of whether an acceptable explanation for the delay has been furnished;(c) any prejudice to the respondent, including any prejudice in defending the proceedings occasioned by the delay, is a material factor militating against the granting of an extension;(d) the merits of the substantive application are properly to be taken into account in considering whether an extension of time should be granted; and(e) considerations of fairness as between the applicant and other persons in a like position are relevant to the exercise of discretion. The relevant decisions under appeal[22] [1984] FCA 176.The Finding Decision The Finding Decision was issued on 8 December 2023. In it, the decision-maker, Deputy Commissioner of Custodial Operations, Mr Gary McCahon ('Mr McCahon'), set out some background, the relevant allegation and a description of some of the Incident that I have set out above from [8] to [35]. The Finding Decision included advice to the Appellant that she was entitled to appeal that decision by way of a fair treatment appeal. Mr McCahon also advised the Appellant about the 21-day time limit for any appeal, referring to s 131(1)(d) of the PS Act, saying that the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission Industrial Registry could provide further information about public sector appeal procedures (providing the relevant website address and phone numbers). The key finding was that the Appellant used force that was not reasonably necessary against the Prisoner by deploying a chemical agent while the Prisoner was restrained and ground stabilised. The initial allegation that the Prisoner was not warned prior to the use of the chemical agent was withdrawn. No doubt that was because the body worn camera footage revealed, conclusively, that the Appellant did in fact warn the Prisoner very clearly, twice in quick succession …"Do you want to be gassed?". Setting out the Appellant's submissions, Mr McCahon appropriately identified that the relevant standard of proof was the balance of probabilities described in the Public Sector Commission Directive Discipline 05/23 ('Directive 05/23') and that it drew from the elements of the case in Briginshaw.[23] He observed that whilst the Corrective Services Act2006 ('CS Act') permitted the use of force that was reasonably necessary to restrain a prisoner who is harming him/herself or attempting to do so, the force must be proportionate to the conduct or threat posed by the prisoner. [23] Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34. Mr McCahon also identified that the Custodial Operations Practice Directive – Use of Force ('COPD') required the Appellant to consider the most appropriate option for a safe and effective outcome to ensure only a reasonable amount of force, justified by law, was used to affect a lawful purpose.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established