Borkowski v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Borkowski v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services) [2021] QIRC 330

PARTIES:

Borkowski, Peter
(Appellant)

v

State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services)
(Respondent)

CASE NO.:

PSA/2021/228

PROCEEDING:

Public Service Appeal - Appeal against discipline decision

DELIVERED ON:

24 September 2021

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Merrell DP

On the papers

ORDER: 

1. Pursuant to s 562C(1)(a) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016, the decisions appealed against are confirmed.

2. Pursuant to s 566(1)(b) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016, the stay of the discipline penalty decision appealed against, made on 20 July 2021, is revoked.

CATCHWORDS:

PUBLIC SERVICE - EMPLOYEES AND SERVANTS OF THE CROWN GENERALLY - PUBLIC SERVICE APPEAL - appellant employed as a Custodial Correctional Officer - finding that appellant failed to report, and to report accurately, the use of force by a Custodial Supervisor against a prisoner - disciplinary action taken against appellant pursuant to s 188 of the Public Service Act 2008 - appeal by appellant against disciplinary findings and disciplinary action taken - whether disciplinary findings fair and reasonable - whether disciplinary action was fair and reasonable - disciplinary findings and disciplinary action taken fair and reasonable - decisions appealed against confirmed

LEGISLATION:

Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 562B, s 562C and s 566

Public Service Act 2008, s 187, s 188, s 197 and s 201

CASES:

Aldrich v Ross [2000] QCA 501; (2001) 2 Qd R 23

Morison v State of Queensland (Department of Child Safety, Youth and Women) [2020] QIRC 203

Nesbit vMetro North Hospital and Health Service [2021] ICQ 005

Page v John Thompson and Lesley Dwyer, As Chief Executive Officer, West Moreton Hospital and Health Service [2014] QSC 252

Police Service Board v Morris [1985] HCA 9; (1985) 156 CLR 397

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. Mr Peter Borkowski is employed as a Custodial Correctional Officer ('CCO') within Queensland Corrective Services ('QCS').

  2. By letter dated 27 May 2021, Mr Gary McCahon, Deputy Commissioner, Custodial Operations, QCS, informed Mr Borkowski that, having regard to two earlier disciplinary findings in respect of which Mr McCahon had found Mr Borkowski, pursuant to s 187(1)(b) of the Public Service Act 2008 ('the PS Act'), was guilty of misconduct ('the discipline findings decision'), he (Mr McCahon) had determined to impose upon Mr Borkowski the disciplinary action of:

    ·a reduction in remuneration level from GS1-9 to GS1-7 for a period of 12 months;

    ·a direction to attend training regarding the Code of Conduct ('the Code') and the Custodial Operations Practice Directive: Use of Force ('COPD'); and

    ·a reprimand ('the discipline penalty decision').

  1. By appeal filed on 18 June 2021, Mr Borkowski appeals against the discipline findings decision and against the discipline penalty decision.

  2. By directions order dated 20 July 2021, I stayed the discipline penalty decision until the determination of Mr Borkowski's appeal or further order of the Commission. I also directed the parties to file and serve written submissions in relation to the appeal. Both parties have…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Borkowski v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Servi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QIRC 330
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Borkowski v State of Queensland (Queensland Corrective Services), the appellant, Mr. Borkowski, contested the disciplinary findings and actions taken against him by the respondent, the State of Queensland, represented by the Queensland Corrective Services (QCS). Mr. Borkowski, a Custodial Correctional Officer, was found to have failed to report and accurately report the use of force by a Correctional Supervisor against a prisoner, and faced disciplinary action pursuant to the Public Service Act 2008. The primary legal issue for the court was to determine whether the disciplinary findings and actions taken against Mr. Borkowski were fair and reasonable. The court had to examine the process followed, the evidence considered, and the proportionality of the penalties imposed in relation to the misconduct.

The court's reasoning focused on the importance of maintaining public confidence in the Queensland Corrective Services and the role of Custodial Correctional Officers in ensuring the proper and just administration of correctional facilities. The court concluded that the disciplinary findings and actions were fair and reasonable, given the substantiated conduct against Mr. Borkowski. The court accepted that the reduction in remuneration from GS1-9 to GS1-7 for a period of 12 months, while significant, was proportionate to the seriousness of the misconduct. The court also noted that the reliance on Custodial Correctional Officers to report suspicions of the use of force against prisoners is crucial to the public service's integrity and the maintenance of public confidence.

The final orders of the court confirmed the disciplinary findings and actions taken against Mr. Borkowski. The court revoked the stay of the discipline penalty decision, allowing the disciplinary actions to proceed. The court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to the requirements of the Code of Practice for the Queensland Public Service, as well as the need for public servants to act with integrity and uphold the law.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 562C(1)(a) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016, the decisions appealed against are confirmed.

