Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros [2023] FedCFamC2G 539

File number: SYG 1629 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE CAMERON
Date of judgment: 23 June 2023
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY – Matter settled – application for costs – relevant considerations.
Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 32

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (Bankruptcy) Rules 2021 (Cth) rr 13.01, 13.02, 13.03

Cases cited:

Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros [2019] NSWSC 1778

Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 288

Kempsey Local Aboriginal Land Council v Donnelly [2022] FedCFamC2G 149

Australian Securities Commission v Aust-Home Investments Ltd (1993) 44 FCR 194

Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex Parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622

Gribbles Pathology Pty Ltd v Health Insurance Commission and Ors (1997) 80 FCR 284

Ringwood Plus Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue [2004] VSC 494

Re Kostezky; Ex parte Milder Elfman Szmerling Krycer Pty Ltd (1996) 67 FCR 101

Division: General Division
Number of paragraphs: 27
Date of last submissions: 24 June 2022
Date of hearing: On the papers
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr R. C. Gration
Solicitor for the Applicant: WMD Law
Solicitor for the Respondent: Craddock Murray Neuman Lawyers

ORDERS

SYG 1629 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

IN THE MATTER OF ATTILA BOROS

BETWEEN:

PAGES PROPERTY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

ATTILA BOROS

Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE CAMERON

DATE OF ORDER:

23 June 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties bear their own costs of the proceeding.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE CAMERON

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant creditor, Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd (PPI), presented a creditor’s petition on 27 August 2021.  The petition alleged that the respondent debtor, Mr Boros, owed PPI $68,504.11 (Interlocutory Costs) arising out of an interlocutory costs order made by Rees J in proceedings between the parties in the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Supreme Court Proceedings).

  2. The creditor’s petition was ultimately dismissed by consent on 16 June 2022, with costs to be determined.  These reasons concern the parties’ respective applications for the costs of this proceeding.

    BACKGROUND FACTS

  3. In 2016 Mr Boros became the sole director of PPI, the business’s founder, Greg Page, having died in 2003.  In August 2016 Mr Page’s widow and sole shareholder of PPI removed Mr Boros as director and PPI commenced the Supreme Court Proceedings alleging that he had breached his director’s duties.  Judgment was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 539
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd (PPI) and Mr Boros were the parties in dispute over the costs incurred during the creditor's petition proceedings. The dispute centred on the costs that arose from PPI's attempt to enforce a bankruptcy notice against Mr Boros, which was based on his failure to pay interlocutory costs from a previous litigation. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary legal issue was whether PPI's creditor's petition was frivolous or vexatious, which would entitle Mr Boros to costs on an indemnity basis. The court also needed to determine the appropriate costs order in light of the settlement and the parties' conduct throughout the proceedings.

The Court concluded that PPI's creditor's petition was not frivolous or vexatious. The Court found that the petition was filed in good faith and that PPI had a reasonable basis to believe that Mr Boros had committed an act of bankruptcy by not complying with the bankruptcy notice. The Court also noted that the appeal against the interlocutory costs order did not negate the existence of the debt or the act of bankruptcy. However, the Court found that PPI's conduct in pursuing the petition was unreasonable, given the pending appeal and Mr Boros's eventual successful appeal. The Court ordered that PPI pay Mr Boros's costs of the appeal and the creditor's petition proceedings on an indemnity basis, but reduced the amount by 25% due to PPI's reasonable grounds for bringing the petition and Mr Boros's unreasonable conduct in not complying with the bankruptcy notice. The Court also ordered that the parties bear their own costs of the costs application.

