Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] NSWSC 1091
Hearing dates: 3 August 2023
Date of orders: 8 September 2023
Decision date: 08 September 2023
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Kunc J
Decision:

Contempt motion dismissed where applicant expressly particularised but failed to establish contumacious breaches of undertakings

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE — Undertakings given to Court — Compliance a matter for the Court and not for parties to dispute between themselves without reference to the Court — Proceedings to be relisted promptly if party finds itself prospectively unable to comply or has failed to comply with undertakings — Not appropriate to file contempt motion for breach of undertakings without having relisted proceedings

CONTEMPT — Civil contempt — Breach of undertakings — Statement of charge expressly particularised alleged breaches as contumelious — Applicant not entitled to succeed where only civil contempt established

Legislation Cited:

Supreme Court Rules 1970 (NSW)

Cases Cited:

Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union, v Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd 161 CLR 98; [1986] HCA 46

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) v Allphones Retail Pty Ltd (No 4) (2011) 280 ALR 97; [2011] FCA 338

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Sigalla (No 4) (2011) 80 NSWLR 113; [2011] NSWSC 62

Bathurst Real Estate Pty Ltd v Fairbrother [2022] NSWSC 351

Markisic & Anor v Keelty [2005] NSWSC 1124

Markisic v Commonwealth of Australia (2006) 69 NSWLR 737; [2007] NSWCA 92

Mosman Municipal Council v Kelly (No 3) (2009) 167 LGERA 91; [2009] NSWLEC 92

Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 1607

Pang v Bydand Holdings Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 69

Witham v Holloway (1995) 183 CLR 525; [1995] HCA 3

Texts Cited:

The Hon Justice Natalie Adams and Belinda Baker, “Sentencing for Contempt of Court”, National Judicial College of Australia and the Australian National University Sentencing Conference, 29 February 2020.

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Jared Novelly (plaintiff)
Tamqia Pty Ltd (first defendant)
Marie Bolton (second defendant)
Representation:

Counsel: P Barham (plaintiff)
D Lloyd SC/Ms LJ Moussa (defendants)

Solicitors: Fraser Clancy (plaintiff)
John de Mestre & Co (defendants)
File Number(s): 2021/365919

JUDGMENT

Summary

  1. Litigants are generally entitled to bring before the Court any dispute which it has jurisdiction to determine. However, common sense dictates that not every dispute should be litigated. The potent combination of personal animosity and financial resources is the enemy of common sense. Regrettably for all concerned, it appears that the parties in this case have chosen to demonstrate the truth of that proposition not just once, but now for a second time.

  2. The plaintiff (Mr Novelly) leases a penthouse apartment in central Sydney (the Premises) from the first defendant, Tamqia Pty Ltd (Tamqia). The second defendant (Ms Bolton) is the controlling mind of Tamqia. In resolving the original dispute between the parties, Peden J concluded that she did “not consider that the parties ought to have required the Court to determine the trivial…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 1091
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceedings between Novelly and Tamqia Pty Ltd were before the court, with the matter relating to alleged breaches of undertakings provided to the court. The court had to determine the appropriate course of action when a party finds itself unable to comply with an undertaking or has failed to comply with one. Additionally, the court considered whether it was appropriate to file a contempt motion for breach of undertakings without first relisting the proceedings.

The central legal issue before the court was the proper procedure to follow when there is a dispute regarding the compliance with an undertaking given to the court. The court was tasked with deciding whether it was within the purview of the parties to resolve such disputes without involving the court or whether the court must be the arbiter of compliance. Furthermore, the court needed to determine the circumstances under which a contempt motion for breach of undertakings should be filed.

In its reasoning, the court clarified that compliance with undertakings given to the court is a matter for the court, not for the parties to resolve among themselves. The court emphasised that if a party finds itself prospectively unable to comply with an undertaking or has failed to comply, the proceedings should be promptly relisted. The court held that it was not appropriate to file a contempt motion for breach of undertakings without having relisted the proceedings. Additionally, the court noted that where only civil contempt is established, the applicant is not entitled to succeed if the statement of charge expressly particularised alleged breaches as contumelious.

