Palmanova Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Palmanova Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia [2023] FCA 1391

File number: NSD 571 of 2021
Judgment of: PERRAM J
Date of judgment: 14 November 2023
Catchwords:

CULTURAL HERITAGE – application under s 37 of the Protection of Movable Cultural Heritage Act 1986 (Cth) (‘the Act') for recovery of Artefact seized by Commonwealth – whether Artefact liable to forfeiture under s 14(1) of the Act.

CULTURAL HERITAGE – whether Artefact a 'protected object of a foreign country' – whether Artefact part of the movable cultural heritage of Bolivia – whether Artefact made by the Tiwanaku civilisation in the first millennium AD – whether Artefact made at city of Tiwanaku in modern day Bolivia – where Bolivian law prohibited removal of objects from monumental ruins at Tiwanaku and Lake Titicaca after 1906 – whether Artefact exported from Bolivia after 1906.

EVIDENCE – burden of proof in civil case – where multiple competing hypotheses – where events traverse 1500 years of human history.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – nature and purpose of a civil trial – relevance of ascertainment of absolute truth.

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – proper construction of s 14(1) of the Act – meaning of 'has been imported' in s 14(1)(a) of the Act – temporal implications of use of present perfect tense instead of past tense.

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) ss 15AB(1)(b)(i), 15AB(2)

Customs Act 1901 (Cth) s 203T

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 140(1), 140(2)

Protection of Movable Cultural Heritage Act 1986 (Cth) ss 3, 14, 14(1), 14(1)(a), 14(1)(b), 14(1)(c), 14(2), 27, 34, 37, 37(3)(b)

Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property, opened for signature 14 November 1970, 823 UNTS 231 (entered into force 24 April 1972) Art 7

Cultural Property Export and Import Act 1975 (Can) s 31(2)

Cases cited:

Bradshaw v McEwans Pty Ltd (1951) 217 ALR 1

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Commonwealth v Baume (1905) 2 CLR 405

Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing & Allied Services Union of Australia v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission [2007] FCAFC 132; 162 FCR 466

Holloway v McFeeters (1956) 94 CLR 470

Jones v Sutherland Shire Council [1979] 2 NSWLR 206

Kuligowski v Metrobus [2004] HCA 34; 220 CLR 363

Martin v Osborne (1936) 55 CLR 367 at 381

Oxford Dictionary of English Grammar (Oxford University Press, 1st ed, 1998)

Palmer v Dolman [2005] NSWCA 361

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; 194 CLR 355

Rhesa Shipping Co SA v Edmunds [1985] 1 WLR 948 at 955; 2 All ER 712

R v Heller, Zango and Kassam (1983) 27 Alta LR (2d) 346

Stephen Gageler, ‘Evidence and Truth’ (2017) 13 The Judicial Review 1

J J Spigelman, ‘Truth and the Law’ in Nye Perram and Rachel Pepper (eds), The Byers Lectures: 2000-2012 (Federation Press, 2012) 232

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Other Federal…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Palmanova Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1391
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Palmanova Pty Ltd, the applicant, sought the return of an artefact seized by the Commonwealth under the Protection of Movable Cultural Heritage Act 1986 (Cth). The primary issue was whether the artefact was liable for forfeiture under section 14(1) of the Act. This hinged on whether the artefact was a protected object of a foreign country and if it was part of the movable cultural heritage of Bolivia, originating from the Tiwanaku civilisation in the first millennium AD. The artefact was allegedly exported from Bolivia after 1906, when Bolivian law prohibited such removals.

The court examined the temporal implications of the phrase 'has been imported' in section 14(1)(a) of the Act, interpreting it as requiring the illegal export to occur after Australia’s accession to the relevant international convention. Given that Australia joined the convention after the artefact was exported, the court concluded that section 14(1) did not apply. The court emphasised that the burden of proof in civil cases involving multiple competing hypotheses and historical events needed careful consideration. Furthermore, the nature and purpose of a civil trial was explored, highlighting that the ascertainment of absolute truth was not always necessary.

The court concluded that the artefact was part of Bolivia's movable cultural heritage and had been unlawfully exported by the 1950s. However, as the act of importation was disconnected from the exportation, section 14(1)(a) did not engage, and the artefact was not liable for forfeiture. The applicant was thus entitled to succeed. The court refrained from addressing costs until it was determined whether the Commonwealth would appeal within 28 days. If an appeal was not filed, the court outlined a process for resolving the costs debate, stipulating the order of submissions and potential mechanisms for presenting evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to confer and provide a short minute of order giving effect to these reasons within 7 days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant drew to my attention this decision and submitted that it provided some support for its construction of s 14(1)(a). In that case the Provincial Court of Alberta (as the Alberta Court of Justice then was) was called on to construe s 31(2) of the Cultural Property Export and Import Act 1975 (Can) which provided that ‘From and after the coming into force of a cultural property agreement in Canada and a reciprocating State, it is illegal to import into Canada any foreign cultural property that has been illegally exported from that reciprocating State’. This was held to require that the illegal export had to occur after Canada had entered into the relevant international convention. As I have already explained, the Act commenced and had effect prior to Australia’s accession to the Convention. I do not think that this case throws any light on the correct approach to s 14(1).Conclusion Since it is not in dispute that the Artefact had been exported from Bolivia by the 1950s and that the act of importation was entirely disconnected from the act of exportation it follows that s 14(1) cannot apply to it. The Applicant is therefore entitled to succeed. 9. RESULT The Artefact is part of the movable cultural heritage of Bolivia and was removed unlawfully from Bolivia at some time no later than the 1950s. However, s 14(1)(a) is not engaged and as a result the Artefact is not liable to forfeiture under s 14. The Applicant is therefore entitled to succeed. I do not think it would be useful to embark on the question of costs if the Commonwealth files a notice of appeal within 28 days. The parties should bring in a short minute of order giving effect to these reasons and providing for the contingent resolution of any costs debate on the papers in the event that a notice of appeal is not filed. The submissions should not exceed 5 pages. If a costs debate ensues, the Commonwealth should go first on why some departure from the ordinary costs rule should be entertained, the Applicant should respond to this, and the Commonwealth should have a right of reply. If evidence is necessary for this debate, the parties should formulate a mechanism for that evidence to be prepared.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established