Pacific Steel Constructions Pty Ltd v Barahona

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: Pacific Steel Constructions Pty Limited v Barahona; Jigsaw Property Group Pty Limited v Barahona [2009] NSWCA 406
HEARING DATE(S): 31 July 2009
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

11 December 2009
JUDGMENT OF: Allsop P at 1; Beazley JA at 1; Giles JA at 1
DECISION: On Jigsaw’s appeal (CA 40440/08):
1. Appeal allowed.
2. Set aside the verdict and the judgment for the plaintiff against the first defendant; and in lieu thereof order that there be verdict and judgment for the first defendant against the plaintiff.
3. Set aside the verdicts and judgments for the cross-claimant/first defendant on the first cross-claim against the first cross-defendant/second defendant and the verdict and judgment for the cross-claimant/second defendant on the second cross-claim against the second cross-defendant/first defendant and the orders that the second defendant indemnify the first defendant and the first defendant indemnify the second defendant each with respect to its liability to the plaintiff; and in lieu thereof order that each of the cross-claims as between the first and second defendants be dismissed.
4. Set aside the order that the first defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs on an ordinary basis until 14 December 2007 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.
5. Set aside the order that the first defendant indemnify the plaintiff in respect of the third defendant’s costs and the order that the first defendant pay the third defendant’s costs of the cross-claim on an ordinary basis up to 6 February 2008 and on an indemnity basis thereafter.
6. Order that the plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs of the trial and that the first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal save in respect of contribution between the appellant and the second respondent.
7. Grant the first respondent a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise qualified.
On Pacific’s appeal (CA 40398/08):
1. Appeal dismissed.
2. Appellant pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.
On Mr Barahona’s cross-appeal (CA 40440/08)
1. Cross-appeal dismissed with costs.
Generally:
1. Reserve liberty for the parties to apply for variations in the orders within ten days.
CATCHWORDS: TORTS – negligence – duty of care – workplace injury –duty of principal to independent contractor – duty arising from need for direction and coordination of activities – whether duty to control system of work of independent contractor – role of foreman – safe work method statements – no assumption of responsibility to supervise – no knowledge of dangerous use of equipment – no duty owed to control system of work - TORTS – negligence – breach of duty - workplace injury – non-delegable duty of employer owed to employee – failure to provide safe system of work - TORTS – negligence – contribution between defendants – apportionment of liability - misdirection in exercise of discretion – failure to give sufficient weight to non-delegable duty of employer to employee - TORTS – negligence – contributory negligence – experienced tradesperson – responsibility of employer to prepare safe work method statement –…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pacific Steel Constructions Pty Ltd v Barahona and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWCA 406
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Pacific Steel Constructions Pty Ltd v Barahona* involved appeals and a cross-appeal heard by the Court of Appeal of New South Wales. The dispute concerned a workplace injury sustained by Mr Barahona, an independent contractor, while working on a construction site. Pacific Steel Constructions Pty Ltd was the principal contractor, and Jigsaw was another entity involved in the project. Mr Barahona had sued Pacific Steel for negligence, and there were also cross-claims between Pacific Steel and Jigsaw regarding contribution and indemnity.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether Pacific Steel owed a duty of care to Mr Barahona as an independent contractor, and if so, whether that duty had been breached. Specifically, the court considered whether Pacific Steel had a duty to control the system of work of an independent contractor, particularly in the context of a foreman's role and the use of safe work method statements. The court also had to determine issues relating to contribution between the defendants, contributory negligence by Mr Barahona, and the availability of damages for gratuitous attendant care services under the *Civil Liability Act 2002* (NSW).

The Court of Appeal found that Pacific Steel did not owe a duty to control the system of work of Mr Barahona, an experienced independent contractor. The court reasoned that there was no assumption of responsibility by Pacific Steel for the supervision of Mr Barahona's work methods, nor was there knowledge of any dangerous use of equipment that would give rise to such a duty. Consequently, Pacific Steel was not liable in negligence to Mr Barahona. The court also addressed the cross-claims between Pacific Steel and Jigsaw, finding no error in the initial assessment of contributory negligence by Mr Barahona. Regarding damages, the court determined that the amended provisions of the *Civil Liability Act 2002* (NSW) applied, and Mr Barahona had not satisfied the requirements to be awarded damages for gratuitous attendant care services.

On appeal, the Court of Appeal allowed Jigsaw's appeal, setting aside the judgment against it and ordering that the cross-claims between Pacific Steel and Jigsaw be dismissed. Pacific Steel's appeal was dismissed, and Mr Barahona's cross-appeal was also dismissed. The orders regarding costs were varied, with Mr Barahona ordered to pay Pacific Steel's costs of the trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

On Jigsaw’s appeal (CA 40440/08):

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the verdict and the judgment for the plaintiff against the first defendant; and in lieu thereof order that there be verdict and judgment for the first defendant against the plaintiff.

3. Set aside the verdicts and judgments for the cross-claimant/first defendant on the first cross-claim against the first cross-defendant/second defendant and the verdict and judgment for the cross-claimant/second defendant on the second cross-claim against the second cross-defendant/first defendant and the orders that the second defendant indemnify the first defendant and the first defendant indemnify the second defendant each with respect to its liability to the plaintiff; and in lieu thereof order that each of the cross-claims as between the first and second defendants be dismissed.

4. Set aside the order that the first defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs on an ordinary basis until 14 December 2007 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

5. Set aside the order that the first defendant indemnify the plaintiff in respect of the third defendant’s costs and the order that the first defendant pay the third defendant’s costs of the cross-claim on an ordinary basis up to 6 February 2008 and on an indemnity basis thereafter.

6. Order that the plaintiff pay the first defendant’s costs of the trial and that the first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal save in respect of contribution between the appellant and the second respondent.

7. Grant the first respondent a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act if otherwise qualified.

On Pacific’s appeal (CA 40398/08):

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. Appellant pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

On Mr Barahona’s cross-appeal (CA 40440/08)

1. Cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

Generally:

1. Reserve liberty for the parties to apply for variations in the orders within ten days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.