O'Sullivan and P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

O'Sullivan and P & O Maritime Service Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2016] AATA 865 (10 October 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2015/0698

Re

Michael O'Sullivan

APPLICANT

And

P & O Maritime Service Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

RULING

Tribunal

Mr S. Webb, Member

Date 10 October 2016
Place Perth

A telephone directions hearing is to be set down at the earliest convenient date once 14 days have elapsed from the date of this ruling.

........................................................................

Mr S. Webb, Member

CATCHWORDS

SEAFARER COMPENSATION – previous accepted injury – compensation paid by previous employer - termination of employment - fresh injury in the form of an ‘aggravation’ – employment relationship with previous employer not established

CASES

O’Sullivan v P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 969

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr S. Webb, Member

10 October 2016

  1. Michael O’Sullivan hurt his back when he slipped on some steps. He lodged a claim for compensation, asserting that P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd (the Company) is liable. The Company rejected the claim. Mr O’Sullivan requested reconsideration. The decision is deemed to have been affirmed as the Company failed to issue a reconsideration decision within the time allowed. Mr O’Sullivan applied for review by the Tribunal.

  2. The course of the proceedings has been somewhat difficult. The Tribunal directed Mr O’Sullivan to provide certain documents. He failed to comply with the direction and the application was dismissed. Mr O’Sullivan sought judicial review of this decision. Siopsis J upheld the appeal, set aside the Tribunal’s order dismissing the application, and remitted the matter to the Tribunal (differently constituted) to be determined according to law.[1]

  3. On 12 September 2016, I heard the parties on how the matter should proceed. A threshold issue arose, relating to Mr O’Sullivan’s employment for the purposes of his claim. The parties agreed, sensibly in my view, that it would be desirable for this issue to be dealt with by way of a ruling, before the application proceeded any further.

  4. It is this matter, alone, that I am dealing with presently.

  5. The parties have been given opportunity to place materials and written submissions before each other and the Tribunal, and to be heard orally.

    Brief facts

  6. On 16 December 1993, Mr O’Sullivan injured his back in a fall. At the time, he was employed by the Company to work as a Greaser on the vessel the Lady Dawn.

  7. The injury resulted in incapacity for work. He claimed and was paid periodic compensation for incapacity by the Company.

  8. On 17 June 1994, Mr O’Sullivan was removed from Register A under clause 3(r)(v) of Schedule X to the Maritime Industry Seagoing Award 1983.

  9. On 19 December 1994, the Company terminated his employment.

  10. On 16 November 1995, the Company ceased payment of compensation for incapacity.

  11. Mr O’Sullivan pursued a common law claim against the Company without success.

  12. After the periodic payment of compensation ceased, Mr O’Sullivan obtained social security…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Sullivan and P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 865
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for compensation under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (SRC Act) brought by Mr O’Sullivan against P & O Maritime Services Pty Ltd (the Company). Mr O’Sullivan alleged he sustained a back injury, described as lumbrosacral radiculopathy and a slipped disc affecting his lower back and left leg, on 26 August 2014. This claim was lodged on 12 November 2014, with Mr O’Sullivan citing the Company as his employer at the time of the alleged injury. The Company rejected the claim on the basis that Mr O’Sullivan was not an employee at the time of the incident.

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Company was Mr O’Sullivan’s actual or deemed employer for the purposes of his compensation claim under the SRC Act, in relation to the injury sustained on 26 August 2014. This required the Tribunal to consider the employment relationship between the parties at the time of the alleged injury, particularly in light of Mr O’Sullivan's prior injury in 1993, for which he had received compensation from the Company, and the subsequent termination of his employment with the Company in 1994.

The Tribunal was required to determine if the circumstances of the 2014 incident constituted a "fresh injury" or an "aggravation" of a pre-existing condition, and crucially, whether an employment relationship with the Company could be established for the purposes of the SRC Act in relation to this later incident. The Tribunal noted that Mr O’Sullivan had been removed from a register of employment and his employment with the Company had been terminated in 1994, and he had subsequently obtained social security benefits and worked for other employers before returning to seafarer employment from 2006 onwards. The Company's rejection of the claim was based on the assertion that Mr O’Sullivan was not an employee at the time of the 2014 injury.

Following a directions hearing, the Tribunal ordered that a further telephone directions hearing be scheduled at the earliest convenient date, to occur no earlier than 14 days from the date of the ruling.

Orders

Orders of the court

A telephone directions hearing is to be set down at the earliest convenient date once 14 days have elapsed from the date of this ruling.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties have been given opportunity to place materials and written submissions before each other and the Tribunal, and to be heard orally.Brief facts On 16 December 1993, Mr O’Sullivan injured his back in a fall. At the time, he was employed by the Company to work as a Greaser on the vessel the Lady Dawn. The injury resulted in incapacity for work. He claimed and was paid periodic compensation for incapacity by the Company. On 17 June 1994, Mr O’Sullivan was removed from Register A under clause 3(r)(v) of Schedule X to the Maritime Industry Seagoing Award 1983. On 19 December 1994, the Company terminated his employment. On 16 November 1995, the Company ceased payment of compensation for incapacity. Mr O’Sullivan pursued a common law claim against the Company without success. After the periodic payment of compensation ceased, Mr O’Sullivan obtained social security benefits and, from 2000 to 2004, some light work. It appears that in 2006 he returned to employment as a seafarer with full certification. He has cited employment in work of this kind with a number of employers from 2006 to 2011.[2][2] T1 folio 21. On 12 November 2014, Mr O’Sullivan lodged a claim for compensation under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (the SRC Act) citing the Company as his employer.[3] He clearly set out the scope of his claim[4] and the circumstances of the alleged injury in the claim form.[5] It can be seen that the alleged injury occurred between 0945am and 1005am on 26 August 2014 “Outside maritime union and maritime mining power credit union building” as Mr O’Sullivan was “Leaving the building after paying union fees and registering for employment and accidently missed the step and jarred my back”.[6] Mr O’Sullivan specified that the nature of the injury under claim is “Lumbrosacral radiculopathy – slipped disc”, affecting “Lower back – left leg”.[7][3] T8 folio 39.[4] Ibid, folio 39.[5] T8 folios 40 to 42[6] Ibid, folios 41 and 42.[7] Ibid, folio 41. Mr O’Sullivan provided clear information in the claim form about his previous injury in 1993.[8][8] Ibid, folio 42. On 21 November 2014, the Company sought further information from Mr O’Sullivan. He responded on 1 December 2014. On 8 December 2014, the Company determined to reject Mr O’Sullivan’s claim as “You were not an employee of P&O Maritime at the time of your injury”.[9][9] T12. On 10 December 2014, Mr O’Sullivan requested reconsideration of this determination, stating that he “is unable to resume duties in the Maritime Industry due to injury”.[10][10] T13. The Company obtained a report from Comcare.[11][11] T14. As no reconsideration decision was issued by the Company within the time allowed under s 79 of the SRC Act, the primary determination is deemed to have been affirmed. Mr O’Sullivan applied for review of this deemed decision.Issues The question to be addressed is whether the Company is Mr O’Sullivan’s actual or deemed employer for the purposes of his claim for compensation under the SRC Act in respect of an injury sustained on 26 August 2014. Employer

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.