O'Sullivan and P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

O'Sullivan and P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2019] AATA 2966 (13 August 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2015/0698

Re:Michael O'Sullivan

APPLICANT

AndP&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:               13 August 2019

Date of written reasons:        30 August 2019

Place:Perth

The Tribunal orders that the respondent have leave to inspect the documents produced under summons by the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons and TAMS Group Pty Ltd.

..........[sgd]..............................................................

Deputy President Boyle

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – objection by the Applicant to the Respondent’s inspection of material produced under summons – whether the documents relate to the proceedings such that there is a real possibility that they may assist in the resolution of issues in the proceedings – privacy of medical records – implicit surrender would apply in the case of claim against an employer under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) – error in summons corrected – objection disallowed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – ss 39(1), 40A, 40A(1), 40B, 40B(1), 40B(2)

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth)

CASES

Comcare v Maganga (2008) 101 ALD 68; [2008] FCA 285

O’Sullivan and P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2018] AATA 2899
O’Sullivan and P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2019] AATA 126
Panagiotou and TNT Australia Pty Ltd [2011] AATA 565
ZFCC and Comcare [2018] AATA 1358

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

13 August 2019

THE APPLICATION

  1. The applicant has objected to the respondent being given leave to inspect documents produced under summons issued at the request of the respondent.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The substantive application in these proceedings seeks the review of the respondent’s decision to deny liability for a back injury claimed by the applicant. As was noted by Member Webb in his reasons for decision in a previous interlocutory application in this matter:[1]

    [1] O’Sullivan and P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2019] AATA 126 at [5].

    5.The factual background has been set out in detail in previous decisions of the Tribunal and court judgments, namely:

    (a)

    O’Sullivan and P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2016] AATA 283


    (3 May 2016);

    (b)

    O’Sullivan and P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2016] AATA 865


    (10 October 2016);

    (c)

    O’Sullivan and P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2018] AATA 2899


    (15 August 2018);

    (d)O’Sullivan v P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [1998] DCWA CIV2466 of 1997 (17 September 1998);

    (e)

    O’Sullivan v P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 969


    (9 August 2016);

    (f)

    O’Sullivan v P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 47


    (2 February 2017);

    (g)

    O’Sullivan v Barker J & Ors [2017] HCA P38 of 2017


    (8 November 2017); and

    (h)O’Sullivan v Barker J & Ors [2018] HCA P62 of 2017 (21 March 2018).

  3. I adopt the facts as set out in the above decisions and judgments. It is not necessary to set the facts out in this decision…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Sullivan and P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 2966
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) considered an objection by the applicant, Mr. O’Sullivan, to the respondent, P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd, inspecting documents produced under summons. The substantive matter involved Mr. O’Sullivan’s claim for compensation for a back injury sustained in 1993, with the respondent disputing its status as the employer at the time of the claimed injury in 2014. The applicant’s objection centred on the process by which the summonses were issued and the potential implications for the privacy of medical records.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the documents produced under the summonses related to the proceedings such that there was a real possibility they might assist in resolving the issues in dispute. Additionally, the applicant raised several procedural objections concerning the validity of the summonses, including allegations of errors in their drafting, the absence of consent, and concerns about the respondent’s legal standing to request the summonses. The applicant also argued that the respondent’s inclusion of its contact details on the summonses constituted an improper attempt to influence potential witnesses or evidence.

Deputy President Boyle P found that the documents produced under the summonses were relevant to the matters before the Tribunal, noting that such documents are typically sought in compensation claims where work and medical histories are pertinent. The Tribunal was satisfied that there was a real possibility the documents could assist in resolving the proceedings. The Deputy President also addressed the applicant’s procedural objections, implicitly finding that any errors in the summonses were either corrected or did not invalidate the process to the extent of preventing inspection. The Tribunal considered that the privacy of medical records was a factor, but the relevance of the documents to the claim outweighed this concern in this instance.

