Ommundson and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

Ommundson and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2017] AATA 1422 (4 September 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2015/6296

Re:Frederick Ommundson

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Linda Kirk
Dr W Isles, Member

Date:4 September 2017

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

...............[sgd].........................................................

Senior Member Linda Kirk

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – postal worker – knee injury – whether Applicant suffered an injury (other than a disease) or an aggravation of a disease – whether injury or aggravation of disease resulted in incapacity for work or impairment – whether aggravation of disease is not an injury by reason of s 7(7) of SRC Act – Tribunal not satisfied that Applicant suffered an injury or an aggravation of a disease – decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 (Cth) s 29

Safety, Rehabilitation, Compensation and Other Legislation Amendment 2007 (Cth)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 5A, 5B, 7, 14

CASES

Comcare v Mooi [1996] FCA 1587; (1996) 69 FCR 439.

Comcare v Power [2015] FCA 1502; (2015) 238 FCR 187; 149 ALD 286; 68 AAR 228.

Comcare v Canute [2005] FCAFC 262; (2005) 148 FCR 232; 89 ALD 258; 41 AAR 539.

Commonwealth v Beattie [1981] FCA 88; 35 ALR 369.

Freeman and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2016] AATA 741.

Kennedy Cleaning Services Pty Limited v Petkoska [2000] HCA 45; (2000) 200 CLR 286; 174 ALR 626.

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19.

Ogden Industries Pty Limited v Lucas [1967] HCA 30; (1967) 116 CLR 537.

Prain v Comcare [2016] AATA 459.

Treloar v Australian Telecommunications Commission [1990] FCA 511; (1990) 26 FCR 316; 97 ALR 321; 12 AAR 535.

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Commonwealth Employees’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Bill 1988 (Cth) Second Reading Speech, House of Representatives, 27 April 1988.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Linda Kirk
Dr W Isles, Member

4 September 2017

  1. Mr Frederick Ommundson (“the Applicant”) was born on 14 May 1954 and is currently 63 years of age. On 14 July 2008, Mr Ommundson commenced employment at the Australian Postal Corporation (“Australia Post”).

  2. On 26 March 2015, Mr Ommundson commenced work at or around 8:00pm. After collecting the keys and the T2 cards, he proceeded to his truck and commenced a check of the vehicle. During the course of securing the straps on the vehicle, he accidently struck a concrete tyre stopper which led him to fall and land on his left knee and left hip (“the incident”). After reporting the incident to his supervisor and completing the necessary incident reports, Mr Ommundson continued with and completed his shift. From the date of the incident until 4 June 2015 Mr Ommundson continued to work full-time and undertake his regular duties and did not take any days off work. He visited a doctor at his general practice on two occasions during May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ommundson and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1422
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr. Frederick Ommundson against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which affirmed a determination by the Australian Postal Corporation. The dispute centred on whether Mr. Ommundson had suffered an injury, or an aggravation of a disease, that resulted in an incapacity for work or an impairment, within the meaning of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) (SRC Act).

The legal issues before the court were whether the AAT erred in finding that Mr. Ommundson had not suffered an injury, or an aggravation of a disease, as contemplated by the SRC Act. Specifically, the court considered whether the AAT's assessment of the evidence, including medical records and Mr. Ommundson's own testimony regarding past knee injuries and his pre-employment medical declaration, was sufficient to support its conclusion. The court also had to consider the application of section 7(7) of the SRC Act, which deals with the definition of an injury in relation to a disease.

The court's reasoning focused on the AAT's evaluative exercise, which involved considering various factors including medical evidence and the applicant's statements. The AAT found that the medical records indicated a history of knee issues, including osteoarthritis, dating back several years before the incident in question. Crucially, the AAT was not satisfied that Mr. Ommundson had suffered a "disease" as defined by the Act, and therefore did not need to engage with the specific provisions of s 7(7) of the SRC Act. The AAT accepted Mr. Ommundson's explanation for his pre-employment medical declaration, finding it plausible that he did not believe he had a current knee problem at that time, given the injuries were several years prior and not serious. However, this did not alter the ultimate finding regarding the absence of a compensable injury or aggravation of a disease.

