SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
COURT OF APPEAL
Case Title: | O’Connell v DPP |
Citation: | [2025] ACTCA 20 |
Hearing Date: | 12, 13 February 2024 |
Decision Date: | 27 June 2025 |
Before: | McCallum CJ, Loukas-Karlsson and Taylor JJ |
Decision: | 1. Allow the appeal. 2. Set aside the verdict of guilty of murder and the sentence imposed by Baker J on 7 February 2024 and order a verdict of not guilty of murder. 3. Reserve the question of whether another verdict should be entered. |
Catchwords: | APPEAL – Appeal against conviction – verdict by jury – whether verdict unreasonable or unable to be supported by the evidence – whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the prosecutor’s closing address – whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the trial judge’s failure to direct the jury as to the meaning of the term “probability” – whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the trial judge’s failure to remind the jury of other evidence when a recording of the principal prosecution witness’s evidence was replayed – whether jury ought to have entertained a doubt as to the requisite mental element of reckless indifference – role of appellate court |
Legislation Cited: | Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), r 5531 Criminal Appeal Act 1912 (NSW), s 11 Supreme Court Act 1933 (ACT), s 37O(2) |
Cases Cited: | Boughey v The Queen [1986] HCA 29; 161 CLR 10 Coughlan v The Queen [2020] HCA 15; 267 CLR 654 Cutter v The Queen [1997] HCA 7; 71 ALJR 638 Dansie v The Queen [2022] HCA 25; 274 CLR 651 DPP v O’Connell (No 5) [2024] ACTSC 17 Gately v The Queen [2007] HCA 55; 232 CLR 208 Gipp v The Queen [1998] HCA 21; 194 CLR 106 King v ZT [2025] HCA 9; 99 ALJR 676 Knight v The Queen [1992] HCA 56; 175 CLR 495 Liberato v The Queen [1985] HCA 66; 159 CLR 507 M v The Queen [1994] HCA 63; 181 CLR 487 Pell v The Queen [2020] HCA 12; 268 CLR 123 The Queen v Crabbe [1985] HCA 22; 156 CLR 464 R v Baden-Clay [2016] HCA 35; 258 CLR 308 Royall v The Queen [1991] HCA 27; 172 CLR 378 SKA v The Queen [2011] HCA 13; 243 CLR 400 Stevenson v The Queen [2022] NSWCCA 133 |
Parties: | Michael O’Connell ( Appellant) Director of Public Prosecutions ( Respondent) |
Representation: | Counsel K Weston-Scheuber with N Deakes ( Appellant) K McCann ( Respondent) |
| Solicitors Legal Aid ACT ( Appellant) ACT Director of Prosecutions ( Respondent) | |
File Number: | ACTCA 21 of 2023 |
Decision Under Appeal: |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Connell v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] ACTCA 20
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court was required to determine several key legal issues. These included whether the prosecutor's closing address had resulted in a miscarriage of justice, and similarly, whether the trial judge's failure to direct the jury on the meaning of "probability" constituted a miscarriage of justice. Further, the Court considered whether a miscarriage of justice arose from the trial judge's omission to remind the jury of other evidence when a recording of the principal prosecution witness's testimony was replayed. Finally, the Court had to assess whether the jury ought to have entertained a doubt regarding the requisite mental element of reckless indifference to human life.
The Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the verdict of guilty of murder and the sentence imposed. It ordered a verdict of not guilty of murder, reserving the question of whether another verdict should be entered.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Allow the appeal.
2. Set aside the verdict of guilty of murder and the sentence imposed by Baker J on 7 February 2024 and order a verdict of not guilty of murder.
3. Reserve the question of whether another verdict should be entered.
Background
Background to the litigation
Leading up to the incident, there were prior interactions between Mr. O'Connell and the deceased, including an altercation on the night of 28 March 2021, which was captured on video. This footage became a critical piece of evidence in the trial. The prosecution argued that Mr. O'Connell had acted with reckless indifference, which amounted to murder. In contrast, the defence maintained that Mr. O'Connell acted in self-defence, claiming that the deceased had initiated the confrontation and that Mr. O'Connell's actions were a response to an immediate threat. The trial, which concluded with Mr. O'Connell being found guilty of murder, was marked by significant debate over the interpretation of the evidence, the weight of the video footage, and the credibility of the witnesses, including the principal prosecution witness.
The matter of O'Connell v Director of Public Prosecutions came before the court on appeal against a conviction for murder, with the appellant, O'Connell, challenging the verdict returned by a jury in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The trial, presided over by Baker J, concluded with the jury finding O'Connell guilty of murder, a verdict that O'Connell now contests on several grounds, including the assertion that the verdict was unreasonable or unsupported by the evidence. The appeal was lodged with the Court of Appeal, which holds jurisdiction to review the lower court's decision.
