Parmalat Australia Ltd v Norco Co-Operative Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Parmalat Australia Ltd & Ors v Norco Co-operative Ltd [2006] QCA 129

PARTIES:

PARMALAT AUSTRALIA LTD ACN 009 698 015
(first plaintiff/first appellant/first cross respondent)
PAULS ICE CREAM & MILK PTY LTD ACN 009 661 732
(second plaintiff/second appellant/second cross respondent)
v
NORCO CO-OPERATIVE LIMITED
ARBN 009 717 417

(defendant/respondent/cross appellant)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 2070 of 2006
SC No 777 of 2005

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

Orders delivered on 20 April 2006
Reasons delivered on 21 April 2006

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3 April 2006

JUDGES:

McMurdo P, Williams JA and Jerrard JA
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made on the appeal, Jerrard JA dissenting on the orders made on the cross-appeal

ORDERS:

1. Appeal allowed, costs order and first declaration made by primary judge on 10 March 2006 set aside and instead declare that the Trademark Licence Agreement dated 30 November 1998 is determinable by the first and second appellants pursuant to clause 15(b) of that agreement by reason of the respondent exercising an option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd in joint venture described in the Joint Venture Agreement dated 27 June 1996 pursuant to clauses 9.2 and 9.3 of that agreement

2. Respondent to pay the appellants' costs of this appeal and original application to be assessed on the standard basis

3. On the cross-appeal declare that the Trademark Licence Agreement dated 30 November 1998 is determinable by the first and second appellants pursuant to clause 15(a) of that agreement by reason of the respondent exercising an option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd in the joint venture described in the Joint Venture Agreement dated 27 June 1996 pursuant to clause 9 thereof and thereby terminating the Joint Venture Agreement

4. No order as to costs on the cross-appeal

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – OTHER MATTERS – where clause 15(b) of the Trade Mark Licence Agreement entitles the licensor to terminate the authority to use the relevant trade marks “if for any reason NDM ceases to conduct the Business Operation” – meaning of “NDM” – whether “NDM” in clause 15(b) is merely a reference to the trading name of the joint venture or is a reference to those entities “now trading as Norco Dairyfields Milk” and to them as joint venturers – meaning of “Business Operation” – whether the term “business operations” in clause 15(b) refers to the business carried on by the joint venture - where the “Business Operation” operated by the Participants, utilising the Assets, are the business activities conducted by the named Joint Venturers and their transferees as part of the Joint Venture, while those named Joint Venturers or their transferees hold an Interest in the Joint Venture – where an Interest in the Joint Venture…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Parmalat Australia Ltd v Norco Co-Operative Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] QCA 129
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Parmalat Australia Ltd and Norco Co-Operative Ltd were parties to a Trade Mark Licence Agreement. The dispute arose from the interpretation of clauses 15(a) and 15(b) of the agreement, which deal with the termination of the licensor's authority to use trade marks under certain conditions. Specifically, clause 15(b) allows for termination if NDM ceases to conduct the Business Operation, while clause 15(a) allows for termination if the Joint Venture Agreement is terminated in accordance with its terms. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia.

The court had to determine the meaning of the term "NDM" in clause 15(b) of the Trade Mark Licence Agreement. It was necessary to decide whether "NDM" referred to the trading name of the joint venture or to the entities now trading as Norco Dairyfields Milk and them as joint venturers. Additionally, the court had to interpret the term "Business Operation" in clause 15(b) to ascertain whether it referred to the business carried on by the joint venture. Furthermore, the court needed to decide whether the Trade Mark Licence Agreement allowed for changes in the composition of the Joint Venture via permitted assignments and whether the termination of the Joint Venture Agreement by the respondent resulted in the determinability of the Trade Mark Licence Agreement.

The court found that "NDM" in clause 15(b) referred to the entities now trading as Norco Dairyfields Milk and them as joint venturers, not merely the trading name. It concluded that the term "Business Operation" in clause 15(b) referred to the business activities conducted by the named Joint Venturers and their transferees as part of the Joint Venture, while they held an Interest in the Joint Venture. The court also determined that the Trade Mark Licence Agreement allowed for changes in the composition of the Joint Venture via permitted assignments and that the termination of the Joint Venture Agreement by the respondent made the Trade Mark Licence Agreement determinable.

The court allowed the appeal, set aside the primary judge's costs order and first declaration, and declared that the Trade Mark Licence Agreement dated 30 November 1998 is determinable by the appellants pursuant to clause 15(b) of that agreement by reason of the respondent exercising its option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields in the joint venture. The court also declared that the Trade Mark Licence Agreement is determinable by the appellants pursuant to clause 15(a) of that agreement by reason of the respondent terminating the Joint Venture Agreement. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellants' costs of the appeal and original application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed, costs order and first declaration made by primary judge on 10 March 2006 set aside and instead

declare that the Trademark Licence Agreement dated 30

November 1998 is determinable by the first and second

appellants pursuant to clause 15(b) of that agreement by

reason of the respondent exercising an option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd in joint venture described in the Joint Venture Agreement

dated 27 June 1996 pursuant to clauses 9.2 and 9.3 of that

agreement

2. Respondent to pay the appellants' costs of this appeal and original application to be assessed on the standard basis

3. On the cross-appeal declare that the Trademark Licence

Agreement dated 30 November 1998 is determinable by the first and second appellants pursuant to clause 15(a) of that agreement by reason of the respondent exercising an option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and

