Elphick v Westfield Shopping Centre Management Company Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Elphick v Westfield Shopping Centre Management Company Pty Limited [2011] NSWCA 356
Hearing dates:14 September 2011
Decision date: 25 November 2011
Before: Young JA at [1]
Whealy JA at [12]
Sackville AJA at [117]
Decision:

ON THE APPEAL

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the first respondent's costs of the appeal

3. The second respondent pay to the first respondent the difference between the first respondent's costs of the appeal assessed on an indemnity basis and the costs, to the extent that they are recoverable, payable by the appellant pursuant to Order 2.

ON THE FIRST CROSS-APPEAL

4. Save for Order 3 above, the first cross-appeal dismissed.

5. The respondent to the first cross-appeal pay the cross-appellant's costs of the first cross-appeal.

ON THE SECOND CROSS-APPEAL

6. The second cross appeal is dismissed.

7. The cross-appellant pay the costs of the respondent to the second cross-appeal of the second cross-appeal.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Catchwords:

APPEAL - shopping centre accident - injured employee of cleaning contractor - liability of occupier - liability of independent contractor - contractual relationship between occupier and independent contractor - indemnity in cleaning agreement - right to indemnity for costs of defending action

PRACTICE - (per Young JA)- there is no right for the one party to be represented by two sets of lawyers just because part of its interest is insured unless the leave of the Court is obtained.
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002 ss 5B, 5C
Civil Procedure Act 2005 s 56(1)
Evidence Act 1995 s 42
Occupational Health and Safety Act 2000 s 32
Occupational Health and Safety Regulation 2001 rr 34, 38
Cases Cited: Australian Safeways Stores Pty Limited v Zaluzna (1987) 162 CLR 479
Carter v Marine Helicopters Ltd (1995) 9 Anz Ins Cas 61-299 at 76-347 (New Zealand High Court)
Hardie & Lame Ltd v Chilton [1928]1 KB 663
Herbert v Badgery (1893) 14 LR (NSW) Eq 321
Jones v Dunkel [1959] 101 CLR 298
Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Fox [2009] HCA 35; (2009) 240 CLR 1
Lewis v Daily Telegraph Ltd (No 2) [ 1964] 2 QB 601
Pacific Steel Constructions Pty Ltd v Barahona; Jigsaw Property Group Pty Ltd v Barahona [2009] NSWCA 406
Re Bubnich [1965] WAR 138
Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd [1986] HCA 1; 160 CLR 16
Sydney Airport Corporation Pty Ltd v Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 1106; 14 Anz Ins Cas 61-718
Sydney Water Corp v Abramovic [2007] NSWCA 248
Tindle v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations)…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elphick v Westfield Shopping Centre Management Company Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWCA 356
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Elphick v Westfield Shopping Centre Management Company Pty Ltd* involved an appeal to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales concerning an accident where an employee of a cleaning contractor, Mr Elphick, was injured at a Westfield shopping centre. The dispute centred on the liability of Westfield as the occupier and the independent contractor, ACS, for the injuries sustained. A key element of the case was the contractual relationship between Westfield and ACS, specifically an indemnity clause within their cleaning agreement that addressed the liability for the costs of defending such actions.

The legal issues before the court included determining the extent of Westfield's liability as an occupier for the injuries sustained by Mr Elphick, an employee of its independent contractor. The court also had to consider the liability of the independent contractor, ACS, and the enforceability and scope of the indemnity provision within the cleaning agreement. Furthermore, the court was required to assess whether certain evidence, particularly concerning prior complaints made by other employees, was admissible and relevant to establishing Westfield's knowledge of the risk that caused the accident.

The court's reasoning, particularly in relation to the evidence of prior complaints, drew upon principles established in cases like *Brodribb*. It was held that even if prior complaints were made, they did not necessarily establish Westfield's liability if they related to a different problem than the one that caused the accident, or if the independent contractor, ACS, was aware of the issue and responsible for devising and supervising its own system of work. The court found that the contractual arrangement between Westfield and ACS placed the primary obligation on ACS to address such risks. The court also noted that there was no evidence that complaints made to maintenance staff were passed on to Westfield's senior management.

