NSL Engineering Pte Ltd v Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

NSL Engineering Pte Ltd v Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited [2017] APO 29

Patent Application:                2013202231

Title:Apparatus for handling containers

Patent Applicant:                   Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited

Opponent:  NSL Engineering Pte Ltd

Delegate:  Ed Knock

Decision Date:  13 June 2017

Hearing Date:  22 March 2017, in Canberra

Catchwords:  PATENTS - section 59 – opposition to grant of patent – shipping container tippler – whether claims fairly based – whether the invention useful - whether claimed invention was novel – whether claimed invention had inventive step – ground of novelty only ground upheld – a number of claims not novel – applicant allowed an opportunity to amend.

Representation:  Counsel for the applicant:  Ian Horak

Patent attorney for the applicant:  Catherine Hustwick of Australian Patent & Trademark Services Pty Ltd, Sydney

Also present for the applicant:  Murray Bridle

Counsel for the opponent:  Craig Smith

Also present for the opponent:  Cameron Hay

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2013202231

Title:Apparatus for handling containers

Patent Applicant:                   Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited

Date of Decision:                   13 June 2017

DECISION

Claims 1, 2, 5 to 15 and 17 to 19 are not novel.

I allow a period of two (2) months from the date of this decision for Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited to file amendments to overcome this ground. 

I award costs according the Schedule 8 against the applicant, Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

1.The present patent application 2013202231 was filed as a divisional application of parent application 2010306065 on 31 March 2013 in the name of Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited (“AMMESA”).  Two other applications - 2013100396 (which is now a certified innovation patent) and 2014253502 – were also filed as divisional applications of application 2010306065, and are thus siblings of the present application.  To complete the picture, I note that the present application has itself spun-off a divisional innovation application – 2015100682 – but the resultant granted innovation patent has now ceased.

2.The progenitor of this family of patent applications - application 2010306065 - started life as an international application PCT/AU2010/001337, and entered the national phase on 4 November 2011.  PCT/AU2010/001337 claims priority from Australian provisional application 2009904983 filed on 14 October 2009.  Present application 2013202231 was made open to public inspection on 2 May 2013 and was advertised accepted on 7 May 2015.

3.Two notices of opposition to the granting of a patent on application 2013202231 were filed on 7 August 2015.  The two opponents were the opponent in the present opposition, NSL Engineering Pte Ltd (“NSL”), plus Qube Bulk Pty Ltd (“Qube”).  The opposition processes proceeded uneventfully, from the filing of statements of grounds and particulars on 9 November 2015, and through the evidentiary stages up to the completion of evidence in answer on 6 May 2016 (NSL) and 12 May 2016 (Qube).  However, on 8 July…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NSL Engineering Pte Ltd v Australian Mobile Mining Equipment... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] APO 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

NSL Engineering Pte Ltd, the patent applicant, contested the decision by the Commissioner for Patents to oppose the grant of a patent to Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited for a shipping container tippler. The dispute was heard and determined in the Federal Court of Australia.

The central issues before the Court were whether the claims in the patent application were fairly based on the matter disclosed, whether the invention was useful, and whether the invention was both novel and involved an inventive step. These questions were addressed under the criteria set out in the relevant sections of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth).

In examining the patent application, the Court found that while the invention had some utility, several claims were not novel as they were anticipated by prior art. The Court ruled that claims 1, 2, 5 to 15, and 17 to 19 were not novel, as they were disclosed in the prior art. However, the Court allowed the applicant a period of two months to amend the claims to overcome the novelty issue. The Court also awarded costs to the respondent, NSL Engineering Pte Ltd, in accordance with the provisions of Schedule 8 of the Federal Court of Australia Rules.

The Court's decision effectively disallowed certain claims in the patent application and provided the applicant with a window to revise and resubmit the claims. This outcome reflects the Court's role in ensuring that patent applications meet the statutory requirements for novelty and inventiveness, thereby maintaining the integrity of the patent system.

Orders

Orders of the court

Claims 1, 2, 5 to 15 and 17 to 19 are not novel.

I allow a period of two (2) months from the date of this decision for Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited to file amendments to overcome this ground.

I award costs according the Schedule 8 against the applicant, Australian Mobile Mining Equipment Systems and Accessories Pty. Limited.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established