The objection to the inspection of the documents was disallowed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant has objected to the respondent being given leave to inspect documents produced under summons issued at the request of the respondent.BACKGROUND The substantive application in these proceedings seeks the review of the respondent’s decision to deny liability for a back injury claimed by the applicant. As was noted by Member Webb in his reasons for decision in a previous interlocutory application in this matter:[1][1] O’Sullivan and P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2019] AATA 126 at [5].5.The factual background has been set out in detail in previous decisions of the Tribunal and court judgments, namely:(a)O’Sullivan and P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2016] AATA 283 (3 May 2016);(b)O’Sullivan and P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2016] AATA 865 (10 October 2016);(c)O’Sullivan and P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2018] AATA 2899 (15 August 2018);(d)O’Sullivan v P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [1998] DCWA CIV2466 of 1997 (17 September 1998);(e)O’Sullivan v P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 969 (9 August 2016);(f)O’Sullivan v P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 47 (2 February 2017);(g)O’Sullivan v Barker J & Ors [2017] HCA P38 of 2017 (8 November 2017); and(h)O’Sullivan v Barker J & Ors [2018] HCA P62 of 2017 (21 March 2018). I adopt the facts as set out in the above decisions and judgments. It is not necessary to set the facts out in this decision other than to note the general nature of the applicant’s claim in these proceedings which was succinctly described by Member Webb as follows:[2]Michael O’Sullivan injured his back in the course of his employment by P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd (the Company) in 1993. He claimed and was paid benefits under the applicable Award. His employment with the Company and benefit payments ceased in 1995. In 2014, Mr O’Sullivan lodged a claim for compensation in respect of a back injury, citing the Company as his employer. The Company rejected the proposition that it was Mr O’Sullivan’s employer and refused the claim. Mr O’Sullivan requested reconsideration of this decision. As no decision was made within the time allowed, the refusal decision is deemed to have been affirmed. Mr O’Sullivan applied to the Tribunal for review.[2] O’Sullivan and P&O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2018] AATA 2899 at [1].The respondent’s request for issue of summonses The relevant facts surrounding the issue of the summonses are accurately set out in the respondent’s submissions dated 1 August 2019 as follows:1. Six Summonses to Produce were lodged with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on 7 June 2019 addressed to:(a)The Royal Australian College of Surgeons;(b)Australian Health Practitioners Regulation Authority (AHPRA), WA Branch;(c)Maersk Shipping (Seaway Agencies Pty Ltd);(d)Sea Corporation Pty Ltd;(e)TAMS Group Pty Ltd; and(f)Atlas Professionals (Offshore Marine) Pty Ltd.2. The Summonses were duly sealed by the Registry and a return date of 12 July 2019 was entered on each by Registry staff. After sealing occurred, the Respondent’s solicitors noted errors in the Summonses to Sea Corporation Pty Ltd, TAMS Group and Atlas Professionals (Offshore Marine). In each case, the categories of documents sought by those Summonses referred to the employment of the Applicant by Maersk which was in error. Consequently, the Respondent’s solicitors lodged Amended Summonses, correcting this typographical error. The Summonses were sealed by Registry staff and returned to the Respondent’s solicitors for service.3. Upon receipt of the amended Summonses, those documents, together with the Summonses directed to the Royal Australian College of Surgeons, AHPRA and Maersk Shipping, were sent to Network Process Service Pty Ltd (NPS) for serving upon each recipient. NPS was instructed to serve each Summons to Produce on their intended recipients, as well as a covering letter prepared by the Respondent’s solicitors. A copy of the bundle of documents sent to NPS on 7 June 2019, comprising a letter of instruction, covering letters to each recipient and sealed Summonses to Produce are attached to these submissions as “Attachment A”.4. Each covering letter:(a)stated that HFW Australia acted on behalf of the Respondent;(b)listed the categories of documents sought by the Summons; and(c)suggested that all documents falling within the nominated categories should be sent to the AAT’s Registry in Western Australia.5. On 20 June 2019, solicitors for the Respondent received telephone calls from employees of Sea Corporation Pty Ltd, TAMS Group Pty Ltd and Seaway Australia Pty Ltd.6. The employee of Seaway Pty Ltd informed Mr Buckhurst of the Respondent’s solicitors that the company did not hold any records relating to the Applicant and that it was a different corporate entity to Maersk. Mr Buckhurst informed her that this should be relayed to the AAT in writing.7. The employee of Sea Corporation Pty Ltd stated that