The appeal was dismissed, with the appellant, Mr Elphick, ordered to pay the first respondent's costs of the appeal. The second respondent was ordered to pay the difference between the first respondent's costs of the appeal on an indemnity basis and the costs recoverable from the appellant. The cross-appeals were also largely dismissed, with costs orders made accordingly.

Orders

Orders of the court

ON THE APPEAL

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the first respondent's costs of the appeal

3. The second respondent pay to the first respondent the difference between the first respondent's costs of the appeal assessed on an indemnity basis and the costs, to the extent that they are recoverable, payable by the appellant pursuant to Order 2.

ON THE FIRST CROSS-APPEAL

4. Save for Order 3 above, the first cross-appeal dismissed.

5. The respondent to the first cross-appeal pay the cross-appellant's costs of the first cross-appeal.

ON THE SECOND CROSS-APPEAL

6. The second cross appeal is dismissed.

7. The cross-appellant pay the costs of the respondent to the second cross-appeal of the second cross-appeal.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Parker did not take any objection to the cross-examination conducted by Mr Catsanos, even though on this issue (whether Westfield had been warned) Mr Elphick and ACS clearly had a substantial common interest. Had objection been taken, this "friendly" cross-examination may have been curtailed, at least to the extent of prohibiting leading questions (section 42 of the Evidence Act 1995 ). Although complaints made by other ACS employees to Westfield did not form part of the pleaded case, Mr Parker did not object to the content of the cross-examination on the ground of relevance. In final submissions at trial, Mr Gross suggested to the primary judge (albeit briefly) that Mr Chrul's evidence supported a finding of breach of duty of care by Westfield (Black, 260, 266). Mr Parker responded in his oral submissions (Black, 303) that Mr Chrul's evidence should not be accepted or relied upon. He submitted that no prior allegation of this kind had been made by Mr Chrul in the statements he had provided to Mr Elphick's experts. He pointed out that the topic had not been opened by Mr Gross and that it was not led in chief by Mr Gross. It simply emerged "in the course of an extremely friendly cross-examination by Mr Catsanos". Mr Parker submitted that the very way in which the evidence had emerged would give the court pause before accepting either its credibility or reliability. The witness, he said, had been "notably vague on being able to remember anything". By contrast, he had been able to suddenly "remember back five years to these discussions, something he had apparently never told anyone else about until that point". More significantly, Mr Parker correctly identified that the complaint made by Mr Chrul, whether it was reliable or not, did not amount to a complaint about the lateral movement of the cage. Ultimately, he asked the primary judge to find that no complaint had been made, even to the Westfield maintenance employees. The primary judge referred to Mr Chrul's evidence, but made no finding either way. This may have been because his Honour perhaps accepted (sub silentio) that no case based on Mr Chrul's evidence had ever been pleaded, particularised or referred to in the plaintiff's opening. Leaving to one side the problems with the uncertain origins of Mr Chrul's evidence, there is nevertheless the difficulty for the appellant that his complaint related to the vertical movement of the cage - "rocking and rolling". He did not make any complaint to the maintenance employees about lateral movement of the cage, which was the cause of the accident. Mr Chrul agreed that this was "a completely different problem" from lateral movement (Black, 175). In my view, Chrul's evidence, even if accepted, does not take this case out of the Brodribb category described by Brennan J at [48]. First, the complaint made by Mr Chrul to the two maintenance men related to a different problem (vertical movement) than the one that caused the accident (lateral movement). Secondly, ACS, whose responsibility it was to devise and supervise its own system of work, was perfectly aware of complaints made about both aspects of the refuse removal problem. Yet it did nothing about either of them. Thirdly, there is no evidence to indicate that the maintenance men passed on the complaint to Westfield's EH&S officers or to the Centre Manager. (Although Ms De Haas and Mr Knott were not called by Westfield, Jones v Dunkel [1959] 101 CLR 298 should be given a limited application in a case where the evidence emerged in the manner it did here). Fourthly, even if there had been evidence that the message had been "passed up" the chain to senior management at Westfield (and there was not), the contractual arrangement between the parties would have entitled Westfield to require ACS to do something about the problem. It had no immediate obligation to act in its own right to address the risk the subject of the complaints, even if it had been made aware of them, whereas ACS had every obligation to do so.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established