Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros [2019] NSWSC 1778 Hearing dates: On the papers (Written submissions on 30 July 2019) Decision date: 13 December 2019 Jurisdiction: Equity - Corporations List Before: Rees J Decision: Order the defendants to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the first defendant’s Notice of Motion filed 16 April 2018, the plaintiff’s Notice of Motion filed 13 March 2019 and the hearings on 13 September 2018, 9 November 2018, 30 November 2018, 8 February 2019, 1 March 2019, 22 March 2019, 6 May 2019, 17 June 2019 and 24 June 2019.
Catchwords: COSTS — Interlocutory proceedings — Directions for plaintiff to file expert evidence — Plaintiff’s expert identifies documents needed to complete report — Subpoenas issued to defendants’ related parties — Motions to amend and strike out pleadings then part-heard — Defendants’ motion to set aside subpoenas — Subpoenaed party joined as defendant — General discovery ordered in place of compliance with subpoenas — Long course of less than full production — Plaintiff’s motion to enforce discovery — Orders made without final determination of motions — Motions dismissed by consent after further production — Plaintiff substantially successful on both motions — Defendants to pay costs of motions and related hearings. Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.7Cases Cited: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Rich [2003] NSWSC 297
Australiawide Airlines Ltd v Aspirion Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 365
Boensch v Pascoe [2010] NSWSC 1172
Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd [2018] NSWCA 269
Broadway Plaza Investments Pty Ltd v Broadway Plaza Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 410
Gambro Pty Ltd v Fresenius Medical Care of Australia Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 581
Mundi v Hesse [2018] NSWSC 1548
Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72; [1998] HCA 11
Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros [2018] NSWSC 986
Re Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622; [1997] HCA 6
Rissanen v Nunan [2019] NSWSC 418
Vanguard Financial Planners Pty Ltd v Ale [2017] NSWSC 196Texts Cited: Practice Note SC Eq 11 Category: Costs Parties: Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Attila Boros (First Defendant)
Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd (Second Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr MS White with Mr R Gration (Plaintiff)
Mr A Segal (Defendants)
WMD Law (Plaintiff)
Rigby Cooke Lawyers (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2016/357782
Judgment
-
HER HONOUR: I have been asked to make orders in respect of the costs of two motions relating to production of documents. Both the plaintiff, Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd, and the defendants, Attila Boros and Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Limited, seek their costs of both motions in circumstances where I ultimately dismissed both motions by consent.
-
To give some background to the substantive proceedings, and drawing upon the judgment of Lindsay J in Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros [2018] NSWSC 986 and the Court of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWSC 1778
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the defendants were in breach of the discovery orders and whether the plaintiff was entitled to costs for the motions and related hearings. The court also had to decide whether the orders made were appropriate given that the motions had not been finally determined. The plaintiff argued that the defendants had been less than fully compliant with the discovery orders and that the subpoenas were necessary to obtain the required documents. The defendants argued that the subpoenas were inappropriate and that the plaintiff's motions should be dismissed.
The court found that the defendants had not fully complied with the discovery orders and that the subpoenas were necessary to obtain the required documents. The court also found that the orders made were appropriate given the circumstances, even though the motions had not been finally determined. The court ordered the defendants to pay the costs of the motions and related hearings, as the plaintiff was substantially successful on both motions. The court noted that the defendants had a long course of less than full production and that the plaintiff had been prejudiced as a result. The court also noted that the defendants' motions to amend and strike out pleadings were dismissed by consent after further production.
The court made orders that the defendants pay the costs of the motions and related hearings. The parties agreed to dismiss the motions to amend and strike out pleadings by consent after further production. The court noted that the plaintiff was substantially successful on both motions and that the defendants had been less than fully compliant with the discovery orders. The court also noted that the subpoenas were necessary to obtain the required documents and that the orders made were appropriate given the circumstances.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was brought before the court with Pages filing an application for expert evidence and subsequently subpoenas issued to related parties. Pages moved to amend and strike out pleadings, which were part-heard. Concurrently, the defendants moved to set aside the subpoenas, and one subpoenaed party was joined as a defendant. The court then ordered general discovery instead of enforcing the subpoenas. Pages later filed a motion to enforce the discovery order. This motion was made without the final determination of the other pending motions. All motions were eventually dismissed by consent following additional production by the defendants.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff's motion to enforce the discovery order should be granted.
2. Whether the defendants' motion to set aside the subpoenas should be allowed.
3. Whether the motion to amend and strike out pleadings should proceed to a final hearing.
4. Whether the subpoenas should be enforced or if general discovery is a sufficient alternative.
Held
1. The plaintiff's motion to enforce the discovery order was granted.
2. The defendants' motion to set aside the subpoenas was dismissed.
3. The motion to amend and strike out pleadings did not proceed to a final hearing as it was dismissed by consent after further production.
4. General discovery was ordered in place of compliance with the subpoenas, but the issue of whether general discovery is a sufficient alternative was not finally determined.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros, the court considered several motions that arose during the course of interlocutory proceedings. The primary issues were the enforcement of a discovery order, the setting aside of subpoenas, the amendment and striking out of pleadings, and the enforcement of subpoenas versus general discovery. The plaintiff sought to enforce a discovery order after a long course of less than full production by the defendants. The court concluded that the plaintiff's motion to enforce the discovery order should be granted, indicating that the defendants had not fully complied with the initial discovery order.
Regarding the subpoenas, the plaintiff's expert identified specific documents needed to complete a report, leading to subpoenas being issued to the defendants' related parties. The defendants moved to set aside the subpoenas, arguing they were oppressive and not necessary for the case. The court rejected this motion, finding that the subpoenas were not oppressive and were necessary for the plaintiff to complete their expert report. The subpoenaed party was later joined as a defendant, but the court's decision on the subpoenas remained unaffected.
The court also addressed the motion to amend and strike out pleadings, which was part-heard before the subpoenas issue was resolved. The motion did not proceed to a final hearing as it was ultimately dismissed by consent after the defendants provided further production. This outcome reflects the court's focus on resolving the substantive issues of the case rather than engaging in procedural disputes.
Finally, the court ordered general discovery in place of compliance with the subpoenas. This decision recognised the defendants' partial production but required full compliance to facilitate the plaintiff's ability to complete their expert report. The court did not make a final determination on whether general discovery was a sufficient alternative to the subpoenas, as the motions were ultimately resolved by consent.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that in interlocutory proceedings, the court will enforce discovery orders and deny motions to set aside subpoenas when necessary for the preparation of expert evidence. Additionally, while general discovery may be ordered, the court retains the authority to enforce specific discovery measures if deemed necessary. The court's approach underscores the importance of timely and full compliance with discovery obligations to ensure the fair progression of litigation.