Patarroyo v Simmonds

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Patarroyo v Simmonds  [2023] QCAT 67

PARTIES:

raul mendez patarroyo

(applicant)

v

tegan simmonds

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

ADL047-20

MATTER TYPE:

Anti-discrimination matters

DELIVERED ON:

6 February 2023

HEARING DATE:

26 August 2022

Closing submissions on 23 September 2022 and 24 October 2022

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

A/Senior Member Traves

ORDERS:

The complaint of Raul Mendez Patarroyo against Tegan Simmonds is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

HUMAN RIGHTS – DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION – DIRECT DISCRIMINATION – ACCOMMODATION – - where respondent landlord made comments to applicant tenant during tenancy - whether direct discrimination on the basis of race - whether discrimination in accommodation area by treating applicant unfavourably in any way in connection with the accommodation within the meaning of s 83(d) of the Anti Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld).

Anti Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld), s 6, s 8, s 10, s 83,

s 210

Australian Iron & Steel Pty Ltd v Banovic (1989) 168 CLR 165

Hagan v Trustees of the Toowoomba Sports Ground Trust [2000] FCA 1615

Woodforth v State of Queensland [2017] QCA 100

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self represented

Respondent:

Self represented

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This is a complaint of direct discrimination by Mr Patarroyo against Ms Simmonds, who was his landlord at the relevant time. Mr Patarroyo contends that Ms Simmonds contravened s 83(d) of the Anti Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) (ADA) by sending two emails to him which he says amounted to less favourable treatment on the basis of race. Mr Patarroyo is from Columbia, South America. He identifies as Latin American.

  2. The emails upon which Mr Patarroyo bases his claim are as follows:

    Email 1: Ms Simmonds to Mr Patarroyo on 19 November 2019

    As mentioned in my email in early October, you are a fraud and a cheat (which is well established), this is what you people do, but in any case I am straightforward and I will inform all authorities and university about people like you – and I will report you to all agencies including and not limited to Immigration.

    Email 2: Ms Simmonds to Mr Patarroyo on 22 November 2019

    I have also contacted the Immigration Office and UQ International Students Services, as I know you talked about applying for PR and to extend, so I will follow up on all of this. I am keeping updated and will follow due process from all aspects.

  3. Mr Patarroyo contends that the treatment (sending the emails) constituted direct discrimination against him on the basis of his race, which was prohibited by s 83, being unfavourable treatment in connection with the accommodation. Mr Patarroyo seeks $1000 in compensation (his original claim of $13 000 was abandoned in the hearing); an order instructing the respondent to withdraw any communications sent to the University of Queensland; Immigration Office; the Police Department of Queensland and UQ International Student Services; and an order that the respondent cease any further communication with him.

  4. Ms Simmonds refutes the contention. She contends that the emails should be viewed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Patarroyo v Simmonds and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Patarroyo v Simmonds, the applicant, Mr Patarroyo, brought a complaint against the respondent, Ms Simmonds, alleging discrimination on the basis of race. The matter was heard and determined by a Magistrate in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The crux of the dispute revolves around the interpretation of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) (ADA) and whether Ms Simmonds' conduct toward Mr Patarroyo constituted direct discrimination based on his race.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Ms Simmonds had engaged in direct discrimination against Mr Patarroyo as defined by the ADA. This required determining if Mr Patarroyo, on the basis of his race, received less favourable treatment than a comparator who was not of the same race, under similar or materially different circumstances. The court also needed to assess the context and content of the relevant communications between the parties to ascertain whether the treatment was based on race.

The court reasoned that the appropriate comparator was a student tenant of Ms Simmonds who engaged in similar conduct and behaviour around the same time as Mr Patarroyo. It was noted that Ms Simmonds had a history of treating her tenants, including international students, in a welcoming and friendly manner. The court considered the context of the emails exchanged between the parties and concluded that Ms Simmonds' comments and threats were not based on Mr Patarroyo’s race but rather his conduct as a tenant. The court found that Mr Patarroyo had not proven, on the balance of probabilities, that the treatment he received was due to his race or that Ms Simmonds' actions constituted direct discrimination.

As the court found that Mr Patarroyo had not established the requisite standard of discrimination, the appropriate order under section 210 of the ADA was to dismiss the complaint. The court's decision rests on the finding that the treatment in question was not based on race but rather on the conduct of the tenant, and therefore, no discrimination under the ADA was established.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, I find that Ms Simmonds did not engage in direct discrimination within the meaning of the ADA. I note the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to make the orders sought by Ms Simmonds.Conclusion As prohibited discrimination has not been established, the appropriate order under s 210 of the ADA is to dismiss Mr Patarroyo’s complaint.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is for the complainant to prove, on the balance of probabilities, that the respondent contravened the Act, subject to exemptions which are not relevant here.[5][5]ADA, s 204.Consideration I find the appropriate comparator to be a person not of Mr Patarroyo’s race, who was a tenant of Ms Simmonds, a University student, and who engaged in the same conduct and behaved the same way around the time the relevant emails were sent. The question is whether Mr Patarroyo, on the basis of his race, received less favourable treatment than the comparator would have done in circumstances that were the same or not materially different.Email 1 It is important to consider the context in which the comment “people like you” in the email was made.[6] This includes the background to the email but also to the context of the statement within the email itself.[6]Hagan v Trustees of the Toowoomba Sports Ground Trust [2000] FCA 1615. Ms Simmonds rents out a large house to several students. The students are invariably international students. Several past students gave evidence to the effect that they have always been welcomed by Ms Simmonds and that she would go out of her way to make them feel at home, at times hosting birthday dinners or get togethers for tenants and their friends. Ms Simmonds’ contact with Mr Patarroyo was similarly caring and friendly, until around October/November 2019 when their relationship became strained. Ms Simmonds in emails to Mr Patarroyo in November 2019 refers to him wanting to break the lease (which he first raised on 6 October 2019 over WhatsApp) because it was week 13 in the University calendar and he did not want to pay rent during the holidays. Ms Simmonds also refers to other students who were tenants of hers at that time in emails using similar terminology, for example, “folks like you”. I accept Ms Simmonds’ evidence that sending an email to a tenant in response to behaviour she regards as inappropriate or unsatisfactory is how she would usually react. Accordingly, I do not find there was less favourable treatment by Ms Simmonds of Mr Patarroyo. Further, for completeness, assuming the treatment was less favourable, I do not find the reason for the treatment to have been Mr Patarroyo’s race. Viewing the evidence as a whole, Mr Patarroyo, in my view, has not established to the requisite standard that Ms Simmonds was referring to people of his race when she said “people like you”. A reasonable construction of the email in context is that the reference to “fraud and cheats” followed by “people like you” was a reference to tenants who are students who, for unmeritorious reasons, try to break their lease, for example, to get out of paying rent over the holidays. It is unnecessary, therefore, to consider the contention based on the content of email 1 further.Email 2 I turn to consider whether the threats Ms Simmonds made in the email dated 22 November 2019 to contact International Student Services and Immigration was less favourable treatment based on race.