Magor v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Magor v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) [2022] QIRC 035

PARTIES:

Magor, Ben
(Appellant)

v

State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

PSA/2020/408

PROCEEDING:

Public Service Appeal – appeal against a disciplinary decision

DELIVERED ON:

11 February 2022

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Hartigan IC

On the papers

ORDERS:

1. Pursuant to s 562C(1)(a) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), the decisions appealed against are confirmed.

2. Pursuant to s 566(1)(b) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), the stay of the decision ordered on 10 December 2020 be revoked.

CATCHWORDS: 

LEGISLATION:

PUBLIC SERVICE – EMPLOYEES AND SERVANTS OF THE CROWN GENERALLY – public service appeal – appeal against a disciplinary finding decision and disciplinary penalty decision – where disciplinary action taken against appellant pursuant to s 188 of the Public Service Act 2008 (Qld) – where appellant submits allegations cannot be substantiated on the evidence – where appellant submits finding decision is unfair and unreasonable – where disciplinary finding decision confirmed – where disciplinary finding decision fair and reasonable – where disciplinary penalty decision confirmed – stay of decision revoked

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld),
ss 562B, 562C and 566

Public Service Act 2008 (Qld) ss 187, 188, 194 and 197

Directive 14/20: Discipline, cls 7 and 8

CASES:

Brandy v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission [1995] HCA 10; (1995) 183 CLR 245

Goodall v State of Queensland (Unreported decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland, Dalton J, 10 October 2018)

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. Mr Ben Magor ('Mr Magor') is employed by the State of Queensland, Queensland Correctional Services ('QCS'), as a Correctional Supervisor at Lotus Glen Correctional Centre ('the Centre'). Mr Magor seeks to appeal both a disciplinary finding decision and a disciplinary penalty decision of the QCS.

  2. On 1 October 2020, a disciplinary finding decision was made which substantiated the following allegations:

    1.       On 16 February 2019 at Lotus Glen Correctional Centre (LGCC), you used force on a Prisoner that was not reasonably necessary in the circumstances. The allegation related to the application of Oleoresin Capsicum (OC) spray to the Prisoner during an incident reported in INCI 249296.

    2.       On 16 February 2019, at LGCC, you prepared an inaccurate officer report regarding the use of force on the Prisoner. This allegation relates to INCI 249296. 

  3. On 20 November 2020, the QCS issued a decision to Mr Magor imposing the following disciplinary penalty:

    ·     a reduction in remuneration of Mr Magor's substantive position, from GS3-4 to GS3-3 for a period of 12 months;

    ·     a reprimand; and

    ·     to complete refresher training in relation to the Code of Conduct.

  1. Mr Magor appealed against the disciplinary finding and disciplinary penalty decision pursuant to s 194(1)(b)(i) of the Public Service Act 2008 (Qld) ('PS Act').

  2. This Commission ordered that the decision subject of the appeal be stayed until the determination of the appeal or further order of the Commission pursuant to s 566(1) of the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Magor v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QIRC 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the court involved Mr Magor, a public service employee, and the State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services). The dispute arose from disciplinary actions taken against Mr Magor for allegedly using excessive force against a prisoner, specifically deploying Oleoresin Capsicum (OC) spray directly into the prisoner's mouth. The court was tasked with determining whether the disciplinary finding decision and the subsequent disciplinary penalty decision were fair and reasonable, and whether they should be confirmed or set aside.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the disciplinary finding decision was substantiated by the evidence and whether it was fair and reasonable. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the disciplinary penalty decision was appropriate and reasonable, given the substantiated findings. The court had to review the evidence presented during the investigation and the responses provided by Mr Magor to the show cause notices. The court also had to consider the relevant provisions of the Public Service Act 2008 (Qld), particularly sections 187 and 188, which outline the grounds for discipline and the types of disciplinary actions that may be taken.

The court found that the disciplinary finding decision was fair and reasonable, as the evidence supported the allegations of excessive force. The court noted that Mr Magor deployed OC spray from a very close distance, causing the prisoner significant discomfort and breathing difficulties. The court also highlighted that the prisoner was restrained by multiple officers and was not posing an immediate threat, making the use of OC spray excessive. Regarding the disciplinary penalty decision, the court determined that the penalty was proportionate to the misconduct and was therefore fair and reasonable.

The court confirmed the decisions appealed against, substantiating the disciplinary findings and penalties imposed on Mr Magor. Additionally, the court revoked the stay of the decision ordered on 10 December 2020, effectively enforcing the disciplinary actions against Mr Magor.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 562C(1)(a) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), the decisions appealed against are confirmed.