she could not locate any records relating to the Applicant. The employee stated that Sea Corporation had used a crewing/manning agency in the past and that this entity may have records relating to the Applicant.8. Mr Lee Bartlett of TAMS Group stated that he had located documents meeting the categories listed in the Summons to Produce that he had received and wanted to know where they should be sent. Mr Buckhurst asked that he send the documents to the AAT in accordance with the directions given on the Summons.9. On 21 June 2019, the Respondent’s solicitors received a letter from Ms Lorraine Yii of the AHPRA seeking further information before a decision would be made whether or not to object to the Summons. A copy of this letter is attached to these submissions as “Attachment B”. 10. On 21 June 2019, the Respondent’s solicitors received an email from Mr A. Arscott of Atlas Professionals informing he was unable to locate any records relating to the Applicant in Atlas’ systems and that he could not locate any records unless precise dates of the Applicant’s employment and the name of the “employing entity” during that time could be supplied. A copy of this email is attached to these submissions as “Attachment C”.11. ...12. On 21 June 2019, Mr Bartlett of TAMS Group forwarded an email to the Respondent’s solicitors stating that a USB stick had been sent to the AAT containing the Applicant’s employee file. A copy of this email is attached to these submissions as “Attachment D”.13. On 27 June 2019 the Respondent’s solicitors forwarded a letter to AHPRA in response to Ms Yii’s letter attached to this submission as “Attachment E”. Ms Yii responded by letter dated 1 July 2019 attached to this submission as “Attachment F”.14. On 3 July 2019, Mr Arscott of Atlas Professional sent an email to the Respondent’s solicitors stating that as he had not received a response to his email of 21 June 2019, he considered the matter closed. A copy of this email is attached to this submission and marked as “Attachment G”.15. On 28 June 2019 two Amended Summonses were lodged with the AAT to the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (as opposed to the Royal Australian College of Surgeons) and the AHPRA. In addition to the change of name, the documents sought by both Summonses corrected a typographical error, changing the date “2994” to “1994” The documents sent to the Registry consisted of two pages, the latter of the pages containing the words “This summons has been issued at the request of the applicant/respondent [delete whichever is not applicable]” and the Respondent’s solicitors’ contact details.16. Those Summonses were accepted and sealed by the Registry. The copies returned to the Respondent’s solicitors were one page in length. Both sealed Summonses were sent to NPS, for service. Copies of the covering letter to NPS, letters to be provided to recipients at the time of service and each amended Summons to Produce are attached to these submissions as “Attachment H.”.17. After service of the Summonses on AHPRA, the Respondent’s solicitors sought instructions in relation to the letter provided by Ms Yii on 1 July 2019. Following receipt of those instructions, Mr Buckhurst of instructing solicitors informed Ms Yii by telephone on 8 July 2019 that an extension of the return of summons date would be sought. The Respondent’s solicitors informed the AAT on 9 July 2019 that they intended to seek an extension of the compliance date to 12 August 2019 by letter dated 9 July 2019 (a copy of this letter is attached as attachment I). The extension was subsequently granted by Deputy President Boyle on 12 July 2019. 18. The Respondent’s solicitors are informed that the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons has provided documents to the Tribunal.19. No documents have been sent to the Respondent’s solicitors by any of the companies or organisations to which Summonses to Produce were directed. Those documents sent to the Tribunal’s registry have not been inspected by or on behalf of the Respondent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subsections 40B(1) and (2) of the AAT Act relevantly provide as follows:(1) Any of the following persons may give a party to a proceeding leave to inspect a document or other thing produced under a summons in relation to the proceeding: (a)the President; (b)an authorised member; (c)an authorised officer. (2)However, an authorised officer must not make a decision about giving leave, and must instead arrange for the President or an authorised member of the Tribunal to make the decision, if: (a)the officer considers that it is not appropriate for the officer to make the decision; or (b)a party to the proceeding applies to the officer to have the decision made by a member of the Tribunal.CONSIDERATION It is important to note two things before considering the parties’ respective submissions. Firstly, the applicant has not inspected the documents produced under the summonses and advised at the hearing that he would not be inspecting the documents.