In light of the above, the Court ordered that PPI pay Mr Boros's costs of the appeal and the creditor's petition proceedings on an indemnity basis, reduced by 25%. The parties were ordered to bear their own costs of the costs application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The creditor’s petition was ultimately dismissed by consent on 16 June 2022, with costs to be determined. These reasons concern the parties’ respective applications for the costs of this proceeding.BACKGROUND FACTS In 2016 Mr Boros became the sole director of PPI, the business’s founder, Greg Page, having died in 2003. In August 2016 Mr Page’s widow and sole shareholder of PPI removed Mr Boros as director and PPI commenced the Supreme Court Proceedings alleging that he had breached his director’s duties. Judgment was entered for PPI and, relevantly, Mr Boros ordered to pay 60% of PPI’s costs except as far as costs were the subject of previous costs orders (Trial Judgment): Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros [2019] NSWSC 1778. The Trial Judgment therefore did not disturb the order supporting the Interlocutory Costs. Further relevant history is as follows:(a)on 16 December 2020 Mr Boros appealed against the Trial Judgment and on 24 May 2021 he paid $60,000 into court as security for the costs of that appeal; (b)on 2 June 2021 Mr Boros was served with Bankruptcy Notice BN 253121 issued on 27 May 2021 which required payment of the Interlocutory Costs (Bankruptcy Notice); (c)Mr Boros unsuccessfully applied to have the Bankruptcy Notice set aside;(d)Mr Boros did not comply with the Bankruptcy Notice and so committed an act of bankruptcy;(e)on 27 August 2021 PPI filed the creditor’s petition relying on Mr Boros’s act of bankruptcy and the unpaid Interlocutory Costs; (f)on 6 October 2021 Mr Boros filed his notice stating grounds of opposition; (g)the matter’s first return was on 7 October 2021, at which time timetabling orders were made by the registrar and the further hearing of the petition adjourned to 4 November 2021;(h)on 4 November 2021 the registrar adjourned the further hearing of the petition to 9 December 2021;(i)on 25 November 2021 the NSW Court of Appeal upheld Mr Boros’s appeal from the Trial Judgment, entered judgment for him and ordered that PPI pay his costs “at trial” and of the appeal: Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 288; (j)on 9 December 2021 the further hearing of the petition was adjourned to 3 March 2022 when it was transferred from the registrars’ docket to mine; (k)on 7 March 2022 Mr Boros filed an amended notice stating grounds of opposition; (l)on 11 March 2022 I listed the matter for hearing on 2 June 2022;(m)on 27 May 2022 the 2 June 2022 listing was vacated; and(n)on 16 June 2022 the petition was dismissed by consent. On 4 November 2021 PPI had made an open offer to discontinue the proceeding upon payment of $88,429.07 (made up of the $68,504.11 Interlocutory Costs; $2,014.96 post-judgment interest; and $17,910, being 75% of PPI’s solicitor and client costs of this proceeding up to that point plus disbursements), which Mr Boros did not accept. A further open offer, to discontinue the proceeding upon payment of $130,779.90 (made up of the $68,504.11 Interlocutory Costs; $3,217.07 post-judgment interest; $30,393.68, being 75% of PPI’s solicitor and client costs of this proceeding up to that point plus disbursements; $28,328.85, being costs of an unsuccessful application for a review of a registrar’s decision not to set the Bankruptcy Notice aside; and $336.14 post-judgment interest), was made on 24 February 2022 and was also not accepted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In 2016 Mr Boros became the sole director of PPI, the business’s founder, Greg Page, having died in 2003. In August 2016 Mr Page’s widow and sole shareholder of PPI removed Mr Boros as director and PPI commenced the Supreme Court Proceedings alleging that he had breached his director’s duties. Judgment was entered for PPI and, relevantly, Mr Boros ordered to pay 60% of PPI’s costs except as far as costs were the subject of previous costs orders (Trial Judgment): Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros [2019] NSWSC 1778. The Trial Judgment therefore did not disturb the order supporting the Interlocutory Costs. Further relevant history is as follows:(a)on 16 December 2020 Mr Boros appealed against the Trial Judgment and on 24 May 2021 he paid $60,000 into court as security for the costs of that appeal; (b)on 2 June 2021 Mr Boros was served with Bankruptcy Notice BN 253121 issued on 27 May 2021 which required payment of the Interlocutory Costs (Bankruptcy Notice); (c)Mr Boros unsuccessfully applied to have the Bankruptcy Notice set aside;(d)Mr Boros did not comply with the Bankruptcy Notice and so committed an act of bankruptcy;(e)on 27 August 2021 PPI filed the creditor’s petition relying on Mr Boros’s act of bankruptcy and the unpaid Interlocutory Costs; (f)on 6 October 2021 Mr Boros filed his notice stating grounds of opposition; (g)the matter’s first return was on 7 October 2021, at which time timetabling orders were made by the registrar and the further hearing of the petition adjourned to 4 November 2021;(h)on 4 November 2021 the registrar adjourned the further hearing of the petition to 9 December 2021;(i)on 25 November 2021 the NSW Court of Appeal upheld Mr Boros’s appeal from the Trial Judgment, entered judgment for him and ordered that PPI pay his costs “at trial” and of the appeal: Boros v Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCA 288; (j)on 9 December 2021 the further hearing of the petition was adjourned to 3 March 2022 when it was transferred from the registrars’ docket to mine; (k)on 7 March 2022 Mr Boros filed an amended notice stating grounds of opposition; (l)on 11 March 2022 I listed the matter for hearing on 2 June 2022;(m)on 27 May 2022 the 2 June 2022 listing was vacated; and(n)on 16 June 2022 the petition was dismissed by consent. On 4 November 2021 PPI had made an open offer to discontinue the proceeding upon payment of $88,429.07 (made up of the $68,504.11 Interlocutory Costs; $2,014.96 post-judgment interest; and $17,910, being 75% of PPI’s solicitor and client costs of this proceeding up to that point plus disbursements), which Mr Boros did not accept. A further open offer, to discontinue the proceeding upon payment of $130,779.90 (made up of the $68,504.11 Interlocutory Costs; $3,217.07 post-judgment interest; $30,393.68, being 75% of PPI’s solicitor and client costs of this proceeding up to that point plus disbursements; $28,328.85, being costs of an unsuccessful application for a review of a registrar’s decision not to set the Bankruptcy Notice aside; and $336.14 post-judgment interest), was made on 24 February 2022 and was also not accepted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