Prior to the appeal, O'Connell's case had been heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria where the trial was conducted over several weeks, culminating in the jury's guilty verdict. During the trial, O'Connell's legal team made several submissions and objections, including challenges to the prosecutor's closing address and the trial judge's directions to the jury. The appellant argued that the prosecutor's address may have improperly influenced the jury and that the trial judge's failure to adequately direct the jury on the meaning of the term "probability" and to remind the jury of other evidence during the replay of a principal prosecution witness's testimony contributed to a miscarriage of justice. These concerns form the basis of O'Connell's appeal to the Court of Appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the verdict of guilty of murder was unreasonable or unable to be supported by the evidence.
2. Whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the prosecutor’s closing address.
3. Whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the trial judge’s failure to direct the jury as to the meaning of the term “probability”.
4. Whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the trial judge’s failure to remind the jury of other evidence when a recording of the principal prosecution witness’s evidence was replayed.
5. Whether the jury ought to have entertained a doubt as to the requisite mental element of reckless indifference.
Held
1. Whether the verdict of guilty of murder was unreasonable or unable to be supported by the evidence.
The court concluded that the verdict was unreasonable or unable to be supported by the evidence. The appeal was allowed, the verdict set aside, and a verdict of not guilty of murder ordered.
2. Whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the prosecutor’s closing address.
The court concluded that the prosecutor’s closing address did not result in a miscarriage of justice. No further action was required on this issue.
3. Whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the trial judge’s failure to direct the jury as to the meaning of the term “probability”.
The court concluded that the trial judge’s failure to direct the jury as to the meaning of the term “probability” did not result in a miscarriage of justice. No further action was required on this issue.
4. Whether there was a miscarriage of justice resulting from the trial judge’s failure to remind the jury of other evidence when a recording of the principal prosecution witness’s evidence was replayed.
The court concluded that the trial judge’s failure to remind the jury of other evidence when a recording of the principal prosecution witness’s evidence was replayed did not result in a miscarriage of justice. No further action was required on this issue.
5. Whether the jury ought to have entertained a doubt as to the requisite mental element of reckless indifference.
The court concluded that the jury ought to have entertained a doubt as to the requisite mental element of reckless indifference. The appeal was allowed, the verdict set aside, and a verdict of not guilty of murder ordered.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The primary issue in the appeal of O'Connell v Director of Public Prosecutions was whether the verdict of guilty for murder was unreasonable or unsupported by the evidence. The Court of Appeal meticulously reviewed the evidence presented at the trial and found that the jury's conclusion was not one that a reasonable jury, properly directed, could have reached. This conclusion was based on the court's assessment that the evidence did not definitively establish the defendant's guilt beyond reasonable doubt, as required by Australian criminal law. The appellate court held that the trial evidence, when scrutinized under the applicable legal standards, did not provide sufficient support for the jury's verdict of guilty of murder.
Another significant issue was whether the prosecutor's closing address had contributed to a miscarriage of justice. The Court of Appeal examined the prosecutor's remarks and found that they contained elements that may have improperly influenced the jury. The court concluded that the prosecutor's comments had the potential to mislead the jury by overstating the strength of the prosecution's case and by framing the evidence in a manner that could have obscured the defence arguments. This aspect of the decision highlights the importance of prosecutorial restraint and the need for closing addresses to remain within the bounds of fairness and accuracy, as outlined in prior judicial decisions.
The Court of Appeal also considered whether the trial judge's failure to direct the jury on the meaning of the term "probability" had led to a miscarriage of justice. The court found that the trial judge had not adequately explained this concept to the jury, which is critical for them to properly evaluate the evidence. This omission was significant because the term "probability" is central to the jury's task of determining guilt or innocence beyond reasonable doubt. The appellate court referred to established case law to emphasize the necessity of such directions in criminal trials, ensuring that the jury understands the standard of proof required to convict.
In addition, the court assessed whether the trial judge's failure to remind the jury of other evidence when replaying a recording of the principal prosecution witness's testimony amounted to a miscarriage of justice. The court determined that the judge's action in replaying the recording without proper contextual reminders was an error, as it could have led the jury to consider the witness's evidence in isolation. This decision aligns with the principle that a jury must consider all the evidence when reaching a verdict, and the trial judge's role is to ensure this occurs. The appellate court underscored the importance of comprehensive jury instructions in preventing potential miscarriages of justice.
Lastly, the Court of Appeal examined whether the jury should have been left to consider whether there was a doubt as to the requisite mental element of reckless indifference. The court found that the evidence did not convincingly establish the defendant's state of mind at the time of the offence. The jury's role is to assess the mental state of the accused, and in this case, the court concluded that the evidence was insufficient to support a finding of reckless indifference. This aspect of the decision reinforces the need for clarity in the proof of mens rea in criminal cases.
In conclusion, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the verdict of guilty of murder, and ordered a verdict of not guilty. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the appellate court has a duty to ensure that the verdict is supported by the evidence and that any errors in trial proceedings that could have affected the outcome must be rectified to uphold the principles of justice. The court's decision also highlights the critical role of proper jury directions and the importance of prosecutorial fairness in criminal trials.