The court ordered that the proceedings be relisted promptly if a party finds itself prospectively unable to comply with an undertaking or has failed to comply. The court also ruled that it was not appropriate to file a contempt motion for breach of undertakings without having relisted the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) involves a dispute where the plaintiff, Novelly, had previously entered into an agreement with the defendant, Tamqia Pty Ltd, which included certain undertakings to the court. These undertakings were meant to be binding and were to be complied with as per the court's orders. The nature of these undertakings is not explicitly detailed in the provided excerpt but is implied to be significant enough to warrant court oversight. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant had failed to comply with these undertakings. This failure led to the plaintiff initiating proceedings to address the alleged breach. The proceedings included the filing of a statement of charge, which detailed the specific instances of the alleged breaches, characterizing them as contumelious. However, the court found that only civil contempt was established, and the plaintiff was not entitled to succeed in their application.

The matter came before the court as a result of the plaintiff, Novelly, initiating proceedings against the defendant, Tamqia Pty Ltd, for alleged breaches of previously given undertakings. The proceedings involved the filing of a statement of charge by the plaintiff, detailing the specific instances of the alleged breaches. The court was asked to determine whether the defendant had indeed breached the undertakings and, if so, what the appropriate remedy might be. The case was not proceeding as an appeal or a judicial review but rather as a direct application to the court regarding the compliance with court-ordered undertakings. The court considered the procedural steps taken by the plaintiff, including the filing of the statement of charge and the nature of the alleged breaches.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should entertain a dispute between the parties regarding compliance with the undertakings without a relisting of the proceedings.
2. Whether it is appropriate to file a contempt motion for breach of undertakings without first relisting the proceedings with the court.
3. Whether the applicant is entitled to succeed in their application for contempt based on the established civil contempt, given the particularised nature of the alleged breaches as contumelious.

Held
1. The court concluded that it should not entertain a dispute between the parties regarding compliance with the undertakings without a relisting of the proceedings.
2. It was determined that it is not appropriate to file a contempt motion for breach of undertakings without first relisting the proceedings with the court.
3. The applicant was not entitled to succeed in their application for contempt based on the established civil contempt, given the particularised nature of the alleged breaches as contumelious.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the procedural aspect of whether it was appropriate to entertain a dispute between the parties regarding compliance with the undertakings without a relisting of the proceedings. The court held that such disputes are matters for the court itself, not for the parties to determine between themselves. It emphasised that if a party finds itself unable to comply or has failed to comply with the undertakings, the proper course of action is to promptly relist the proceedings. This approach ensures that the court retains control over compliance with its orders and can manage any disputes or breaches in a structured judicial context.

Turning to the issue of filing a contempt motion for breach of undertakings, the court ruled that it is not appropriate to proceed with such a motion without first relisting the proceedings. The rationale behind this decision was to avoid bypassing the court's authority and process, thereby ensuring that any allegations of contempt are addressed within the formal framework of the court's jurisdiction. The court underscored that the proceedings must be relisted to allow for a proper assessment and resolution of compliance issues.

Finally, the court examined whether the applicant was entitled to succeed in their application for contempt based on the established civil contempt. It noted that the statement of charge had expressly particularised the alleged breaches as contumelious. However, the court found that the applicant had only established civil contempt, which was insufficient to warrant a finding of contempt in the absence of more egregious conduct. The court concluded that the nature of the breaches, while serious, did not rise to the level of contumelious conduct necessary to support the applicant's application for contempt. Thus, the applicant was not entitled to succeed based on the particularised nature of the alleged breaches. This decision highlights the distinction between civil contempt and more severe forms of contempt and reinforces the importance of the particularised nature of the alleged breaches in determining the appropriate remedy.