[3][3] Transcript at 6. Secondly, the documents produced are relevant to the matters to be determined by the Tribunal. The summons to RACS sought the last known contact details of three identified doctors who had, at some stage, treated the applicant. As it turns out the documents produced by RACS indicate that two of those doctors are deceased. The summons addressed to TAMS sought documents relating to the applicant’s employment with TAMS from 2010. In both cases the documents sought by and produced under the summonses are of the type that are invariably sought by respondents in compensation matters where work and medical histories are relevant considerations. I am satisfied that there is a real possibility that the documents that have been produced may assist in the resolution of the issues in the proceedings.[4]The parties’ submissions[4] See Comcare v Maganga (2008) 101 ALD 68; [2008] FCA 285 (Maganga) at [37].Applicant’s submissions Based on the applicant’s written submissions of 22 July 2019 and on his oral submissions made at the hearing, the thrust of the applicant’s objection appears to be as follows:(a)The applicant had not given his consent to the issuing of the summonses.(b)The back page of the summonses as issued had not been completed to delete “the applicant” where the pro-forma summons provided: “This summons has been issued at the request of the applicant/respondent [delete whichever is not applicable]”.(c)The respondent’s solicitor included his firm’s phone number and him as the person to contact in the section of the pro-forma summons which provides:For further information please contact:Firm/Agency:Person dealing:Telephone:(d)Two of the summonses that had been issued at the request of the respondent contained errors and were replaced by corrected summonses. Relevantly, the relevant summons that had been initially issued was wrongly addressed to the Royal Australian College of Surgeons rather than the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons and had referred to the year in a date as “2994” rather than “1994”. (e)The respondent has in resisting the substantive proceedings disputed (amongst other things) that it was the applicant’s employer at the time of the claimed injury in 2014. The applicant asserts that:The crucial reason was P&O have presented a defence to the claim that they are not the employer and have no identity or legal status to instruct their solicitors to apply to the AAT for such an order, because in what circumstances P&O was Mr O’Sullivans [sic] deemed employer for the purposes of proceedings before the Tribunal has not been considered and determined by the Tribunal [Gordon J High Court] and without that being established the issue of summonses requiring the mentioned persons to produce documents does not arise.[5][5] 22 July 2019 submissions at para. 10.(f)The applicant disputes the Tribunal’s power to issue summonses.[6][6] 22 July 2019 submissions paras. 12 and 13.(g)The summonses as issued were:in a condition of disrepair, and he [the respondent’s lawyer] had prior opportunity to taint the witnesses or documents to be produced when he provided his contact details on the summonses, to refer to, for further information without declaring the position he, or his Firm [sic], were acting for in accordance with the document.(h)The summonses did not comply with procedural fairness or natural justice.[7](i)The proper parties to proceedings under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (SRC Act) are the applicant and the employer and the Federal Court found that the respondent was not the “Actual” employer on the relevant date being 26 August 2014.[8] For the purposes of the AAT Act and the SRC Act the respondent cannot maintain that defence.[9](j)The summonses that contained errors had been served at the time when the summonses were revoked by the Tribunal.(k)The copies of the summonses provided to the applicant were different to those issued by the Tribunal because the back page of the copies of the summonses sent by the Tribunal to the applicant do delete “whichever is not applicable [applicant/respondent]” and identify the summonses as having been issued at the request of the respondent.[10](l)On 5 July 2019 the applicant received correspondence from the respondent’s solicitors (with copies of summonses enclosed) which referred to “Amended” summonses as having been issued to various organisations which identified the amendments as being the correction of the reference to the Royal Australian College of Surgeons to the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons and the correction of the reference of 2994 to 1994, but did not mention the change on the back page to identify the summonses as having been issued at the request of the respondent.[11](m)The applicant accordingly considers the summonses as served to be “an illegal search warrant” because of the “error riddled condition that was accepted for filing, sealing, and service…” and that the respondent’s solicitors “may have tainted the evidence or, if called, the witnesses”.[12][7] 22 July 2019 submissions para. 13.[8] 22 July 2019 submissions para. 14.[9] 22 July 2019 submissions para. 16.[10] 22 July 2019 submissions paras. 27 and 28.[11] 22 July 2019 submissions paras. 29-31.[12] 22 July 2019 submissions paras. 38 and 39.