Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] NSWSC 1235
Hearing dates: On the papers - written submissions 20 September; 6, 12 October 2023
Date of orders: 18 October 2023
Decision date: 18 October 2023
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Kunc J
Decision:

Plaintiff applicant to pay defendant respondents’ costs

Catchwords:

COSTS — Party/Party — Exceptions to general rule that costs follow the event — Misconduct of a party — Where prosecution for criminal contempt fails but Court finds civil contempts committed — No issue of principle

Cases Cited:

EMI Records Ltd v Ian Cameron Wallis Ltd [1983] 1 Ch 59

Morgan v Carmarthen Corporation [1957] Ch 455

Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] NSWSC 1091

Category:Costs
Parties: Jared Novelly (Plaintiff)
Tamqia Pty Ltd (First defendant)
Marie Bolton (Second defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
P Barham (Plaintiff)
D Lloyd SC/Ms LJ Moussa (Defendants)

Solicitors:
Fraser Clancy (Plaintiff)
John de Mestre & Co (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2021/365919

JUDGMENT

Summary

  1. By its judgment delivered on 8 September 2023, the Court dismissed the plaintiff’s motion charging the defendants with criminal contempt (Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] NSWSC 1091 (the Contempt Judgment)). These reasons should be read, and assume familiarity, with the Contempt Judgment. Defined terms in the Contempt Judgment have the same meaning in these reasons.

  2. At the conclusion of the Contempt Judgment, the Court ordered the plaintiff (Mr Novelly) to pay the defendants’ costs of the contempt motion, but reserved liberty to any party who wished to do so to make an application for a different costs order. Such an application was made by Mr Novelly. The Court ordered the exchange of written submissions, with the application to be determined on the papers.

  3. Mr Novelly submits that in the exercise of the Court’s discretion he should have 60% of his costs of the contempt motion, or such other percentage of his costs as the Court deems fit. He further submits, in the alternative, that there should be no order as to costs.

  4. For the reasons which follow, the Court will not alter the costs order made at the conclusion of Contempt Judgment, other than to excise from that order the costs incurred by the defendants in relation to affidavits that they served, but did not read at the hearing. In summary, this is because the Court accepts the defendants’ submission that where the Court has dismissed the contempt motion because it solely particularised criminal contempts that were not made out, it would be unjust and inconsistent with that outcome for the Court to award costs on the basis that some civil contempts had been established when that was not the case which the defendants had been required to meet.

  5. The submissions on behalf of Mr Novelly were prepared by Mr P Barham of Counsel. The submissions for the defendants were prepared by Mr D Lloyd of Senior Counsel with Ms LJ Moussa of Counsel.

  6. It was common ground that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Novelly v Tamqia Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 1235
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Novelly brought an action against Tamqia Pty Ltd in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The dispute centred around allegations of misconduct and breaches of contract. The court was tasked with determining the legal issues that arose from the complex web of claims and counterclaims presented by both parties. Specifically, the court needed to decide whether certain conduct by Tamqia Pty Ltd constituted civil contempt and whether Novelly was entitled to costs under particular circumstances.

The court addressed the legal issues by examining the nature of the alleged misconduct and its impact on the proceedings. It was clear that while the prosecution for criminal contempt failed, there were instances of civil contempt committed by Tamqia Pty Ltd. The court found that the general rule that costs follow the event did not apply in this case due to the exceptional circumstances presented. The misconduct of Tamqia Pty Ltd warranted a deviation from the usual cost-bearing principle, allowing Novelly to seek costs despite the failure of the criminal contempt prosecution.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the established legal precedents regarding the discretionary power to award costs in cases of misconduct. It concluded that the exceptional circumstances, including the proven civil contempts, justified an exception to the general rule. Consequently, the court ruled in favour of Novelly, awarding them costs as appropriate in the circumstances. This decision underscores the court's commitment to ensuring justice is served, even in the face of procedural complexities.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a series of contractual and commercial disputes between Novelly and Tamqia Pty Ltd. Novelly is a shareholder and director of Tamqia Pty Ltd. In late 2018, Novelly initiated legal proceedings against Tamqia Pty Ltd, alleging breaches of fiduciary duty and mismanagement by the other directors. These proceedings led to a series of interlocutory applications and hearings, including an injunction sought by Novelly to restrain Tamqia Pty Ltd from disposing of certain assets. The dispute also involved allegations of disclosure of confidential information and obstruction of Novelly's efforts to manage the company's affairs. Throughout the litigation, there were multiple instances of alleged misconduct by Novelly, including non-compliance with court orders and attempts to influence witnesses.

In 2019, a prosecution for criminal contempt was brought against Novelly due to these alleged acts of misconduct. This prosecution ultimately failed, but the Court found that Novelly had indeed committed acts of civil contempt. The Court was tasked with determining the appropriate costs order in light of these findings.

The case began with Novelly filing a claim against Tamqia Pty Ltd in 2018, seeking relief for alleged breaches of fiduciary duty and mismanagement. Throughout the litigation, there were several interlocutory applications and hearings, including an application for an injunction to restrain the disposal of company assets. Following the failed prosecution for criminal contempt, the Court conducted a hearing to determine the appropriate costs order. The Court considered the findings of civil contempt and the conduct of Novelly throughout the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether misconduct by a party in civil proceedings, even if not amounting to criminal contempt, justifies an exception to the general rule that costs follow the event.
2. How to appropriately assess and allocate costs in cases where civil contempt has been found, despite the failure of a prosecution for criminal contempt.

Held
1. The court held that misconduct by a party in civil proceedings, even if not amounting to criminal contempt, can justify an exception to the general rule that costs follow the event.
2. The court held that in cases where civil contempt has been found, despite the failure of a prosecution for criminal contempt, the court should appropriately assess and allocate costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the general rule that costs follow the event should be departed from due to misconduct by a party in civil proceedings. It acknowledged that misconduct, even if not amounting to criminal contempt, can warrant an exception to this rule. The court referred to previous cases where similar misconduct was considered, establishing that such exceptions are permissible when the misconduct is significant and affects the fairness of the proceedings. In this case, the misconduct was deemed serious enough to warrant an exception.

Regarding the assessment and allocation of costs, the court noted that where civil contempt has been found but a prosecution for criminal contempt fails, the principles guiding costs in civil contempt cases must be applied. The court held that the costs incurred due to the civil contempt proceedings should be allocated in a manner that reflects the misconduct and its impact on the proceedings. The court did not find any issue of principle in imposing costs in such circumstances and relied on precedents where similar allocations were made.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that misconduct by a party in civil proceedings, even if not amounting to criminal contempt, can justify an exception to the general rule that costs follow the event. Additionally, where civil contempt is found, the court has the discretion to assess and allocate costs in a manner that reflects the misconduct's impact on the proceedings. The court did not depart from prior authority on this matter but applied established principles to the specific facts of this case.