Dairyfields Pty Ltd in the joint venture described in the

Joint Venture Agreement dated 27 June 1996 pursuant to

clause 9 thereof and thereby terminating the Joint Venture

Agreement

4. No order as to costs on the cross-appeal

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the interpretation and application of the terms of a Trade Mark Licence Agreement between Parmalat Australia Ltd (the licensor) and Norco Co-Operative Ltd (the licensee). The Trade Mark Licence Agreement, dated 30 November 1998, grants Norco the authority to use certain trade marks. Clause 15(b) of the agreement allows for the licensor to terminate the authority if Norco ceases to conduct the business operations. Clause 15(a) provides for termination if the joint venture is terminated in accordance with the Joint Venture Agreement. The case revolves around the interpretation of the terms "NDM" and "Business Operation" in clause 15(b), and the implications of changes in the composition of the joint venture on the enforceability of the trade mark licence. The joint venture in question involved Norco, Pauls Trading Pty Ltd, and Dairyfields Pty Ltd.

The Joint Venture Agreement, dated 27 June 1996, outlines the terms under which the joint venture operates, including the rights of the joint venturers and the procedure for assigning interests in the joint venture. Clause 9 of the Joint Venture Agreement allows for the purchase of the interest of a defaulting participant joint venturer by the remaining participants. The scenario presented involves the respondent exercising its option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd in the joint venture, potentially leading to a change in the composition of the joint venture.

The matter originated from an application by the appellants seeking a declaration that the Trade Mark Licence Agreement was determinable due to the respondent's acquisition of the interests of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd. The appellants sought an interlocutory order and later appealed against the dismissal of their application. The appeal was heard by the court, which set aside the earlier orders and made new declarations regarding the determinability of the trade mark licence agreement under clauses 15(a) and 15(b) of the agreement. The respondent subsequently cross-appealed against the determination of the trade mark licence agreement under clause 15(a).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the meaning of "NDM" in clause 15(b) of the Trade Mark Licence Agreement?
2. What is the meaning of "Business Operation" in clause 15(b) of the Trade Mark Licence Agreement?
3. Does the Trade Mark Licence Agreement allow for changes in the composition of the joint venture via permitted assignments?
4. Does the acquisition of the interests of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd by the respondent terminate the Trade Mark Licence Agreement under clause 15(b)?
5. Is the Trade Mark Licence Agreement determinable by the appellants pursuant to clause 15(a) of that agreement by reason of the respondent exercising its option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd in the joint venture and thereby terminating the Joint Venture Agreement?

Held
1. The meaning of "NDM" in clause 15(b) of the Trade Mark Licence Agreement is a reference to those entities "now trading as Norco Dairyfields Milk" and to them as joint venturers, not merely a reference to the trading name of the joint venture.
2. The meaning of "Business Operation" in clause 15(b) of the Trade Mark Licence Agreement refers to the business carried on by the joint venture, which are the business activities conducted by the named Joint Venturers and their transferees as part of the Joint Venture, while those named Joint Venturers or their transferees hold an Interest in the Joint Venture.
3. The Trade Mark Licence Agreement does allow for changes in the composition of the joint venture via permitted assignments.
4. The acquisition of the interests of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd by the respondent does not terminate the Trade Mark Licence Agreement under clause 15(b).
5. The Trade Mark Licence Agreement is determinable by the appellants pursuant to clause 15(a) of that agreement by reason of the respondent exercising its option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd in the joint venture and thereby terminating the Joint Venture Agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court examined the terms of the Trade Mark Licence Agreement and the Joint Venture Agreement to determine the meaning of "NDM" and "Business Operation" in clause 15(b). The Court found that "NDM" refers to those entities "now trading as Norco Dairyfields Milk" and to them as joint venturers, and "Business Operation" refers to the business carried on by the joint venture, specifically the activities conducted by the named Joint Venturers and their transferees as part of the Joint Venture, while holding an Interest in the Joint Venture. The Court also considered whether the Trade Mark Licence Agreement allows for changes in the composition of the joint venture via permitted assignments, concluding that it does. The Court found that the acquisition of the interests of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd by the respondent did not terminate the Trade Mark Licence Agreement under clause 15(b), as the business operation continued under the remaining joint venturer. However, the Court did find that the Trade Mark Licence Agreement is determinable by the appellants pursuant to clause 15(a) of that agreement by reason of the respondent exercising its option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd in the joint venture and thereby terminating the Joint Venture Agreement. The Court applied the principles of contract interpretation, relying on the plain meaning of the contract terms and the context in which they were used. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Trade Mark Licence Agreement allows for changes in the composition of the joint venture via permitted assignments and that the agreement is determinable by the appellants when the respondent exercises its option to acquire the interest of Pauls Trading Pty Ltd and Dairyfields Pty Ltd in the joint venture and thereby terminating the Joint Venture Agreement.