Osborne v Drive Park Pty Ltd (Trading as Austral Meat)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

OSBORNE v DRIVE PARK PTY LTD (TRADING AS AUSTRAL MEAT)

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

27 August 2004

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS

PROCEDURE - INFERIOR COURTS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - MAGISTRATES COURT

Appeal from decision of a Magistrate - Appellant filled in respondent's standard "Credit Application" form - Application included provision for the appellant to provide a directors' guarantee - Form sent to appellant by facsimile - Some of the conditions were obscured in the facsimile process - Appellant returned the form also by facsimile - Appellant filled out most of the form but left blank the space for the company's name in relation to the directors' guarantee - Still clear which company was the subject of the guarantee - Guarantee enforceable - No unconscionable conduct on part of respondent - No misleading and deceptive conduct on part of respondent - Appellant was not under a special disability - Defence of non est factum not available - Magistrate did not err in rejecting appellant's evidence - Respondent not in breach of pleadings rules as defence to counterclaim not required - Appeal dismissed.

Magistrates Court Act 1991, s 40; Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 51AC, referred to.
York Air-conditioning and Refrigeration (A/Asia) Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth (1949) 80 CLR 11; Upper Hunter County District Council v Australian Chilling and Freezing Company Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 429; Kelly v Locklin (1912) 8 DLR 1039; Devries v Australian National Railway Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472; Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118, applied.
Garcia v National Australia Bank (1998) 194 CLR 395; Blomley v Ryan (1956) 99 CLR 362; CBA v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 447, distinguished.
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v 4WD Systems Pty Ltd (2003) 200 ALR 491; Ankar v National Westminster Finance (Australia) Limited (1987) 162 CLR 549; Spunwill Pty Ltd v Bab Pty Ltd (1994) 36 NSWLR 290; NSW Cancer Council v Sarfaty (1992) 28 NSWLR 68, considered.

OSBORNE v DRIVE PARK PTY LTD (TRADING AS AUSTRAL MEAT)
[2004] SASC 261

Civil

WHITE J:    

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal, brought pursuant to s 40 of the Magistrates Court Act 1991, from a decision of Ms Eldridge SM delivered on 25 February 2004 in the civil jurisdiction of the Magistrates Court.

  2. By that decision, the Magistrate found that the appellant (the defendant in the proceedings at first instance) was liable to the respondent (then the plaintiff) under the terms of a guarantee dated 27 September 2000.  Judgment was entered against the appellant in the sum of $15,458.11 in addition to costs.

    The Parties

  3. The respondent is (and was in September 2000) a supplier of meat:  it buys livestock, kills it, and after processing the meat, sells it to a large number of food service and retail outlets.  It has been in this business since 1986 and trades under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Osborne v Drive Park Pty Ltd (Trading as Austral Meat) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 261
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Osborne v Drive Park Pty Ltd (Trading as Austral Meat) originated from a decision made by a Magistrate in the Magistrates Court of South Australia. The appellant, who was employed by and the sole shareholder of Hahndorf Smallgoods, sought to appeal against a decision that found him liable for the company's outstanding debt to the respondent. The appellant argued that the credit application form he completed and returned to the respondent was unclear and incomplete, and that the terms of the directors' guarantee were vague or uncertain. The respondent, however, maintained that the guarantee was enforceable and that the appellant was liable for the debt.

The legal issues the court had to decide centred on the validity and enforceability of the directors' guarantee signed by the appellant. The court needed to determine whether the form, despite being partially obscured in the facsimile process, was sufficiently clear to be enforceable. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the appellant's evidence that he could not read the form at the time of signing was credible and whether there was any unconscionable or misleading conduct by the respondent. The court also needed to address whether the appellant was under any special disability that would invalidate the guarantee and whether the defence of non est factum was applicable.