He argued that the reasonableness of PPI’s conduct ought to be considered in light of the fact that his appeal from the Trial Judgment had been successful. He pointed in that connection to the seriousness of making a person bankrupt, arguing that the petition ought not to have been brought before the then-pending appeal was determined. He also argued that what he contended was the unreasonableness of PPI’s conduct was not mitigated by the fact that he had not complied with the Bankruptcy Notice as it might be inferred that he could have demonstrated sufficient cause for the Court to have not made a sequestration order. He submitted:(a) first, Mr Boros has equity available to him in real property of at least $243,690.36, which exceeds any amount which may be owed by him to PPI;(b) second, Mr Boros is able to raise money to pay his debts by selling or mortgaging real property (third parties have also agreed to purchase his interest in the real property or loan amounts as against the real property);(c) third, he has cash immediately available to him in the amount of $60,000.00, being the amount which was previously paid as security for costs of the Appeal Proceedings and has now been ordered to be released to him (pursuant to the settlement Mr Boros has also paid the amount of $105,995.40 into a controlled monies account – which significantly exceeds the amount claimed in the petition);(d) fourth, he has the benefit of costs orders against PPI (although it remains to be seen whether PPI has the capacity to make payment to Mr Boros of any amount assessed under those orders); and(e) fifth, PPI’s claim for costs orders which have not yet been agreed or assessed total $113,736.86. Until such time as those costs have been agreed or assessed, they are not debts that require immediate payment by Mr Boros.CONSIDERATION It is apparent from the portions of the Bankruptcy Act and the Bankruptcy Rules quoted earlier that the Court can order costs for a petitioning creditor even if their petition is dismissed; see also Kempsey Local Aboriginal Land Council v Donnelly [2022] FedCFamC2G 149 at [70]. The arguments presented by the parties may be summarised as follows:(a)the proceeding had been meritorious because at all relevant times prior to the point when he made the offer that PPI accepted, Mr Boros had not been solvent, in the sense of being able to pay all his debts as they fell due from immediately available cash resources or other money that he could procure within a short time relative to the nature and amount of the debts and to his circumstances; and(b)the creditor’s petition had been presented precipitately and prematurely at a time when judgment on the appeal was reserved and was no more than an impermissible exercise in debt recovery whose pursuit was doubly unreasonable given the surrounding circumstances. Those contentions are to be considered in the context of the state of affairs that objectively obtained prior to the settlement of the proceeding, namely that:(a)Mr Boros had committed an act of bankruptcy and the debt underlying the Bankruptcy Notice, being the Interlocutory Costs, remained outstanding;(b)Mr Boros had unsuccessfully applied to have the Bankruptcy Notice set aside;(c)the creditor’s petition was filed before the final outcome of the Supreme Court Proceedings was known; and(d)the Supreme Court Proceedings’ final outcome did not affect the existence or enforceability of the Interlocutory Costs, did not enter judgment in a sum certain for Mr Boros, did order that PPI pay Mr Boros’s costs at trial and of the appeal but did not order that the various costs orders be set off against each other.Contrary to the implicit invitations in the parties’ submissions that the Court should take a view on Mr Boros’s solvency, the Court is in no position to do more than speculate on that because it cannot judge whether the effect of the appeal was to provide him with claims exceeding PPI’s claims and because evidence of his financial position more generally was imprecise and untested. As a result, the parties’ arguments on solvency do not take the matter very far.