CITATION: Botany Bay v Permtree Botany Bay v BAS Botany Bay v Jazabas [2009] NSWSC 896 HEARING DATE(S): 09/06/09; 12/06/06
Judgment reserved 27/07/09
JUDGMENT DATE :
31 August 2009JURISDICTION: Equity Division JUDGMENT OF: Macready AsJ at 1 CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS - winding up - winding up in insolvency - oppression or abuse of process. - PROCEDURE - costs –security for costs order subject of statutory demand – defendants entered costs order as a judgment debt and successfully applied to registrar to pay debt by instalments – clerical error meant first instalments were not paid - whether winding up proceedings could continue – whether present procedure is a way of avoiding statutory stay – proceedings dismissed. PARTIES: Botany Bay City Council v Parmtree Pty Ltd
Botany Bay City Council v BAS Developments Pty Ltd
Botany Bay City Council v Jazabas Pty Ltd
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 4553/08; 4552/08; 4549/08 COUNSEL: Mr G McNally SC for plaintiff
Mr PE King for defendantsSOLICITORS: Houston Dearn O'Connor for plaintiff
Cropper Parkhill for defendants
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
ASSOCIATE JUSTICE MACREADY
Monday 31 August 2009
4553/08 Botany Bay City Council v Parmtree Pty Ltd
4552/08 Botany Bay City Council v BAS Developments Pty Ltd
4549/08 Botany Bay City Council v Jazabas Pty Ltd
JUDGMENT
1 His Honour: In this matter the plaintiff has sought an order to wind up the three defendants in insolvency under s 459E of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The applications are made based upon service of a contentious statutory demand dated 4 July 2008 in the sum of $46,251.82. The matters have been heard together with the evidence in one being the evidence in others. Reference to the defendants is a reference to all three defendants in each action.
2 A further amended notice of appearance was filed by the defendants in relation to matter number 4549 (Jazabas) which opposes the plaintiffs application for winding up for the reasons that the judgment debt is not due and payable, the defendant is solvent, the application to wind up was brought for a collateral purpose and are an abuse of process, and further, that the plaintiff has failed to comply with the requirements of the Corporations Act and Regulations, particularly Corporations Regulations 5.4 and 5.6 and sections 465A and 470(1) of the Act.
3 There is also a notice of motion filed by the defendant in each proceeding on 7 November 2008 seeking to have the proceedings dismissed as an abuse of process.
4 The parties have provided detailed submissions which I have incorporated with amendments.
Background
5 The plaintiff is a local government authority that administers an area in south eastern Sydney.
6 The defendants are each corporations. Jazabas and Permtree have been engaged in residential property development and BAS Developments Pty Ltd builds the Jazabas and Permtree developments. The three corporations have as their managing director Mr Stephen Haigh. The defendants contend that Permtree is no longer active, its only…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Botany Bay v Permtree Botany Bay v BAS Botany Bay v Jazabas and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 896
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the winding up proceedings could proceed and if the current procedure was a way to avoid the statutory stay on winding up. The court had to consider the implications of the defendants' actions in treating the costs order as a judgment debt and the subsequent application to pay by instalments. It was also necessary to assess if the winding up proceedings were appropriate given the nature of the dispute and whether the defendants' actions could be considered oppressive or an abuse of process.
The court found that the winding up proceedings were inappropriate due to the defendants' actions not amounting to an abuse of process or oppression. The court emphasised that the current procedure was not a means of circumventing the statutory stay on winding up, as it was not the defendants' fault that the first instalments were not paid due to a clerical error. The court dismissed the winding up proceedings, noting that the defendants' actions did not warrant such extreme measures and that the statutory stay on winding up should not be circumvented.
The court ordered that the winding up proceedings be dismissed and that Botany Bay bear the costs of the proceedings. The court made it clear that winding up proceedings should not be used lightly and that the statutory stay on winding up should be respected. The court also highlighted the importance of accurately following legal procedures to avoid unnecessary and potentially oppressive actions against other parties.
Background
Background to the litigation
The winding up proceedings against Permtree, BAS, and Jazabas were initiated by Botany Bay in the Supreme Court. Botany Bay obtained a costs order against Permtree, which was subsequently entered as a judgment debt. Permtree applied to the registrar to pay this debt by instalments, and a statutory demand was issued. Due to a clerical error, the first instalments were not paid. Botany Bay then sought to continue the winding up proceedings. The case was dismissed on the basis that the procedural steps taken were an attempt to avoid the statutory stay on winding up proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the winding up proceedings can continue given the procedural steps taken by the defendants.
2. Whether the present procedure employed by the defendants is a way of avoiding the statutory stay on winding up proceedings.
Held
1. The court held that the winding up proceedings could not continue given the procedural steps taken by the defendants.
2. The court held that the present procedure employed by the defendants is a way of avoiding the statutory stay on winding up proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced its analysis by examining whether the winding up proceedings could continue in light of the procedural steps taken by the defendants. It was noted that the defendants had entered a costs order as a judgment debt and subsequently applied to the registrar to pay the debt by instalments. A clerical error resulted in the first instalments not being paid. The court found that this procedural misstep, although inadvertent, significantly impacted the defendants' ability to comply with the statutory requirements necessary to proceed with the winding up proceedings. Consequently, the court concluded that the winding up proceedings could not continue.
In addressing the second issue, the court delved into whether the defendants' current procedure was a means to circumvent the statutory stay on winding up proceedings. The court examined the statutory provisions governing winding up proceedings and found that the defendants' actions, while not malicious, were calculated to delay the proceedings, thereby avoiding the statutory stay. The court reasoned that allowing such procedural tactics would undermine the integrity of the statutory protections afforded to debtors. Therefore, the court held that the present procedure was indeed a way of avoiding the statutory stay on winding up proceedings. The court dismissed the proceedings, reinforcing the importance of adhering to statutory provisions and timelines in insolvency matters. The ratio decidendi of this case is that procedural missteps, even if inadvertent, can result in the dismissal of winding up proceedings, and that attempts to circumvent statutory stays are not permissible.