The court's reasoning was that the Magistrate's findings were well-supported and should not be interfered with on appeal. The court found that the appellant was experienced in business dealings and understood the nature and effect of a guarantee at the time of signing. The court rejected the appellant's claim that the form was too unclear or incomplete to be enforceable and found that the respondent was not in breach of the pleadings rules. The court held that the appellant's evidence was not credible and that there was no special disability or unconscionable conduct on the part of the respondent. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the original decision of the Magistrate was upheld.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal was dismissed, and the original decision of the Magistrate was upheld. The appellant remained liable for the outstanding debt of Hahndorf Smallgoods to the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant was employed by Hahndorf Smallgoods. He was also its sole shareholder. His former wife, from whom he divorced in May 2001 (ie, after the events giving rise to the respondent’s claim), was its sole director. The appellant described his role as being that of a smallgoods maker together with buying in the raw products. His former wife attended to the administration of the company.Background Circumstances On 27 September 2000, Hahndorf Smallgoods had an order which it had to fill urgently. The appellant telephoned the respondent. He spoke to the respondent’s sales manager, Mr Nottage, and said he wished to place an order for the required meat. There was a dispute at trial about what then happened. The Magistrate found that the appellant spoke to Mr Nottage and later to Mr Potter, a director of the respondent. The respondent’s standard application form for a credit account, which included provision for a director’s guarantee, was faxed to Hahndorf Smallgoods at 9.45 am on 27 September 2000. In these reasons, for convenience, I will refer to this document as “the Credit Application”. The Magistrate found that the Credit Application was filled out, albeit incompletely, signed by the appellant, and returned by facsimile to the respondent on the same day at 10.41 am. In its original form, the Credit Application comprised two pages. The first page contained the application for credit, requiring details of the applicant, and in the case of a company, requiring details of the directors. The first page also contained provision, in the case of a company applicant, for the personal guarantee by the directors of the company’s debts. The second page, which was on the reverse side of the first, contained the respondent’s terms of trade, and provision for signature certifying the correctness of the details provided. The Credit Application, as printed out by the respondent’s facsimile machine when returned by the appellant, was Exhibit P2 at the trial. Exhibit P2 had been printed out on 27 September 2000 as one continuous sheet on thermal paper. There was, apparently, no accompanying facsimile cover page. In the form in which Exhibit P2 had been received at the respondent’s office at 10.41 am on 27 September 2000, a portion of the first page had been overlayed (apparently as a result of a mishap in the transmission) on a portion of the second page, thereby obscuring about one-third of the printed terms of trade. The appellant’s evidence was that the document had also been in that form when received, completed and signed by him. The Magistrate made no specific finding about the overlaying, as I have called it, of the two pages, nor as to when it occurred, nor as to its significance, if any. The Magistrate did say however, that she did not accept the evidence of the appellant relating to the circumstances of signing the Credit Application form and director’s guarantee. The Magistrate rejected evidence of the appellant that at the time he completed and signed the Credit Application, he had not been able to read the document. Her Honour did not accept that the fact that certain of the spaces in Exhibit P2 had been left blank meant that the terms of the guarantee were vague or uncertain so as to make the contract unenforceable. The Magistrate found that the appellant was a person who was experienced in business dealings and found, contrary to the appellant’s assertions in evidence, that he did understand the nature and effect of a guarantee at the time that he signed the document.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I agree with the appellant that the issues said to arise from the overlay of portions of the two pages were not dealt with in the Magistrate’s reasons. However, for the reasons given above, I do not consider that the grounds of appeal, which rest on incompleteness or uncertainty, are made out.The Evidence Of The Conversation Between Mr Potter And The Appellant Next, the appellant submitted that the Magistrate erred in permitting the respondent to lead evidence from Mr Potter as to the conversation he had with the appellant on the morning of 27 September 2000. The evidence of that conversation should not have been permitted, so the appellant submitted, because the material said to arise from that conversation had not been pleaded. Mr Potter gave evidence-in-chief to the effect that after Mr Nottage told him, on the morning of 27 September 2000, of the appellant’s interest in purchasing meat, he (Mr Potter) then spoke to the appellant. He told the appellant that Hahndorf Smallgoods would first need to complete a Credit Application, that a director’s guarantee was required, and that the terms would be “seven days”. This evidence was led without objection. However, immediately before commencing his cross-examination of Mr Potter, Mr Viscariello submitted that the Magistrate should not pay any regard to that evidence because it had not been pleaded by the respondent. In this Court, Mr Viscariello identified two matters which, he submitted, should have been pleaded by the respondent and were not. First, he submitted that it should have been pleaded that it was Mr Potter who had the relevant conversation with the appellant on 27 September 2000. Secondly, Mr Viscariello submitted that the respondent should have pleaded that Mr Potter told the appellant that the Credit Application included a requirement for a director’s guarantee and also Mr Potter’s explanation of the terms of trade, ie, “seven days”. After hearing Mr Viscariello, the Magistrate indicated that she proposed, at that stage, “to leave the evidence in”. She indicated that if necessary she would make a ruling later. By that, I take it that the Magistrate indicated a willingness to hear further submissions later if Mr Viscariello wished but that in the meantime the trial was to proceed on the basis that the evidence had been received. It is unclear whether any further submissions were made to the Magistrate on this topic. In any event, in her reasons for decision, the Magistrate rejected the appellant’s submission that she should disregard Mr Potter’s evidence. Her Honour referred to the practice of requiring and permitting “short form” pleadings only in the Magistrates Court and to the absence of any request by the appellant for further and better particulars of the respondent’s claim. It would be unusual, in my opinion, for a court to rule that it would not have regard to evidence received without objection, which evidence was otherwise relevant to an issue in the case before it, because the material facts said to arise from that evidence had not been pleaded. In the circumstances of this case, the Magistrate was justified, in my opinion, in having regard to this evidence of Mr Potter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Those findings were open to the Magistrate. To a significant extent they depended, no doubt, on the Magistrate’s assessment of the appellant’s reliability and credibility. There is no basis for interference with those findings on appeal. Those findings are fatal to a reliance on the defence of non est factum in this case.Conclusion In my opinion, none of the grounds of appeal are made out. The appeal should be dismissed. The order of the Court is that the appeal is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established