2. Pursuant to s 566(1)(b) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016, the stay of the discipline penalty decision appealed against, made on 20 July 2021, is revoked.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I confirm the discipline findings decision and the discipline penalty decision.Background By letter dated 27 August 2020, Mr McCahon informed Mr Borkowski that:·he was in receipt of an investigation report prepared by the Ethical Standards Group ('ESG') regarding an alleged incident on 7 October 2018 involving Mr Borkowski and several other officers that took place at the Princess Alexandra Hospital Secure Unit ('the Secure Unit'); ·15 allegations were investigated by the ESG;·Allegations 12 and 13 of the investigation report concerned him (Mr Borkowski); and·he (Mr McCahon) was of the view that in relation to those two allegations, Mr Borkowski may be liable for disciplinary findings pursuant to s 187 of the PS Act and that Mr Borkowski was required to show cause as to why a disciplinary finding should not be made against him. The two allegations against Mr Borkowski were set out in this correspondence. In addition, significant particulars of each allegation were provided to Mr Borkowski in that correspondence.Allegation 1 The first allegation was that on 7 October 2018, at the Secure Unit, Mr Borkowski failed to report suspected wrongdoing, namely, a use of force by a Correctional Supervisor ('CS') on a prisoner that was not reasonably necessary in the circumstances ('Allegation 1'). Mr McCahon informed Mr Borkowski that having considered the investigation material before him in respect of Allegation 1, he considered that Mr Borkowski may be liable to disciplinary action on the basis that: The second allegation was that on 7 October 2018, Mr Borkowski prepared an inaccurate officer's report regarding an incident at the Secure Unit, involving a prisoner ('Allegation 2'). Mr McCahon informed Mr Borkowski that having considered the investigation material before him in respect of Allegation 2, he considered that Mr Borkowski may be liable to disciplinary action on the same basis as referred to in paragraph [11] of these reasons, except that there was no allegation of a contravention of cl 1.1 of the Code. Mr Borkowski was provided with a redacted version of the investigation report dated 25 July 2019 including attachments, ch 6 of the PS Act, the Code, the Department of Justice and Attorney-General Workplace Policy and the COPD. Mr McCahon afforded Mr Borkowski the opportunity to respond, within 14 days of receipt of Mr McCahon's letter, to show cause why disciplinary findings should not be made against him in relation to Allegations 1 and 2. By letter dated 14 September 2020, Mr Jack McDonald, Solicitor of Sibley Lawyers, responded on Mr Borkowski's behalf ('Mr Borkowski's first response'). By letter dated 21 January 2021, Mr McCahon informed Mr Borkowski that having considered Mr Borkowski's first response, he determined that in relation to Allegation 1 and 2, both allegations were substantiated and that pursuant to s 187(1)(b) of the PS Act, Mr Borkowski had engaged in misconduct, namely, inappropriate or improper conduct in an official capacity within the meaning of s 187(4)(a) of the PS Act. Mr McCahon informed Mr Borkowski that in relation to the taking of disciplinary action he was currently giving serious consideration to:·a reduction of remuneration level from GS1-9 to GS1-7 for a period of 12 months and that the pay-point progression at the completion of that period would be in accordance with the Correctional Employees Award - State 2015;·a direction to attend training regarding the Code and the COPD; and·a reprimand ('the proposed disciplinary action').

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, in my view, Mr McCahon's disciplinary finding decision, in respect of Allegation 2, was fair and reasonable.The discipline penalty decision was fair and reasonable The aim of disciplinary proceedings is for the protection of the public[6] and the maintenance of public confidence.[7] It has been held, in respect of Queensland Police Service disciplinary proceedings, that the primary purpose of such disciplinary proceedings is the maintenance of public confidence in the Service and the maintenance of integrity in the performance of the duties of police officers.[8] In my opinion, these principles are equally applicable to the QCS and to CCOs because they provide an essential public service and the public must have confidence QCS and CCOs will act according to the law and with integrity.[6] Nesbit vMetro North Hospital and Health Service [2021] ICQ 005, [99] (Davis J, President).[7] Police Service Board v Morris [1985] HCA 9; (1985) 156 CLR 397, 412 (Brennan J).[8] Aldrich v Ross [2000] QCA 501; (2001) 2 Qd R 235, [42] (Thomas J A, Pincus JA at [1] and Muir J at [53] agreeing). Mr Borkowski submits that the disciplinary action taken against him, namely, a reduction in remuneration from GS1-9 to GS1-7 for a period of 12 months, and the resultant financial impact on him, is severe because:·it will take him two years to progress back to his original pay point level; ·the financial impact on him, he estimates, will be $15,000 in the first year and then approximately $2,874 in the second year; and·if he retires in the next two years, given he is currently 65 years of age, he will suffer more substantially given that he is a member of a Defined Benefit superannuation scheme. Mr Borkowski also submits that QCS, in determining the discipline penalty, did not take into account the mental and emotional anguish from which he had suffered by being under investigation and subject to a show cause process since April 2019 and that it did not take into account his exemplary work record of over 35 years. I accept that there will be an immediate impact on Mr Borkowski's remuneration by virtue of the first aspect of the discipline decision. However, in my opinion, a reduction in two pay‑points for a period of 12 months, having regard to the substantiated conduct against Mr Borkowski, is not disproportionate and is fair and reasonable. There are four reasons for my view. First, it is obvious, having regard to the requirements of the COPD referred to earlier in these reasons, that QCS relies upon its CCOs to report their suspicions where force is used against a prisoner which may not be reasonably necessary. As QCS submits, if CCTV footage of the use of force observed by Mr Borkowski was not available, his report of the use of force by the CS would not have been a reliable record of what occurred. It is clear, having regard to the COPD, that such an obligation on a CCO is important to the proper and just administration of any facility for which QCS has operational responsibility. Mr Borkowski clearly failed in complying with that obligation. For this reason, Mr Borkowski's misconduct was serious.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established