Our Town FM Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

1

)

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT

REGISTRY

)

No. 311 of 1987

1

GENERAL DIVISION

)

BETWEEN:

JENS

INGO

SCHLIESKE

Applicant

AND :

THE

MINISTER

FOR

IMMIGRATION AND ETHNIC

AFFAIRS

First Respondent

JOHN REGINALD TUCHIN

Second Respondent

ROSS WILLIAM ROBILLIARD

Third Respondent

Coram:

GUMMOW J.

Place: Sydney

Date:

14 July 1907

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT (EXTEMPORE)

These proceedings were

commenced by an application

filed on 9 July 1987. On 10 July 1987, after an initial hearing of an application for interlocutory relief in respect

of

that application, directions

were given with

a vlew to

having the matter ready for hearing on an

:

2 .

today. Pursuant to those directions the applicant has filed an amended application for review under the provisions of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977, which I shall call the ADJR Act.

The applicant relies upon two affldavits sworn by his solicitor, Mr O'Brien on 9 and 13 July 1987. There is no evidence from the applicant himself. The respondents to the amended application rely upon the affidavit of the third respondent, Mr Robilliard, sworn today.

The

present

applicatlon

arlses

out of what the

applicant apprehends is

the imminent carrying into effect of a

deportation order made

in respect of the applicant on 3 October

1986 under s.18 of the Migration Act 1958, whlch I shall call the Migration Act. The deportation order recited that the applicant was deemed to be a prohibited non-citizen by virtue of s.16(1) of the Migration Act, in that the applicant was not

at the time of his entry into Australia on 29 June 1986 an Australian citizen and in that at the time of that entry he produced to an officer of the Department in respect of his

entry Into Australia a

p ssport that was not issued to hlm; in

addition, the applicant was

not the holder of an entry permit

of a kind referred to in that section of the Migration Act.

3.

The making of the deportation order on 3 October 1986 was preceded by a submission to the decision maker dated 2 October. The submission was a document of some 23 paragraphs supported by detailed annexures.

It appears

that the applicant flrst entered Australia

on 26 June 1985 at Sydney and for the purpose of securing entry into this country he produced an Italian passport issued under

another name and

endorsed with an Australian visa.

He was

granted a temporary entry permit

valld until 2 4 August 1985; he

was subsequently granted two further temporary entry permits. The second of these was for a perlod to expire on 26 December

1985. The applicant departed Australla under the name of the person identified in the Itallan passport. He

did so on 25

December 1985.

The applicant returned to Australia on 29 June 1986 and it is the circumstances of this entry into Australia whlch are recited in the terms of the deportation order that I have described. On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Our Town FM Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (No 3... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1987] FCA 393
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Our Town FM Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (No 3), the Federal Court of Australia was presented with an application for review by Jens Ingo Schlieske against the Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs, John Reginald Tuchin, and Ross William Robilliard. The applicant, Schlieske, sought to challenge a deportation order made against him under the Migration Act 1958 and the subsequent direction for his detention pending deportation. The primary legal issues involved the procedural fairness of the decision-making process, the validity of the deportation order, and the applicability of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 to the execution of the deportation order.

The court addressed several grounds for review, including whether the decision-maker provided adequate procedural fairness, whether the decision-maker considered the applicant's willingness to leave voluntarily, and whether the delay in executing the deportation order rendered it invalid. The court found that the decision-maker had provided sufficient procedural fairness, the question of voluntary departure was considered, and any delay in executing the order did not affect its validity. Furthermore, the court concluded that the provisions of the Migration Act did not confer a power to dictate the destination of deportation and that the direction for detention did not require procedural fairness. The court ultimately dismissed the application, finding no serious questions to be tried.

The court's decision was based on the principles established in previous cases, which held that the Migration Act does not provide for the suspension of deportation orders and that the validity of such orders is not affected by delays in execution. The court also noted that the officers of the Department had acted to avoid using the Migration Act to facilitate extradition proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Jens Ingo Schlieske, is a non-citizen who entered Australia on 29 June 1986 using a Swiss passport issued under another name and endorsed with an Australian visa. He was granted a temporary entry permit but was subsequently deemed a prohibited non-citizen under the Migration Act 1958 due to his use of a non-issued passport. On 3 October 1986, a deportation order was made against him, and on 9 July 1987, a direction was issued to keep him in custody pending deportation. The applicant filed an application for interlocutory relief to stay the deportation order and seek his release from custody, leading to the current proceedings.

The case came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for interlocutory relief filed on 9 July 1987. On 10 July 1987, an initial hearing was held regarding the application, and directions were given to prepare the matter for a final hearing. The applicant filed an amended application for review under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977. The matter was heard extempore by Gummow J on 14 July 1987.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the making of the deportation order on 3 October 1986 was procedurally unfair.
2. Whether the delay in executing the deportation order affects its validity.
3. Whether the Migration Act provisions allow for deportation to a destination unacceptable to the deportee.
4. Whether procedural fairness was required for the direction issued on 9 July 1987.

Held
1. The making of the deportation order on 3 October 1986 was procedurally fair; the application challenging this was dismissed.
2. The delay in executing the deportation order does not affect its validity; the application challenging this was dismissed.
3. The Migration Act provisions do not allow for deportation to a destination unacceptable to the deportee; however, this did not lead to the application's success.
4. Procedural fairness was not required for the direction issued on 9 July 1987; the application challenging this was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the application for judicial review of a deportation order made under the Migration Act. The applicant, Jens Ingo Schlieske, contested the validity and execution of the deportation order made on 3 October 1986 and a subsequent direction issued on 9 July 1987. The court found that the applicant had sufficient opportunities to make representations and that procedural fairness was observed as per the principles established in Kioa v The Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs. The decision-maker had considered the applicant's willingness to leave voluntarily, which was part of the submissions provided by the applicant. The court also noted that the delay in executing the deportation order, while concerning, did not invalidate the order as per the provisions of the Migration Act. The act does not confer a power to deport to a destination unacceptable to the deportee, but this did not affect the court's decision since there was no evidence of any such decision being made. Finally, the court held that procedural fairness was not required for the direction issued on 9 July 1987, as the power under s.39 was exercised strictly within the scope of the Migration Act. The application was dismissed as no serious questions were presented to be tried.