NSW Crime Commission v Lee

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: NSW Crime Commission v Lee And Anor [2011] NSWSC 80
Hearing dates:28 June 2010
Decision date: 28 February 2011
Before: RS HULME J
Decision:

(i) That Elizabeth Park be examined on oath concerning her own affairs, and including the nature and location of any property in which she has an interest;

(ii) That Brendan Pak be examined concerning the affairs of Jason Lee or Elizabeth Park including the nature and location of any property in which either has an interest;

(iii) The Notice to Produce filed by the First Defendant on 16 June 2010 be set aside except insofar as it refers to the production of the notice referred to in paragraph 1 thereof; and

(iv) The First Defendant is to pay the Plaintiff's costs of the Notice of Motion filed on 17 June 2010.

Legislation Cited: Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990
Australian Crime Commission Act 2002 (Cth)
New South Wales Crime Commission Act 1985
Cases Cited: Hammond v Commonwealth of Australia (1982) 152 CLR 188
Australian Crime Commission v OK [2010] FCAFC 61
NSW Crime Commisison v Murchi (2000) 49 NSWLR 465
Waind v Hill and Anor [1978] 1 NSWLR 372 at p382
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: New South Wales Crime Commission
Representation: Counsel:
Mr P Singleton
Mr G Jones
Solicitors:
John M Giorgiutti NSW Crime Commission
File Number(s):119077/2010

JUDGMENT

  1. RS HULME J : These reasons concern two Notices of Motion. In the first, filed on 10 June 2010, the New South Wales Crime Commission seeks orders that may be summarised as follows:-

(i) That Jason Lee be examined on oath concerning his own affairs, and including the nature and location of any property in which he has an interest;
(ii) That Elizabeth Park be examined on oath concerning her own affairs, and including the nature and location of any property in which she has an interest;
(iii) That Seong Won Lee be examined concerning the affairs of Jason Lee or Elizabeth Park including the nature and location of any property in which either has an interest;
(iv) That Brendan Pak be examined concerning the affairs of Jason Lee or Elizabeth Park including the nature and location of any property in which either has an interest; and
(v) Such other order as the Court sees fit.
  1. In the second, filed on 17 June 2010, the Crime Commission seeks an order that:-

(i) Paragraph 2 of the Notice to Produce to the Court filed by the First Defendant on 16 June 2010 be set aside;
(ii) The First Defendant pay the Plaintiff's costs of the application; and
(iii) Such other order as the Court sees fit.
  1. To appreciate some of the issues that arise in respect of the first Notice of Motion it is necessary to record some history. By Summons filed on 13 May 2010, the Crime Commission sought, inter alia:-

(i) Orders pursuant to s 10A of the Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 , and subject…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NSW Crime Commission v Lee and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of NSW Crime Commission v Lee, the Supreme Court of New South Wales was tasked with making several orders in relation to examinations and the production of documents in an asset recovery case. The New South Wales Crime Commission sought orders for examinations of Jason Lee, Elizabeth Park, Seong Won Lee, and Brendan Pak, as well as the setting aside of a Notice to Produce filed by the first defendant. The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the current application was an abuse of process, whether orders for examination should be limited, and if the Notice to Produce had a legitimate forensic purpose.

The court determined that the application was not an abuse of process, as the orders sought were made in circumstances that did not contain the same potential for invalidity as the earlier orders. However, the court decided that no orders for examination should be made against Jason Lee and Seong Won Lee due to the risk of self-incrimination. The court also found that the terms of the orders sought were not too wide, and that there was no basis for limiting the examination to specific questions or topics.

Regarding the Notice to Produce, the court found that while the main paragraph of the subpoena was too wide, paragraph 2 of the subpoena was sufficiently specific. However, the court set aside the subpoena as it could not conclude that the documents might assist the first defendant in either piece of litigation.

The final orders made by the court were:

1. Elizabeth Park be examined on oath concerning her own affairs, and including the nature and location of any property in which she has an interest.
2. Brendan Pak be examined concerning the affairs of Jason Lee or Elizabeth Park, including the nature and location of any property in which either has an interest.
3. The Notice to Produce filed by the First Defendant on 16 June 2010 be set aside, except insofar as it refers to the production of the notice referred to in paragraph 1.
4. The First Defendant is to pay the Plaintiff's costs of the Notice of Motion filed on 17 June 2010.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the New South Wales Crime Commission seeking orders against Jason Lee, Elizabeth Park, Seong Won Lee, and Brendan Pak. The commission aims to examine these individuals concerning their own affairs and the nature and location of any property they might have an interest in. This follows an earlier application by the commission on 13 May 2010, where orders were made ex parte to examine Jason Lee and Elizabeth Park on oath concerning their own affairs and the affairs of each other. Jason Lee, Seong Won Lee, and Elizabeth Park have sought leave to appeal against these earlier orders. The commission has now filed a new Notice of Motion seeking similar orders, which are the subject of this case. In addition, the commission seeks to set aside a Notice to Produce filed by the first defendant on 16 June 2010.

The procedural history of this matter begins with the New South Wales Crime Commission filing a summons on 13 May 2010, seeking various orders, including restraining orders and examination orders under the Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990. Buddin J made several ex parte orders on the same day, including orders for the examination on oath of Jason Lee and Elizabeth Park concerning their own affairs and the nature and location of any property they have an interest in. Jason Lee, Seong Won Lee, and Elizabeth Park have sought leave to appeal these orders. Subsequently, the commission filed a Notice of Motion on 10 June 2010, seeking similar examination orders, and a second Notice of Motion on 17 June 2010, seeking to set aside a Notice to Produce filed by the first defendant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HULME J
Issues
1. Whether the examination orders sought against Jason Lee and Seong Won Lee should be made, given the principle of not compelling self-incrimination.
2. Whether the examination orders sought should be limited to specific topics or can cover a broader scope.
3. Whether the Notice to Produce filed by the first defendant should be set aside, particularly concerning its requirement to judge the legal effect of documents and its lack of a legitimate forensic purpose.

Held
1. The examination orders sought against Jason Lee and Seong Won Lee should not be made, given the principle of not compelling self-incrimination.
2. The examination orders sought should not be limited to specific topics but can cover a broader scope.
3. The Notice to Produce filed by the first defendant should be set aside, particularly concerning its requirement to judge the legal effect of documents and its lack of a legitimate forensic purpose.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HULME J

The court considered the application for examination orders under the Criminal Assets Recovery Act 1990 and the New South Wales Crime Commission Act 1985. It was established that Jason Lee and Elizabeth Park could provide evidence on the topics referred to in the proposed orders. However, the court ruled that the examination orders against Jason Lee and Seong Won Lee should not be made to avoid compelling self-incrimination, following the principle established in Hammond v Commonwealth of Australia. This decision was based on the risk of interference with the administration of justice if the individuals were questioned about matters relevant to charges against them. The court also decided that the examination orders should not be limited to specific topics but could cover a broader scope. It found no reason to restrict the questioning in the way suggested by the respondents, given the importance of examining individuals who may not be disposed to cooperate fully. The court further ruled that the Notice to Produce filed by the first defendant should be set aside because it required the recipient to judge the legal effect of documents and lacked a legitimate forensic purpose. The court relied on the authorities of Patonga Beach Holdings Pty Ltd v Lyons and Waind v Hill to determine that the Notice to Produce was too wide and should be set aside, except for the production of the notice referred to in paragraph 1.