The decision under review was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Furthermore, Katzmann J found that such a conclusion had to be reached after an evaluative exercise having regard to relevant factors including those set out in s 5B(3).[37]B. EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMedical evidence[37] [2015] FCA 1502; (2015) 238 FCR 187; 149 ALD 286; 68 AAR 228 at [93]-[94]; 204-205; 304; 246-247.Patient records from Provincial Medical Centre The Respondent tendered patient records from Mr Ommundson’s file held by his general practice, the Provincial Medical Centre. Relevant extracts include the notes written by his treating doctors as follows:·May 2004 – Injury to the right knee with no record of time off work or any follow up treatments or investigation.·1 September 2004 – Injury to the left knee while working for Albion Steel. He did take some time off work but was not sure how long. On this consultation there was a possible positive McMurray’s test (for meniscal tear). At a later examination the test was thought to be negative. The diagnosis was soft tissue injury. Mr Ommundson was cleared to return to work by 9 October 2004.·8 February 2010 – Mr Ommundson was referred to an exercise physiologist, Mr Peter Heuvelmans, for an exercise program to assist with his weight and diabetes. The form completed by Mr Heuvelmans notes “chronic bilateral knee pain”.·29 October 2010 – Mr Ommundson suffered an injury to his right knee at work after falling. He saw Dr Ng on several occasions in November 2010. He did not have time off work and there is no real diagnosis, but Dr Ng did refer to continuing soreness, and on 2 November 2010 he prescribed Panadeine Forte, a strong analgesic. By 16 November 2010 Dr Ng reported he was much better. But four months later on 14 March 2011 he was still complaining of right knee pain. He was seen two days in a row, and it is not clear if there was time off work.·21 Dec 2011 – reference by Dr Bonifacio to osteoarthritis of the foot only.·22 May 2012 – letter from Dr Ng refers to Mr Ommundson using Voltaren tablets and various creams for “osteoarthritis” without stating where these were used.·29 October 2012 – Mr Ommundson was referred to Greater West Physio which he attended on 7 November 2012. The physiotherapist’s note mentions “twisted right knee” and reference is made in a pictogram of the right knee.·29 October 2012 – Mr Ommundson had an x-ray of the right knee which showed mild to moderate joint space narrowing and other changes which the medical experts agree is evidence of mild osteoarthritis.·5 April 2013 – reference by Dr Bonifacio to “bilateral shoulder pain, neck pain and sore knees”.·October 2013 – entry which reads “L Knee, did not see ortho surgeon uses a cream”.·16 November 2013 – Applicant saw Dr Pich about his left knee. Reference made to Mr Ommundson having twisted his knee nine years ago. X-ray of the left knee was performed which showed a prominent joint effusion, no loose bodies and slight joint narrowing. He was given one day off work.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, as the Tribunal is not satisfied that Mr Ommundson suffered a “disease”, it does not need to consider the application of s 7(7) of the SRC Act to determine whether the disease shall not be taken to be an “injury” to him for the purposes of the SRC Act.DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Bodel said that it was unlikely that Mr Ommundson had suffered a significant injury as a consequence of the incident on 26 March 2015. He formed this view after the evidence was put to him about Mr Ommundson not mentioning his symptoms during two medical appointments in May 2015, that he continued working full-time following the incident, and that he did not see a doctor about his left knee symptoms until 4 June 2015.Pre-employment medical declaration and assessment forms On 15 April 2008 Mr Ommundson underwent a pre-employment medical examination for Australia Post. When asked to outline any previous medical problems Mr Ommundson answered “no” next to the question “Do you or have you ever had the following … Knee injury, swelling or pain”. The only finding at that time was “some laxity of the left LCL”, which refers to the Lateral Collateral Ligament. Associate Professor McGill explained that this ligament stabilises the knee and laxity can be caused by prior injury to the ligament or by osteoarthritis which decreases the height of the articular cartilage, bringing the bones of the joint closer together thereby loosening the ligament. The records of the pre-employment medical support the other medical evidence before the Tribunal which indicates that in April 2008 Mr Ommundson’s knees were in reasonable condition, and that his symptoms did not commence until some years later in or around 2012.Evidence of the Applicant – Mr Frederick Ommundson Mr Ommundson provided two statements dated 14 June 2016 and 18 April 2017 and gave evidence at the hearing. In his evidence to the Tribunal, Mr Ommundson described his previous work history and was asked about the practitioners’ notes from Provincial Medical Centre, including the injuries he sustained to his left and right knees in May and September 2004 respectively when he was working at Albion Steel. He said he could not recall if he took time off work when these occurred or what the doctor said about the injuries, but that the injuries resolved quickly and he returned to work on full duties.Pre-employment medical examination In his evidence to the Tribunal, Mr Ommundson was asked about the form he completed and signed when he underwent the pre-employment medical examination for Australia Post in April 2008. He explained his failure to answer “yes” to the “Knee injury, swelling or pain” question by saying that he thought it referred to his current health status, although the question read “Do you or have you ever had the following?”. The Tribunal considers Mr Ommundson’s explanation to be plausible as the injuries in 2004 were four years prior to the medical assessment and were not serious. In addition, his knees seemed to be in good shape at the time as he passed the medical examination, including performing five squats. Also, the GP records show that his knee problems did not start for some years after the medical assessment. Mr Jones for the Respondent emphasised the fact that Mr Ommundson signed his pre-employment health questionnaire stating that the information provided was truthful and acknowledging the penalty if it was otherwise. Mr Ommundson was adamant that he did not believe he had, nor did he intend, to provide false information on the form. The Tribunal accepts that many people do not fully read or even fully understand the process and, like Mr Ommundson, will sign the form as they are keen to co-operate when undergoing such a pre-employment examination.