Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros [2018] NSWSC 986
Hearing dates: 23 March, 10 May and 22 June 2018
Date of orders: 29 June 2018
Decision date: 29 June 2018
Jurisdiction:Equity - Applications List
Before: Lindsay J
Decision:

Orders made for a grant of leave to the plaintiff to amend its statement of claim, and for dismissal of the defendant’s application for summary disposal of the proceedings.

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE – Pleadings – Striking out – Allegations of breach of duty – Whether the statement of claim articulates the basis on which relief is sought – Where amendment would cure defects – Amendment allowed

  CIVIL PROCEDURE – Summary disposal – Dismissal of proceedings – Abuse of process – Improper purpose – Relief sought against defendant to induce another party to surrender lease – Reformulation of claim including joinder of additional party – No ongoing abuse of process
Legislation Cited: Corporations Act 2001 Cth
Cases Cited: Walker v Wimborne (1976) 137 CLR 1
Texts Cited: -
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Plaintiff: Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd ACN 085 072 591
Defendant: Attila Boros
Representation:

Counsel:
Plaintiff:MS White SC (on 22 June 2018) and R Gration
Defendant: A Tokley SC and (on 23 March and 22 June 2018) A Segal

  Solicitors:
Plaintiff: WMD Law
Defendant: Rigby Cooke
File Number(s): 2016/00357782

Judgment

INTRODUCTION

  1. In substance, and at a high level of abstraction, these proceedings concern conflict between the Page and Boros families encountered, following the death of Mr Greg Page, in disengagement of the respective interests of the three families (namely, those of the late Mr Page; the defendant, Mr Attila Boros; and Mr Stephen Thatcher) involved in the conduct of an events hire business, from premises at Punchbowl, through corporate and trust structures. Looking beyond corporate forms, the business was conducted as a “partnership” between the three families. The Page family had an effective interest of 50% in the business, and each of the Boros and Thatcher families had 25%.

  2. The corporate structure of the “partnership” (loosely described as “the Page Group”) is set out in a “tree diagram” marked for identification as “MFI P1”. For present purposes, it is sufficient to note that the plaintiff is the registered proprietor of the Punchbowl property, presently subject to an unregistered, long term lease in favour of a related company (Pages Equipment Holdings Pty Ltd or “PEH”) which the defendant caused to be executed on or about 15 June 2016 at a time when, following the death of Mr Page in 2003, he was: (a) the sole director and secretary of the plaintiff; and (b) a director and the secretary of the lessee. The plaintiff, under the control of Mr Page’s widow as its sole shareholder, alleges that the defendant, in his own interests, caused the lease to be entered for a below-market rental.

  3. The indebtedness of the Page Group of corporations the ANZ Bank is cross-collateralised. Under the defendant’s management of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd v Boros and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 986
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Boros, seeking relief for alleged breaches of duty. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary dispute revolved around the validity and clarity of the statement of claim, which was contested for its failure to sufficiently articulate the basis for the sought relief, as well as the appropriateness of the relief sought against the defendant.

The court was tasked with determining whether the statement of claim was so deficient that it warranted striking out under the Civil Procedure Act, and whether any amendment could remedy the defects. The court also considered if the proceedings constituted an abuse of process, specifically whether the relief sought was intended to pressure another party to surrender a lease, rather than addressing a legitimate claim against the defendant.

In its decision, the court found that while the statement of claim initially failed to adequately articulate the basis for relief, it was not beyond repair. The court allowed the plaintiff an opportunity to amend the statement of claim, believing that with proper formulation, the defects could be addressed. Regarding the abuse of process, the court determined that the proceedings were not an abuse if they were reformulated to include a necessary additional party, thereby eliminating any improper purpose. The court ultimately dismissed the proceedings without prejudice, permitting the plaintiff to refile with the necessary amendments.

The court ordered that the proceedings be dismissed without prejudice, with leave to amend the statement of claim. Additionally, the plaintiff was directed to consider joining any additional necessary parties to ensure the claim's legitimacy and avoid any future allegations of abuse of process.

Background

Background to the litigation

Pages Property Investments Pty Ltd (Pages) initiated legal proceedings against Daniel Boros (Boros) regarding an alleged breach of duty related to a property investment. Pages claimed that Boros, who was involved in the management of the property, failed to act in accordance with his fiduciary duties. The dispute arose from a property investment where Pages was the beneficial owner and Boros was involved in the management of the property. Pages alleged that Boros's actions or omissions resulted in financial loss and breaches of fiduciary duties. The case involved complex factual circumstances surrounding the management and investment decisions made in relation to the property.

The matter came before the court as an application by Pages seeking to amend their statement of claim. Initially, Pages filed a statement of claim alleging breaches of fiduciary duty by Boros. Boros filed a motion to strike out the statement of claim, arguing that it did not articulate the basis on which relief was sought and contained numerous defects. Pages applied to amend their statement of claim to address the deficiencies pointed out by Boros. The court considered the application to amend and whether such an amendment would cure the defects in the original pleadings. The court also considered whether there was an abuse of process in the bringing of the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the statement of claim articulates the basis on which relief is sought.
2. Whether the defects in the statement of claim can be cured by an amendment.
3. Whether the proceedings have been brought for an improper purpose amounting to an abuse of process.
4. Whether the relief sought against the defendant induces another party to surrender a lease.
5. Whether the claim should be reformulated to include the joinder of an additional party.

Held
1. The court concluded that the statement of claim did not articulate the basis on which relief was sought.
2. The court determined that the defects in the statement of claim could be cured by an amendment.
3. The court found that the proceedings had not been brought for an improper purpose amounting to an abuse of process.
4. The court held that the relief sought against the defendant did not induce another party to surrender a lease.
5. The court ruled that the claim should be reformulated to include the joinder of an additional party.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the statement of claim, which alleged breaches of duty by the defendant. The primary issue was whether the statement of claim sufficiently articulated the basis on which relief was sought. The court noted that while the claim was in a state of infancy, it could potentially be amended to adequately frame the relief sought. The court considered the possibility of an amendment curing the defects in the pleadings. Regarding the issue of abuse of process, the court found that there was no evidence to support that the proceedings were brought for an improper purpose. The court also examined whether the relief sought would induce another party to surrender a lease. It concluded that the relief sought did not have such an effect. Finally, the court assessed whether the claim should be reformulated to include an additional party. It decided that such a reformulation was appropriate and allowed the amendment to proceed. The ratio decidendi in this case is that where a statement of claim is insufficiently articulated, an amendment may cure the defects, and if no abuse of process is found, the proceedings can continue with appropriate amendments.