2. Pursuant to s 566(1)(b) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), the stay of the decision ordered on 10 December 2020 be revoked.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons contained herein, I have found that the decisions were fair and reasonable. Background On 30 July 2019, an allegation was made by a prisoner at the Centre that Mr Magor had used 'excessive force' by allegedly deploying Oleoresin Capsicum ('OC') spray directly into the prisoner's mouth during an incident on 16 February 2019. On 1 October 2019, the Ethical Standards Group ('ESG'), commenced an investigation into allegations of unreasonable use of force by Mr Magor and the completion of an inaccurate Officer Report. On 18 February 2020, during the course of the investigation, the ESG investigator interviewed Mr Magor. On 7 May 2020, the ESG investigator issued an investigation report. On 17 August 2020, a show cause notice was issued by Deputy Commissioner Gary McCahon ('Deputy Commissioner McCahon') to Mr Magor in the following relevant terms:Dear Mr Magor On 8 September 2020, Mr Magor provided a response to the show cause notice. On 1 October 2020, the decision maker issued Mr Magor the disciplinary finding decision and a second show cause notice – decision on disciplinary finding and proposed disciplinary action. On 13 October 2020, Mr Magor provided a response to the second show cause notice. The disciplinary finding decision substantiated allegations one and two and put Mr Magor on notice that the QCS was giving serious consideration to taking disciplinary action. With respect to allegation one, the factual findings made included, but were not limited to, the following:…· At the time you deployed a burst of OC spray towards the prisoner's face, he was lying on the ground with his hands behind his back, with three CCOs in the process of restraining him, soon to be joined by a fourth. · CS Muller had taken control of and was holding the prisoner's head down with his right cheek to the floor. · CCO Nihcolls had already incurred the injury from the prisoner's free arm, and he was then restrained.· You deployed the burst of OC spray towards the prisoner's face from a distance of, at most, half a metre away. The force you used against the prisoner in that particular instance was excessive and applied in a manner that was likely to cause injury to the prisoner. · Your use of the OC spray caused the prisoner breathing difficulties and stinging and burning sensations to his face and eyes. · Your use of OC spray was not reasonably likely to de-escalate the situation (and nor did it).· In the lead up to your use of the OC spray, I am satisfied the following occurred: oAt 11:11.53, following your direction, the prisoner approached the door between the S25 unit and the spine, where he waited until 11:12.13 when the door was opened, and he entered the doorway. oThe prisoner was waiting compliantly by the door in accordance with your direction to him while up to nine (9) officers were assembling closely just inside the doorway. You have not provided any explanation as to why so many officers were assembled in anticipation of his entry. oIn t's interview he stated that when confronted by nine officers, he 'freaked out' and backed away as CS Muller attempted to 'punch' him. Having regard to the evidence of CS Muller and CS Shem Beguely, I am satisfied that upon entering the doorway did not place his hands on the wall and instead backed out of the spine. On the CCTV footage the prisoner has his hands raised, open palmed in a submissive gesture as CS Muller attempts to grab him. oOn the evidence available, I am satisfied the prisoner was lunged at/grabbed at by CS Muller and quickly backed out of the door. He was then rushed closely by the nine officers (of which you were the fifth), backwards into the S25 common dining area. I note you have not provided me any explanation as to what prompted all nine officers (including yourself) to rush at the prisoner.oI am not satisfied the prisoner's refusal to place his hands on the wall warranted nine officers rushing out at him as he backed up with his hands raised in a submissive gesture. In the absence of any explanation, it is unclear to me why the officers involved would have done so, and it is particularly concerning in circumstances where the approached encouraged by QCS in managing prisoners is effective tactical communication and de-escalation. As an experienced CS you would have known, or ought to have reasonably known, that this approach was instead likely to escalate the situation.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 194 of the PS Act relevantly identifies the decisions against which appeals may be made as follows: 194 Decisions against which appeals may be made(1)An appeal may be made against the following decisions—…(b)a decision under a disciplinary law to discipline—(i)a person (other than by termination of employment), including the action taken in disciplining the person; or Section 187 of the PS Act provides for the grounds for discipline as follows:187 Grounds for discipline(1)A public service employee’s chief executive may discipline the employee if the chief executive is reasonably satisfied the employee has—(a)engaged in repeated unsatisfactory performance or serious under performance of the employee’s duties, including, for example, by performing duties carelessly, incompetently or inefficiently; or(b)been guilty of misconduct; or(c)been absent from duty without approved leave and without reasonable excuse; or(d)contravened, without reasonable excuse, a direction given to the employee as a public service employee by a responsible person; or(e)used, without reasonable excuse, a substance to an extent that has adversely affected the competent performance of the employee’s duties; or(ea) contravened, without reasonable excuse, a requirement of the chief executive under section 179A (1) in relation to the employee’s appointment, secondment or employment by, in response to the requirement—(i)failing to disclose a serious disciplinary action; or(ii)giving false or misleading information; or(f)contravened, without reasonable excuse, a provision of this Act; or(g)contravened, without reasonable excuse, a relevant standard of conduct in a way that is sufficiently serious to warrant disciplinary action.(2)A disciplinary ground arises when the act or omission constituting the ground is done or made.(3)Also, a chief executive may discipline, on the same grounds mentioned in subsection (1) —(a)a public service employee under section 187A; or(b)a former public service employee under section 188A .(4)In this section—misconduct means—(a)inappropriate or improper conduct in an official capacity; or(b)inappropriate or improper conduct in a private capacity that reflects seriously and adversely on the public service.Example of misconduct—victimising another public service employee in the course of the other employee’s employment in the public servicerelevant standard of conduct, for a public service employee, means—(a)a standard of conduct applying to the employee under an approved code of conduct under the Public Sector Ethics Act 1994; or(b)a standard of conduct, if any, applying to the employee under an approved standard of practice under the Public Sector Ethics Act 1994.responsible person, for a direction, means a person with authority to give the direction, whether the authority derives from this Act or otherwise. Section 188 of the PS Act identifies the disciplinary action that may be taken against a public service employee as follows:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established